Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel angry at celebrating the NHS

587 replies

TaylorSwifting · 05/07/2023 08:42

The NHS is falling apart and today people are all full of glee at the NHS yippee 75 years today, it’s making me so angry!!!!!!!!!
My family member has been diagnosed with cancer, 2 months down the line and has had no treatment and terrible delays for tests…..still yet to see an oncologist. 2 months!!!!!!!!! Family member only has pain management because us family have begged and fought to get it. It is an utter disgrace and I had no idea how bad things were until this awful diagnosis in our own family.
We are not alone / it hasn’t been a mistake or being lost in the system by accident! Record high cancer patient delays - this is what so many people are facing. I am in utter disbelief!
I won’t be celebrating today.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
Gooniesnecersaydie · 09/07/2023 11:55

NoNotHimTheOtherOne · 05/07/2023 09:00

I think we can celebrate the fact that - against substantial political and professional opposition - the UK managed to introduce healthcare free at the point of delivery in 1948. I don't think it can be disputed that there are significant problems with the NHS at present, and these aren't simply a matter of the amount of money allocated to it.

Any celebrations should take into account that there are powerful groups opposed to the principle of universal healthcare who need to be fought against while recognising that the model for delivery of care needs to be rethought and desperately needs to include social care and preventative action rather than just remedial management of existing conditions.

Yep. Prior to the NHS men, women and children were needlessly dying because paying Dr's fees wasn't an option.

There are obvious problems with the NHS now but the fact that no-one in this country needs to worry about paying for an ambulance and hospital treatment when they're suffering a medical emergency should be celebrated.

Brightandshining · 08/07/2023 20:36

This is not the fault of the NHS as a concept it's the fault of a government who systematically underfund it and are selling parts of it off with a view to further privatisation
The NHS as a concept certainly should be celebrated. It is a wonderful concept and we need to fight to keep it alive. We need to vote in governments that will prioritise it and keep it free at point of access.
Our NHS is still world's ahead of the situation in many other countries.
Is it perfect? No. But it's very much worth celebrating as a concept because it has saved countless lives and improved quality of life in the UK over the years. We should not abandon it

Blossomtoes · 08/07/2023 20:31

3BSHKATS · 08/07/2023 17:51

I meant emotional attachment to the patience, but it’s mildly amusing that that’s how you interpreted it. They might run out of warm bodies.

No you didn’t. We all know health care professionals don’t have an emotional attachment to their patients. There was only one way to interpret it and backtracking constantly doesn’t change it.

pointythings · 08/07/2023 17:57

OK, so now you're saying wanting to get people well is wrong and you should put a calculator where your heart is? You just get better and better.

Anyway, I know too many clinicians to think that is how they operate.

3BSHKATS · 08/07/2023 17:51

I meant emotional attachment to the patience, but it’s mildly amusing that that’s how you interpreted it. They might run out of warm bodies.

Blossomtoes · 08/07/2023 17:03

purely on the basis that anybody with a learning or physical hasn’t had the opportunity to acquire the necessary means to pay for the insurance policy.

Nor have older people with the worst health outcomes. Life expectancy and healthy life expectancy are hugely affected by affluence or the lack of it. People from deprived areas have many fewer years on both measures. Those people are those with a life time of low incomes. So essentially what you’re saying is we treat people according to wealth, with those whose health is worst getting least treatment.

pointythings · 08/07/2023 16:24

Anybody that works in the health service or the care system has a vested interest in keeping these old people going whether it’s in their best interests or not.

Oh don't be silly. Given the length of waiting lists in the NHS and the fact that NHS Trusts can't recruit or retain staff, this isn't about people who are worried they might not have a job if they don't treat old people. That's the most ridiculous thing you've posted on this thread so far.

3BSHKATS · 08/07/2023 16:04

@pointythings no purely on the basis that anybody with a learning or physical hasn’t had the opportunity to acquire the necessary means to pay for the insurance policy. I’m not proposing that if an 80-year-old gets hit by a bus, they aren’t scraped up off the floor and patched up. I think we just need to draw the line with regards to quality of life.

Anybody that works in the health service or the care system has a vested interest in keeping these old people going whether it’s in their best interests or not. So I wouldnt expect anything other than faked horror from them.

pointythings · 08/07/2023 16:00

@3BSHKATS I'm aware, don't be patronising.

But the system is as it is and until we decide to change it, we don't get to deny its use to anyone except for clinical reasons. Anything else is Logan's Run territory.

As I've said, I wouldn't be opposed to an insurance based system like the ones that operate in France, Germany and the Netherlands - as long as, like those systems, there was provision for people who are older or have long term, chronic or incurable conditions to keep their premiums affordable. Until we make that move, we make our treatment decisions on clinical grounds only.

