Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Child out of wedlock / illegitimate - does it still matter

329 replies

Bananabreadandstrawberries · 05/07/2023 13:30

Does it still matter in any way whether your child was born within a marriage or not? Is there any stigma to being an ‘unwed mother’ or ‘illegitimate child’ (apologies no offence intended). Do you view people differently before of this status? Are there any practical implications?

For those of you who feel it doesn’t matter, would you still prefer your own daughter were married before having children?

I ask as I feel despite most people not minding this about other people, the couples ‘doing better’ in life still tend to marry before having children. I am not sure

AIBU that legitimacy doesn’t matter anymore?
YES = Makes a difference (even though it’s not PC to say so)
NO = Makes no difference about being married before children.

OP posts:
jauty · 05/07/2023 18:38

I had my first dc out of wedlock (unplanned) and dc2 and dc3 when I was married (to a different man from dc1's father). I definitely felt a sense of security with dc2 and dc3 that wasn't there with dc1. I would prefer my dc's to be married before having children and that's most common in my family (which is from a non British background and far more traditional).

I'm very aware of the legal differences between cohabiting couples and married couples and I would not have had dc2 and dc3 without being married.

QueenoftheNimbleFlyingCat · 05/07/2023 18:37

Bananabreadandstrawberries · 05/07/2023 14:15

Absolutely makes a big difference to financial security in the event of separation.

For some women, yes. For me, marriage would have made me worse off. I won't be encouraging my daughter to marry but to insist on her financial independence.

Lastusernamecantthinkofanotherone · 05/07/2023 18:32

RadoxRita · 05/07/2023 18:22

Practical implications: I’m not in this position, but my understanding from friends that are, is that if you have a child out of wedlock and then have a child in wedlock (even with the same partner), if you don’t have a will written or amend the child’s birth certificate to reflect the parents’ new married status, then any children born in wedlock would automatically inherit your full estate after your death.

This is incorrect. Check the family reform act:

Right of illegitimate child to succeed on intestacy of parents, and of parents to succeed on intestacy f illegitimate child(1)Where either parent of an illegitimate child dies intestate as respects all or any of his or her real or personal property, the illegitimate child or, if he is dead, his issue, shall be entitled to take any interest therein to which he or such issue would have been entitled if he had been born legitimate.

Bananabreadandstrawberries · 05/07/2023 18:31

RadoxRita · 05/07/2023 18:22

Practical implications: I’m not in this position, but my understanding from friends that are, is that if you have a child out of wedlock and then have a child in wedlock (even with the same partner), if you don’t have a will written or amend the child’s birth certificate to reflect the parents’ new married status, then any children born in wedlock would automatically inherit your full estate after your death.

Is this really the case re: inheritance?!

As someone mentioned earlier, any experience from people who are a child of unwed parents who then marry someone else and have children later?

OP posts:
CurlewKate · 05/07/2023 18:30

There are always so many "good" reasons for the children having their father's name. Or for the woman taking the man's name on marriage. It's all male ego, though, isn't it? Cone on, tell the truth and shame the devil!

bellocchild · 05/07/2023 18:29

No legal difference since 1976.

CharChar91 · 05/07/2023 18:26

My fiancé and I have two children out of wedlock and they were both born before becoming engaged. Only comments I've ever had were from the older generations. I don't pay any attention!

RadoxRita · 05/07/2023 18:22

Practical implications: I’m not in this position, but my understanding from friends that are, is that if you have a child out of wedlock and then have a child in wedlock (even with the same partner), if you don’t have a will written or amend the child’s birth certificate to reflect the parents’ new married status, then any children born in wedlock would automatically inherit your full estate after your death.

TrishTrix · 05/07/2023 18:22

@Jeansmuddy that was being discussed the last time it came up!!

bumblebee2235 · 05/07/2023 18:21

@Jeansmuddy because we are getting married, and was taking his name. So it's temporary we have separate names :) i have a few reasons on taking his surname which are personal (bad past, fresh start, new beginning type things)

Jeansmuddy · 05/07/2023 18:19

TrishTrix · 05/07/2023 17:47

I think the legal protections for woman who tend to take the bigger career hit when they have kids are better if you are married.

the vast majority of my peer group who have children are married.

those that weren’t are now quietly getting married due to the inheritance tax rules and our advancing age.

there is socioeconomic difference in who is married vs who is not and I wonder why this is? Money for a big wedding vs money for a house and people choosing house?
awareness of legal issues?
more culturally conservative.

the only two acquaintances I have who are not married who have kids are a rabid anti-marriage person who has spent a fortune to try to emulate the legal protections offered.
and a person whose OH is a family lawyer. I don’t like him and their non-married state is part of this. She gave up work to care for their children (4 of them). Pre-kids she was a professional. he owns the house and all their assets. And I just know he will fuck her over if their relationship ends. And she will find it really difficult to get back to work after 12yrs + at home.

Would the anti marriage person get a civil partnership?

RoseslnTheHospital · 05/07/2023 18:17

Parental rights don't depend on marriage. Apart from the specific situation where parents are married, the husband is assumed to be the father and can register the birth on his own. If not married then the father needs to attend the registrar appointment to be named as the father. Once that's done, then both married and unmarried fathers have parental responsibility.

