Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School mum claiming her child has 'inherited' her binge eating disorder

298 replies

Geraniumgal · 05/07/2023 13:31

My daughters class had an end of term tea party yesterday. Typical kids party foods were shared out. However one child was literally grabbing and eating every biscuit she could get her hands on.
This went on for over 20mins and I'm sorry to say it was upsetting to watch. The little girl is 7 and already clearly overweight.

Her Mum arrived to collect her and myself and a few parents mentioned her daughter had only really eaten the biscuits and cake so she knew she hadn't eaten a proper tea.
Mum just laughed it off basically claiming she seems to have inherited her own binge eating.

The child is 7! Is this in any way normal?

OP posts:
Fairislefandango · 05/07/2023 15:45

However, I think the parent in the OPs example was reacting defensively to a bunch of parents being pretend-caring smug.

^This. You can do literally nothing about this, so why comment? Do you actually think it's going to help the little girl? Of course it's not. It's just going to make the mum feel bad, which no doubt she already does.

Coralsunset · 05/07/2023 15:44

nokidshere · 05/07/2023 14:22

This went on for over 20mins and I'm sorry to say it was upsetting to watch.

So upsetting that you stood by and did/said nothing? Just watched? Then had the audacity to tell the child's mother about it when she arrived? Oh you and 'a few others' who apparently incapable of supervising a child's party.

The mother was probably mortified at your utter rudeness and made some flippant comment - in private where everyone could hear.

You are most definitely the unreasonable one in this scenario

Yes I agree with this.

I hope you and your friends enjoyed yourselves.

Geraniumgal · 05/07/2023 15:44

OK to clarify. The Mum was given the heads up that the only food items her child had eaten were biscuits. So she knew she had not eaten a substantial tea. This was said Privately.
The Mum collected her child and the MUM said in front of HER child I think she has got her Binge Eating Disorder from me. The child and mum laughed.
No Shaming Took Place.

OP posts:
Chocolateship · 05/07/2023 15:43

Hibiscrubbed · 05/07/2023 15:20

I guarantee that if the thread was about a child who refused to eat because they said they didn’t want to be fat, and then a very slim mother turned up to collect her, whatever the OP did, posters would be laying into the mother for ‘projecting clear ED onto her daughter’.

Exactly. Whenever a child is overweight though the responses are always along the lines of mind your own business even though its a form of abuse. Poor child.

ElEmEnOhPee · 05/07/2023 15:43

Maybe the child is overeating to deal with emotions of being bullied by the children of mothers who see fit to comment on the weight of other children within earshot. Bullying, just like being overweight, can be a learnt behaviour.

MammaTo · 05/07/2023 15:41

It sounds like a passing comment from a mum who’s probably conscious of her own weight.

Why do some people make mountains out of mole hills.

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 05/07/2023 15:40

I'd only read the goady OP but have now read the thread. I'm so glad that other posters see this crap for what it is.

Mariposista · 05/07/2023 15:39

hollybubs · 05/07/2023 15:36

Is 'shaming' really such a bad thing? We've been doing it for as long as humans have existed.

It's a social mechanism that helps people make better choices. We judge others for all sorts of things, and generally there are good reasons for it. People seem to prefer the idea of the government stepping in to enforce behaviour!

It is bloody awful that such a young child should be so overweight, and the poor girl is facing a lifetime of bad health and unhappiness.

Nothing else seems to stop these people from ruining their children's health.

This!

Hibiscrubbed · 05/07/2023 15:39

How do people propose tackling the ‘obesity crisis’ if talking about it, or even showing concern is rebranded as ‘gleeful fat shaming’?

What measures should be taken?

nokidshere · 05/07/2023 15:37

Nothing the OP has said suggests they were standing around gossiping and shaming the child. The mum was spoken to privately.

If the mum was spoken to privately why did it take more than one person (ie not private) and how could the child have overheard?

hollybubs · 05/07/2023 15:36

Is 'shaming' really such a bad thing? We've been doing it for as long as humans have existed.

It's a social mechanism that helps people make better choices. We judge others for all sorts of things, and generally there are good reasons for it. People seem to prefer the idea of the government stepping in to enforce behaviour!

It is bloody awful that such a young child should be so overweight, and the poor girl is facing a lifetime of bad health and unhappiness.

Nothing else seems to stop these people from ruining their children's health.

MotherofGorgons · 05/07/2023 15:34

Geraniumgal · 05/07/2023 13:53

My point is if a child hears a parent using the term binge eating disorder to excuse excessive over eating it then normalises it for the child. It's not language that should be used around children surely?

It's a joke. Lighten up. She doesn't mean it literally.

bellac11 · 05/07/2023 15:34

Hibiscrubbed · 05/07/2023 15:31

Then to make it worse, you and your clique of school mums decide to single out the parent and the child by shaming her. I can almost hear the whispers between you all, each time that child reached in for another biscuit.

Multiple posters are making this sort of scenario up in order to prop up their own outrage that someone has dared be upset and worried about an overweight child displaying unhealthy behaviours around food.

Why? Is it a reflection on some posters’ own relationships with food? I can only assume so.

Nothing the OP has said suggests they were standing around gossiping and shaming the child. The mum was spoken to privately.

I just don’t understand why, as has been seen on other threads that I will see if I can find when I get a moment, there is always considerably less sympathy for people at the other end of the weight scale.

Good try but the mum was very clearly NOT spoken to privately its there in the OP. And the child was in earshot, again not private

And overweight children are definitely a concern, no one is saying otherwise, but there are appropriate people who need to deal with that, and a group of school mums at a birthday party are not those people

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 05/07/2023 15:32

CarrieO · 05/07/2023 13:40

The Mum will be well aware of her daughter’s eating and may just not want to discuss them with a bunch of other school parents who are commenting on them, and so laughed it off and made a joke.