Just a question - since you favour denying people treatment based on age, do you also favour denying treatments to people with learning difficulties or physical disabilities? After all it's distinctly likely that as a group, they aren't paying their way.

3BSHKATS · 08/07/2023 15:46

pointythings · 08/07/2023 15:44

Of course older people are more frequent users of health services. That comes with age. Those older people have also paid into the system through their taxes.

And the fact that older people are getting treatment isn't evidence that younger people aren't. That isn't how data works.

How many people do you think are contributors, and have actually covered the cost of their birth to the NHS never mind anything else and I would include myself in that number.

It just doesn’t work like a bank account where you put money in and you withdraw it out when you need it. The numbers just do not stack up.

pointythings · 08/07/2023 15:44

3BSHKATS · 07/07/2023 23:02

In England in 2017, there were 16.6 million hospital admissions for people of any age (Figure 1). Of these, 3.5 million (22.2%) were amongst people aged 75 years and older, despite this age group only representing 8.2% of the population.

obviously, these numbers are out of date but I can’t imagine they’ve diminished can you?

It’s disproportionate, obviously nobody is going publish the costs. Nobody is going to highlight the bleeding obvious that the resources are not infinite. Despite the claims that they are, they clearly not.

Of course older people are more frequent users of health services. That comes with age. Those older people have also paid into the system through their taxes.

And the fact that older people are getting treatment isn't evidence that younger people aren't. That isn't how data works.

user1497207191 · 08/07/2023 15:34

DappledOliveGroves · 05/07/2023 09:32

The NHS is not fit for purpose and hasn't been for years. Yes, there are pockets of good care, but the fact that the British public put up with this system and seem to think it's wonderful astonishes me. France, Austria, Australia, Germany - all have far superior healthcare, no-one dies because they can't afford to pay, their funding models are better, their treatment is better and I wish wholeheartedly we could scrap the NHS and start over.

No-one wants the American model. The idea that the only two options are US-style healthcare, or the NHS, is ridiculous. I'd vote for a party who would grasp the nettle, commission a massive study into the various healthcare systems around the world, and then come up with a model that actually works.

Nail on the head. Such a shame that the politicians are too spineless to address the NHS problems properly. The answer is always "throw more money at it", which is part of the solution, but not without fundamental changes throughout.

Trouble is also that Joe Public can't be trusted to vote intelligently. The national ID card system was scrapped because it was unpopular, likewise John Prescott's regional assemblies (which to be honest was batshit!), then we had the libdem's hard fought voting referendum that the public rejected, though it could have been the start of electoral reform, then Brexit - say no more, then Boris getting re-elected - say no more.

Joe Public isn't capable of researching, logical thought, and voting based on facts rather than image or habit - the media play to that, and as such, so do politicians. Reform of the NHS is unpopular so it will never happen!

carequalworker · 08/07/2023 15:20

And if you want to try and prolong it, it should be at your expense. I actually would draw a line in the sand and pick an age beyond which certain treatments are offered.

This is beyond the pale. But not surprising given this poster has form for truly vile posts. Honest to fuck hope she doesn't work in the health or care sector.

GardenWorkOverWeekend · 08/07/2023 08:43

I'm sad and frustrated looking at the 75th celebrations, maybe because I do not feel like celebrating - we've several staff members who left, struggle to recruit, waiting times are the longest I remember, people we see have very complex needs that we cannot help with and it's a struggle to refer anywhere, so we end up with revolving doors. A couple of photo opportunities won't help.

creativeusername23 · 08/07/2023 00:28

I totally appreciate the many, many wonderful staff that work within the NHS, often in really rubbish conditions and the care I’ve had in hospitals for myself or my children has been amazing.

Where I’ve noticed the failings of late however are the call handlers and think the service needs an overhaul or ‘something’ to stop this apparent habit of just passing the book, letting serious red flags go untreated and not wanting to take action. Perhaps it’s lack of training, perhaps too much of a workload and too little funding, perhaps too many people utilising it when they don’t need to; I’m not sure of the cause.

I called 111 with what I didn’t know at the time, a pulmonary embolism. MN actually diagnosed me because I was just told by 111 to go to a pharmacy rather than A&E. I don’t like to think about what may have happened had I not posted here with doubts and being urged to go to be seen. I complained and have it in writing that I was failed and the call handler repeatedly didn’t seek further advice from a clinician or ask me further questions to clarify.

We were told to ring 999 on another occasion by our GP reception, for a rash on baby DD which wasn’t fading under glass and had changed in colour/type. We rang 999 where we got stuck with a call handler for ages who deemed us not of urgency, didn’t need an ambulance and they’d just pass it back to a GP at our surgery to ring us back in 10 minutes. GP rang absolutely furious at their response and insistent that any child, especially a baby, with a non blanching rash, must go to hospital.

