Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Different political views

163 replies

NotGotAClue1 · 05/07/2023 19:30

Just that really. My partner and I have VERY different political views on most things and I don’t want to bring things up and feel tense when the news is on because I don’t want to argue. I love him, we have a toddler and he treats us both well, we’re very happy together but some of the things he says really really bother me and don’t sit well at all and I certainly don’t want our child having these views.

A few examples… he makes sweeping statements, he’s anti illegal immigration, thought Rwanda was a good idea, thinks the rnli shouldn’t be involved and he stopped donating to them because of it. He also makes a lot of assumptions. I recently showed him an article about someone who was stabbed to death and I obviously thought how sad but his first reaction was oh it’ll be gang related. He disagrees with children being told they can identity as whatever in schools at a young age etc.

I should mention he was in the police for a long time and served on very deprived London boroughs and has seen and experienced terrible things so I definitely feel what he has seen/ dealt with has skewed him somewhat. I just didn’t realise how far apart we were on things.

Please don’t flippantly say leave him. I love him and will not break our family up over politics, I just wonder if anyone is in relationships with different views and how you navigate it?

OP posts:
WandaWonder · 06/07/2023 11:28

I think there can be a thing that is more 'I am right and you are wrong' with some attitudes when it comes to politics so I guess work out what is more important being one of you think is right? Or your relationship as whole

GasPanic · 06/07/2023 11:26

This may come as a bit of a shock, but kids will not necessarily take your views. So probably best prepare yourself for that.

If they are smart they will take opinions from everyone around them and come to their own conclusions. Which may coincide with yours. And may not.

The most important thing to me is to teach them to be open minded and think carefully before choosing their opinions, to have empathy and to help them understand the dangers of extremism.

Also, this may be a fairly technical point, but illegal immigration is ... illegal !

That's why we have passports and visas.

notwavingbutdrowning1 · 06/07/2023 11:23

I love how lefties talk about "tolerance" so much, but can't even tolerate their spouse's opinions.

I think you’d be hard put to find a leftie who said racism and walking by while people drown should be tolerated.

Tolerance per se is not a virtue. It all depends on what you are tolerating.

OurFlagMeansAfternoonTea · 06/07/2023 10:54

I love how lefties talk about "tolerance" so much, but can't even tolerate their spouse's opinions.
Frankly, he's right that gender ideology shouldn't be taught in schools. It's all a dangerous lie and leads to children being sterilised and mutilated.

AbsolutelyExhausted · 06/07/2023 10:53

@NotGotAClue1 you may have answered this, but does your dh have a diverse group of friends?

Capitalismwantsyou · 06/07/2023 10:46

10HailMarys · 05/07/2023 21:15

The views you’re describing aren’t just “political views”. They are his core values. He is a racist who would rather see human beings drown than have RNLI save them. That isn’t a political issue; it’s a moral one. You are married to a racist, inhumane bigot. If my partner expressed views like that I would feel sick.

hmm, you think you are saying the "right thing" - yes? well, guess what, most people who believe the opposite think they are doing the "right thing" too.

Capitalismwantsyou · 06/07/2023 10:43

OP ignore the extremists - your DH sounds like a good man. not a perfect one. your kids can grow up understanding both sides of a debate and decide for themselves. i know it's frustrating. mine still hasn't peaked on the trans thing. it drives me mad. i'm going to keep working on it though, cos that's what loved ones do.

ummWTH · 06/07/2023 10:19

@Leastsaidsoonestscrewed

"Funny how the right wing are behind you on that one and you see no issue with such fellow travellers..."

That's because most normal people don't expect to align fully with everyone around them.

So what if I agree with a right wing person on one issue? Well, what about it? People are perfectly capable of disagreeing on one subject and agreeing on another. It completely natural.

Are you telling me that if a right wing person said something you would automatically disagree with that stance just based on the fact that the person saying it was right wing?

What if Nigel Farage discussed how child abuse was bad? Could you stand to align with him on that issue, and would you care when the nonces started saying to you "Funny how the right wing are behind you on that one and you see no issue with such fellow travellers..."? I doubt it.

ummWTH · 06/07/2023 10:11

bozzabollix · 06/07/2023 06:47

You both sound like my mother and father in law. He’s so loud and boorish about his racist views that everyone avoids them both - she is lovely but misses out as they always come as a pair. My husband can’t bear the racism and is furious with his Dad for being so ignorant.

In the future see your adult kids alone if you can! If they’ve had any kind of education they’ll be appalled by his views.

Letting people drown in the sea would be beyond disgusting. The annoying thing is the racist arseholes that say it if they were on that boat would want to save them, and would be cured of their thoughts if they actually had a conversation about what drove these people to try and get here. It’s the likes of Farage that’s wound them up.

