Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Close family members disinterested in our baby - unsure if normal or not?

163 replies

Birminghambabe · 05/07/2023 09:36

I’m not really sure how I feel on this one. Myself and DH have a 3 month old and of course to us the centre of our whole world.

I’ve always been a firm believer of just because you’re getting married, having babies etc doesn’t mean everyone else around you is going to be as obsessed as you are because they’ve got their own life going on.
Yet for some reason since our baby has been born part of me is a bit miffed that one of my siblings and one of DH siblings are so disinterested in the fact we’ve had a baby. They never ask how baby is, haven’t met our baby yet (have cancelled plans to do so or said they’re busy).
At the same time I’m saying to myself it’s fine, they’re not baby people, they didn’t ask to be an aunt and uncle etc but when people mention how our siblings are loving auntie and uncle life I say they haven’t met our baby and they follow with “wow, that’s so bad!”

Please let me know what you think about this? Right now I’m not super hurt about it, but as time goes on maybe I am getting a bit bothered

YANBU - They probably should at least ask how baby is, maybe make a bit of effort
YABU - It’s fine that they aren’t interested, they’re just not baby people

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Cakecakecheese · 06/07/2023 17:21

My sister isn't massively into babies and I'm not really a dog person but she set up a standing order to pay some money into my baby's savings account each month and I buy her dogs Christmas presents. Not saying they should do that but even if you're not bothered it doesn't take long to ask after your family member's child every now and then.

Grumpy101 · 06/07/2023 14:20

I think it shows you and the siblings are polite but not very close. The only babies I give a shit about are those of people who I love and I am super close to. I would not go out of my way to meet a baby, it would be more to see the happy couple and chat etc.

It's OK to be a little bit sad but move on, recognize you're not close and keep them out of your mind.

Thepowerhouseofthecell · 06/07/2023 14:05

I just find it bizarre that people think 'not being a baby person' is a good reason not to meet your own neice/nephew. It would be more understandable to me if the op and her husband were not very close with thier siblings in the first place and hardly ever talked anyway. But if that's not the case op is justified in thinking they should have met the baby by 3 months old and I would be hurt too.

My sister is not a baby person and lives 3 hours away but I know for a fact that if I had another baby she would plan a visit. She just wouldn't be changing any nappies!

TumbleweedRolling · 06/07/2023 08:01

I don’t understand why anyone would think anyone else would care about your kids…
It makes no sense.
And calling people names or whatever if and when they don’t care, is just beyond crazy.

Some parents really need a reality check.

Florissante · 06/07/2023 07:19

OP, you have a sensible attitude and I applaud you for it. It would be lovely if your sister and in-laws took an interest, of course, but you are giving yourself peace but accepting the situation for what it is.

Enjoy the time with the new member of your family!

Milkand2sugarsplease · 05/07/2023 23:00

DS is 2

Number of times family have seen him.

GPs - 5
Brother - 5
Brother - 1
Sister - 0
Sister - 0
Sister - 0

They're not interested, I'd rather fill his life with people that are.

LaBefana · 05/07/2023 22:55

For the avoidance of doubt, I loved both my babies to bits, still do now they are grown up, but I have never been able to work up very much interest on other peoples' babies. They just seem like ugly little aliens with big heads that make the most awful noise. And I find other women who are only interested in babies a bit tedious. Sorry, but that's the way I am.

ClemFandango1 · 05/07/2023 22:34

My bro doesn't give a crap about my DC - it's hurtful but it is what it is. I love him too much to hold it against him.

LaylaLjungberg · 05/07/2023 22:23

I absolutely adore my nephew, I don’t have children myself but I honestly love him so much. I love to be part of his life and am here to help as much I can. BUT when he was a baby I was useless, I didn’t get involved at all, I feel a bit sad now but at the time I just didn’t know what to do so stayed out of it until he was about 1. Always wanted to hear about him though. So their loss. Don’t worry about it.

SoSoSoSo · 05/07/2023 22:19

I think we've been talking more generally lately, Birminghambabe. It's clear that you have a very levelheaded and balanced approach to your Sister and DH's brother's lack of enthusiasm. You seem lovely. Congratulations on your precious baby boy.

