Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think that downloading hundreds of sexual and abusive images of children should mean jail?

132 replies

Countdowntowinter · 05/07/2023 14:42

YABU - there should not be jail time for some who download hundreds of images of child abuse

YANBU - downloading hundreds of images of sexual abuse of children should mean jail

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Countdowntowinter · 06/07/2023 12:29

So, "Ian Taylor, chair of the bench of magistrates, said: "These offences would normally attract immediate custody. However, because of the time lag, no reoffending and because probation feel they can rehabilitate you it's going to be an unusual sentence because we're going to suspend the sentence."
Mr Taylor added it did not detract from how serious these matters were with children being "subjected to horrific acts". They also stated "they had decided to suspend a 12 month jail term, something they conceded was "unusual".

The reason there was a time lag was because the person was trans. It clearly states that:
"The case had been adjourned following an application by Norfolk Probation Service for an extension to complete reports, including referring the case to the Transgender Case Board.
This was introduced in 2017 to make decisions about the appropriate location and management of transgender prisoners.
A ban on trans women with male genitalia who are violent or sexual offenders serving sentences in female prisons came into force earlier this year."

Therefore, if the case wasn't delayed then they are saying that they would not have taken this action. The delay was due to it being trans. There you go - different treatment due to being trans which led to the delay which meant no prison which they said was unusual....

The actual offences were:

  1. having dozens of indecent images of children has been spared jail after magistrates said they took an "unusual" decision.
  2. A separate charge of possessing 100 "grossly offensive" extreme pornographic images and videos on the same date."

However, it was in a dark place at the time (any paedophile could use this one)
Only trans could have the Transgender Case Board have a look at their cases though.

Thanks for the voting.

I ignore the abuse, since not worth engaging with a person who brushes aside concerns and responds with personal abuse. Thanks to others who engaged without abuse.

OP posts:
Flickersy · 06/07/2023 10:55

Naunet · 06/07/2023 10:23

He has still committed a crime and has responsibility for it. But the risk of reoffending and to the public is substantially lower where a crime is committed when judgement is impaired. Therefore the sentencing usually reflects that

Nope, sentencing should be based on the crime already committed, not the likelyhood of reoffending.

This person was convicted for possession of images, not for abuse of a child. From a legal perspective it is hard to take the impact on the victim into account when the victims are not present in court, unidentified, and of unknown status

Im very clearly not talking about this specific case but the fact you just typed that as if there’s a chance the children are undamaged by what was done to them, is pretty fucking shocking. Do you have any interest in the impact child abuse has on a victim, is your concern only with the paedos? Maybe try reading some studies on the impact it has on children for the rest of their lives and educate yourself on the other side of this issue.

Paedophila is a complex disorder which is not very well understood compared to others (understandably, people are reluctant to study it or to take part in such studies). There is no single answer to why men and women present with it at different rates

Umm, seems to imply that maybe mental health is just the excuse then, not the cause.

Nope, sentencing should be based on the crime already committed, not the likelyhood of reoffending

It is. And then it is adjusted to take into account various factors.

Im very clearly not talking about this specific case but the fact you just typed that as if there’s a chance the children are undamaged by what was done to them, is pretty fucking shocking. Do you have any interest in the impact child abuse has on a victim, is your concern only with the paedos? Maybe try reading some studies on the impact it has on children for the rest of their lives and educate yourself on the other side of this issue.

The key part in my post is "from a legal perspective". We know the horrendous damage sexual abuse causes, that goes without saying. But in court if you don't have a victim or know who the victim is, whether they're still living, where they are, it is very hard to gather victim impact statements. It is often the case with child abuse images that identification of the victims is impossible.

Naunet · 06/07/2023 10:49

@Flickersy
Paedophila is a complex disorder which is not very well understood compared to others (understandably, people are reluctant to study it or to take part in such studies). There is no single answer to why men and women present with it at different rates

You know this undoes everything you’ve said so far? It’s not understood, but we can let a judge decide their chance of reoffending, we can use mental health (even when undiagnosed because apparently a paedo would never lie) to give a lighter sentence because even though paedophilia is hugely under studied, we can be sure that this undiagnosed mental health issue definitely can make a man suddenly become a paedo? Seems like you just say whatever works best to defend these men - understudied when it suits them, but full of ‘facts’ when it doesn’t.

You write as if you’re some kind of expert on the topic but haven’t discussed the impact on children once and only got your knowledge from reading the news it seems.

A combination of arrogance and ignorance is never good.