I’ve talked to several fisherman on the Kent coast and the one person they wouldn’t pull out of the water is Nigel Farage!

This is what OP was talking about re branding someone with all sorts of hateful accusations based on a snippet of information.

WTH makes you think her husband is like your FIL exactly? Who told you he's boorish and loud? What gives you the impression his own children will avoid him?

Post after post accusing him of wanting people left to drown..is that what he said? No that's what you have all chosen to take from his statement, based on nothing other than the fact that you disagree with him. And the sad thing is none of you will ever know because instead of wanting an open discussion with people you disagree with, you're busy throwing angry accusations and name calling. Who is truly ignorant here? And wilfully so.

I'm so sick of people arrogantly making such sweeping statements and refusing to allow others room to speak and listen. I'm left wing, never voted Tory, remain, I care about refugees, care about the poor, about children, the elderly, workers rights, the right to protest, the environment...all sorts. But you ignorant loud mouths trying to drown out any opposition make the world a less pleasant place for us all. Most people don't want to live in an angry environment filled with hate where everyone sees things in black and white, no room for grey..no room for discussion and learning from eachother. Where people just shout eachother down and others are left feeling like they cant express themselves. I see you as no better than any other extremists, despite the fact you might align with me politically, your personalities are extremely unpleasant to me 🤷🏽‍♀️

Florissante · 06/07/2023 10:01

LadyBird1973 · 06/07/2023 08:10

It wouldn't be a problem for me. Your child will grow up learning that people have different opinions and that's okay. It's actually bad for kids to think that only one pov is morally correct and everyone who doesn't share it is a bad person. And weirdly, you get that more from the left, who like to market themselves as better people, than those on the political right!

His opinions have been formed by his life experiences and he's entitled to hold those views. That's what freedom means - hearing stuff you personally disagree with but respecting their right to hold those views.
Your child will hear them anyway, so better that they see an example of each parent respecting the pov of the other, even while disagreeing.

I'd focus on the important everyday things like attitude towards money or how to raise children, division of labour domestically etc.

Nice to see a calm, sensible post.

Florissante · 06/07/2023 10:00

JaneyGee · 05/07/2023 22:48

Being opposed to illegal immigration is hardly an extreme point of view. It’s a perfectly normal, sensible one. In general, I find moderate conservatives far more thoughtful, tolerant and willing to listen than those on the left.

I agree. The hyperbolic personal attacks are coming from those on the left.

Bobbielikespeas · 06/07/2023 09:16

If it hasn't come up till now doesn't sound like you'd be too bothered deep down. So just carry on as you were? As for the children, they're probably more likely to pick up their politics online either way. And if they end up like your dh, there's already plenty of right wingers in the country so a few more won't make much difference anyway

LadyBird1973 · 06/07/2023 09:09

Not really the same thing @notwavingbutdrowning1
The OP is talking about different political views, not crimes.

I actually doubt that if he was making the decision re illegal immigrants on boats, that he would irl let people drown. Very very few people would be that cold. I suspect he's just expressing frustration at this situation never being resolved and the complete ineffectiveness of the government in putting a stop to it. No one actually wants people to die, but in allowing it to continue more people will ultimately drown as there's no disincentive to get on the boats.

notwavingbutdrowning1 · 06/07/2023 08:49

It's actually bad for kids to think that only one pov is morally correct

Sometimes only one pov IS morally correct. That’s why we have societal consensus on stuff like murder, rape and child abuse.

Or would you like your kids to grow up hearing multiple pov on those, @LadyBird1973 ?

LadyBird1973 · 06/07/2023 08:10

It wouldn't be a problem for me. Your child will grow up learning that people have different opinions and that's okay. It's actually bad for kids to think that only one pov is morally correct and everyone who doesn't share it is a bad person. And weirdly, you get that more from the left, who like to market themselves as better people, than those on the political right!

His opinions have been formed by his life experiences and he's entitled to hold those views. That's what freedom means - hearing stuff you personally disagree with but respecting their right to hold those views.
Your child will hear them anyway, so better that they see an example of each parent respecting the pov of the other, even while disagreeing.

I'd focus on the important everyday things like attitude towards money or how to raise children, division of labour domestically etc.

NotGotAClue1 · 06/07/2023 07:06

wildfirewonder · 06/07/2023 07:03

The human-hating anti-immigration types always say this. But those coming in small boats, if refugees fleeing warnor persecution, are coming legally and are in genuine need.

But your husband wants the RNLI to leave them to drown.

I know, I was shell shocked when he said it. I can’t understand how a decent hum would think this :(

OP posts:
cakeorwine · 06/07/2023 07:06

You aren't going to get him to alter his views anymore than he can get you to alter your views.

