Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for a reduction in rent?

138 replies

Lonelycats · 05/07/2023 09:01

Landlord just told us that a three months long extensive refurbishment project is starting NEXT WEEK! Scaffolds, windows covered up, extensive work on our roof. Landlord says to expect ‘some dust’ and also says the works are noisy by nature.

I know that the landlord is not required to compensate us is in any way, but is it worth asking?

  • With such short notice we were never given an opportunity to plan around these works, or move out.
  • I work from home (I know it’s not their problem as the house was not advertised as office space, but these are my circumstances)
  • we have only planned two weeks holiday as one of my children is doing exam revision this year so we are going to be here for the next five weeks…! Studying and working. Other children are in day camps in and off to allow for some peace and quiet at home. I’d lose all my money for these activities if we were to try and go somewhere else for the summer
  • I can’t bear the thought of not being able to open any windows on a hot day
OP posts:
caringcarer · 06/07/2023 10:51

You could ask. She what LL says.

Regholdsworthswaterbed · 06/07/2023 10:30

Would you prefer a slum landlord who doesn't give a shit about the condition of the house?

deveronvalley · 06/07/2023 10:27

It's worth a try I don't really know. However, I'm currently sitting in my (own) home with the noise of the roof getting replaced. We had our start date pushed back a few times, they were supposed to start in March/April and well here we are. They've not had a clear run of more than 1 day at a time to get the job done so I often have no idea if they're coming from one day to the next. They've had issues with weather, previous jobs overrunning, scaffolding, a missing skip and a broken down telehandler so far. Oh and one of the workers unexpectedly took a few days off to go and help his Dad with sheep-shearing. Just to give an insight into the lack of notice period!

ButImNotOldEnough · 06/07/2023 09:56

It’s the summer, surely your DC can take a break from study as there’s no exams until next year? Same for your HE child, let them have a summer holiday. No suggestions for you with work though unfortunately, might just be a case of sucking it up the best you can. You can certainly ask for a rent reduction but be prepared to be told no, it’s not likely in those circumstances.

strongtsandcs · 06/07/2023 08:14

CeriB82 · 05/07/2023 17:50

i would definitely refuse. Be careful here, your LL could easily increase your rent to aid the costs.

They can raise rents once a year. You can also refuse to accept the rent increase

Pluvia · 05/07/2023 17:52

strongtsandcs · 05/07/2023 11:55

Poor you, sitting in your home, with your mortgage, on your asset.

Grateful you don't know anything about housing law.

Yes, me at home in the cold in my modest 2-bedroom terrace. The bloody cheek of me, owning my own home. Put me (and millions of other hard-working taxpayers) up against a wall and shoot me come the revolution...

CeriB82 · 05/07/2023 17:50

i would definitely refuse. Be careful here, your LL could easily increase your rent to aid the costs.

Caspianberg · 05/07/2023 16:50

I would.
I think with such short notice you haven’t had time to plan alternatives ie working elsewhere or using a few weeks annual leave to go away. If it was your own property you could have arranged alternatives months ago when they were cheaper or still had spaces.

I would say it’s inconvenient now as such last minute. Explain you will prob now incure extra unplanned for costs such as extra school holiday clubs or you paying to work in coffee shops or ad hoc office rental space etc.. all things you hadn’t budgeted for for ‘next week’.

drpet49 · 05/07/2023 16:46

Dozycuntlaters · 05/07/2023 09:27

YABU - this is the prime time of year to get work like that done plus it's good you actually have a LL that gives a shit.....you would be the first to complain if the rook had a real problem and sprang a massive leak.

By all means ask, but realise that this will mark you as not being great tenants and may even lead to a section 21. Personally, I think you need to just suck it up.

This

strongtsandcs · 05/07/2023 16:37

ladidah2 · 05/07/2023 13:31

I assume this is EWS1, it's a regulation that came in after Grenfell to ensure that all cladding is safe. If the owner is having to pay for it (sometimes up to £50k per flat) then they will not grant you a reduction.

Who says they won't?

WaitingForNothingGood · 05/07/2023 13:59

I'd definitely ask for a discount. The landlord was shitty not to give you a heads up when they first realised the work needed doing.

JMSA · 05/07/2023 13:34

Definitely worth a punt. They can only say no.

ladidah2 · 05/07/2023 13:31

I assume this is EWS1, it's a regulation that came in after Grenfell to ensure that all cladding is safe. If the owner is having to pay for it (sometimes up to £50k per flat) then they will not grant you a reduction.

Curledupwithabook · 05/07/2023 12:53

As far as I know this is something you can negotiate on but may not be required for the landlord to offer.

I lived in a houseshare where the landlord took the kitchen out of use for six weeks to re-do, as well as building an understair wet room (all with the plan of renting it at higher cost) Builders given keys, in and out all day, no supervision. No locks on our bedroom doors (not to accuse builders of anything but we had no way of vetting them, or managing privacy)

All the LL was required to compensate us was £10 a day to 'cover' the cost of eating out.
When the work was complete he served us all with s21 notices, increased the rent per room as well as converting the living room into a bedroom to increase the overall rent. I had to argue even to get him to replace my hoover that the builders had killed by using it to hoover up brick dust.

Renting sucks.

CockyTeeHunz4Eva · 05/07/2023 12:24

I'm a Landlord and I would absolutely discount the rent under these circumstances. My tenants are paying for a service and part of that service is 'quiet enjoyment'. Perhaps I wouldn't if it was a week or two (I sent a hamper to my tenants as a thank you for being so tolerant when I had to have a roof repaired that took 5 days), but 3 MONTHS? That's awful. So disruptive and intrusive.