Naunet · 06/07/2023 10:23

Flickersy · 06/07/2023 10:15

So do you think a man who abuses a child and has depression, is somehow not responsible for his crime?

He has still committed a crime and has responsibility for it. But the risk of reoffending and to the public is substantially lower where a crime is committed when judgement is impaired. Therefore the sentencing usually reflects that.

Should the impact on the child and their mental health be given just as much consideration, or no?

This person was convicted for possession of images, not for abuse of a child. From a legal perspective it is hard to take the impact on the victim into account when the victims are not present in court, unidentified, and of unknown status.

Why do you think women don’t behave in the same way?

Paedophila is a complex disorder which is not very well understood compared to others (understandably, people are reluctant to study it or to take part in such studies). There is no single answer to why men and women present with it at different rates.

He has still committed a crime and has responsibility for it. But the risk of reoffending and to the public is substantially lower where a crime is committed when judgement is impaired. Therefore the sentencing usually reflects that

Nope, sentencing should be based on the crime already committed, not the likelyhood of reoffending.

This person was convicted for possession of images, not for abuse of a child. From a legal perspective it is hard to take the impact on the victim into account when the victims are not present in court, unidentified, and of unknown status

Im very clearly not talking about this specific case but the fact you just typed that as if there’s a chance the children are undamaged by what was done to them, is pretty fucking shocking. Do you have any interest in the impact child abuse has on a victim, is your concern only with the paedos? Maybe try reading some studies on the impact it has on children for the rest of their lives and educate yourself on the other side of this issue.

Paedophila is a complex disorder which is not very well understood compared to others (understandably, people are reluctant to study it or to take part in such studies). There is no single answer to why men and women present with it at different rates

Umm, seems to imply that maybe mental health is just the excuse then, not the cause.

Flickersy · 06/07/2023 10:15

Naunet · 06/07/2023 09:59

Yes, increase the risk of acting on paedophilic urges, not create those urges in the first place. Bit different.

So do you think a man who abuses a child and has depression, is somehow not responsible for his crime? Should the impact on the child and their mental health be given just as much consideration, or no? Why do you think women don’t behave in the same way?

So do you think a man who abuses a child and has depression, is somehow not responsible for his crime?

He has still committed a crime and has responsibility for it. But the risk of reoffending and to the public is substantially lower where a crime is committed when judgement is impaired. Therefore the sentencing usually reflects that.

Should the impact on the child and their mental health be given just as much consideration, or no?

This person was convicted for possession of images, not for abuse of a child. From a legal perspective it is hard to take the impact on the victim into account when the victims are not present in court, unidentified, and of unknown status.

Why do you think women don’t behave in the same way?

Paedophila is a complex disorder which is not very well understood compared to others (understandably, people are reluctant to study it or to take part in such studies). There is no single answer to why men and women present with it at different rates.

badluckorbadvibes · 06/07/2023 10:11

Going to prison mostly does not cure anyone of anything so it's a good question what will.

Nothing will cure them, that why they need locked up. To protect our children.

Highdaysandholidays1 · 06/07/2023 10:07

The original post only asked if viewing child sex abuse should be punishable by jail. It is not strange, then, to suggest that even if the answer is yes, that the sheer quantity (over a 1000 a month) of prosecutions is making viewing CSA alone something that's likely not always to be punishable by prison just for sheer logistics (and lots of evidence is backed up and unlooked at as it's so hard to process this quantity of material). It's also related to the 'badness' of the images which is calculated in levels (god help the poor people who have to view it and categorise these).

Going to prison mostly does not cure anyone of anything so it's a good question what will. It also does signal societal disgust, which is positive, but it also then means those individuals are less able to be integrated back into society (e.g. for work or housing), which can make them more dangerous and hang with others on the same disgusting margins.

The trans issue did not come up til later.

Naunet · 06/07/2023 09:59

Flickersy · 06/07/2023 09:45

It's well understood that mental health issues can increase the risk of acting on paedophilic urges. This is not news and it should be obvious (to anyone with a modicum of common sense) that someone who is mentally impaired is more likely than someone who isn't to do horrible things.

https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/article-abstract/195539

In the off chance that you are genuinely interested, this is a study that is just over 20 years old.

Yes, increase the risk of acting on paedophilic urges, not create those urges in the first place. Bit different.

So do you think a man who abuses a child and has depression, is somehow not responsible for his crime? Should the impact on the child and their mental health be given just as much consideration, or no? Why do you think women don’t behave in the same way?

