Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think they shouldn’t close 1,000 rail ticket offices?

356 replies

TiredArse · 05/07/2023 17:19

Latest plan to ‘improve’ the railways. Up to 1,000 will close.

We’ll be left with those shitty, self service machines that are a pain to use on a good day. Got a disability or struggle to use a machine? Tough shit. Got a query? Tough shit.

Does anyone actually believe that the money saved will reduce fares or improve services?

You can fill in the consultation form here - not easy to see, you have to click on the words ‘consultation response form’. https://www.transportfocus.org.uk/train-station-ticket-office-consultation/

OP posts:
lieselotte · 27/07/2023 10:52

christmaspudding43 · 27/07/2023 10:49

There is no chance any cost savings will be passed on to rail users and I'm surprised anyone would think otherwise given the governments' performance over the years. Did you notice a reduction in your costs when supermarkets moved towards self service? An increase in your savings rate as banks moved more towards online and/or self service machines?

Well quite, it all goes to shareholders.

As for the Equality Act issues, goodness knows how this complies. Ditto moving to apps to pay for car parking.

lieselotte · 27/07/2023 10:51

I wonder how disabled people manage in other countries. When I am in Germany there seem to be more people with visible disabilities using the trains than in the UK and I wonder how they manage to buy tickets when many stations there don't have ticket offices (and quite impenetrable ticket machines). Not sure if they can do more online than we can - they certainly had e-tickets years/decades before we did.

Same in Australia - back in 2009 the stations in Perth didn't have ticket offices and often only took notes of a certain denomination so if you didn't have the right note or card, tough. There were ticket barriers.

christmaspudding43 · 27/07/2023 10:49

There is no chance any cost savings will be passed on to rail users and I'm surprised anyone would think otherwise given the governments' performance over the years. Did you notice a reduction in your costs when supermarkets moved towards self service? An increase in your savings rate as banks moved more towards online and/or self service machines?

Quisquam · 27/07/2023 10:32

We both wanted to fill in the consultation as we know that MIL (deceased this year) would have been unable to use ticket machines (she couldn’t use ATMs, basic mobile phones never mind smart phones, computers; or even a new microwave) and DD1 has learning disabilities. DM is visually impaired and can’t see Kindles, self service till screens, computer screens, etc.

We live outside London, so clicked on the link for outside London. We could not find our station on the list. We realised, it counted as a station within London. We went back to the first page and clicked on the link for London. A list of train lines came up. Our train line is owned by one company; but the line has a different name. We clicked on what we assumed is our line’s new name; and were taken to an email address. We were told to email our views.

I don’t have learning disabilities, so can only imagine what it’s like; but it seemed to us the whole consultation was designed to be impenetrable to anybody but reasonably bright, computer savvy people - who would have no problems operating ticket machines and would therefore agree to the closure of ticket offices.

There was no Easy Read information nor Easy Read questionnaire; as I imagine some people with LD could answer questions with answers in short chunks, where they might struggle to structure all their views in a free form email?

We considered the whole consultation to be discriminatory and in breach of The Equality Act?

If people cannot operate a ticket machine, how are they going to get on the platform to access help from the staff? If a person on crutches needs special assistance, say to carry their suitcase, how are they going to get that help after being dropped off by a taxi outside the station?

Would there be staff on every platform?
Our station has a car park either side. If a frail or disabled person or mother with a buggy) can only find a space in the car park on platform 4 side, do they face having to go up and down the stairs twice to get over the railway bridge to platform 1, if the only member of staff is there and then back again (especially when the lift is broken)?

We all know the number of staff on the stations will be cut!

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 27/07/2023 09:58

Simonjt · 26/07/2023 18:27

Ticket offices being open are vital for my husband, due to his disability he cannot use the machines to buy or retrieve tickets, he can’t put his ticket in the little slot that reads it and opens the barrier, he can’t hold his phone in a position that enables him to scan an e-ticket to open the barriers. Without ticket office staff he can’t actually enter any platforms, so he would have to just stand and wait until one happened to walk by the entrance.

They’ll have to do away with ticket barriers if they’re going to get rid of full time staff in stations.

since the office closed (not officially - the guy that worked in it retired during lockdown and just hasn’t been replaced ‘yet’ apparently) the ticket barriers at our local station have just had to be left permanently open.