Theoldgreygoose · 07/07/2023 23:25

3BSHKATS · 07/07/2023 20:59

No, no, you misunderstood. I don’t think he should’ve gone to the hospital every few weeks either, unless he is paying himself. Then he/you can do whatever he likes.
Decisions like that will be in people like me’s hands when we get to the ballot box.

He never called an ambulance himself for these hospital trips - what was he supposed to do when one turned up, tell them sorry, I don't want to go into hospital even though you think I should!! As I've already told you, he wouldn't have died if he didn't go to hospital, but would have had a shit quality of life - apparently that is the price one pays for getting old in your skewed little world.

As for "paying himself" - I've never heard of a hospital here which tells patients they can pay if they want to.

Reading through the posts on this thread you are very much in the minority in your ideas, and even if the government changes when you get to the ballot box what makes you think the new govt. will change the way your health service works (unless of course you will be in charge of it!!!).

Here we have a change of government every few years, nothing has changed about the how the elderly are treated under any of them.

Blossomtoes · 07/07/2023 23:24

3BSHKATS · 07/07/2023 23:02

In England in 2017, there were 16.6 million hospital admissions for people of any age (Figure 1). Of these, 3.5 million (22.2%) were amongst people aged 75 years and older, despite this age group only representing 8.2% of the population.

obviously, these numbers are out of date but I can’t imagine they’ve diminished can you?

It’s disproportionate, obviously nobody is going publish the costs. Nobody is going to highlight the bleeding obvious that the resources are not infinite. Despite the claims that they are, they clearly not.

That’s because more old people get sick. It’s not rocket science.

3BSHKATS · 07/07/2023 23:02

pointythings · 07/07/2023 22:12

Nope, not buying it. We don't make people pay more because they're old, that's wrong. People should be prioritised on waiting lists according to purely clinical criteria, not age.

Where's your evidence that younger people are not being seen? Show us the data.

In England in 2017, there were 16.6 million hospital admissions for people of any age (Figure 1). Of these, 3.5 million (22.2%) were amongst people aged 75 years and older, despite this age group only representing 8.2% of the population.

obviously, these numbers are out of date but I can’t imagine they’ve diminished can you?

It’s disproportionate, obviously nobody is going publish the costs. Nobody is going to highlight the bleeding obvious that the resources are not infinite. Despite the claims that they are, they clearly not.

pointythings · 07/07/2023 22:12

Nope, not buying it. We don't make people pay more because they're old, that's wrong. People should be prioritised on waiting lists according to purely clinical criteria, not age.

Where's your evidence that younger people are not being seen? Show us the data.

3BSHKATS · 07/07/2023 22:07

pointythings · 07/07/2023 21:22

I don't understand why you have a problem with doctors taking decisions based on the clinical picture and the clinical prognosis. That makes sense. You are proposing blanket age criteria based on cost. That's grotesque. There may be a political party that will put that in its manifesto, but I don't see them getting a lot of votes - even if we changed from FPTP to PR.

And a good thing too.

When a patient is in front of the clinician, they make the decision on the prognosis, the issue is that so many of the younger patients are never even getting that far before it’s too late.

I am not denying medical treatment people over the age of 80 in this scenario, but if it’s purely life-prolonging as opposed to pain management, and they need to pay extra.

pointythings · 07/07/2023 21:22

I don't understand why you have a problem with doctors taking decisions based on the clinical picture and the clinical prognosis. That makes sense. You are proposing blanket age criteria based on cost. That's grotesque. There may be a political party that will put that in its manifesto, but I don't see them getting a lot of votes - even if we changed from FPTP to PR.

And a good thing too.

Blossomtoes · 07/07/2023 21:08

Looks like you’re politically homeless then.

3BSHKATS · 07/07/2023 21:05

pointythings · 07/07/2023 21:02

Decisions like that will be in people like me’s hands when we get to the ballot box.

What political party do you support that thinks like that, just out of interest?

I'm in favour of making treatment decisions on the basis of an individual's clinical presentation and health/recovery prospects alone.

I think most doctors and medical professionals do exactly that. B because currently they aren’t under much in the way of financial pressure. It’s no skin off their nose who is prioritised. Nor should they ever be put into that position hence they need the line in the sand.

Will have to wait and see who is going to take the necessary measures. And that’s where the X will go.

pointythings · 07/07/2023 21:02

Decisions like that will be in people like me’s hands when we get to the ballot box.

What political party do you support that thinks like that, just out of interest?

I'm in favour of making treatment decisions on the basis of an individual's clinical presentation and health/recovery prospects alone.

Swipe left for the next trending thread