Flickersy · 06/07/2023 09:45

Naunet · 06/07/2023 09:36

So no evidence that mental health issues lead to brain changes that create a new desire in men to watch children being raped? How unsurprising.

It's well understood that mental health issues can increase the risk of acting on paedophilic urges. This is not news and it should be obvious (to anyone with a modicum of common sense) that someone who is mentally impaired is more likely than someone who isn't to do horrible things.

https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/article-abstract/195539

In the off chance that you are genuinely interested, this is a study that is just over 20 years old.

Pedophilia

This article addresses the risk factors associated with the psychiatric disorder pedophilia, its treatment, and treatment outcomes. It addresses physician responsibilities associated with case identification of victims and possible roles in the medical...

https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/article-abstract/195539

Naunet · 06/07/2023 09:36

Flickersy · 06/07/2023 09:32

It is obvious to anyone who reads the news or has a basic knowledge of mental illness that mental health problems can cause people to do horrible, irrational, incomprehensible things. There was that awful case of Emily Jones, a young girl killed in a park by someone who was in the depths of paranoid schizophrenia.

Given your attitude and insults I expect I would be wasting my time trying to explain the legal process any further.

So no evidence that mental health issues lead to brain changes that create a new desire in men to watch children being raped? How unsurprising.

Flickersy · 06/07/2023 09:32

Naunet · 06/07/2023 09:27

I’m not talking about sentencing, I’m talking about YOU acting as if some kind of self diagnosed ‘dark place’ is an excuse for looking at children being raped. Can you link to studies which clarify which mental health problems lead to a desire to wank off over children being tortured and raped? Why don’t those conditions seem to take hold of women? What health conditions make a man do that?
You seem to think your very wise on this topic so I’m sure you’ll have all the details…

It is obvious to anyone who reads the news or has a basic knowledge of mental illness that mental health problems can cause people to do horrible, irrational, incomprehensible things. There was that awful case of Emily Jones, a young girl killed in a park by someone who was in the depths of paranoid schizophrenia.

Given your attitude and insults I expect I would be wasting my time trying to explain the legal process any further.

Countdowntowinter · 06/07/2023 09:28

WomblingTree86 · 05/07/2023 17:26

I know someone who was downloading and also distributing images of sexually abused children and they still didn't get jail so I doubt it is highly unusual for no prison or anything to do with this person being trans.

I also know of someone who was a gay male in his 20's and he was sent to jail and first offence. So I guess some parts of the country may let people 'off' and others not.

However, this individual was given consideration by the 'transgender board' and other straight or gay people are not. So this individual was given consideration due to 'it' being trans. A separate board to look at the crime. Perhaps just look at the crime and ignore what the perpetrator feels 'it' is.

OP posts:
Naunet · 06/07/2023 09:27

Flickersy · 06/07/2023 09:23

You don't seem to understand how sentencing for crimes (all crimes) works in this country.

An offenders mental state is taken into account where appropriate. For example, someone in the grip of psychosis who is a first time offender (for any crime) is unlikely to repeat that when they are in a healthy state of mind. Therefore prison is not necessarily the correct sentence, as they may be helped more effectively by proper treatment, and the risk to the public is low.

The sentencing would be different for a persistent offender who has no history of mental health difficulties.

I’m not talking about sentencing, I’m talking about YOU acting as if some kind of self diagnosed ‘dark place’ is an excuse for looking at children being raped. Can you link to studies which clarify which mental health problems lead to a desire to wank off over children being tortured and raped? Why don’t those conditions seem to take hold of women? What health conditions make a man do that?
You seem to think your very wise on this topic so I’m sure you’ll have all the details…

Flickersy · 06/07/2023 09:23

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

You don't seem to understand how sentencing for crimes (all crimes) works in this country.

An offenders mental state is taken into account where appropriate. For example, someone in the grip of psychosis who is a first time offender (for any crime) is unlikely to repeat that when they are in a healthy state of mind. Therefore prison is not necessarily the correct sentence, as they may be helped more effectively by proper treatment, and the risk to the public is low.

The sentencing would be different for a persistent offender who has no history of mental health difficulties.

Countdowntowinter · 06/07/2023 09:17

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 05/07/2023 18:23

Thanks Florissante

I'm sure I'll be accused of transphobia by at least one poster here but this is wrong. Apart from the fact that crime is horrific crime stats are being skewed because apparently this piece of male bodied scum believes he is a woman and the system seems happy to take his word for it.

