Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think they shouldn’t close 1,000 rail ticket offices?

356 replies

TiredArse · 05/07/2023 17:19

Latest plan to ‘improve’ the railways. Up to 1,000 will close.

We’ll be left with those shitty, self service machines that are a pain to use on a good day. Got a disability or struggle to use a machine? Tough shit. Got a query? Tough shit.

Does anyone actually believe that the money saved will reduce fares or improve services?

You can fill in the consultation form here - not easy to see, you have to click on the words ‘consultation response form’. https://www.transportfocus.org.uk/train-station-ticket-office-consultation/

OP posts:
SaturdayGiraffe · 09/07/2023 08:35

It means the train companies will lose money from free rides.

User106487665 · 09/07/2023 08:24

Yes, I didn't pay the Trainline surcharge on principle and bought my ticket at the station, can't remember if I used the ticket office or machine, I didn't realise at the time the train companies own websites were free and it put me off buying online as I thought it was a bit sneaky especially as it wasn't even a special offer ticket just a normal day return

Talia99 · 09/07/2023 08:19

badluckorbadvibes · 08/07/2023 19:13

Nobody gives a shit about the job losses either, because they all have trainline downloaded Hmm

And ironically anyone using trainline is being ripped off as they charge a surcharge for each ticket while the ticket offices (and of course the train companies’ own websites) don’t.

badluckorbadvibes · 08/07/2023 19:13

Nobody gives a shit about the job losses either, because they all have trainline downloaded Hmm

40friedfish · 08/07/2023 19:01

Haven't you paid any attention to the rail strike ? This was one of the main areas of contention, not just pay. It's been publicised for months, why have you only just noticed ?

Chesneyhawkes1 · 08/07/2023 18:58

@user1497207191 who do you think puts the ramp up on driver only trains?

Staff from the platform / ticket office.

And mark my words, the government will come for the guards next.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 08/07/2023 18:00

Astsjakksmso · 08/07/2023 16:47

Barriers don't matter in terms of 'helping vulnerable passengers' - i.e those who wouldn't know how to use the machines, or otherwise get where they're going. At least for buses the driver will tell you if you've got it wrong and help you buy your ticket.

It IS patently ridiculous to rely so much on technology. Unless they let people go for free when it doesn't work. I have had to use a ticket counter because I had no data/WiFi too bad and machine didn't work. It can happen to anyone.

Of course, you could argue that whatever system the 'manned counter' was using could go down too, but presumably people could work something out? What are you supposed to do when faced with just a machine?

Ridiculous.

Barriers don't matter in terms of 'helping vulnerable passengers' - i.e those who wouldn't know how to use the machines, or otherwise get where they're going. At least for buses the driver will tell you if you've got it wrong and help you buy your ticket.

That was my point…

Despite not having ticket points people can still get to buses and trams to get tickets/help from the driver or guards as there are no barriers.

At at unmanned train station they’ll not get that far as so many have barriers.

user1497207191 · 08/07/2023 17:30

Astsjakksmso · 08/07/2023 16:47

Barriers don't matter in terms of 'helping vulnerable passengers' - i.e those who wouldn't know how to use the machines, or otherwise get where they're going. At least for buses the driver will tell you if you've got it wrong and help you buy your ticket.

It IS patently ridiculous to rely so much on technology. Unless they let people go for free when it doesn't work. I have had to use a ticket counter because I had no data/WiFi too bad and machine didn't work. It can happen to anyone.

Of course, you could argue that whatever system the 'manned counter' was using could go down too, but presumably people could work something out? What are you supposed to do when faced with just a machine?

Ridiculous.

During Storm Desmond, our nearest "big town" had widespread power cuts. Their main line train station just shut it's doors and trains didn't stop. So having a "manned" ticket office didn't help one jot. No one could use the station, neither able bodied nor disabled, old nor young.

user1497207191 · 08/07/2023 17:27

Catspyjamas17 · 08/07/2023 15:53

It's hard enough for wheelchair users to travel as it is. Imagine all unmanned stations so no-one to put the ramp up to the train door for them.

