Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for a reduction in rent?

138 replies

Lonelycats · 05/07/2023 09:01

Landlord just told us that a three months long extensive refurbishment project is starting NEXT WEEK! Scaffolds, windows covered up, extensive work on our roof. Landlord says to expect ‘some dust’ and also says the works are noisy by nature.

I know that the landlord is not required to compensate us is in any way, but is it worth asking?

  • With such short notice we were never given an opportunity to plan around these works, or move out.
  • I work from home (I know it’s not their problem as the house was not advertised as office space, but these are my circumstances)
  • we have only planned two weeks holiday as one of my children is doing exam revision this year so we are going to be here for the next five weeks…! Studying and working. Other children are in day camps in and off to allow for some peace and quiet at home. I’d lose all my money for these activities if we were to try and go somewhere else for the summer
  • I can’t bear the thought of not being able to open any windows on a hot day
OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
HamBone · 14/07/2023 15:45

I think this is a good result, OP. It’ll still be inconvenient, but your landlord has acknowledged this and and overall it’s better that they’re addressing the error made by the previous contractor rather than leaving the house in a poor state.

Your landlord still should have given your more notice, but at least they’re doing the right thing now. Good luck with everything. 🤞

Lonelycats · 14/07/2023 15:20

And also this is not ‘routine’ upkeep, it’s the result of an error made by a previous contractor, just adding this for full context

OP posts:
Lonelycats · 14/07/2023 15:18

an update: last week, the landlord emailed us to offer a 15% reduction in rent. At that point we had only asked for the contact details of the site manager, to learn more about the schedule of the works, we had not made any complaints whatsoever - or whinged, as some posters put it :) The landlord also informed us that the works will now take four months instead of three…

We feel happy with this, the reduction in rent will cover the cost of a local drop in office space where we can work/study as needed.

OP posts:
MurielSpriggs · 08/07/2023 08:06

Worthlessthannothing · 08/07/2023 07:55

Also compensation should be provided. You wouldn't expect to pay full price at a hotel and not receive a discount, so why is a home any different.

Exactly, only in renting are you a CF or 'entitled' for expecting what you pay for. The LL isn't doing the tenant some sort of favour, they're recieving (what is often a substantial amount of) money in return for the use of their property.
If this happened in any other area where the customer was paying and weren't receiving what they were paying for, the least expectation is a reduction to the price paid, and apologies. Yet private renting, still paying money for a service, the attitude is put up and shut up because the LL is doing you some sort of massive favour by allowing you to pay them money in return for the property they've acquired and decided to offer for rent.

If you rented an air BnB and they turned up and started putting scaffolding up with very little notice, well, I can just imagine the comments, and they wouldn't be suck it up and be grateful you're allowed to stay there in return for the money you're paying, and stop being so entitled.

Both the law (and at least currently) the rental market are on the landlords' side on this one. No compensation and no rent reduction needed.

Legally the landlord is obliged to do routine maintainance and the tenant is obliged to put up with the inconvenience caused in the process.

Thankfully for both sides the law treats licensees (in hotels and AirBnB rooms) differently from tenants. If someone would rather have the level of service provided for by a hotel, or a "serviced apartment" then that option is available (although there are some downsides!).

Worthlessthannothing · 08/07/2023 07:55

Also compensation should be provided. You wouldn't expect to pay full price at a hotel and not receive a discount, so why is a home any different.

Exactly, only in renting are you a CF or 'entitled' for expecting what you pay for. The LL isn't doing the tenant some sort of favour, they're recieving (what is often a substantial amount of) money in return for the use of their property.
If this happened in any other area where the customer was paying and weren't receiving what they were paying for, the least expectation is a reduction to the price paid, and apologies. Yet private renting, still paying money for a service, the attitude is put up and shut up because the LL is doing you some sort of massive favour by allowing you to pay them money in return for the property they've acquired and decided to offer for rent.

If you rented an air BnB and they turned up and started putting scaffolding up with very little notice, well, I can just imagine the comments, and they wouldn't be suck it up and be grateful you're allowed to stay there in return for the money you're paying, and stop being so entitled.

BoomBoom70 · 08/07/2023 00:04

Watch out for a rent increase once it is done.

Mamanyt · 07/07/2023 23:29

Check on the IegaIities of notice from IandIords. He is probabIy within the Iaw. Even so, it is not unreasonabIe to ask, but keep in minds that he is aIso not being unreasonabIe to say "no."

Cucucucu · 07/07/2023 23:16

If it means incurring extra cost like extra washing , using AC or fans or similar then yes you should be compensated

WingingItFTM · 07/07/2023 22:52

I was in this position a few years ago. We weren’t given much notice but then the building works ran on for much longer than expected (outside of the landlords control). We emailed our landlord (not a big agency, just someone with a couple of properties) and they offered a rent reduction over the holiday period it was now affecting - we accepted. Always worth trying surely? Good luck!