This is my concern.

  1. That a paedophile was given special consideration by the transgender board so not looked at in the same way.
  2. That the offender was listed as a 'woman' rather than under 'its' biological sex of male - this means that more crimes are being shown as by women when they are not committed by women.
  3. I'm also concerned that people will stick up for anything if the person says they are 'trans'. Even paedophilia.

All crimes of this nature are sick. Whether by a man who says he is a man or a man who feels he is a woman. The problem is hiding behind 'trans' and pretending this was a woman's crime, being listed as a women's crime and not be sentenced to prison because the transgender board looked at it separately to a crime committed by a man (which is was).

OP posts:
badluckorbadvibes · 06/07/2023 09:16

This is common where I live, the local paper is full of court reports of cases juts like this with no custodial sentence.

Countdowntowinter · 06/07/2023 09:09

I'm not sure how deranged it is to be very concerned about a paedophile not being given a sentence since it describes himself as a 'women'. Seems there are people out there willing to stand up for paedophiles if they describe themselves as 'trans'.

For the record @Failingjuggler as another poster said:

*"obviously a trans issue.

"A transgender woman caught with indecent images of children was spared jail after her case was delayed so a decision could be made on whether she should be housed in a male or female prison...."

It's gone to the Transgender Case Board so they can decide whether this man's feelings should be deemed more important than women prisoner's human rights, feelings and safety, and their privacy and dignity and respect for their mental health and rehabilitation prospects. Additionally, the human rights of the prison staff who'll be required to deal with him.

Do hope you're not still here. We're very very tired of women simping for men with lady feelz."*

You can scream abuse at me as much as you want. The only person who deserves punishment or abusive comment is the person who sat down and watched hundreds of images of CHILDREN being abused and enjoyed it until 'it' was caught and given a non custodial sentence. CHILDREN are what matters here, not the feelings of the paedophile.

The reason it's a trans issue is that crime was committed by a trans and the 'transgender case board' decided on a punishment, so separate considerations for the trans perpetrator due to 'it' being trans. 'It' is beneath contempt and sick in the head. But you carry on supporting 'it' and abusing me for being concerned!

OP posts:
Naunet · 06/07/2023 08:17

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

EmmaGrundyForPM · 06/07/2023 01:17

@Whatifitallgoesright I think the point being made is that, although this particular perpetrator is trans, loads of men get non custodial sentences for similar offences. So he's not being treated any more lightly just because he's trans.

The sentencing guidelines are a joke. There is no recognition that the people (the vast majority of whom are male) downloading/buying this horrendous stuff are fuelling child abuse.

TooBigForMyBoots · 05/07/2023 23:50

WTF is the Transgender Case Board?

Whatifitallgoesright · 05/07/2023 23:11

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Literally NOT lying, obviously a trans issue.

"A transgender woman caught with indecent images of children was spared jail after her case was delayed so a decision could be made on whether she should be housed in a male or female prison...."

It's gone to the Transgender Case Board so they can decide whether this man's feelings should be deemed more important than women prisoner's human rights, feelings and safety, and their privacy and dignity and respect for their mental health and rehabilitation prospects. Additionally, the human rights of the prison staff who'll be required to deal with him.

Do hope you're not still here. We're very very tired of women simping for men with lady feelz.

JuvenileEmu · 05/07/2023 21:31

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I seem over invested? On a thread about a convicted paedophile, where you've chosen to be abusive to a woman upset by a person found guilty of watching children being raped for fun? I would hope that any normal adult would be invested yes. Your behaviour on the other hand, is really disturbing.

Failingjuggler · 05/07/2023 21:24

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

JuvenileEmu · 05/07/2023 21:12

@Failingjuggler in an attempt to have some kind of reasonable discussion with you (I realise almost certainly impossible), I had a look at the CUP dictionary website. The definition they give is :

Meaning of deranged in English

deranged
adjective
UK /dɪˈreɪndʒd/ US /dɪˈreɪndʒd/
completely unable to think clearly or behave in a controlled way, especially because of mental illness:
a deranged criminal/mind/personality
to be mentally deranged
Synonym
crazed
Related word
derangement

None of this is applicable to the OP, and I think rather than repeatedly call the OP deranged it might be helpful if you tried to explain what it is about her posts that you consider to be "deranged".

I've done some more reading about the case due to this thread, and it does seem that the sentencing judge referred to the paedophile being trans as a factor in deciding not to send them to prison.

Failingjuggler · 05/07/2023 21:01

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.