Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel angry at celebrating the NHS

587 replies

TaylorSwifting · 05/07/2023 08:42

The NHS is falling apart and today people are all full of glee at the NHS yippee 75 years today, it’s making me so angry!!!!!!!!!
My family member has been diagnosed with cancer, 2 months down the line and has had no treatment and terrible delays for tests…..still yet to see an oncologist. 2 months!!!!!!!!! Family member only has pain management because us family have begged and fought to get it. It is an utter disgrace and I had no idea how bad things were until this awful diagnosis in our own family.
We are not alone / it hasn’t been a mistake or being lost in the system by accident! Record high cancer patient delays - this is what so many people are facing. I am in utter disbelief!
I won’t be celebrating today.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
AgathaSpencerGregson · 05/07/2023 11:07

The NHS has helped to achieve huge improvements in public health since 1948. Of that there is no doubt and that should be recognised. The population and its expectations has changed hugely since then and it is not wrong to ask if the model needs to change. It is also not wrong to point to the clear problems with culture and governance within the NHS and the professions which work within it (some of which problems of course predate the NHS).

BCCoach · 05/07/2023 11:05

grafittiartist · 05/07/2023 08:49

Plenty of the world would be grateful for the NHS.
I think it's a date worth celebrating!

Which other developed countries would be grateful for the NHS?

Badbadbunny · 05/07/2023 11:05

NoChanceYouMetalBastard · 05/07/2023 08:46

Agreed. The ridiculous NHS worship that started during the pandemic continues.

The stupidity started long before Covid. Have we forgotten the vomit inducing scenes at the start of the London Olympics?

I won't be celebrating. The NHS woefully neglected to treat both my father (2010) and my mother in law (2008) who both had cancer and both suffered ridiculous levels of neglect and inefficiency leading to their deaths. In my father's case, despite the much celebrated short waiting lists, it took them 18 months to operate on his cancer, after one delay/foul up after another - no one cared, every cancelled operation was just glibly shrugged off as "one of those things" whether it was the surgeon being on a course, the operating theatre being decorated - some of the reasons (excuses) were crazy. But basically because he'd missed the (I think) 20 week "target", there was no incentive to operate as the target had been missed, so others close to the target were prioritised and he was left languishing on a hospital ward! Very similar with my mother in law - lost files, missing staff at appointments/treatments, etc - consultations and treatment sessions just glibly cancelled without reason, re-scheduled for a few weeks later, no sense of urgency. It's heartbreaking when you see your previously fit/healthy relatives continue to deteriorate whilst supposedly under the "care" of the NHS - I've heard it's referred to as "supervised neglect" when basically they're just monitoring your condition etc but not actually doing anything about it!

saveforthat · 05/07/2023 11:03

KnickerlessParsons · 05/07/2023 08:46

Well my DH has has absolutely fantastic care and support throughout his cancer journey. Wouldn't have got better care if we'd gone privately. So many people are looking after him - we estimate his treatment and ongoing care must have cost at least £1m.

I had the same experience as your DH. I will be celebrating. The NHS definitely needs an overhaul though.

Cakesandbabes · 05/07/2023 11:03

Themselves · 05/07/2023 10:52

This. Great post.

I lived in Germany many years ago. The difference was astonishing. You have a health problem and you get treatment. People there could not believe or comprehend that it is usual and accepted to wait months, often years, for essential treatment in the UK. (That really is crazy when you stop and think about it). It is an insurance-based system but it's nothing like America - no-one is left without treatment.

I have a close friend with cancer who is experiencing similar to the OP. It is so frightening. You can die in the UK from lack of medical care. How is that a system fit for purpose?

My family in central europe had access to gps, dentists etc as usual months before people in uk. Face to face, not having to describe infected tonsils on a phone after trying to call or 4 days to get phone appointment....
They are like Germans, surprised at lack of access in UK.
Quality has been joked about for decades. Broken leg? Aw, have a paracetamol. Decades

Tootyfilou · 05/07/2023 11:00

I am so very sorry that your relative is ill and is waiting so long for treatment.
However your anger should be against the Tories who have starved the NHS of funding, depleted it of staff and done their very best to bring it to its knees.
Despite all that it continues to perform, saves lives and gives … for the most part … wonderful medicine and care.
All free from the point of contact.
I have worked in the NHS for 40 years and would literally lay down my life to save it.

Sweetashunni · 05/07/2023 11:00

ButterCrackers · 05/07/2023 10:54

People get denied treatment and fobbed off until they die. The nhs is not fit for purpose. It’s paid for by taxes so people have paid but can’t see a dentist , gp, get a test etc. Truly a shoddy service. The people who work there are doing jobs they are not angels or happily in service they need to be paid right. It’s not an honour to work there it’s a job.

But an awful lot of people aren’t paying taxes, or nowhere near enough to contributing more to the system than they take. We have a very very high proportion of the public on out of work benefits. This is the result. No cash and strained services.