LauraNicolaides · 07/07/2023 19:04

Jaichangecentfoisdenom · 07/07/2023 18:59

No, you are not being unreasonable. Have you asked yet? No point bumbling on here if you haven't actually bothered to ask the LL the question.

Yes - how could it be unreasonable to ask? And no one here can tell you the likely answer, which depends a lot in where you live and what your rent is like in relation to market prices.

I would definitely ask.

Jaichangecentfoisdenom · 07/07/2023 18:59

No, you are not being unreasonable. Have you asked yet? No point bumbling on here if you haven't actually bothered to ask the LL the question.

DVL · 07/07/2023 18:37

Bet you’d want a reduction if the roof started leaking too 🤣

I’d say suck it up

KarmaStar · 07/07/2023 12:15

To keep cooler it's better to not open the Windows and to keep blinds and curtains shut,however in the evenings it's so nice to open the Windows and I really feel for you.there's some flat being done in town and it's been wrapped for 18 months now,residents hate it.
Has the LL got another property you can stay in for freer for the duration?

strongtsandcs · 07/07/2023 11:46

Namechangeforanamechange · 06/07/2023 18:28

What you are legally required to do as a landlord when a tenant's boiler breaks down, @MooMooSharoo, is make sure the tenants have access to hot water for bathing and washing dishes, and heating (if heating is needed) within 24 hours because it is a health hazard.

If you can't replace the boiler within 24 hours, a kettle is fine for washing up. You would need to pay for alternative accommodation or the use of alternative washing facilities (eg at a gym/pool) if there is no hot water to bathe. It's wise to have an electric shower fitted in rental properties as a back up for this reason. If heating is required, you should provide electric heaters and pay for any extra energy costs.

No.

They have to get a contractor to attend within 24 hours, not complete the repair within that time.

The landlord can't physically provide hot water but they can heaters via plug in heaters. A kettle boiling hot water isn't hot water for bathing.

It would depend on the needs of the tenants as to when you could decide to decant.

Also compensation should be provided. You wouldn't expect to pay full price at a hotel and not receive a discount, so why is a home any different.

MooMooSharoo · 07/07/2023 11:26

Namechangeforanamechange · 06/07/2023 18:28

What you are legally required to do as a landlord when a tenant's boiler breaks down, @MooMooSharoo, is make sure the tenants have access to hot water for bathing and washing dishes, and heating (if heating is needed) within 24 hours because it is a health hazard.

If you can't replace the boiler within 24 hours, a kettle is fine for washing up. You would need to pay for alternative accommodation or the use of alternative washing facilities (eg at a gym/pool) if there is no hot water to bathe. It's wise to have an electric shower fitted in rental properties as a back up for this reason. If heating is required, you should provide electric heaters and pay for any extra energy costs.

The property manager handles all contact with the tenants (and ultimately it's not my property either), so I'm not sure exactly what the conversations were. I know they were offered heaters but declined them.

This website would suggest that a kettle is sufficient for washing purposes.

"Lack of hot water is an emergency regardless of the season. Tenants can use a kettle for boiling water for washing purposes, but that doesn’t mean landlords can hold out on the repairs.

Some repairs might take more than the reasonable time, in which case the landlord needs to provide equipment for heating. If your landlord cannot fix the problem in time and cannot provide any replacement heaters, you should ask for temporary accommodation. You can stay with a B&B or a hotel for a few days, while waiting for the repairs to be done. This should be covered by your landlord, but if it is not, you have a strong claim for compensation with the courts."

Yes, an electric shower might be a good idea in the future, if and when this shower breaks, but hopefully now there's a brand new boiler in place there won't be any issues for a number of years to come.

I'd like to think DH is a good landlord. From our point of view at least, the managing agent seems pretty good too (other than charging DH £100 for a new shower head once!) and these tenants have been great too - they've been there for about 5 years now I think. There were concessions during Covid when they couldn't afford to pay their rent and they have a short 2-month rolling tenancy contract at their request as they're on a social housing waiting list.

I do think OP's landlord should offer some compensation though for the disruption that the works will cause.

henlee · 07/07/2023 10:52

CM1897 · 06/07/2023 18:37

Remember a landlord can increase the rent too, so if you get on the wrong side of them they may put it up

Hmm

Renters should be able to raise issues without fear of being punished via rent hikes.

In additon, the LL wouldn't be able to get new tenants at market price anyway whilst this work is being carried (no one is going to choose to rent a place where they get no natural sunlight and cannot open the windows in the height of summer, if they don't have to)

@Lonelycats I've had a rent reduction when scaffolding was put up all over the building which meant for security reasons we had to lock all the windows at night - this was during one of the heatwaves where the flat was getting to 37 degrees (!) and recommendations were to shut windows in the day and open at night.