OhmygodDont · 05/07/2023 22:15

User1438423 · 05/07/2023 15:54

I think it's awful, really rude and hurtful. I think most posters on here just try to be controversial these days, I don't believe so many people think it is ok not to bother to go and meet a nice/nephew when they usually see you about once a month especially!

Not at all but I was raised that just because you are related doesn’t mean you have to like let alone love each other. My husbands sisters kids are exactly that plus the oldest is annoying as shit 😅

OCDmama · 05/07/2023 21:52

I have a twin sister I'm very close to.

I've got two kids and she is happy to talk about them, but no real interest. I know she loves them and will definitely be a cool aunt, but she's just not a baby/kid person.

Each to their own!!

TimeToMoveIt · 05/07/2023 21:42

It's odd, especially as you are willing to travel. Some people just don't seem to have any interest in their family though. You see it all the time on here

Birminghambabe · 05/07/2023 21:29

I think this thread has taken a bit of a turn.

I just want to reiterate that I’m not hurt by it to an extent because I’ve always known they are not fans of young babies. I’m not shocked by it, and like I said before they never asked to be aunts and uncles and I can’t force them to be interested, if I was to force them or push it on them - it would be fake which I’d rather it not be.

I was having a convo with some friends over dinner and all were shocked. I had a small wedding late last year and we all (friends, our siblings) got on well which is why they asked how they are at being aunts and uncles. It made me question more if I should be annoyed or not as beforehand I brushed it off.

I have decided to move on from it and just remind myself that it is not personal.
Yes they did send a congratulations card! No gift but that’s not an issue as we had a lot of gifts from others so baby had more than enough.

Do I wish deep down that they saw my beautiful baby boy? Yes! I do. He is my baby born after losses and I’m very proud of him. But reading these comments made me realise that not every aunt / uncle wants to be involved. So I’ve come to the conclusion that it is normal

OP posts:
TumbleweedRolling · 05/07/2023 20:55

Tandora · 05/07/2023 20:50

What rubbish. It’s not just women but men also who are very much affected by these things. It’s not just about wanting babies, often people who don’t want them can find it v difficult as well- because we live in a profoundly pro-Natalist society that promotes the idea that having a baby is of moral/ superior value/ worth. Also because relationships and priorities change when people have babies and that can be hard for those close to the situation, especially if they are people who dislike or don’t want children. It’s hard, it’s triggering, it affects both men and women, not all of these dynamics are conscious.

I think you got the wrong person….

TumbleweedRolling · 05/07/2023 20:51

Tandora · 05/07/2023 20:26

I had exactly the same reaction. Sounds like someone likes to bask in the limelight, and doesn’t appreciate when others don’t show her sufficient attention 😆😆

But you must remember!
She is carrying the first, FIRST, grandchild on THAT SIDE of the family!
😂

Tandora · 05/07/2023 20:50

TumbleweedRolling · 05/07/2023 20:35

🙄
Good lord!
You really think very highly of yourself, huh?

Of course, women are just so jelous of mothers! All women only want babies!

Main character syndrome?
You mean like op, and many other mothers?
Funny, it’s only mothers, never fathers who demand attention and care once they have a kid 😉

What rubbish. It’s not just women but men also who are very much affected by these things. It’s not just about wanting babies, often people who don’t want them can find it v difficult as well- because we live in a profoundly pro-Natalist society that promotes the idea that having a baby is of moral/ superior value/ worth. Also because relationships and priorities change when people have babies and that can be hard for those close to the situation, especially if they are people who dislike or don’t want children. It’s hard, it’s triggering, it affects both men and women, not all of these dynamics are conscious.

thecatsthecats · 05/07/2023 20:35

When my friends and family have babies, I'm primarily concerned for their welfare post birth. Not meeting the baby.

I'm actually a bit sorry for my brother, who lives near me. Poor sod isn't going to be given the chance not to meet my baby like he dodged all my other nieces and nephews, my parents will bring him over when they come.

I don't see what benefit my baby will get out of a network of random aunts and uncles. I had some I loved, some I barely saw. I didn't give a fig about the ones who didn't give a fig about me. No harm done.

TumbleweedRolling · 05/07/2023 20:35

Irequireausername · 05/07/2023 15:27

I'm going to say something that society wouldn't expect, but when having a baby, some people get really upset and/or angry for various reasons.

