Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think they shouldn’t close 1,000 rail ticket offices?

356 replies

TiredArse · 05/07/2023 17:19

Latest plan to ‘improve’ the railways. Up to 1,000 will close.

We’ll be left with those shitty, self service machines that are a pain to use on a good day. Got a disability or struggle to use a machine? Tough shit. Got a query? Tough shit.

Does anyone actually believe that the money saved will reduce fares or improve services?

You can fill in the consultation form here - not easy to see, you have to click on the words ‘consultation response form’. https://www.transportfocus.org.uk/train-station-ticket-office-consultation/

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
LlynTegid · 31/10/2023 21:47

As for using machines or buying online, the UK rail fare structure being what it is, I find it easier to book a train journey in Germany from home than one in the UK.

rwalker · 31/10/2023 21:28

they Should keep the offices but it need to be a joint effort they reduced the number of them and staff
and the people who NEED to not want only use them
i was checking the screens next to ticket office the majority of transactions were straight forward ticket on card that could of been done at machines

FrivolousTreeDuck · 31/10/2023 20:21

Ticket office at my station was closed this morning - staff having to help people use the vending machines, which was taking longer than it would have to simply sell them a ticket, and creating long queues.

Not to worry, my train was running 17 minutes late so I had plenty of time ...

DdraigGoch · 31/10/2023 19:32

StamppotAndGravy · 31/10/2023 14:58

The ticket machines are horrendous if you're not local. The last one I used at an airport had 6 different options to go from the airport to the city, only one of which would have been valid on the next train leaving and no indication of which one that was! Without local knowledge of routes, peak hours and operators they're impossible without someone explaining. My English is good but I had to get a member of staff to explain which I wanted. God help anyone who doesn't speak good English

Was it Manchester by any chance?

DdraigGoch · 31/10/2023 19:29

LlynTegid · 31/10/2023 13:14

Ticket offices probably were never going to be closed in large numbers, it was possibly done so the Tories could claim to have listened, and in any case many were in marginal Tory seats. Or if it was the intention, it was to reduce numbers of people in the RMT and other rail unions.

What may happen is that they have reduced hours, and if a staff member is unexpectedly absent, be closed on a particular day.

The view in the DfT and the Treasury is that "no one is travelling by train anymore" (god knows why so many trains are packed around here then) so they thought that they could just get a mass closure over with and no one would notice. They might have rolled back a couple of closures in order to produce a few "minister saves the day" headlines. They weren't expecting the backlash they got, and have now had to abandon the whole plan.

The minister is being incredibly dishonest by claiming that the proposals had come from the operators when in fact the operators have to follow the government's orders.

Flapjacker48 · 31/10/2023 18:36

As expected from the Tories but the government have a bloody cheek. It was the dft who ordered the train companies to come up with these proposals and now they are playing "look we are strong government we have stopped these awful plans produced by the companies"

AutumnCrow · 31/10/2023 15:15

Thank you to everyone who signed petitions, responded to consultations and contacted their MPs Smile

Oh and dear Wera Hobhouse: maybe, just maybe, the 10% of people who need to buy tickets using ticket offices are actually the 'most vulnerable minority', not the blue-haired demo-enfants with their iPhones that you spend all your time championing?

StamppotAndGravy · 31/10/2023 14:58

The ticket machines are horrendous if you're not local. The last one I used at an airport had 6 different options to go from the airport to the city, only one of which would have been valid on the next train leaving and no indication of which one that was! Without local knowledge of routes, peak hours and operators they're impossible without someone explaining. My English is good but I had to get a member of staff to explain which I wanted. God help anyone who doesn't speak good English

wildfirewonder · 31/10/2023 14:54

lieselotte · 31/10/2023 14:39

For the avoidance of doubt, this was the government's idea. They made the rail companies do the consultation. They received 750,000 responses and have had to back down.

People want ticket offices and they want staffed stations.

Yes absolutely. Tory policy, tried and tried to force it through.

Glad they've admitted defeat.

Tories are on a 'limit the losses' strategy now for the next year. There's no point in having this fight now.