Jeansmuddy · 05/07/2023 18:15

bumblebee2235 · 05/07/2023 17:37

@Jeansmuddy haha I couldn't double barrel or use both.. as my surname alongside his turns into act.. ie mine sounds like a verb and his is an action. 😬 very awkward, would have been amusing when they do a register at school though.

Did you just use his name and if so why that and not yours?

Another option is combining both names into one new one. Or everyone choosing a new name. So many options beyond the automatic assumption that only the male name gets to be passed down.

Anyotherdude · 05/07/2023 18:07

No stigma, but things can get complicated if E.g. a parent dies and the other wasn’t married to the deceased partner and no will exists. This was brought home in sharp relief in the 2010 TV series “Single Father” starring David Tennant.
Marriage as a contract makes everything so much easier in terms of inheritance and parental rights than co-habiting…

Ontheperiphery79 · 05/07/2023 18:05

I was born in '79 as a result of an extramarital affair (my Mother was the OW). She lied for 18 years, saying that she had been married to (and subsequently divorced my Dad). SHE felt great shame and used to use the term 'bastards'.
I only got married because I somehow thought that marriage was a sign that a man REALLY loved me. Had children and separates when DC twins were 4 months.
As a Catholic, I've felt judged for being a divorcée! I no longer take my daughters to Mass in our town.
I'm actually the only single parent in my DC's year! I don't know who is married and who is cohabiting and I really don't care.

MollysBrolly · 05/07/2023 18:05

I have 2 dcs and never married, and they have different fathers. Think of me however you like but remember single parents are so for a reason.
would you think of me and say a widow the same bringing up dcs. You should single parent is a single parent

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 05/07/2023 18:05

ReliantRobyn · 05/07/2023 14:57

Agreed, illegitimate children tend to do better in life than those legitimate. It must be down to stability. Its hard to not judge those children born out of wedlock.

I don't understand what you mean.

And what sort of adult judges a child by the circumstances of their birth? Shame on you.

My parents were never married, I was born in 1982. No idea if they faced stigma - I know my maternal grandparents weren't thrilled my parents had no intention of marrying, but they rather have us in their lives and unmarried than not.

My children were all born before I was married. I only got married after reading on here about the protections it offers - otherwise I was uninterested.

girlfriend44 · 05/07/2023 18:03

Matter to who?

It dosent matter to the people who aren't married.

Marchintospring · 05/07/2023 18:02

Nope.
And to be fair if you have a father that pays his share of maintenance it’s not even that bad financially. Especially if you meet someone else.

Although I guess I was lucky.

Whenisitsummer · 05/07/2023 18:00

I don’t think it matters. There was a comment earlier that 75% of women earning over 40k are married. I find this interesting, I work in a female dominated profession. We all earn> 40k in our sept and it’s about 50/50 married vs cohabiting. I wouldn’t encourage my children to marry, financial splits are more likely to be equal in the event of separation.

Lastusernamecantthinkofanotherone · 05/07/2023 17:59

CurlewKate · 05/07/2023 17:43

"A man with a different name is assumed to be stepdad or unrelated"

So what? Might that dent his ego a little?

Nothing to do with ego but needing documentation every time you want to be informed about your child.

dr’s visit? It they suspect you don’t have PR because you have a different name they can’t discuss your child’s medical issue.

school won’t discuss children’s progress if they have reason to believe you aren’t a parent.

it’s especially a problem if they child’s mum won’t put you on the contact list.

dh stays in hotels with 15 year old dd for her sport. Hotels now ask for both names to safeguard against child trafficking. Me staying with her with different names doesn’t raise any concern.

Blossomtoes · 05/07/2023 17:56

Bananabreadandstrawberries · 05/07/2023 17:06

I find that very interesting too!
I suppose there was something about their parents arrangement that they did not want to emulate? Or perhaps their mother wanted differently for her DD?
Are their parents together?

No, they separated when the eldest was ten.

TrishTrix · 05/07/2023 17:47

I think the legal protections for woman who tend to take the bigger career hit when they have kids are better if you are married.

the vast majority of my peer group who have children are married.

those that weren’t are now quietly getting married due to the inheritance tax rules and our advancing age.

there is socioeconomic difference in who is married vs who is not and I wonder why this is? Money for a big wedding vs money for a house and people choosing house?
awareness of legal issues?
more culturally conservative.

the only two acquaintances I have who are not married who have kids are a rabid anti-marriage person who has spent a fortune to try to emulate the legal protections offered.
and a person whose OH is a family lawyer. I don’t like him and their non-married state is part of this. She gave up work to care for their children (4 of them). Pre-kids she was a professional. he owns the house and all their assets. And I just know he will fuck her over if their relationship ends. And she will find it really difficult to get back to work after 12yrs + at home.

Twoshoesnewshoes · 05/07/2023 17:46

I got married to my DCs Dad many years after they were born . We hadn’t intended to ever marry. DCs have both of our names, we each just have our own last name.
I would never describe them or anyone else as ‘illegitimate’ and would be offended if anyone else did.
I would prefer my DD to not be married when having DCs, though of course I would support whatever she wanted to do. I would be a bit sulky if she changed her name to her partner’s though!

CurlewKate · 05/07/2023 17:43

"A man with a different name is assumed to be stepdad or unrelated"

So what? Might that dent his ego a little?