Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To buy a bomb site for £1.1 million?

190 replies

Losingmyusername · 05/07/2023 18:56

Just that really. 17th century, listed, 6 bedrooms and a self contained annex with 3 bedrooms (no bathroom or kitchen fitted and no floors).
It was occupied by squatters who have smashed all the windows. Significant damp issues in one room. Horrible interior fittings, and needs bathroom and kitchen fully remodelling, as its previous use was a hostel.
Asking price is £1.4, but I think the work is very substantial and I suspect the survey may show additional issues.
Would need planning permission/LBC for the refit and ideally would want to add a door to the garden.
I think we probably couldn't live in it for six months.
Can afford it if our current place sells for 650 and we get rental income from the annex and have my sister move in as well.
It would give space for all the kids and potential for then to live in the house when they're grown up and we live in the annex.
Only reason I'm even thinking about is because I realised the sums just add up if survey is ok and obviously if I keep my job. I picture being able to restore this local house to its former glory and am carried away with the idea of sweeping staircases and decorated ceilings (right now it has a shitty cheap staircase, no decor and that horrible chip wallpaper). I'm not great at DIY but my husband is and loves it. I already live in a listed building so have some idea what would typically be granted/refused and how to apply.
Am I an idiot to even think about putting an offer in?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
LoisLane66 · 07/07/2023 18:45

If the sums add up, go for it. You only live once.
Good luck 🍀🍀🍀

Feedthatgoat · 07/07/2023 15:42

I just did a very small extension on my 4 bed house which is in excellent condition and it cost me over £100,000. You can multilply that by at least 10 if you have a house that is falling to bits so your 1.2 million will end up being 2.5 million easily. Are you mad or rich?

Rinkydinkydink · 07/07/2023 10:41

QueenCamilla · 07/07/2023 10:36

@Rinkydinkydink

You really are being silly.

Because absolutely, 100% you can't tell if the rainwater goods, roof or structure of the property is fine from the photos! You can make a guess I suppose...? Might be right or wrong.

How can you tell if the rainwater drains well and where to?
On first inspections (from the ground) by roofers and construction companies no one could tell that the gutters were back-flowing into our house. From the outside even the original wooden fascia board was in top nick and so was the wooden gutter.

The roof looked fine at first and no visible water damage inside. Well, that's until it was found (months later) that there's a rare cavity wall in our Victorian terrace between the houses. All the water running through a faulty join between us and the neighbour, was disappearing into that cavity, running all the way down to the ground floor and harboring dry rot there. Unfortunately, the staircase was affected and will be expensive to fix.

I've also had an architect and a builder stood in my Victorian kitchen extension unable to tell if it needs underpinning without a test dig to see what the walls are stood on.

The substandard concrete floors throughout the ground floor need to be dug up...

Another massive obstacle and ££££ is a concrete in-filled bomb shelter by the back wall. Great.

None, absolutely none of the above would have been evident from a few photos.

Goodness me your highness
Luckily I don’t need to put so much effort into proving myself these days

As an architect, historic building surveyor and currently doing 5 Quinquennials with over 30 years experience under my belt I think I know exactly what I can do.

jeaux90 · 07/07/2023 10:40

My partner is doing a big project at the moment, it's his 4th and we are looking for another now. There is absolutely no way we would take on a listed building.

QueenCamilla · 07/07/2023 10:36

@Rinkydinkydink

You really are being silly.

Because absolutely, 100% you can't tell if the rainwater goods, roof or structure of the property is fine from the photos! You can make a guess I suppose...? Might be right or wrong.

How can you tell if the rainwater drains well and where to?
On first inspections (from the ground) by roofers and construction companies no one could tell that the gutters were back-flowing into our house. From the outside even the original wooden fascia board was in top nick and so was the wooden gutter.

The roof looked fine at first and no visible water damage inside. Well, that's until it was found (months later) that there's a rare cavity wall in our Victorian terrace between the houses. All the water running through a faulty join between us and the neighbour, was disappearing into that cavity, running all the way down to the ground floor and harboring dry rot there. Unfortunately, the staircase was affected and will be expensive to fix.

I've also had an architect and a builder stood in my Victorian kitchen extension unable to tell if it needs underpinning without a test dig to see what the walls are stood on.

The substandard concrete floors throughout the ground floor need to be dug up...

Another massive obstacle and ££££ is a concrete in-filled bomb shelter by the back wall. Great.

None, absolutely none of the above would have been evident from a few photos.

Talia99 · 07/07/2023 09:47

Eventingmum · 07/07/2023 09:36

Do it, life's too short not to

Or alternatively, life’s too short to take on a labour intensive money pit that will basically take up your entire life for years. It depends on how you look at it.