Togiveandtoreceive · 07/07/2023 05:26

fancydressjess · 07/07/2023 01:09

Ugh!! Everyone acting like she should be grateful work is getting done...
It's 3 months of disruption and noise and being surrounded by scaffolding with feck all notice... It's going to make her work and schooling arrangements pretty unmanageable in a long term way...
And she would have chosen to just move out if she'd known... at which point, of course, likely noone else would want to move in....
So yeah, I think rent reduction is certainly in order, or maybe she can be allowed to be immediately released from her contract (even though it will be a pain)...
3 month works don't just get planned overnight and then booked for the next week... And realistically it will probably be even longer.... The LL knew about this and chose not to tell her.

It's going to make her work and schooling arrangements pretty unmanageable in a long term way.

drama llama 😂

it is all external. Having just had the similar to my property - there’s no dust, no builders underfoot and little noise

Unmanageable 😂

I am curious how it would appear that all this work os going ahead but never once did the contractor actually visit the property to assess the roof and do any investigations in order to quote.

fancydressjess · 07/07/2023 01:09

Ugh!! Everyone acting like she should be grateful work is getting done...
It's 3 months of disruption and noise and being surrounded by scaffolding with feck all notice... It's going to make her work and schooling arrangements pretty unmanageable in a long term way...
And she would have chosen to just move out if she'd known... at which point, of course, likely noone else would want to move in....
So yeah, I think rent reduction is certainly in order, or maybe she can be allowed to be immediately released from her contract (even though it will be a pain)...
3 month works don't just get planned overnight and then booked for the next week... And realistically it will probably be even longer.... The LL knew about this and chose not to tell her.

CM1897 · 07/07/2023 00:36

Daphnis156 · 06/07/2023 21:00

Oh to have a landlord that actually does work on the property, and tells you.

I came home to my rented flat one day years ago to find my staircase had been moved!

Sorry but this made me laugh 😂🙈

neverenoughplants · 06/07/2023 23:44

The notice period is definitely ridiculous, especially for three months of work. I wonder if your landlord just assumes that everyone's out of the house during the day, but that's no excuse, they definitely should have discussed it with you much earlier.

For your work (maybe this already been suggested) - you could potentially look into co-working spaces. My city has them - you pay a fee to use a desk/office space for a few hours/a day/a week depending on what you need. I'm not sure if they would allow your kids to accompany you though.

Or an alternative would be city/town libraries which will have computers as well as kids areas, and will be free. It's obviously not fair that you should be in this situation at all, but unless your landlord postpones the work (which will probably just create the same problem later in the year), it sounds like you're stuck.

Daphnis156 · 06/07/2023 21:00

Oh to have a landlord that actually does work on the property, and tells you.

I came home to my rented flat one day years ago to find my staircase had been moved!

SideWonder · 06/07/2023 20:30

it sounds like this won’t be a very good environment for learning over the coming three months.

Ypur subsequent posts make me lose sympathy for you. You’re making quite tendentious excuses and “what ifs”.

You can manage around exterior building works. It’s surprising how little noise from roof works transmits into a house. Maybe move your WFH space to the ground floor?

Your LL is correcting an error made by a contractor. I’ll bet that if there were repairs that needed doing that you felt affected you, you’d be clamoring for them to be done yesterday.

The owner of the house wants to keep their property in good shape. Why are you complaining about this?

If you don’t like works done, move or buy your own property. Then you might understand why your landlord is actually doing a good thing.

strongtsandcs · 06/07/2023 20:24

Newyearnewus · 06/07/2023 19:56

Beggars belief! Landlords can’t do right for doing wrong. LL is clearly trying to ensure the property is up to standard. Yes it’s not ideal and some more notice would’ve been better but given how hard it is to find reputable tradespeople I wouldn’t hold them to ransom. You could equally have a LL who doesn’t give a shit. What would you rather?

Doesn't mean you don't tell your tenants. The works seem very intrusive

strongtsandcs · 06/07/2023 20:23

Newyearnewus · 06/07/2023 19:57

And for what it’s worth if you were my tenant (I am a landlord) and you came to me whinging about me to trying to upkeep my property and ensure YOUR home is safe, secure etc I would be seriously considering if you were the right person to be living in my property

Maybe you should look at the rights of tenants as well.

Newyearnewus · 06/07/2023 19:57

And for what it’s worth if you were my tenant (I am a landlord) and you came to me whinging about me to trying to upkeep my property and ensure YOUR home is safe, secure etc I would be seriously considering if you were the right person to be living in my property

Swipe left for the next trending thread