MiniTheMinx · 05/07/2023 11:00

NoNotHimTheOtherOne · 05/07/2023 09:00

I think we can celebrate the fact that - against substantial political and professional opposition - the UK managed to introduce healthcare free at the point of delivery in 1948. I don't think it can be disputed that there are significant problems with the NHS at present, and these aren't simply a matter of the amount of money allocated to it.

Any celebrations should take into account that there are powerful groups opposed to the principle of universal healthcare who need to be fought against while recognising that the model for delivery of care needs to be rethought and desperately needs to include social care and preventative action rather than just remedial management of existing conditions.

This 100%

PrincessTigger · 05/07/2023 11:00

Clementineorsatsuma · 05/07/2023 10:55

It's falling apart because of the Tories.

Not because of itself.

They've saved 3 people close to me in recent years and 2 family members work tirelessly as Paramedics saving others.

How dare you.

It’s a democracy and our terrible healthcare system which defends negligent doctors and nurses means our relatives have lost their lives too soon, so I dare.

If your paramedic family members are 2 of the good ones they should be calling out the bad ones, they shouldn’t fear criticism if they’re any good.

TakeMe2Insanity · 05/07/2023 10:58

The NHS has been let down by the government. They absolutely need to celebrate what they stand for so that they can remain true to themselves and not the watered down version that will be given to us if the government has their way.

Clementineorsatsuma · 05/07/2023 10:55

It's falling apart because of the Tories.

Not because of itself.

They've saved 3 people close to me in recent years and 2 family members work tirelessly as Paramedics saving others.

How dare you.

ButterCrackers · 05/07/2023 10:54

People get denied treatment and fobbed off until they die. The nhs is not fit for purpose. It’s paid for by taxes so people have paid but can’t see a dentist , gp, get a test etc. Truly a shoddy service. The people who work there are doing jobs they are not angels or happily in service they need to be paid right. It’s not an honour to work there it’s a job.

Notonthestairs · 05/07/2023 10:54

"France, Austria, Australia, Germany - all have far superior healthcare,"

"In 2022 the UK spent $5493 per capita, the OECD $5009 - this includes some lower income members. France $6517, Denmark $6279, Germany $8010 NZ 6061 Spain $4461 Australia $6596 Finland $5676 Belgium $6600"

twitter.com/nedwards_1/status/1676217117803266050?s=46&t=Uw4lJNwxFZFnX0Xs3doHYg

Nigel Edwards is CEO of the Nuffield Trust.

•	Average day-to-day health spending in the UK between 2010 and 2019 was £3,005 per person – 18% below the EU14 average of £3,655.
•	If UK spending per person had matched the EU14 average, then the UK would have spent an average of £227bn a year on health between 2010 and 2019 – £40bn higher than actual average annual spending during this period (£187bn).
•	Matching spending per head to France or Germany would have led to an additional £40bn and £73bn (21% to 39% increase respectively) of total health spending each year in the UK.
•	Over the past decade, the UK had a lower level of capital investment in health care compared with the EU14 countries for which data are available. Between 2010 and 2019, average health capital investment in the UK was £5.8bn a year. If the UK had matched other EU14 countries’ average investment in health capital (as a share of GDP), the UK would have invested £33bn more between 2010 and 2019 (around 55% higher than actual investment during that period).

www.health.org.uk/news-and-comment/charts-and-infographics/how-does-uk-health-spending-compare-across-europe-over-the-past-decade

I'm not opposed to change but the Government have to be straightforward with the electorate.

Themselves · 05/07/2023 10:52

DappledOliveGroves · 05/07/2023 09:32

The NHS is not fit for purpose and hasn't been for years. Yes, there are pockets of good care, but the fact that the British public put up with this system and seem to think it's wonderful astonishes me. France, Austria, Australia, Germany - all have far superior healthcare, no-one dies because they can't afford to pay, their funding models are better, their treatment is better and I wish wholeheartedly we could scrap the NHS and start over.

No-one wants the American model. The idea that the only two options are US-style healthcare, or the NHS, is ridiculous. I'd vote for a party who would grasp the nettle, commission a massive study into the various healthcare systems around the world, and then come up with a model that actually works.

This. Great post.

I lived in Germany many years ago. The difference was astonishing. You have a health problem and you get treatment. People there could not believe or comprehend that it is usual and accepted to wait months, often years, for essential treatment in the UK. (That really is crazy when you stop and think about it). It is an insurance-based system but it's nothing like America - no-one is left without treatment.

I have a close friend with cancer who is experiencing similar to the OP. It is so frightening. You can die in the UK from lack of medical care. How is that a system fit for purpose?

PrincessTigger · 05/07/2023 10:51

Through medical negligence the NHS killed my friend’s mum, my gran, and nearly killed me and DS. They don’t take responsibility and just gang up against you. Nothing ever changes.