Eventingmum · 07/07/2023 09:36

Do it, life's too short not to

Ukrainebaby23 · 07/07/2023 05:12

Relying on a relative to move in and pay rent is going to be very stressful. I wouldn't do it but I'm a low risk person generally.

LookingforMaryPoppins · 07/07/2023 05:01

I would also add, does it have much land? There is a cost associated with the upkeep! We have large gardens and subsequently have a gardener one day each week (we are not green fingered and with working and 3 children we just don't have the time). We also have some fields which need fencing replaced regularly, topping, brush cutting etc.

Also factor in the running costs, heating etc when oil was cheap, 1200 litres every 6 weeks (in the winter) was OK! We also get through a huge amount of electricity.

The house was bought as a house for life and is a great family home, in hindsite I can't see us staying in old age given the size and running costs!

LookingforMaryPoppins · 07/07/2023 04:53

I haven't read the full thread but the house looks lovely and certainly sounds to have lots of potential.

My advice would be that whatever you estimate the renovation costs to be, they will invariably be far higher! If you can cost up the essentials and afford those, and are happy to live in it as is and do everything else slowly then go for it :)

We bought an old farmhouse which we renovated. It's beautiful now but the costs were much higher than expected largely because old houses are money pits! Whatever work you have done invariably leads to discovering more needs doing / rectifying which increases the cost of the carefully budgeted work you are currently doing!

Surveys absolutely do not give you the full picture! They only tell you what is visible - we had a full structural (what a waste of money 🤣🤣)

alwayscrashinginthesamecar1 · 07/07/2023 02:28

Hibiscrubbed · 06/07/2023 20:16

You don’t understand why someone would like to live in a huge stately home that they could renovate and make their own?

I don't really understand it either, it sounds like a massive pain in the arse to me! I absolutely would not like to live in a huge house with inadequate heating and spending all my cash on repairs and maintenance! It sounds like a miserable existence to me. Although I wouldn't fancy a stately home even if I was minted to be honest, I'm more of a beach house kind of person.

Furries · 07/07/2023 02:04

Haven’t read the full thread, just OP posts.

I would make sure you know exactly what is entailed re doing work on a listed building. Costs will be higher and restrictions may well prevent what you want to achieve.

Make absolutely sure re any covenants re annex. They are often built with a clause that means you can never rent them out - ie they are great if you have family you want to move in, but don’t rely on them generating funds/rent at a later date.

CelestiaNoctis · 07/07/2023 01:20

6 months until you could move in. Lol what. With the amount of work it sounds more like 2 years. You're assuming the tradesmen you get are gonna do a good job, often they don't. And that the sale is smooth sailing, often its not. And also you don't have that kind of money either. It sounds like a lovely dream and maybe you should just make your mistake but I don't think it's worth it. Move further north and you could get a lovely place for half that price with no work required.

LolaButt · 07/07/2023 00:20

Erm. I assume you’re in catchment for Stantonbury?

If so, spend your money on your kids education and save them from having to go to that absolute shit hole of a school.

Rinkydinkydink · 07/07/2023 00:02

DeliciouslyDecadent · 06/07/2023 09:13

Oh don't be silly.

A lot of houses very close to me have subsidence and it can't be seen without a survey.

Rude!

Ridiculous remark, a professional doesn’t need to do a survey to spot subsidence, they do the survey to write a specification for the works.

Owners will be told they need a ‘survey’ for the above and to claim on insurance, cost the works etc

Not to spot whether it exists because anyone who is qualified can spot it very very easily.

anon666 · 06/07/2023 23:39

Unless you are very well off, it will be a stressful money pit.

ReadingSoManyThreads · 06/07/2023 22:47

spriggit · 06/07/2023 22:07

We bought an 8 bedroom 17 th century house split into 3. The biggest problem we have is getting builders to do the work! No one is interested in doing individual jobs. They just want us to do the whole thing at once which we can't afford. It's resulting in them coming to look then buggering off and never even giving us a quote. One builder came out march 2022 and agreed to start work march 2023. We contacted him Jan 2023 to ask the exact date he would start and he said" too busy, it will be 2024 now!". I dream of winning the lottery and letting them see someone else getting the work.

We have this problem with renovating our house and I'm at the point where I DETEST trades wasting my precious time by coming round spending an hour or more talking things through then never hearing from them again. So fucking sick of it. Finally, after years of being let down, I've found a decent set of trades, each one recommended the other trade, who WILL do some jobs so that we can continue doing our house one room at a time, which is all we can manage to do both financially and with having to live in the house.

ManyATrueWord · 06/07/2023 22:15

This is my dream house, a grade 2 listed vicarage that has been gutted on the inside.

