Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Have people just got a lot better at baking?

156 replies

Sunflowering · 05/07/2023 15:22

Or is it just me?

When I was little (born late 70s) home baking was a popular pastime but generally the things people made weren't that brilliant- homemade bread was always like a brick, homemade cake was generally an overcooked sponge that had gone a bit wrong or rock cakes. Or chocolate cake made by swapping a spoonful of flour for cocoa. All gratefully eaten by me obviously but pretty hit and miss.

Now everyone I know who bakes (including myself) makes things which are pretty much as good as you'd get from a professional baker. Homemade bread is a treat. Cakes are almost always perfect and far more elaborate than anyone would have attempted at home in the 70s-80s.

Just wondered if other people had found this? I can think of various reasons- the popularity of baking shows as inspiration, the internet as a source of knowledge, people maybe spending more on ingredients, more reliable ovens etc. But I wondered whether other people had noticed the phenomenon. Maybe my mum and her friends were just shit cooks, but even my mum has upped her game now.

OP posts:
LittleBrownJug · 05/07/2023 17:14

Catspyjamas17 · 05/07/2023 15:54

No. I went to a school bake sale recently and it was very hit and miss. Mostly miss.

Our DC must go to the same school 😐

itme · 05/07/2023 17:14

I actually really miss golf old home baking. It’s all a bit overblown and fancy now. I don’t like cupcakes with huge whirls of sickly buttercream - I want little fairy cakes with a bit of glacé icing and some jelly diamonds, or some little scones (not the huge ones you get now). And I was only thinking the other day that I haven’t had or made rock cakes for nearly 40 years. That’s what I’ll do this weekend - bake rock cakes and that chocolate concrete stuff that you used to get for school dinners.

My mum used to bake bread in the 80s and it was always delicious and her cakes were good too - I think some people had the knack and some didn’t but it depended upon how you’d been taught to make as there was no internet for people to look at to teach themselves.

Rottenapples · 05/07/2023 17:11

I think it’s that internet recipes come with ratings and reviews and comments saying what works well and what doesn’t. Back in the day the recipe was out of a magazine or book and you had no idea of it was shit till you tried it. Nowadays you can trawl the internet for a recipe with thousands of 5 star reviews and tips on the comments from people who’ve tried it and how to spruce the recipe up even further.

BellaTheDarkOverlord · 05/07/2023 17:10

The only times I've ever had to bake something for school I always made cornflake buns. Cheap chocolate, cheap cornflakes and bun cases. Maybe a mini egg on top if lucky. According to DC these were the first things snapped up by the kids at school 😂Why go to all that trouble if all the kids want are cornflake buns.

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 05/07/2023 17:07

I think more people are baking than I ever remember and baking more ambitious items

Often with home bakers I've found it's style over substance though ... beautifully cooked Victoria sponge say or scones are still a skill.

Saying that a lady I work with must be Mary Berry's long lost sister ... she made malt loaf a few weeks ago. She handed it round and it was just a Joyful Silence all round as we slowly ate it Grin

pontipinemum · 05/07/2023 17:04

I am not much of a baker. But I have discovered a very easy Mary Berry chocolate cake. I worked it out, because I am like that, it takes €2.11 for me to make it. I put all the ingredients into my food processor, then into the tin and into the ninja for 30 minutes. And yay, I have a beautiful, non chemically tasting cake for afternoon breaks all week.

So the internet gave me the recipe and kitchen appliances made it fool proof for me.

StrictlyAFemaleFemale · 05/07/2023 17:03

I think they look prettier, dunno if they taste better. I'm not really a cake person. Although dd8 and I love watching is it cake on Netflix.

itsapalaver · 05/07/2023 16:58

As others have said, ovens are better, equipment is better ( my nan used to beat her butter and sugar with a wooden spoon and as a result had arms like a Russian shot putter) whereas now I use an electric mixer.

Plus people use the internet for inspo/presentation.

Cassandra9 · 05/07/2023 16:58

I disagree. I think it’s all show now and tend to taste awful and most of the time are just over complicated for no real benefit. The amount of homemade soggy/dense/dry cakes I’ve sampled in recent years is shocking. It tends to be somebody who thinks of themselves as a good baker so everyone tells them it’s lovely to not hurt their feelings and they carry on with confidence. A lot of cafes also serve synthetic tasting cake that your grandmother would be ashamed of. I think our mothers and grandmothers were far superior in the kitchen and actually understood how to bake properly.

WiddlinDiddlin · 05/07/2023 16:57

I don't know that I agree that access to decent ingredients is 'spoiling' us... we used to eat stuff that tasted like fuck all (particularly chocolate sponges that were just brown and did not taste like chocolate at all!)...

I do think access to cooking videos makes a huge difference. Lots of people learn better from seeing, rather than reading, and seeing what each stage is meant to look like can REALLY help avoid disasters!

sevenbyseven · 05/07/2023 16:56

My mum made lovely cakes, but not particularly fancy ones with decorative icing etc.

