Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel angry at celebrating the NHS

587 replies

TaylorSwifting · 05/07/2023 08:42

The NHS is falling apart and today people are all full of glee at the NHS yippee 75 years today, it’s making me so angry!!!!!!!!!
My family member has been diagnosed with cancer, 2 months down the line and has had no treatment and terrible delays for tests…..still yet to see an oncologist. 2 months!!!!!!!!! Family member only has pain management because us family have begged and fought to get it. It is an utter disgrace and I had no idea how bad things were until this awful diagnosis in our own family.
We are not alone / it hasn’t been a mistake or being lost in the system by accident! Record high cancer patient delays - this is what so many people are facing. I am in utter disbelief!
I won’t be celebrating today.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
3BSHKATS · 06/07/2023 11:11

Theoldgreygoose · 06/07/2023 06:18

Did you miss the fact that he would have had multiple further trips to hospital without a new valve? That was the reason the procedure was done after his third hospital visit as a doctor could see it happening again and again. Would you rather he be killed off so he didn't have to be a drain on the health service? Given that he started his working life at 14 I think he had more than contributed his fair share of taxes. If anything is "disgusting" it is you.

Anyway he hasn't taken anything from "the pot" - we don't live in the UK. Our own health system is in enough of a crisis of its own, but thank goodness not as bad as yours.

Clearly no understanding as to how the tax system works. I absolutely guarantee even working from the age of 14 he has not put in more than he’s taken out. As for his multiple trips to the hospital no I’m sorry just no.

There has to come a point in everyone’s life where people are made comfortable but that’s it you’re allowed to flipping die. It’s a natural part of the process it’s going to happen to all of us. No matter how long we try and prolong at we’re gonna get there in the end.
And if you want to try and prolong it, it should be at your expense. I actually would draw a line in the sand and pick an age beyond which certain treatments are offered.

but given your comments aren’t even related to the NHS, I’m not actually sure why you think it’s relevant to comment.

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 06/07/2023 11:09

I think our attachment to and worship of the NHS is stopping us from considering better options.

I certainly don't think it helps.

But every thread like this mentions the US as the obvious alternative and I think a lot of the British public don't think that deeply and would assume the same thing if an insurance system was mentioned. So any party that wanted to consider serious reform would never win an election.

BCCoach · 06/07/2023 11:07

Tootyfilou · 05/07/2023 11:21

The people slagging off the NHS… careful what you wish for. Do you really want private healthcare! ? We don’t realize how fortunate we are. People died before the NHS because they couldn’t afford medical treatment.
Peoples anger should be at the Tories who have done everything since its inception to underfund it.
It appalls and horrifies me how little some people value it.

People want an insurance based healthcare system, like every other European country. Because people know that their friends and relatives in Germany, France, Spain, Sweden etc have much better healthcare experiences than we do here.

Happyfluffball · 06/07/2023 11:04

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 06/07/2023 11:02

But some of the comments on this thread have sailed pretty close to this attitude. Which lives are worth less than others to these people? At what age do we just let people die?

I think the current system means that loads of people are dying early, whether it's from delayed cancer treatment or long term complications from delays to surgery for hip/knee replacements/heart surgery etc. I think the NHS in its current form just isn't fit for purpose but I don't see any political party having the appetite to change it. Very depressing really.

I think our attachment to and worship of the NHS is stopping us from considering better options.

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 06/07/2023 11:02

But some of the comments on this thread have sailed pretty close to this attitude. Which lives are worth less than others to these people? At what age do we just let people die?

I think the current system means that loads of people are dying early, whether it's from delayed cancer treatment or long term complications from delays to surgery for hip/knee replacements/heart surgery etc. I think the NHS in its current form just isn't fit for purpose but I don't see any political party having the appetite to change it. Very depressing really.

ElizabethBest · 06/07/2023 11:00

TrixieFatell · 05/07/2023 09:35

I have mixed feelings.

I work in the NHS and I love that people can access Healthcare without worry about astronomical fees or insurance bills. It makes a massive difference to a lot of lives. The basic premise behind the NHS is worth celebrating. Ive had mixed experiences with the NHS over my lifetime but we have managed to get treatment when needed.

However I also am angry how years of underfunding and mismanagement have eroded the NHS. How the government decided to elevate it and their staff to being heros, making it a vocation and not treating their staff as the skilled professionals they are. This leads to feelings of anger towards the NHS and means that the staff should be grateful for some claps and a badge.
I hate the abuse we get almost daily because of the waiting times and I see so many of my colleagues burning out and leaving.

So I won't be celebrating the nhs's birthday. But I will be thinking of the staff who work so so hard to keep the NHS going against insurmountable odds.

Exactly this. I love what the NHS could and should be. None of us are going to work every day for a low salary, high stress and long hours to let people down, but there are no beds, no funds and more and more staff are leaving, so we are all very, very tired. I have spent the last year covering 4 full time jobs at once.

The government seem to think that we can carry on indefinitely on clapping and badges and no investment, and the stupid thing is that because we don't want to put people at risk, we keep trying. There's little to celebrate, but I am still proud to work for the NHS and have (ever decreasing) hope that we might be able to turn things around.