Someone suggested that the NHS should have an accident investigation system like the air travel industry, but it’s never going to happen because of all the NHS worship.

The NHS is a BAD system. Every budget they throw billions more money at it and it’s still a bad system. So many European countries have better systems and better outcomes than us.

Sweetashunni · 05/07/2023 10:47

cwanne · 05/07/2023 10:40

I completely agree with DappledOliveGroves.

So do I.

Chocolateship · 05/07/2023 10:42

3BSHKATS · 05/07/2023 10:39

The salaries are generous by any CEO standard.
Not suggesting the people shouldn’t get paid. Of course they should, but they should actually get paid market rate.

If you look at them as an average then sure as that includes the CEOs for SMEs etc too, if you look at similar size organisations with similar level of responsibility and skills etc then no they aren't.

cwanne · 05/07/2023 10:40

DappledOliveGroves · 05/07/2023 09:32

The NHS is not fit for purpose and hasn't been for years. Yes, there are pockets of good care, but the fact that the British public put up with this system and seem to think it's wonderful astonishes me. France, Austria, Australia, Germany - all have far superior healthcare, no-one dies because they can't afford to pay, their funding models are better, their treatment is better and I wish wholeheartedly we could scrap the NHS and start over.

No-one wants the American model. The idea that the only two options are US-style healthcare, or the NHS, is ridiculous. I'd vote for a party who would grasp the nettle, commission a massive study into the various healthcare systems around the world, and then come up with a model that actually works.

I completely agree with DappledOliveGroves.

Hadjab · 05/07/2023 10:39

We can celebrate the NHS as a concept and celebrate the great people who work in it, whilst railing against its failings. If we want to save it, we need to get the current government out. The power is in our hands but we have consistently failed to grasp it.

3BSHKATS · 05/07/2023 10:39

The salaries are generous by any CEO standard.
Not suggesting the people shouldn’t get paid. Of course they should, but they should actually get paid market rate.

turkeyboots · 05/07/2023 10:38

FiL died last year, 8 month's after a stage 4 cancer diagnosis, and never once saw an oncologist. The local hospital couldn't fill the vacancy and the cover doctor from another hospital also quit.
Its hard to celebrate it in its current shambles.

Chocolateship · 05/07/2023 10:37

Artycrafts · 05/07/2023 10:27

So underfunded,it pays its chief executives huge salaries.

The salaries aren't huge for the role though, they're lower than the same level would get in the private sector. You need people with experience for these roles and to attract them you need to at least make an attempt to pay a reasonable salary. The opposite is why healthcare staff pay is crap, because the NHS is by far the largest employer and for some roles the only one that offers certain things that they have known up to now that people by and large will deal with low pay as there aren't a whole host of alternatives.

The reason for delays is lack of staff, the government is doing nothing to address this, its not the fault of the concept of the NHS though, its the government.

3BSHKATS · 05/07/2023 10:37

Sweetashunni · 05/07/2023 09:39

What does this mean? What sort of situations are you referring to specifically?

Several examples spring to mind, firstly, an elderly lady who lives at the end of our road, who, honest to goodness never leaves the house I have never seen the woman in daylight. She must be 85. Next week she’s going into hospital for some sort of heart operation. If the woman survives, it’ll be nothing short of a miracle. But I’m sorry if I was 85 I would be refusing to go through that level of treatment. What is actually the bloody point ?
2nd example, ex friend, back problems - the woman actually genuinely does have back problems. She is obese, with diabetes no doubt she would say because because she cant exercise. Even though 80% of weight management is what goes in your mouth. Whatever they do for her is literally just going to manage the pain she’s never gonna walk again properly. She’s never gonna be employed. But it hasn’t stopped her having three children with somebody who earns 20,000 a year.

Obviously, I don’t want the woman to be in pain, but this is why the NHS is fucked.

ThatSunCreamSmell · 05/07/2023 10:37

It seems like it'a a complete lottery. There are stories from both ends of the spectrum.

Personally I've heard more on the negative / delayed side and had a terrible experience both during and after childbirth. I'm petrified of me or my family getting seriously ill and being unable to access adequate care.

Whatsun · 05/07/2023 10:35

TaylorSwifting · 05/07/2023 08:52

But by celebrating, we ARE celebrating the government and giving them a big pat on the back.

Exactly.

The NHS is a fantastic concept. I totally buy into the fact that we need a nationalised health service funded by taxation that is free at the point of use.

At the moment it's not working very well and it's causing a lot of people pain, distress, poorer outcomes and even death. It has to change. It has to improve.

Politicians love spinning it as a thing of sentiment. Like a child that you have to love unconditionally. It's not. We need to be critical and we need to criticise because otherwise it will not be fit for purpose. It's not a little child that we celebrate merely for existing. It is something that had to fulfil its purpose.