Fortunately I realised long ago that I don't like housework and I hate gardening, so no big properties for us unless we get so rich we can afford a staff too.

spriggit · 06/07/2023 22:07

We bought an 8 bedroom 17 th century house split into 3. The biggest problem we have is getting builders to do the work! No one is interested in doing individual jobs. They just want us to do the whole thing at once which we can't afford. It's resulting in them coming to look then buggering off and never even giving us a quote. One builder came out march 2022 and agreed to start work march 2023. We contacted him Jan 2023 to ask the exact date he would start and he said" too busy, it will be 2024 now!". I dream of winning the lottery and letting them see someone else getting the work.

wellstopdoingitthen · 06/07/2023 22:06

i have not had a chance to read the full thread so apologies if it’s already been suggested.
Can you afford to hire a project manager? A good pm can save you lots of hassle & stress.

Bugbabe1970 · 06/07/2023 21:59

It's stressing me out planning my new kitchen
This would be an absolute stressful nightmare for me

Novemberoflastyear · 06/07/2023 20:45

Hibiscrubbed · 06/07/2023 20:16

You don’t understand why someone would like to live in a huge stately home that they could renovate and make their own?

No, I totally don't, hence my asking...

doingthehokeykokey · 06/07/2023 20:40

NellyBarney · 06/07/2023 17:33

@Mirabai someone has to renovate it, otherwise these beautiful old buildings would collapse. It takes a long time if you do it properly as everything needs to be done by hand, and I never heard of anyone, including the royal family, who had enough money to do it all in 1 go, and you need to repaint and do spot repairs externally every other year just for maintenance. And then there are the gardens. As an example, we had 3 joiners working for us exclusively, often 50 hours weeks, for 2 years just to restore the windows (all 45 of them), the floors, the doors, and the wall panelling. The wall panelling in the drawing room alone took 4 months to make and install, and another 6 weeks to decorate and install a copy of the original chinoiserie wallpaper, which was printed bespoke to fit the panels. All this after it took 4 lime experts 2 months to repair the lath ceiling and to redraw the plaster covings by hand. All that after another 4 months to repair joists, repoint the walls, lay new floorboards, restore windows and fix secondary glazing, and to open up and repair and line the 2 chimneys (15m high, from lower groundfloor, there are 15 chimney chambers and fireplaces all together, every single one needed significant work). This one room alone cost about 80k to restore. There are 25 rooms in total, admittingly many are much smaller, but then you have extra costs for bathrooms and kitchen, and of course repointing and electrics. We had 5 miles of cables put down in the house, there are 7 wifi router outlets, there are 8 different heating zones, 2 boilers, 1 heatpump, underfloor heating in the kitchen and about 35 massive 6-column radiators. Even Buckingham Palace has a timeframe of 10 years for repairs, but I bet it will take 20, and the royals are turning the heating down. It's a labour of love to renovate an old property, and you will never (or should never) put the heating on 24 hours/day to 21 degrees. These houses were built to be heated 1 room at a time, and that's what we try to do. We heat the kitchen when we are in, we heat the bedrooms for 1 hour before getting up and before going to bed. We sit in front of a fire in the snug. Drawing rooms are summer rooms, we don't heat them in the winter, nor do we heat our 13m high, 30 square meter big entrance hall and side hall - that would just be like burning 10 pound notes. I wouldn't do it if I was a billionaire. There is always a warm room, but most of the house is about 13 or even 10 degrees in winter (the heating comes on when it goes below 10 degrees to prevent frost damage). The boilers are so strong though, and the heating zones so small, that it takes minutes to heat up a room when you need to.

Sounds amazing. Can you post a pic?! <nosey>

Does the 25 rooms include bathrooms? I need a sense of scale so I can quantify my jealousy 😁

Hibiscrubbed · 06/07/2023 20:16

Novemberoflastyear · 06/07/2023 18:11

But why do you want/need 25 rooms?? Honestly it's baffling. I live in a listed property with a few little rooms like most people. I'm utterly baffled why anyone would need or want what sounds like a stately home. How many of you live there? I just cannot see the point.

Your point about heating is wrong, you shouldn't leave rooms completely cold or they will become damp.

You don’t understand why someone would like to live in a huge stately home that they could renovate and make their own?

Mashedstrawberries · 06/07/2023 19:21

I live in a teeny 17th century cottage with a thatched roof that is chaos and a money pit! But I adore it and if I ever have the money to move, I’d buy another old house. Unfortunately we don’t have much money and finding the cash for the upkeep of this house is really tough.

Im sad to read other people saying ‘if it wasn’t listed knock it down’, people love such houses because they are pieces of living history. If you have the time, effort and money to own an old house then go for it. But do it for the love of it, because they’re not easy to own.