What do you think already happens at all the unmanned stations?

The guard/train manager puts out the ramp!

Or do you think wheelchair users don't use trains outside the cities and main lines?

Astsjakksmso · 08/07/2023 16:47

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 08/07/2023 15:37

It means nobody selling tickets at all. Machines and apps only.

I don’t know of any bus or tram stations that have ticket barriers so that’s one massive difference.

Barriers don't matter in terms of 'helping vulnerable passengers' - i.e those who wouldn't know how to use the machines, or otherwise get where they're going. At least for buses the driver will tell you if you've got it wrong and help you buy your ticket.

It IS patently ridiculous to rely so much on technology. Unless they let people go for free when it doesn't work. I have had to use a ticket counter because I had no data/WiFi too bad and machine didn't work. It can happen to anyone.

Of course, you could argue that whatever system the 'manned counter' was using could go down too, but presumably people could work something out? What are you supposed to do when faced with just a machine?

Ridiculous.

Catspyjamas17 · 08/07/2023 15:53

It's hard enough for wheelchair users to travel as it is. Imagine all unmanned stations so no-one to put the ramp up to the train door for them.

Seymour5 · 08/07/2023 15:41

Lincslady53 · 08/07/2023 10:46

I rarely use the train, but this year have been on 4 rail journeys. Booked the tickets via Trainline very easy, no need for a ticket office in every station. It does need someone by the ticket machines to help those having trouble with the machines. I am 70, most of our friends are 65 to 80, and they all manage apps and technology perfectly well.

I’m over 70 and buy online when I’m travelling out of my county. However, all pensioners in my county are entitled to half price rail travel county wide. Those tickets are not available online or via machines, they have to be bought at the ticket office. Just one example of why closing them will disadvantage some travellers.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 08/07/2023 15:37

Astsjakksmso · 08/07/2023 14:31

What confuses me here - that I can't find the answer to here - is the meaning of 'closed ticket office'.
Do they mean nobody sitting behind counters, selling tickets?
Or nobody selling tickets at the station at all?

The references to 'ticket machines and apps' seem to imply the latter.

As a technologist myself you absolutely cannot rely on apps and ticket machines! Disability aside all of these things have been down at multiple times. But there have always been staff standing around that could sell you tickets with those handheld machines... The kind that they use for train tickets. Keeping them at the station just not behind the counter is fair enough.

Interestingly most buses don't have ticket offices. And trams don't in Greater Manchester. Why the exception, and furore, over trains?

It means nobody selling tickets at all. Machines and apps only.

I don’t know of any bus or tram stations that have ticket barriers so that’s one massive difference.

badluckorbadvibes · 08/07/2023 15:23

@user1497207191

My point is that the regions and rural/semi rural areas have been screwed over for decades, but those living in cities didn't care.

I take it you haven't actually read my previous posts?

I do not live in a city.

I already have to travel further because my local station is unstaffed.

user1497207191 · 08/07/2023 15:19

badluckorbadvibes · 08/07/2023 14:38

@user1497207191

So you didn't care when it was happening to other people and now only care when it's potentially going to affect you?

Oh, no, it would have affected me back then too - interesting that you think the only possible reason I wasn't fighting for ticket offices 30 years ago is that I didn't care.

That said. Even if that was the case, it would still be valid. It's ok to learn.

My point is that the regions and rural/semi rural areas have been screwed over for decades, but those living in cities didn't care. What with loss of public transport, loss of facilities such as small schools, libraries, small hospitals, and the run down of town centre retail and centralisation of decent jobs into the cities. Not a squeak from city dwellers.

Now that all that is spreading to city centres, there are howls of protest - "how will they cope" etc - well, those in rural/semi rural areas have had to cope, and have found ways to deal with the loss of what city dwellers think is normal.

