Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think they shouldn’t close 1,000 rail ticket offices?

356 replies

TiredArse · 05/07/2023 17:19

Latest plan to ‘improve’ the railways. Up to 1,000 will close.

We’ll be left with those shitty, self service machines that are a pain to use on a good day. Got a disability or struggle to use a machine? Tough shit. Got a query? Tough shit.

Does anyone actually believe that the money saved will reduce fares or improve services?

You can fill in the consultation form here - not easy to see, you have to click on the words ‘consultation response form’. https://www.transportfocus.org.uk/train-station-ticket-office-consultation/

OP posts:
TabbyM · 06/07/2023 10:58

Absolutely not. Skilled staff with knowledge of the network will be lost. People will have to travel to buy railcards etc and nobody will be in a known location to assist disabled people or provide advice/information.

FridayNeverHesitate · 06/07/2023 10:56

My mum's 85. She's very mobile and amazing for her age, but she really struggles with buying train tickets online or from a machine. She has questions to ask - will she be able to return via X route? Is her dog allowed on the train? Would it be cheaper to come back before 4pm? Will her ticket still be valid if she misses the train she has seat reservations for? For her, trying to find the answers to her concerns from a computer is utterly confusing and soul-destroying. Also, she gets flustered if she's trying to work the ticket machine and a line of people build up behind her.

Most of her friends are the same (those of whom who are actually mobile enough to get the train).

For those suggesting that people buy their ticket on the train, it is much more expensive that way!

Such a shame - older people should be able to enjoy what independence they still have, while they still can. My mum and her friends will become virtual prisoners if this goes ahead.

the80sweregreat · 06/07/2023 10:47

Some people are definitely more technically minded than others. It's a fact of life , but it can and does go wrong for people regardless and we all need some human interaction sometimes.
I Was listening to a young caller on lbc this morning worried about more AI and voice recognition and how won't always be used for the greater good either. I've heard this from other people too.

Confuzzlediddled · 06/07/2023 10:44

As a disabled user who needs a ramp it's going to make it many times harder, not only trying to get hold of a staff member to deploy the ramp to get on (and if they aren't there ready you won't be allowed to board and bumped to the next train) there's also that fear of nobody being at the other end to let you off...

I book my assistance on the app but then you still need to find a member of staff at the station, even with offices it can be a nightmare in some (reading I'm looking at you) so without it will be many times worse!

Plumbear2 · 06/07/2023 10:41

Happyfluffball · 06/07/2023 10:07

They can learn to use one. I know old people hate learning new things but it's probably better for them and reduces the risk of alzeimers.

Oh dear. It's not a case of people not wanting to learn. It's about elderly people who carnt learn how to use apps etc because of eye slight, dementia, etc. Do you know anyone with early alzermas? Because I do and it's not as simple aslearning new things 🙄. Younger people can have strokes, again it's not a simple case of learning new things. Have a word with yourself.

Talia99 · 06/07/2023 10:37

Happyfluffball · 06/07/2023 10:34

They don't sound too fragile to be travelling on trains.

Who doesn’t?

Talia99 · 06/07/2023 10:36

Happyfluffball · 06/07/2023 10:32

My mum has told me this many times. And yet when I can't call her back in time she somehow works it out.

And the elderly lady I know doesn’t work it out and just sits and suffers.

One might almost think not all elderly people are the same.

badluckorbadvibes · 06/07/2023 10:36

@Happyfluffball

At this point. I think you are just taking the piss.

badluckorbadvibes · 06/07/2023 10:35

@Happyfluffball

They don't sound too fragile to be travelling on trains.

What the actual fuck Hmm

Happyfluffball · 06/07/2023 10:35

badluckorbadvibes · 06/07/2023 10:34

@Happyfluffball

My mum has told me this many times. And yet when I can't call her back in time she somehow works it out.

And your mum being awkward with you is your basis for deciding all elderly and disabled people can learn new things, is it?

There are people who genuinely have disabilities or illnesses but a good proportion of them just refuse to learn.

badluckorbadvibes · 06/07/2023 10:34

@Happyfluffball

My mum has told me this many times. And yet when I can't call her back in time she somehow works it out.

And your mum being awkward with you is your basis for deciding all elderly and disabled people can learn new things, is it?

Happyfluffball · 06/07/2023 10:34

Talia99 · 06/07/2023 10:30

This. Having just had to deal with an elderly learning disabled lady reduced to literal sobbing distress by a standard letter from BT saying they are transferring her to Digital Voice (for a lady who has literally never touched a computer and who got rid of her non-smart mobile phone because it was beyond her), I can assure you that some people absolutely cannot learn.

The lady in question lives in sheltered accommodation. I have no doubt some of her 90 year old neighbours are ubering to the station to use their smartphone tickets to whiz off to the nearest city on a regular basis. Others like ‘Susan’ can just about manage the local public transport on a route they know well.

The bus company changed the route of one of the two buses she took. She couldn’t cope with the new route so she no longer goes to those shops unless someone gives her a lift. A minor change and it literally cut her activities in half. I offered to go with her the first time but she simply doesn’t have the confidence and is terrified of getting the wrong bus.

I can see similar happening to a lot of elderly / disabled people.

They don't sound too fragile to be travelling on trains.

Talia99 · 06/07/2023 10:33

Fizbosshoes · 06/07/2023 10:22

Where are people buying tickets on trains? And how would you get on the train if you couldn't get through the barrier?
The only member of staff on the train that I occassionally see is a ticket inspector and they're more likely to fine you for not having a ticket than sell you one?