Simonjt · 26/07/2023 18:27

Ticket offices being open are vital for my husband, due to his disability he cannot use the machines to buy or retrieve tickets, he can’t put his ticket in the little slot that reads it and opens the barrier, he can’t hold his phone in a position that enables him to scan an e-ticket to open the barriers. Without ticket office staff he can’t actually enter any platforms, so he would have to just stand and wait until one happened to walk by the entrance.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 26/07/2023 18:10

dayslikethese1 · 26/07/2023 18:07

Does this mean that soon all railcards will have to be digital then? Atm I renew mine at the ticket office.

DD renews hers online, but has an actual card sent out (she breaks phones too often to rely on a digital one). I assume they’ll push more and more people into that

dayslikethese1 · 26/07/2023 18:07

Does this mean that soon all railcards will have to be digital then? Atm I renew mine at the ticket office.

lieselotte · 16/07/2023 12:38

MadamWhiteleigh · 14/07/2023 14:28

Don’t listen to the media. Closure of the ticket offices does not mean less staff. They’re just bringing them out from behind the desks. No redundancies are planned. There’ll still be plenty of help available for those who need it.

Well according to the Sunday Times today 2000 redundancies are planned, so so much for no staff losing their jobs.

So we can expect even more strikes.

nasanas · 16/07/2023 10:10

@LorraineInSpain

But not all disabled people will want or need to use a ticket office.

Obviously not, but we are not talking about the people who don't need to use the ticket offices, we are talking about people who do - they are not rare.

Dashdotdotdash · 16/07/2023 10:05

LorraineInSpain · 16/07/2023 09:44

But not all disabled people will want or need to use a ticket office.

Do we need to demonstrate that every disabled person needs a ticket office before making reasonable accommodations for those who do?

Fizbosshoes · 16/07/2023 09:50

Oblomov23 · 16/07/2023 09:30

It's obvious that they are going to close. Everything is becoming nonpersonal these days - banks, closing etc. Nothing we say is going to stop that. They see it as : a very rare disabled person, or an equally rare elderly person who can't use the technology, is just not enough to justify the salary of a person to sit there selling tickets. I get that.

I'm reasonably competent using tech, and do 90% of banking online but I do occassionally need to pay cash or cheques in (yes I know you can on the app but there are limits with how much you can pay, and the cheque paying in facility with barely is very hit and miss - mostly miss!)
Yesterday I had 2 queries with my kids accounts at Metro. The first time we went in it was very busy so we went and did some shopping and went back.We spoke to someone, they opened new accounts and issued cards within about 15 min. To try and do that online or over the phone I'm sure would have taken a lot longer, and been faffy. Other people in there were paying money (coins)in, or querying direct debits. Obviously you can't pay cash in online, and I imagine you'd have to go through a whole load of menus or speak to a chat bot to sort out a direct debit. Even for people who are confortable with tech, and no disabilities there are still many scenarios where you might need to speak to a real person. (In both encounters I saw no one I would think of as elderly sobMN can't really do the usual ageist thing and dismiss it as an "old people who can't use tech" problem)

LorraineInSpain · 16/07/2023 09:44

nasanas · 16/07/2023 09:33

Disabled people are not rare Confused

But not all disabled people will want or need to use a ticket office.

nasanas · 16/07/2023 09:33

Oblomov23 · 16/07/2023 09:30

It's obvious that they are going to close. Everything is becoming nonpersonal these days - banks, closing etc. Nothing we say is going to stop that. They see it as : a very rare disabled person, or an equally rare elderly person who can't use the technology, is just not enough to justify the salary of a person to sit there selling tickets. I get that.

Disabled people are not rare Confused

Oblomov23 · 16/07/2023 09:30

It's obvious that they are going to close. Everything is becoming nonpersonal these days - banks, closing etc. Nothing we say is going to stop that. They see it as : a very rare disabled person, or an equally rare elderly person who can't use the technology, is just not enough to justify the salary of a person to sit there selling tickets. I get that.

Talia99 · 15/07/2023 20:04

User106487665 · 15/07/2023 18:39

I'm an occasional traveller who was put off buying online by the surcharge on Trainline for what was a standard day return

While I definitely think the ticket offices should remain open, you don’t need to use trainline to buy online. If you check the website for your local train company, they probably sell tickets without the surcharge.