If I were you I wold find a (reasonable) quote for local office space and ask for the LL to cover/contribute. Hopefully you can get a space with two desks so your revising child can go with you. There is a balance to be struck here, but this is absolutely not reasonable through school holidays/exam periods.

Just my opinion, and definitely get advice from Shelter on this. x

User9753224 · 05/07/2023 12:22

Back21970 · 05/07/2023 09:34

3 months is a long time to put up with the inconvenience so yes, I think it’s reasonable to ask for a rent reduction.

They can only say no so worth a go.

I agree with you.

No person viewing this property with a view to renting it would take it on if they knew about a forthcoming quarter of the year being so disrupted 😱

strongtsandcs · 05/07/2023 12:10

LadyJ2023 · 05/07/2023 12:05

Erm no pay your rent he's improving his house which is a good landlord and your going to benefit

It's not benefiting her. It's outside the property.

Lonelycats · 05/07/2023 12:09

Pluvia · 05/07/2023 11:43

Do you like the house, OP? Do you like the area? Would you like to stay there? You've said the landlord is professional and is clearly prepared to spend money on keeping the property in good order which would seem to be bode well.

If it's yes to those questions, I'd count my chickens. You've talked about works to the facade and having to live with scaffolding and noise — presumably at the front of the house. So how about moving the room in which you work to the back of the house, temporarily? There'll be residual noise but probably not so bad and you can have a window open.

Do you have friends/ family/ neighbours in the area who might be able to offer a quiet spare bedroom in which you could work temporarily? Could your DD go and study with a friend? Or in the library (lots of kids studying at my main library). There will be lots of days when there's no one working on the house. It doesn't take three months of continual work to sort out exterior issues. There'll be wet days and weeks when no one's around.

Have a cup of tea, calm down and try not to catastrophise. Worse things happen at sea.

It’s all of the house on all three sides unfortunately .

OP posts:
LadyJ2023 · 05/07/2023 12:05

Erm no pay your rent he's improving his house which is a good landlord and your going to benefit

strongtsandcs · 05/07/2023 11:55

Pluvia · 05/07/2023 11:49

You left your tenants without hot water and heating for a week? Unfortunately you can't compare it as "one of those things" to be compared to an owner-occupier and you should have provided some monetary compensation.

I went three weeks this winter without heating and hot water. I own my own home and I simply couldn't get an engineer out before that. I rang everyone available in the area. British Gas came out to have a look but couldn't do the work for weeks.

Do you really imagine that home-owners have some magic number they dial and hey presto, a new boiler in 24 hours? Reality check required.

Poor you, sitting in your home, with your mortgage, on your asset.

Grateful you don't know anything about housing law.

Pluvia · 05/07/2023 11:49

You left your tenants without hot water and heating for a week? Unfortunately you can't compare it as "one of those things" to be compared to an owner-occupier and you should have provided some monetary compensation.

I went three weeks this winter without heating and hot water. I own my own home and I simply couldn't get an engineer out before that. I rang everyone available in the area. British Gas came out to have a look but couldn't do the work for weeks.

Do you really imagine that home-owners have some magic number they dial and hey presto, a new boiler in 24 hours? Reality check required.

strongtsandcs · 05/07/2023 11:45

MooMooSharoo · 05/07/2023 11:32

I have mixed feelings on this. DH has a property he rents out and I was wondering what he would do in this situation if the house needed some major repairs.

I would like to think he would offer them some sort of credit against the rent for the inconvenience caused. That said, when the boiler broke, he had it replaced as soon as possible, but the tenants were still inconvenienced for a week or so. No credit was given then, as, ultimately, it's just one of those things that could happen when you either rent or own.

I think the time factor is what is making the biggest difference to me though in this scenario. If you're going to have noisy, dirty, disruptive works to your home for 3 months, that's a very different thing compared to a week without hot water.

I think you need to clarify whether they will be expecting to use your power and water supplies though. If they are, you definitely should be getting reimbursed for any extra costs incurred.

You left your tenants without hot water and heating for a week? Unfortunately you can't compare it as "one of those things" to be compared to an owner-occupier and you should have provided some monetary compensation.

Pluvia · 05/07/2023 11:43

Do you like the house, OP? Do you like the area? Would you like to stay there? You've said the landlord is professional and is clearly prepared to spend money on keeping the property in good order which would seem to be bode well.

If it's yes to those questions, I'd count my chickens. You've talked about works to the facade and having to live with scaffolding and noise — presumably at the front of the house. So how about moving the room in which you work to the back of the house, temporarily? There'll be residual noise but probably not so bad and you can have a window open.

Do you have friends/ family/ neighbours in the area who might be able to offer a quiet spare bedroom in which you could work temporarily? Could your DD go and study with a friend? Or in the library (lots of kids studying at my main library). There will be lots of days when there's no one working on the house. It doesn't take three months of continual work to sort out exterior issues. There'll be wet days and weeks when no one's around.

Have a cup of tea, calm down and try not to catastrophise. Worse things happen at sea.

Jaichangecentfoisdenom · 05/07/2023 11:36

As a landlord, I always give a rent reduction for an agreed period when I know there are scheduled works which are likely to upset the routine of tenants, particularly as the current ones work from home. Unfortunately, we have had works needing to be done on the block for a decade or so and although they have finally been planned for since 2020, the owners of flats in the block often only get notified by the property managers the evening before the work is due to start, so it's obviously hard to give tenants advance warning in that case.

TheyWentToSeaInASieve · 05/07/2023 11:32

Also I think you can raise concerns over noise, heat, dust and schedule with your landlord, but asking for a reduction in rent seems like chancing your arm a little.