TheHoover · 06/07/2023 10:55

Andrew Lansley was a fucking disgrace and was rewarded for his incompetence and (IMO absolute dedication to feathering his own nest) with a peerage. One of the (many) reasons why I despise the HoLs in its current form.

Yes, millions down the drain in dismantling PCTs, paying out six figure redundancies, re-hiring the staff again in new commissioning organisations filled with administrators and beurocrats undergoing pointless tendering exercises and creating the new job of contract management. All in the name of separating the commissioner from the provider and opening up the market to private providers.

beguilingeyes · 06/07/2023 10:49

pointythings · 05/07/2023 15:32

@Sweetpeasaremadeforbees the note has been a long standing tradition of outgoing governments for many decades, though the wording varies. It's meaningless. It's just that the Tories are the first government to have used it for political gain. People don't know this, which is tragic.

This. The way the Tories have weaponised this is disgusting..and the whole country has swallowed it. We've got more government debt under this government than we ever had in the Blair/Brown years.

"“But we seem to be paying an extraordinary amount of money to people who literally just exist.”

Curious about this. What type of person just exists and shouldn’t get free healthcare?"

Also this. It's my belief that the likes of Johnson and Rees Mogg have nothing but contempt for us plebs, the majority of the population and couldn't care less about the NHS as they'll never have to use it (the Grenfell victims were basically stupid and 'let the bodies pile high' etc)
But some of the comments on this thread have sailed pretty close to this attitude. Which lives are worth less than others to these people? At what age do we just let people die?

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 06/07/2023 10:32

but nothing has happened over the last 15 years to convince me there is a purposeful aim rather than just neglect. To be honest I don’t think they have the competence to carry out a long term heist.

Yes I agree, I think most MPs are pretty shit and incompetent really.

It’s a legal requirement under the 2012 Health Act. Which is the most shit piece of health legislation ever approved by Parliament. Hopefully the next government will make repealing that section of it a priority.

Andrew Lansley was a fucking disgrace and was rewarded for his incompetence and (IMO absolute dedication to feathering his own nest) with a peerage. One of the (many) reasons why I despise the HoLs in its current form.

1dayatatime · 06/07/2023 10:29

cwanne · 06/07/2023 08:01

This is why it was so encouraging when Wes Streeting was talking about reform earlier in his time as shadow health secretary. It's probably only with a Labour government that we can have a proper conversation about structural change. However, he seems to have been brought back to heel by Starmer so I'm not hopeful.

No political party will ever get elected with a policy of reforming the NHS - it is a sacred cow.

Blossomtoes · 06/07/2023 10:09

I assumed the handing out of contracts for certain services to private companies was done by local health authorities not by MPs.

It’s a legal requirement under the 2012 Health Act. Which is the most shit piece of health legislation ever approved by Parliament. Hopefully the next government will make repealing that section of it a priority.

Sweetashunni · 06/07/2023 10:06

Notonthestairs · 06/07/2023 08:08

Obviously Trump was talking out of turn.

'Speaking at a joint press conference, US President Donald Trump said the National Health Service would form part of negotiations over a possible future trade deal between the UK and US.
"When you're dealing in trade, everything is on the table," he said.
The president's comments come after the US ambassador to the UK, Woody Johnson, told the BBC's Marr programme that the United States would seek business access to the NHS as part of trade negotiations after Brexit.'
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/av/uk-48516196

It pharma prices that they'd really want to get their hands on.

Im not a conservative voter, I will never be a conservative voter, but nothing has happened over the last 15 years to convince me there is a purposeful aim rather than just neglect. To be honest I don’t think they have the competence to carry out a long term heist.

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 06/07/2023 10:06

Personally I dont want politicians anywhere near decisions over the NHS.
Its their short termist policies that have driven it in to the ground in the first place.
Id be interested for health economists to trawl countries for options and provide that sort of information. No donors. No backroom deals. No 5 year plans.

I agree with that. But I don't believe that there is a plan by the Tories to privatise by stealth or otherwise. I assumed the handing out of contracts for certain services to private companies was done by local health authorities not by MPs. And the public service industry is notoriously shit at negotiating a good deal for taxpayers (see PFI deals for hospitals where companies can charge £100 for going in to change a lightbulb).

Blossomtoes · 06/07/2023 10:01

Teabutnotasweknowit · 06/07/2023 07:59

The trust I worked in until recently had a band 7 'ward manager' and several band 6 sisters. That was the norm for every ward.

I don’t believe you. The NHS has 40,000 nursing vacancies, even when it didn’t that level of over staffing was unheard of.

Notonthestairs · 06/07/2023 09:41

"the Tories want to run the NHS down “insidiously”??
okaaaayyyy"

A decade of underfunding infrastructure, estates, IT and salaries and failing to provide a funded workforce plan (despite persistent pleas from the Health Select Committee), ignoring retention issues and failing to provide comprehensive Social Care plan - one of the key means to lift pressures on the NHS - doesn't exactly fill me with confidence, no.