My sil actually cried and was angry, even though she didn't want kids, it made her feel like she was lacking.

My sister barely asked about our babies because she felt she'd left it too late to have her own.

My mum wasn't coping as she thought i'd stop caring as much about her, and more about my PILs.

There's so many times i've seen this with friends and family.

Strangely everytime it's been women, not men, who get angry/upset at others having kids.

Avoiding seems to easier for them. It's threatening to their main character syndrome.

🙄
Good lord!
You really think very highly of yourself, huh?

Of course, women are just so jelous of mothers! All women only want babies!

Main character syndrome?
You mean like op, and many other mothers?
Funny, it’s only mothers, never fathers who demand attention and care once they have a kid 😉

Tandora · 05/07/2023 20:32

Instawars · 05/07/2023 10:13

Babies can do funny things to families. When my brother and his wife had a baby it was incredibly painful for me. I had heard for years about their struggles to conceive and how painful it was for them etc, all the while I was going through similar struggles but didn’t want to add further upset to the family by telling them my own issues with having a child.
when they got pregnant everyone was delighted and I was expected to be over the moon, and whilst thrilled for them it is incredibly painful seeing them have a baby whilst I am still childless.

they might not be interested, they might dislike children or find babies boring, they might have had to reconcile themselves to the fact they can’t have children. Just leave them be and concentrate on the people who are interested in your baby rather than pushing on those who aren’t interested.

i get that it’s a really exciting time for you and you want to show off the new addition, but stick to those who are interested -I’m sure there are plenty of those

This 100%. I think what people don’t factor in is how many emotions it can bring up in others when those close to them have babies for so many complicated reasons. It’s unlikely to be a case of simply bored and can’t be arsed.

Tandora · 05/07/2023 20:26

TumbleweedRolling · 05/07/2023 20:01

I just find it funny how you are calling other’s self absorbed, while you’re being self absorbed 😆

I had exactly the same reaction. Sounds like someone likes to bask in the limelight, and doesn’t appreciate when others don’t show her sufficient attention 😆😆

Aquamarine1029 · 05/07/2023 20:24

FoodFann · 05/07/2023 11:11

Not liking babies is one thing. But I think what’s more disappointing for me is that our siblings have been almost completely useless in helping us adults during those first few weeks post-partum.

When they have babies I’m going to show up with food, drink, vacuum, cleaning products and put a proper shift in!

They turned up here once, did one load of laundry for me, and then wanted a full meal and a photoshoot with my new baby when I was very ill and one day post c-section.

They should show up for YOU, not just the baby.

Your sense of entitlement is astonishing. Why do you think it's anyone else's responsibility, aside from your husband's, to care for you after your baby was born, and has it not occured to you that your siblings may not want you hanging around after they have their children?

ThisIsACoolUserName · 05/07/2023 20:15

LaBefana · 05/07/2023 20:04

People who expect me to coo all over their babies and be very interested in every crap they have really get on my tits. Double if they think there's 'something wrong with me' for being like this.

My MIL tells DH and I EVERY small, boring detail about the impending arrival of her grandchild.
I get it, she's overcome with excitement. But I want to grip her by the shoulders, shake her and shout 'I'm a 39 year old who has CHOSEN not to have kids. Why the FUCK do you think I'd be interested in this!!?'

TallTrees78 · 05/07/2023 20:14

I'm childfree by choice and not keen on children but I love my sibling's children. I'm very close to my siblings though so maybe that makes a difference?

TumbleweedRolling · 05/07/2023 20:13

FoodFann · 05/07/2023 11:11

Not liking babies is one thing. But I think what’s more disappointing for me is that our siblings have been almost completely useless in helping us adults during those first few weeks post-partum.

When they have babies I’m going to show up with food, drink, vacuum, cleaning products and put a proper shift in!

They turned up here once, did one load of laundry for me, and then wanted a full meal and a photoshoot with my new baby when I was very ill and one day post c-section.

They should show up for YOU, not just the baby.

You chose to have a kid!
Why would anyone else have to deal with that?
Unless you asked their opinion on the matter before you went and got knocked up.

If someone said to me ”hey, I had a baby, come clean my house, make me a dinner and change the kids nappy”.
I’d think their lost their minds and never see them again.
How selfish and entitled can you be?