I still prefer an old-school fairy cake with some lemon glacé icing than a huge cupcake with piped buttercream though 🤷‍♀️

BrioNotBiro · 05/07/2023 16:55

I did a simple chocolate Victoria sponge like I would have done decades ago, and as you say OP, substituting a couple of spoons of flour for cocoa. It was so disappointing!

We are so spoilt by rich brownies, devil's food cake, ganaches etc now a simple chocolate sponge doesn't cut it.

HappiDaze · 05/07/2023 16:50

GBBO and lockdown gave us more confidence and time

Failingjuggler · 05/07/2023 16:47

I think people put a lot more effort in these days instead of being ‘better’

hiredandsqueak · 05/07/2023 16:47

I've always baked, I remember baking from dm's Bero book. It's easier now with electric scales, stand mixers, food processors, more accurate ovens. I bake mostly because we don't like cake smothered in frosting and icing. For school bake sales my little iced fairy cakes with sweets or sprinkles always sold well.

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 05/07/2023 16:39

MrsLilaAmes · 05/07/2023 16:34

I think we forget that the recipes being baked in the 70s were still very heavily influenced by rationing- a generation had grown up being used to the idea that it wasn’t what you were willing to spend on butter and eggs that was the limiting factor, but simply that there was a hard limit on how much you could ever have. Recipes made with one egg are always going to be stodgy compared to recipes made with four.

Not in my experience. My family just reverted to the old recipes as soon as the ingredients were freely available again.

AlwaysRequiresImprovement · 05/07/2023 16:38

This thread has inspired me to bake a strawberry and white chocolate cake loaf 😂

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 05/07/2023 16:35

I think decorating has got better because of the cheap piping/moulding/decorating equipment and endless step by step tutorials available.

Have the cakes underneath all that bumf improved? I'd say the opposite. Everything is style over substance and often tastes crap, but it's perfect for taking a picture and posting on social media.

Completely agree. I don't like lots of icing and I hate dry cake. If I'm going to eat something calorific, I want it to taste good and be a real treat. Sweet, sickly icing does nothing for me.

As an aside, one of the many reasons so many people are now overweight must surely be the huge size of muffins and cookies (US imports in both cases) and the enormous amount of icing sugar and fat used to decorate them, often washed down with sugary drinks. Bring back the small fairy cakes with a blob of glace icing and half a glace cherry!

Also, I was born in the early 1960s and I can confirm:

  1. We had cake mix in shops back in the 60s and 70s.
  2. We had electric hand whisks. It's a mystery to me why anybody needs an expensive machine on a stand when a cheap hand whisk and a big mixing bowl do a perfectly good job and are much easier to store.
  3. We had decent recipe books. Delia Smith got going in the 1970s and is still my favourite because her recipes always work.
  4. Many, many children (probably mostly girls) learned to bake at home. I did. All the women in my family were excellent plain cooks and bakers.
  5. Most girls (not many boys, to be fair) learned how to do simple baking at school. My mum didn't make shortcrust pastry but I learned that in Home Economics lessons.
MrsLilaAmes · 05/07/2023 16:34

I think we forget that the recipes being baked in the 70s were still very heavily influenced by rationing- a generation had grown up being used to the idea that it wasn’t what you were willing to spend on butter and eggs that was the limiting factor, but simply that there was a hard limit on how much you could ever have. Recipes made with one egg are always going to be stodgy compared to recipes made with four.

AwfulSomething · 05/07/2023 16:33

I haven't baked since school Home Ec classes! Sounds like it has all moved on since the day of wholemeal scones so hard they would make impressive weapons

Handholdplease85 · 05/07/2023 16:33

@henrypenry maybe it’s just my area. I have been to numerous kids parties and I can only remember there being one obviously supermarket-bought cake. All the others were either professional cakes to fit with the party theme (Frozen etc) or homemade to an Instagram-level (multiple tiers, ombré icing, or elaborate decorations etc. Not necessarily matched in flavour though… didn’t try them myself!)

littleripper · 05/07/2023 16:32

baking is like cycling. It used to just be what people did, some more than others, some better than others. Now it is a fancy hobby and competitive and expensive as a result

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 05/07/2023 16:29

Well, of course?

There's a million different websites with recipes, your bog-standard cook books for the purists, and bake off and it's supporting websites, books, tiktoks etc. We've never been more surrounded by support and easy to follow recipes.

Gymmum82 · 05/07/2023 16:29

@PuttingDownRoots i agree with you. I cannot bake. My cakes never turn out how I hope. But I’m pretty epic at decorating. Luckily I only make kids birthday cakes and they don’t seem to care what it tastes like so my secret is safe

ShakeYourFeathers · 05/07/2023 16:24

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request