OnlyTheBoresKnowItAll · 31/10/2023 14:44

I'm delighted that this ridiculous proposal has been kicked out the door. it would have severely hampered the ability of so many disabled/elderly/ vulnerable people's to go about their day to day lives. What has really pissed me off is how the majority of people just don't give a toss about these groups; made apparent by lots of ' who needs a ticket office , pay on your phone ', 'use your card on the self service machine ', 'oh don't worry about no ticket staff being available for help, just ask anyone ' blah blah . Do people realise that not everyone can do these things?? What about the elderly person who has never used a debit card in their life and who relies on cash payments ? Or the visually impaired person who requires assistance with getting to the platform? Or the young teenage girl who is reassured by the consistent presence of a member of staff when travelling alone at night? I could go on. This smacks of the ' as long as I'm alright jack' attitude which prevails nowadays. When will people start thinking of others?

lieselotte · 31/10/2023 14:39

For the avoidance of doubt, this was the government's idea. They made the rail companies do the consultation. They received 750,000 responses and have had to back down.

People want ticket offices and they want staffed stations.

Arbutusflower · 31/10/2023 14:25

rwalker · 05/07/2023 17:39

We have touch screen ones there brilliant

between buying on line phone apps and self service I don’t think they can final justify having them

In all the years I’ve commuted and used train when kids were small I’ve never needed ticket office

Our touch screen machines often don't work. I had a bruised fingertip after bashing it so hard to actually make it give me a bloody ticket. The woman at our station is a bit of a grumpy mare but at least you can get a ticket and some advice.

It will really disadvantage disabled people, something all those on thread who just want cheap fares ( which won't happen btw) clearly don't give a toss about.

LlynTegid · 31/10/2023 13:14

Ticket offices probably were never going to be closed in large numbers, it was possibly done so the Tories could claim to have listened, and in any case many were in marginal Tory seats. Or if it was the intention, it was to reduce numbers of people in the RMT and other rail unions.

What may happen is that they have reduced hours, and if a staff member is unexpectedly absent, be closed on a particular day.

Pumpkinpie1 · 31/10/2023 13:02

We heavily rely on ticket office. Machines don’t recognise carer discounts and take cash . Often the ticket offices are substantially cheaper fairs whereas the machines and train line are useless
My friends son who has DS has been greatly helped by ticket staff without them many disabled people will be unable to use trains.
But that is the ConPartys intention .

DdraigGoch · 27/07/2023 21:21

Badbadbunny · 27/07/2023 11:20

But how does someone in a ticket office booth help someone being dropped off in a taxi? They don't lock up and come out to help now, do they? Especially when there's only one person in the ticket office. They won't even know that someone's just been dropped off in a taxi.

They do pull the blind down to go out and assist passengers. In some locations that's the only way that a wheelchair user can get to the other platform because the footbridge isn't accessible and they have to be escorted across the track. At single-manned stations it is the booking office clerk who provides this assistance.

How much help do you think Northern's "Journey Makers" will be if they only visit for two hours a day?

DdraigGoch · 27/07/2023 21:15

Badbadbunny · 27/07/2023 11:00

Yes, a small minority, and they will almost certainly become available online or from machines in due course. Just because they have to be bought at a ticket office today, doesn't mean that won't ever change. Just a simple programming change to the ticketing system and hey-presto!

But even ticket machines will probably be obsolete in, say, a decade's time, as you can already buy tickets online and just show your phone screen to the guard, so paper tickets themselves will soon be obsolete.

Well sort that out first, before you start removing staff. Put the horse in front of the cart.

DdraigGoch · 27/07/2023 21:12

The other thing with Germany is that they don't generally have the absurdly complex ticketing system we've got. Between Manchester Airport and Manchester there are nearly two dozen types of ticket you could choose from (not counting Advances). How is a foreign tourist supposed to get the right one out of the machine? Even the natives struggle.

DdraigGoch · 27/07/2023 21:10

lieselotte · 27/07/2023 10:51

I wonder how disabled people manage in other countries. When I am in Germany there seem to be more people with visible disabilities using the trains than in the UK and I wonder how they manage to buy tickets when many stations there don't have ticket offices (and quite impenetrable ticket machines). Not sure if they can do more online than we can - they certainly had e-tickets years/decades before we did.

Same in Australia - back in 2009 the stations in Perth didn't have ticket offices and often only took notes of a certain denomination so if you didn't have the right note or card, tough. There were ticket barriers.