PrincessTigger · 06/07/2023 09:18

TheHoover · 06/07/2023 09:01

@PrincessTigger
oh I missed your glorious last post. I have a list of about 50 things I can criticise about the NHS. Does that make me ignorant and right wing?

Apparently so.

AgathaSpencerGregson · 06/07/2023 09:03

Notonthestairs · 06/07/2023 08:46

I was simply pointing out what was in the US interests in any UK US trade deal.

It's not about selling the NHS. Just running it down and then giving access.

Far more complex and insidious than simply selling it.

so you think that the fact that US pharmacy companies have an interest in the UK market is evidence that the Tories want to run the NHS down “insidiously”??
okaaaayyyy

TheHoover · 06/07/2023 09:01

@PrincessTigger
oh I missed your glorious last post. I have a list of about 50 things I can criticise about the NHS. Does that make me ignorant and right wing?

cwanne · 06/07/2023 08:54

Notonthestairs · 06/07/2023 08:10

Personally I dont want politicians anywhere near decisions over the NHS.
Its their short termist policies that have driven it in to the ground in the first place.
Id be interested for health economists to trawl countries for options and provide that sort of information. No donors. No backroom deals. No 5 year plans.

This makes sense. We need to have a serious discussion about different systems and the trade offs.

Notonthestairs · 06/07/2023 08:46

I was simply pointing out what was in the US interests in any UK US trade deal.

It's not about selling the NHS. Just running it down and then giving access.

Far more complex and insidious than simply selling it.

TheHoover · 06/07/2023 08:46

@AgathaSpencerGregson how
about you stop straw manning (continuing to use the word ‘sell’).

AgathaSpencerGregson · 06/07/2023 08:40

Notonthestairs · 06/07/2023 08:35

I remember when the Conservatives were pretty keen for a US trade deal - they needed the boost post Brexit. And it would be a huge mistake or just plain dumb to overlook the influence US Pharma companies have within US politics.

"If the United States can get a provision that allows it to influence UK drug prices into a trade deal with the United Kingdom, then, in theory,* *drug prices around the world could rise.
“The UK system is a benchmark in all sorts of ways. That might be specific decisions on pricing or whether it allows a drug to be used in the NHS,” says Mark Dayan, a policy analyst at Nuffield Trust, another health think tank. “Decisions made in the UK will be noticed internationally and could affect how decisions are made in other countries.”
Getting a sweet deal with the United Kingdom would provide another boost for both the drug lobby and US trade negotiators: it would set a precedent for any future US trade deals with other countries."

https://edition.cnn.com/2019/12/06/business/nhs-trump-trade-drugs-analysis-intl-ge19/index.html

When you’ve found some actual evidence that it’s Tory policy to privatise the NHS and sell it to “the US” (who within the US?), you let me know.
til then I’ll keep working on those tinfoil hats.

Notonthestairs · 06/07/2023 08:35

I remember when the Conservatives were pretty keen for a US trade deal - they needed the boost post Brexit. And it would be a huge mistake or just plain dumb to overlook the influence US Pharma companies have within US politics.

"If the United States can get a provision that allows it to influence UK drug prices into a trade deal with the United Kingdom, then, in theory,* *drug prices around the world could rise.
“The UK system is a benchmark in all sorts of ways. That might be specific decisions on pricing or whether it allows a drug to be used in the NHS,” says Mark Dayan, a policy analyst at Nuffield Trust, another health think tank. “Decisions made in the UK will be noticed internationally and could affect how decisions are made in other countries.”
Getting a sweet deal with the United Kingdom would provide another boost for both the drug lobby and US trade negotiators: it would set a precedent for any future US trade deals with other countries."

https://edition.cnn.com/2019/12/06/business/nhs-trump-trade-drugs-analysis-intl-ge19/index.html

US pharma companies really do want Britain to pay more for drugs | CNN Business

When President Donald Trump arrived in the United Kingdom this week, he landed bang in the middle of a huge political fight about the country’s National Health Service.

https://edition.cnn.com/2019/12/06/business/nhs-trump-trade-drugs-analysis-intl-ge19/index.html

TheHoover · 06/07/2023 08:33

@AgathaSpencerGregson
youll be saying the government isn’t systemically defunding and dismantling the bbc with support from the right wing media next. Tut these conspiracy theorists.

AgathaSpencerGregson · 06/07/2023 08:25

Notonthestairs · 06/07/2023 08:08

Obviously Trump was talking out of turn.

'Speaking at a joint press conference, US President Donald Trump said the National Health Service would form part of negotiations over a possible future trade deal between the UK and US.
"When you're dealing in trade, everything is on the table," he said.
The president's comments come after the US ambassador to the UK, Woody Johnson, told the BBC's Marr programme that the United States would seek business access to the NHS as part of trade negotiations after Brexit.'
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/av/uk-48516196

It pharma prices that they'd really want to get their hands on.

If we’re taking the pronouncements of trump as proof of what Tory policy is or was, then I am afraid we have lost our minds.

Swipe left for the next trending thread