Lots of stations in the Midlands without barriers (even in stations where the London train stops) Also, barriers usually left open when ticket office shut.

I regularly hear the conductor being asked for a ticket to Y station from X station when I’m sitting on the train.

Happyfluffball · 06/07/2023 10:32

badluckorbadvibes · 06/07/2023 10:10

@Happyfluffball

They can learn to use one.

No, not they can't. Quite often older people lose the ability to learn new things. The same with disabled people, it's not something they can juts decide to suddenly find ability for, if they can't do it they can't do it. How dare you suggest otherwise Angry

My mum has told me this many times. And yet when I can't call her back in time she somehow works it out.

the80sweregreat · 06/07/2023 10:31

Ds2 is mid 20s is good with tech and has a job using a PC all the time and uses his phone for mostly everything , but he still messed up his train ticket online once and couldn't get a refund. It's easy done even by those who know what they are doing.
Trying to correct any genuine mistakes or talk to anyone is impossible these days and that will get worse.
It's all down to the individual, which is a slippery slope and I bet they factor in the extra money they will make by people not finding the right deals or maybe messing it up.

PuggyMum · 06/07/2023 10:30

I'm disabled. Not old and work in project management in a Bank...

When I travel, I want a ticket - not on my phone. I'm all apped out and am on an old iPhone 7 so some apps aren't supported anyway. I'm about to upgrade but why should people be expected to spend money they don't always have?

I prefer to pay cash as my account is a black hole so I take out £200 and we can keep better track of what we are spending.

I can see both sides as if there isn't the footfall to justify it can be hard as a business but when cinemas sell tickets at the popcorn counter there has to be a compromise somewhere.

Unfortunately this is the way everything is going and I can guarantee people won't get a better service at the end of it.

Talia99 · 06/07/2023 10:30

User106487665 · 06/07/2023 10:17

Are you deliberately trying to be goady or are you always so ignorant.

This. Having just had to deal with an elderly learning disabled lady reduced to literal sobbing distress by a standard letter from BT saying they are transferring her to Digital Voice (for a lady who has literally never touched a computer and who got rid of her non-smart mobile phone because it was beyond her), I can assure you that some people absolutely cannot learn.

The lady in question lives in sheltered accommodation. I have no doubt some of her 90 year old neighbours are ubering to the station to use their smartphone tickets to whiz off to the nearest city on a regular basis. Others like ‘Susan’ can just about manage the local public transport on a route they know well.

The bus company changed the route of one of the two buses she took. She couldn’t cope with the new route so she no longer goes to those shops unless someone gives her a lift. A minor change and it literally cut her activities in half. I offered to go with her the first time but she simply doesn’t have the confidence and is terrified of getting the wrong bus.

I can see similar happening to a lot of elderly / disabled people.

badluckorbadvibes · 06/07/2023 10:25

Fizbosshoes · 06/07/2023 10:22

Where are people buying tickets on trains? And how would you get on the train if you couldn't get through the barrier?
The only member of staff on the train that I occassionally see is a ticket inspector and they're more likely to fine you for not having a ticket than sell you one?

I'm in Scotland and a lot of our smaller stations are without barriers so it's common for people to jump in and buy on board. Even at Edinburgh the LNER services Aberdeen - London are usually on platform 2/19 which have no barrier so you can get on without a ticket and buy on board.

I always travel to my nearest town because I might need assistance at the station. The local small station is no use to me.

User106487665 · 06/07/2023 10:23

My late DF couldn't physically use a smartphone because of health conditions but he went out a lot on trains and buses, he had one of those very simple phones with large numbers to use for calls

Fizbosshoes · 06/07/2023 10:22

Where are people buying tickets on trains? And how would you get on the train if you couldn't get through the barrier?
The only member of staff on the train that I occassionally see is a ticket inspector and they're more likely to fine you for not having a ticket than sell you one?

User106487665 · 06/07/2023 10:17

Happyfluffball · 06/07/2023 10:07

They can learn to use one. I know old people hate learning new things but it's probably better for them and reduces the risk of alzeimers.

Are you deliberately trying to be goady or are you always so ignorant.

Catspyjamas17 · 06/07/2023 10:16

I don't mind as long as:

  • stations are (still) adequately staffed
  • ticket machines and online resources/apps actually work
  • there are still options to buy a ticket from a person - from station staff on the platform or on the train itself
  • there are still guards on trains/properly staffed trains. I don't think driver only trains are a good idea.
badluckorbadvibes · 06/07/2023 10:13

another point to note is that while putting staff on stations may sound like a reasonable solution the platform is often far/out of sight of the gates. If the staff member has gone through the gates to the platform nobody will be able to access help in getting their ticket.

Fizbosshoes · 06/07/2023 10:11

I travel by train daily. I have a season ticket (that I bought at the ticket office - I could have got online)
However when I take DS on the train his fare is £2 ....but not all the ticket machines have the £2 child fare, the default setting is half fare which is much more expensive.And some super off peak fares mean tapping through several pages of options to find. (Probably annoying the people behind in the queue or prompting an AIBU - why do people faff about so much when buying rail tickets - answer because the ticket machines are designed with the most popular and most expensive fares most easy to find)

I do understand that it's not cost effective to man ticket offices if no one buys a ticket there but I'm also 100% sure it's not a saving that will be passed on to the passenger.

badluckorbadvibes · 06/07/2023 10:10

@Happyfluffball

They can learn to use one.

No, not they can't. Quite often older people lose the ability to learn new things. The same with disabled people, it's not something they can juts decide to suddenly find ability for, if they can't do it they can't do it. How dare you suggest otherwise Angry