User106487665 · 15/07/2023 18:39

I'm an occasional traveller who was put off buying online by the surcharge on Trainline for what was a standard day return

DdraigGoch · 15/07/2023 18:17

Chocolatelabradorsarethebest · 15/07/2023 08:11

I haven’t used a ticket office in years and at my local station (a London suburb) it’s really rarely used. The 2 people that are there full time sit around chatting at the coffee hut or help man the shop/kiosk.

I also hate the generic ‘what about old people’ argument, old people aren’t all helpless and incapable of using a ticket machine! And if they are, there will still be people around to help out. All the ‘what if’ scenarios that get thrown about are probably only going to happen a few times a month and someone will be about to help I’m sure.

The main arguments to keep offices open I’ve heard are from people that use the trains/ the offices once or twice a year, not the commuters and the ones that this change would actually benefit and the ones that pay the most toward the service.

Occasional travellers are precisely the people the railway needs to attract in order to grow. Good experiences will lead to repeat business. Several operators are currently running marketing initiatives directed at occasional travellers so they must think them worth their while.

DdraigGoch · 15/07/2023 18:15

SouthCountryGirl · 15/07/2023 08:04

Some of those tickets can only be purchased at a ticket office.

Some, yes. It's a long way from most. For example someone who is visually impaired or who will be remaining in a wheelchair is entitled to a discount on Anytime tickets, even if they don't have a Disabled Railcard. The only way to purchase these discounted tickets is from a member of staff. Going forward therefore, many people with disabilities will not be able to obtain the discounts they are entitled to.

But then it's not like the government gives a stuff about people with disabilities, is it?

DdraigGoch · 15/07/2023 18:10

Florenz · 15/07/2023 02:58

I can't imagine the train companies being willing to shut ticket offices if it's going to cost them 120 million ticket sales. They're clearly confident that if those people have to buy the tickets by other means, they will do so.

Or they're just doing what the government is telling them to do. The people who benefit the most from staffed stations are the most vulnerable, it costs more to assist them so if the government can discourage them from travelling then it's a saving.

Never mind equality etc., it's beancounting that matters.

Florenz · 15/07/2023 11:32

I don't disagree that train's are a mess in this country. It's a disgrace, we invented the train. We should have the best trains in the world., better than Japan with their "bullet train".

Chesneyhawkes1 · 15/07/2023 10:14

@Florenz the way our franchise works is the government get the revenue from the ticket sales. This is very much a government (RDG) led proposal.

They most certainly won't pass any cost saving on to passengers. They will still put the ticket prices up every year.

Fizbosshoes · 15/07/2023 10:07

FrivolousTreeDuck · 15/07/2023 09:25

using a parking machine to park a car.

Yes, because that's going so well at the moment 😆

People having to download a different app for each car park and mess about with validation emails, or getting scammed into scanning bogus QR codes. Great system.

I parked in a carpark the other day. The machine was broken. I have the app but accidentally put the wrong password in , it wouldn't let me try again so had to request a verification code. That never arrived, so had to request again via email, then put in, go to reset password etc....and had to pay 20p more to park than having to use the machine. The whole thing took 5 or 10 min ....and that's when I already had the app and am reasonably competent about using tech.

FrivolousTreeDuck · 15/07/2023 09:25

using a parking machine to park a car.

Yes, because that's going so well at the moment 😆

People having to download a different app for each car park and mess about with validation emails, or getting scammed into scanning bogus QR codes. Great system.

Bayleaf25 · 15/07/2023 08:27

I’d rather keep the cost of rail travel down and just buy ticket via app / website/ machine (which to be honest I’ve been doing for the last 10 years anyway). I can’t remember the last time I bought a ticket at the station. My more elderly parents are the same. My wheelchair bound friend is very savvy about doing everything online as it suits them.

I’m in Europe on holiday at the moment and it’s very common here too (although admittedly public transport seems top notch compared to the uk). No ticket offices at smaller stations though and seems to function very well.

I suspect it’s happening anyway though and we’ll just get used to it like buying plane tickets online or using a parking machine to park a car.