It's all too late to start squealing now - that's just shutting the stable door after the horse has bolted. You should have taken more notice over the past 20-30 years during which politicians have been obsessed with cities at the expense of rural and semi rural areas, just using them as a kind of test-bed to find out how far they can go cutting services etc - they found that they can, so now they're extending it to cities too!

badluckorbadvibes · 08/07/2023 14:38

@user1497207191

So you didn't care when it was happening to other people and now only care when it's potentially going to affect you?

Oh, no, it would have affected me back then too - interesting that you think the only possible reason I wasn't fighting for ticket offices 30 years ago is that I didn't care.

That said. Even if that was the case, it would still be valid. It's ok to learn.

Astsjakksmso · 08/07/2023 14:31

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 08/07/2023 13:17

Does seem pointless keeping them open when so many people use the ticketing apps these days.

Only if you consider it pointless that a public service like the railway should be considering that the people who can’t use apps are, generally, among the most vulnerable in society.

What confuses me here - that I can't find the answer to here - is the meaning of 'closed ticket office'.
Do they mean nobody sitting behind counters, selling tickets?
Or nobody selling tickets at the station at all?

The references to 'ticket machines and apps' seem to imply the latter.

As a technologist myself you absolutely cannot rely on apps and ticket machines! Disability aside all of these things have been down at multiple times. But there have always been staff standing around that could sell you tickets with those handheld machines... The kind that they use for train tickets. Keeping them at the station just not behind the counter is fair enough.

Interestingly most buses don't have ticket offices. And trams don't in Greater Manchester. Why the exception, and furore, over trains?

user1497207191 · 08/07/2023 13:47

badluckorbadvibes · 08/07/2023 12:37

No I wasn't fighting then. I don't relent see why that fact would make this fight any less valid though?

So you didn't care when it was happening to other people and now only care when it's potentially going to affect you?

VegetablesFightingToReclaimTheAubergieneEmoji · 08/07/2023 13:45

LorraineInSpain · 08/07/2023 13:44

Into the bank and then use a card?

That seems easy

LorraineInSpain · 08/07/2023 13:44

VegetablesFightingToReclaimTheAubergieneEmoji · 08/07/2023 13:39

Where do I put my cash?

Into the bank and then use a card?

SouthCountryGirl · 08/07/2023 13:43

user1497207191 · 08/07/2023 11:36

@badluckorbadvibes

The people who NEED these staff are the people we are fighting for.

We you fighting 20-30 years ago when unstaffed stations started to happen more widely? Our local station lost it's ticket office and all platform staff in the mid 90s. Everyone in our town has managed perfectly well ever since - they've had to. Those who can't use apps/websites just pay on the train.

And get through the barrier how?

VegetablesFightingToReclaimTheAubergieneEmoji · 08/07/2023 13:39

MrsEG · 08/07/2023 12:42

I get the train for work (via Manchester Piccadilly and Stockport, as it happens) and haven’t used their ticket office in years. I just buy my tickets on the Trainline app and scan through. Conductors still come along on I’d say 90% of the journeys I’m on to scan tickets. As long as my phone is charged I’m good to go.

Does seem pointless keeping them open when so many people use the ticketing apps these days.

Where do I put my cash?

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 08/07/2023 13:17

Does seem pointless keeping them open when so many people use the ticketing apps these days.

Only if you consider it pointless that a public service like the railway should be considering that the people who can’t use apps are, generally, among the most vulnerable in society.

MrsEG · 08/07/2023 12:42

I get the train for work (via Manchester Piccadilly and Stockport, as it happens) and haven’t used their ticket office in years. I just buy my tickets on the Trainline app and scan through. Conductors still come along on I’d say 90% of the journeys I’m on to scan tickets. As long as my phone is charged I’m good to go.

Does seem pointless keeping them open when so many people use the ticketing apps these days.

Catspyjamas17 · 08/07/2023 12:40

20-30 years ago most Mumsnetters would've been at school!

Swipe left for the next trending thread