It's easy to see how someone can follow people on social media, read headlines and stories that appeal to their views and reinforce them, and can have their own view of the world confirmed to them. Listening to other stories, hearing different perspectives can make dents in someone's own view - challenge their view of the world - but a change can only come from within.

There are so many facts about refugees that people just don't know. The number of displaced people in the world is staggering.

108 million people displaced

Turkiye alone has 3.6 million refugees

That kind of puts the numbers coming here into perspective.

But you aren't going to change his views.

wildfirewonder · 06/07/2023 07:03

NotGotAClue1 · 06/07/2023 06:42

Anti-illegal immigration. He says he has no problem with people coming here legally and those in genuine need.

The human-hating anti-immigration types always say this. But those coming in small boats, if refugees fleeing warnor persecution, are coming legally and are in genuine need.

But your husband wants the RNLI to leave them to drown.

bozzabollix · 06/07/2023 06:47

You both sound like my mother and father in law. He’s so loud and boorish about his racist views that everyone avoids them both - she is lovely but misses out as they always come as a pair. My husband can’t bear the racism and is furious with his Dad for being so ignorant.

In the future see your adult kids alone if you can! If they’ve had any kind of education they’ll be appalled by his views.

Letting people drown in the sea would be beyond disgusting. The annoying thing is the racist arseholes that say it if they were on that boat would want to save them, and would be cured of their thoughts if they actually had a conversation about what drove these people to try and get here. It’s the likes of Farage that’s wound them up.

I’ve talked to several fisherman on the Kent coast and the one person they wouldn’t pull out of the water is Nigel Farage!

NotGotAClue1 · 06/07/2023 06:42

HamBone · 05/07/2023 22:32

Is he anti-immigration altogether or anti-illegal immigration through criminal means?

I’m an immigrant and definitely pro-immigration. But I also recognize that the traffickers who accept money from desperate people to load up boats for these extremely dangerous crossing are criminals, and need to be stopped.

The Rwanda idea was ridiculous, but immigration reform is desperately needed.

Anti-illegal immigration. He says he has no problem with people coming here legally and those in genuine need.

OP posts:
LadyWithLapdog · 06/07/2023 00:07

@Leastsaidsoonestscrewed maybe it’s late and I’m tired but I don’t understand your point about the fellow travellers. From the little the OP has told us I agree with her DH on one point only. It’s a superficial agreement at this stage, as I don’t know his views and how much they align with mine or not. His might come from a homophobic starting point, so if that’s your point about fellow travellers then you’re right. I should wait to hear more. But that’s for another day, or not at all.

Leastsaidsoonestscrewed · 05/07/2023 23:44

Mutabiliss · 05/07/2023 22:30

I'm struggling to grasp it because I talk to my partner about politics all the time. Like, daily. We comment on things in the news, on politicians, on local news. There's no way in five years it could have escaped my notice that he thought immigrants should be left to drown.

It sounds like you're a True Blue Tory and he's more of the newly minted UKIP Tory variety. Two sides of the same coin, tbh.

Oh don't talk bollocks. The All Tories are Pure Evil cant on here is so fucking tiresome and ignorant.

And no, I'm not and never have been.

Leastsaidsoonestscrewed · 05/07/2023 23:40

LadyWithLapdog · 05/07/2023 19:37

These views won’t have suddenly struck him. So what’s changed in you that you find them abhorrent now? He sounds like an arsehole, sorry. Apart from children ID as they want, I can understand that view.

Funny how the right wing are behind you on that one and you see no issue with such fellow travellers...

Ricochetsandwhich · 05/07/2023 23:38

People in relationships with similar values will always tell you that’s the only way. It’s certainly easier and provides a stable plinth to build on but I’d like to think is not the only way to have a successful relationship.

What are his other core values? Is he a thoughtful and caring partner and father? Is he loving and supportive of his wider family and friends? Does he respect you, help you, and respect your opinion? These are also important. Probably more important for a life partner than political leanings that are shaped by his upbringing and life experiences. Although I consider my partners views questionable at times I understand knowing him how he came to think like that and I can recognise that he’s a much better person than I when it comes to being thoughtful and nurturing our relationship and he beats me hands down at being helpful inside and outside the family home. Nobody is perfect you just have to recognise and value the good and decide how much weight you want to give to the rest.

LadyWithLapdog · 05/07/2023 23:02

As has been said ad Infinitum on these boards, some of these people don’t have a legal way to apply for asylum. I don’t know the solution. I’m not a politician. But let me tell you who would know : the fucking Tories who’ve been in charge for 13 years and haven’t sorted this and all the other mess.