I think this too. I can imagine the glee (and I don't buy 'upsetting' for a single second).

Hibiscrubbed · 05/07/2023 15:31

Then to make it worse, you and your clique of school mums decide to single out the parent and the child by shaming her. I can almost hear the whispers between you all, each time that child reached in for another biscuit.

Multiple posters are making this sort of scenario up in order to prop up their own outrage that someone has dared be upset and worried about an overweight child displaying unhealthy behaviours around food.

Why? Is it a reflection on some posters’ own relationships with food? I can only assume so.

Nothing the OP has said suggests they were standing around gossiping and shaming the child. The mum was spoken to privately.

I just don’t understand why, as has been seen on other threads that I will see if I can find when I get a moment, there is always considerably less sympathy for people at the other end of the weight scale.

Hayliebells · 05/07/2023 15:30

I mean yes, it's not good to have a binge eating disorder, and then when through modelling that behaviour, the child does it too. The mum probably realises it's not good for her, not good for her daughter, so was making a light-hearted comment, in the face of what appears to be judgment from other parents. So what are you going to do about it? If you were actually the mum's friend you could help support them, but as you're not, your judgement isn't really going to help them. The school are probably aware, this families' doctor are probably aware, let the professionals deal with it. I highly doubt social services will get involved, unless there's other neglect.

Sunshinebuttercupsrainbows · 05/07/2023 15:29

You could quite easily be describing my 6yo DS. Take him anywhere where food is on display buffet style and he will want all of it with complete disregard to the fact that it’s shared and there should be enough for everyone. I’m trying really hard with him - he has ASD, FASD, ADHD, GDD and Pica so it’s not an easy task. You have no really idea of what this mum is already doing to try to tackle her daughters eating so to come and post about it on an online forum judging both her and her child is nasty.

Freddiefox · 05/07/2023 15:28

Poor child on her own, listening or feeling being spoken about by a group of mums judging her food intake, while clutching their pearls

NoTouch · 05/07/2023 15:26

Op, are you going to clarify how this allegedly private conversation with a "few" parents came about and how the child would have heard?

Or are you going to stick to shaming someone you and other parents ambushed on a personal topic that you know nothing about and is none of your business

Aussiegirl88 · 05/07/2023 15:24

Geraniumgal · 05/07/2023 14:07

It was in no way fat shaming and was said privately.
It is and was very upsetting to watch. That child at 7yrs of age has clearly been brought up in a household of disordered eating. And if its normalised as binge eating by parents then to me its an excuse for abysmal parenting.

Hardly surprising we have an obesity problem in children judging by these replies.

But you did nothing to stop her nor redirect her so are also contributing to that problem no??

Then to make it worse, you and your clique of school mums decide to single out the parent and the child by shaming her. I can almost hear the whispers between you all, each time that child reached in for another biscuit.

You're the the type that should be avoided in the school yard!

bellac11 · 05/07/2023 15:21

Geraniumgal · 05/07/2023 14:54

A 7yr old shouldn't be hearing the word Binge in relation to any over eating. It normalises it for a child. In exactly the same way young primary school kids all now claim to be suffering from anxiety.
They are learning this language from their parents.

I think your whole thread is ridiculous but how does hearing a word like binge, 'normalise it'

What is 'it'?

You dont know if the child 'binge eats' or even if she was eating too much. You just felt uncomfortable watching a fat child eat biscuits in the way that you wouldnt have felt watching a skinny child eat biscuits.

Sugargliderwombat · 05/07/2023 15:21

Geraniumgal · 05/07/2023 13:53

My point is if a child hears a parent using the term binge eating disorder to excuse excessive over eating it then normalises it for the child. It's not language that should be used around children surely?

This sounds a whole lot like nothing to do with you.

Hibiscrubbed · 05/07/2023 15:20

I guarantee that if the thread was about a child who refused to eat because they said they didn’t want to be fat, and then a very slim mother turned up to collect her, whatever the OP did, posters would be laying into the mother for ‘projecting clear ED onto her daughter’.

Hibiscrubbed · 05/07/2023 15:18

IAmAnIdiot123 · 05/07/2023 15:10

If one person had had a quiet word of actual concern, your point may be valid.

That is clearly not what happened here, displayed by the fact it was considered a group activity to go for this woman about her daughters eating habits at a party.

Oh and it was a 'private' conversation, absolutely bit heard by any of the other children (likely to then go and use this as a stick to bully the daughter about) yet the OP is worried about the girl hearing the words. It can't have been that private then could it?

The responses would be exactly the same if the child was underweight, it did not need to happen in that way. It is the delivery most people are upset about. If you can't see that, then I can only assume you also indulge in these mean girl group sessions. How utterly sad and pathetic for you.

If you can't see that, then I can only assume you also indulge in these mean girl group sessions. How utterly sad and pathetic for you.

What on earth are you talking about?

Degenerating into name-calling just illustrates the intense oversensitivity around this issue.

Mariposista · 05/07/2023 15:16

Hibiscrubbed · 05/07/2023 15:03

Why is it so bad to be concerned that an overweight child, with a very overweight mother, displayed deeply unhealthy behaviours around food? Behaviour which the mother laughed off as just her ‘binge eating disorder’.

People weren’t gossiping and laughing, they were worried. Should they have said nothing because the child is over weight?

Would the same apply if the child was underweight and had said they didn’t want to eat anything because they didn’t want to be fat? I bet the responses would be very different.

A lot of the responses on here make me wonder about posters’ own relationships with food.

Totally this - you see a skinny child with ribs sticking out, and it's child abuse. Yet you see a porky one who can't run about and enjoy playing as a CHILD should do, and that's ok? Being fat is as bad for a child as being too thin!