Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for a reduction in rent?

138 replies

Lonelycats · 05/07/2023 09:01

Landlord just told us that a three months long extensive refurbishment project is starting NEXT WEEK! Scaffolds, windows covered up, extensive work on our roof. Landlord says to expect ‘some dust’ and also says the works are noisy by nature.

I know that the landlord is not required to compensate us is in any way, but is it worth asking?

  • With such short notice we were never given an opportunity to plan around these works, or move out.
  • I work from home (I know it’s not their problem as the house was not advertised as office space, but these are my circumstances)
  • we have only planned two weeks holiday as one of my children is doing exam revision this year so we are going to be here for the next five weeks…! Studying and working. Other children are in day camps in and off to allow for some peace and quiet at home. I’d lose all my money for these activities if we were to try and go somewhere else for the summer
  • I can’t bear the thought of not being able to open any windows on a hot day
OP posts:
SideWonder · 06/07/2023 14:51

As a LL, I'd give you a 20% reduction in rent for 3 months. But really - if the roof needs doing, it needs doing. Do you want a ratty roof in the winter?

HarpyValley · 06/07/2023 14:43

Regholdsworthswaterbed · 06/07/2023 10:30

Would you prefer a slum landlord who doesn't give a shit about the condition of the house?

As if that's the only other option. 🙄

I imagine the OP would like a LL who looks after the property AND considers his tenants; it's not impossible to do both.

OP, I'd raise it by presenting some options: something like you appreciate the work is necessary but three months (or more, if disrupted by lack of supplies / bad weather) will have an impact on your quiet enjoyment of the property...would he consider contributing toward the cost of renting office space in a business hub for the length of the works, or pay for a weekly cleaner to keep on top of the dust, whatever seems reasonable and beneficial.

cittigirl · 06/07/2023 14:37

If the landlord as a large portfolio...he may have a vacant one at the same time? Worth asking.

sigfey · 06/07/2023 14:36

Also worth pointing out that the LL would not be able to get new tenants in if you left, so you do have some leverage @Lonelycats

Sunshineishere1988 · 06/07/2023 14:35

Ive been through work in the Summer and its not as bad as it sounds. Advice for hot days is also windows open in the morning, closed in the day and open again in the evening. As long as the scaffolding isnt blocking every single window (presumably not), I dont think its too much of a problem. You might need to move around the house to find a quiet space if the work is loud in one particular area.

I think the landlord should have let you know in advance though - that would have been the decent thing to do, especially if he knows you WFH.

Namechangeforanamechange · 06/07/2023 14:30

Is it actually a repair because the contractors didn't do the renovation work correctly or is it a rectification because the landlord didn't have listed building consent for the changes or the contractors didn't use the appropriate materials? Has anyone been to inspect the property to investigate this issue since you moved in? Given that you haven't had any issues and the stucco facade is one of the things being "repaired" (but you have had no issues with damp and there aren't any visible issue like cracks, bulging etc), I suspect it might be that the landlord has been told to change the renovations back to how they were previously because it is a listed building...

If you haven't reported any issues and no one has been to inspect the property, I would also guess that the landlord knew about this before you moved in or has done for a very long time. It may have taken this long to get listed building consent. It took us 2 years to come to an agreement on the correct colour mortar for repairs to our facade... It could also be that the renovations failed the building regs inspection, I suppose, but that also means he has known about the issue for a very long time.

When did you renew your AST? If the landlord knew about the major works when you moved in, that would be misrepresentation. However, you only have 90 days after signing the contract to complain. I believe the clock resets every time you agree a new contract though (not a lawyer but a landlord and a former housing advice volunteer). The remedy would be allowing you to break the contract, which doesn't help you much unless you want to move out immediately?

I also believe there is precedence where the courts have awarded compensation to tenants for inconvenience when the landlord has not told the tenant before signing the contract that major works are planned, even where there has been no financial loss due to the works. I would have thought that the landlord could pursue the builders for any loss of rental income from you if the "repairs" are due to the builders mistake.

I would get legal advice and ask for a rent reduction. Shelter are very busy and prioritise tenants facing eviction. Do you have legal cover with your house insurance? There may be a free housing legal advice clinic in your borough. CAB can also help advise. Which? also have a very cheap legal advice service.