I don't know about Australia but continental Europe is a long way behind us in many locations regarding access for all on trains. There are European Technical Standards for Interoperability covering Persons with Restricted Mobility but they only apply to new trains, whereas in the UK anything non-compliant had to be withdrawn by the end of 2020.

In Germany there are still many stations with ticket offices, in towns as well as cities. In rural areas they sometimes provide the Ticket Vending Machine onboard the train, where the conductor can help you use it. Fare evasion is rife in Germany. These days of course there is a Deutschland-ticket giving unlimited regional travel for €49/month so people don't need to buy tickets unless they are travelling on ICEs. Can you really see the UK government offering unlimited travel for £49/month?

Quisquam · 27/07/2023 12:08

But how does someone in a ticket office booth help someone being dropped off in a taxi? They don't lock up and come out to help now, do they? Especially when there's only one person in the ticket office. They won't even know that someone's just been dropped off in a taxi.

I have never used special assistance myself, but the family used to book it for MIL when she travelled by train to see us; and booked a taxi from her home to the station for her. Most taxis drop people off right outside the main entrance. I'd leave my suitcase where it was, go inside to the ticket office, which is usually just inside the main entrance and ask the ticket office staff for the special assistance, I'd already booked. At our local station, that would mean a walk of approximately eight feet from where the taxi drops you, to the ticket station staff. If the ticket staff were instead deployed to the platforms, how would MIL have got through the ticket barriers, bearing in mind she couldn't use an ATM, never mind a ticket machine; to ask for special assistance from the staff on the platform?

Talia99 · 27/07/2023 11:28

Badbadbunny · 27/07/2023 11:20

But how does someone in a ticket office booth help someone being dropped off in a taxi? They don't lock up and come out to help now, do they? Especially when there's only one person in the ticket office. They won't even know that someone's just been dropped off in a taxi.

Yes? I don’t know about where you are but at my local one-man station, he sticks up a card saying ‘back soon’ and goes to help.

At larger stations, the ticket office person uses a radio to summons assistance. I accept that doesn’t get someone from the taxi drop off to the ticket office but it solves the other problems.

Badbadbunny · 27/07/2023 11:20

SouthCountryGirl · 27/07/2023 11:09

"If people cannot operate a ticket machine, how are they going to get on the platform to access help from the staff? If a person on crutches needs special assistance, say to carry their suitcase, how are they going to get that help after being dropped off by a taxi outside the station?"

I've argued this. Apparently, there will be staff hanging around the ticket machines.

Some people have said there'd be staff on the platform. But as a visually impaired person I don't want to be wandering around a station trying to find someone. If I can't find anyone at the gate, I'll go (and have been told to by Transport for Wales) to the ticket office.

But how does someone in a ticket office booth help someone being dropped off in a taxi? They don't lock up and come out to help now, do they? Especially when there's only one person in the ticket office. They won't even know that someone's just been dropped off in a taxi.

SouthCountryGirl · 27/07/2023 11:09

"If people cannot operate a ticket machine, how are they going to get on the platform to access help from the staff? If a person on crutches needs special assistance, say to carry their suitcase, how are they going to get that help after being dropped off by a taxi outside the station?"

I've argued this. Apparently, there will be staff hanging around the ticket machines.

Some people have said there'd be staff on the platform. But as a visually impaired person I don't want to be wandering around a station trying to find someone. If I can't find anyone at the gate, I'll go (and have been told to by Transport for Wales) to the ticket office.

Badbadbunny · 27/07/2023 11:00

SouthCountryGirl · 15/07/2023 08:04

Some of those tickets can only be purchased at a ticket office.

Yes, a small minority, and they will almost certainly become available online or from machines in due course. Just because they have to be bought at a ticket office today, doesn't mean that won't ever change. Just a simple programming change to the ticketing system and hey-presto!

But even ticket machines will probably be obsolete in, say, a decade's time, as you can already buy tickets online and just show your phone screen to the guard, so paper tickets themselves will soon be obsolete.

Badbadbunny · 27/07/2023 10:56

None of our local stations have manned ticket offices anymore anyway. People seem to cope absolutely fine. Our nearest small village station must have lost it's ticket office in the 80s, and the other two (small towns) maybe in the noughties. People buy tickets at the machines or from the guard on the train.