Zipps · 06/07/2023 14:15

We're landlords and you have to get work done when contractors are available. We wouldn't be giving compensation as well as paying for the work. Would you rather the landlord look after the property or neglect it?
Honestly no wonder a lot of landlords are selling up, which will only drive rents up to the max people will pay.

sigfey · 06/07/2023 14:14

Toniii · 05/07/2023 09:32

@Darkandstormynite so all rented properties when having work done to improve/repair an issue that come with some noise mean that the tenant should be compensated? As a renter, I would never expect a LL to not only pay for all the repairs but also pay me for the inconvenience of the repairs. I suppose it's not about opinions, it's about what's in the contract.

My building had an issue that meant we could not flush toilet paper for around 3 weeks (in the middle of summer) and there were regular times when we could not run water either while repairs were made.

My landlord messaged me apologies and halved my rent for the month for the inconvience.

Doobeedoobeedoobee · 06/07/2023 14:07

I’m a landlord and would probably offer a rent reduction for something like this unprompted. Definitely definitely worth you asking as they may just not have thought about it.

forgotmyusername1 · 06/07/2023 14:00

could you check how much it costs to rent a hot desk type temporary office facility for 3 months and see if landlord will contribute

near me it would be 150 a month to rent an office in a building

stichguru · 06/07/2023 13:54

Definitely ask for help towards renting another office space. That's probably easier than asking for a reduction in rent because it's a clear amount of money that is directly caused by the works. "I can't do my job from home because it's going to be too noisy. This a direct result of you planning works at this time. I am therefore going to have to spend X amount per day to work somewhere else, you need to cover this." Though before you ask this outright, definitely ask if the works could be moved to a more convenient time.

travailtotravel · 06/07/2023 13:53

I think not being able to open windows/fresh air etc would be a big issue for me - obvs I can go out after work etc, but will they provide temporary air con for you or fans?!

maryso · 06/07/2023 13:50

Buildings need periodic maintenance. The reality is that the cost of this work to your landlord far exceeds your total annual rent.

One option is to ask the landlord to release you from the contract and move somewhere else, if you really think the work effectively renders your contract voidable. Another is to look at how to work around this essential maintenance.

A rent reduction will not reduce the impact of the work, so it's unreasonable. However plenty of people make unreasonable demands, as long as you're confident there is no downside you are not prepared to stomach, you certainly don't need validation from strangers with limited knowledge of your appetite for engagement.

ladyvivienne · 06/07/2023 13:50

I don't understand wanting money off either.

Your landlord is improving your living situation (which you already say is good) for FREE - and you want even more money off?

Paperairplane · 06/07/2023 13:44

Of course you should get a discount, and I'm bemused by people not realising that. The landlord is essentially improving their asset (even if it is because a contractor screwed up). Why the hell should you suffer for that?

Xenia · 06/07/2023 13:43

Try but if xpensive works have been forcd on the landlord due to Grenfell he may have much less not more money to give out on discounts.
My son and his friend at university had scaffolding up just about the whole last academic year 2019/20. It was really difficult as his bed room was always dark, so dark the house plants almost died and like most building works took about 50% longer than planned - no one's fault but just how it goes sometimes.

LoisPrice · 06/07/2023 13:43

You can also refuse to accept the rent increase

it can be negotiated,

AllIwantforChristmas22 · 06/07/2023 13:43

Your DC can use a library to revise
can you use a shared office space? Get a desk for a month?

LoisPrice · 06/07/2023 13:38

Yes but if you owned the home and chose to get major works done you would have completed autonomy over when they happened!

and the helot bill for the works

DarkForces · 06/07/2023 13:38

We rent out a property. When the oven broke we gave the renter some money to acknowledge the inconvenience.

Theunamedcat · 06/07/2023 13:31

Yeah you might need to be able to rent a mobile office or work space for you and your child perhaps price them up and go to the landlord explain that you could have planned around this had you actually known sooner and this is what your going to be out

Hankunamatata · 06/07/2023 13:16

I would ask if possible for reduction during works so you can hire a work space outside the home. Reasonable request imo

Luckyduc · 06/07/2023 13:11

Opening your windows on a hot day is making your house hotter.....shut the windows and curtains during the day and open them all when the sun sets will make your house cool all day.

TheLurpackYears · 06/07/2023 11:16

Assuming the trades will need electric and water, what provision has the LL made for this? Also toilet provision, LL needs to provide a portaloo.
If it's grade 2 listed then the ll will have also had to get listed building consent from the council, so speak to the conservation officer at the council if you have you.

GirlsAndPenguins · 06/07/2023 10:57

I’m a teacher and intrigued on the child who’s revising. Most schools/ colleges / unis have come to the end of the examination period. Is your DC already predicting November resits?
I know this isn’t the point but just found it intriguing

Swipe left for the next trending thread