Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Device in Primary Schools

62 replies

Ihearticecream · 05/07/2023 06:48

Hi, we are being told from year 4 we have to buy a mini laptop for our children to use in school and for their homework.
School openly admits we shouldn’t have to pay for it but the government are squeezing education and there’s no money but that this will help our children’s education and lead them into the future.

It costs about £500 including software and warranty for their three remaining years at Primary School. There are payment plans available, where interest is applied.
It will have appropriate safe guards and be monitored by the school.

We don’t feel we’ve been given much time to get used to the idea (essentially about six weeks from when they told us about it to the deadline to sign up).

It has split the year group as some think it’s amazing and others think it’s too expensive or they’re too young (children are currently 8 years old). But it’s an all or nothing where if not everyone or the majority sign up then no-one in this year can have it.

We know a lot of senior schools have a device and that seems to make more sense with various subjects in different class rooms and carrying it all around. It also means paying for one thing and then paying again at senior school (gov really should step in here).

AIBU to not know what to do?
What would mumsnetters do?

OP posts:
Chocolateship · 05/07/2023 07:49

At least its laptops and not bloody tablets. I work in med tech now and lots of young colleagues cant easily operate a computer because a lot of their learning and playing is on tablets and mobiles; trouble is lots of work will never move over to these platforms fully so it's useful to know.

Anyway...its tricky as if schools don't have the budget then they don't have the budget, but it is a big expense for something the school is insisting on and that a lot of people wouldn't choose to buy otherwise. I honestly can't believe that the specs are going to be the best for the price through their supply chain. I also think it'd be far better for schools to try and fundraise or have donations of desktops from local businesses; we did this and DS' school now has a computer lab- a lot were happy to help. Children shouldn't be needing devices for homework at primary, its also a bit sad that paper and pen is no longer sufficient. Wouldn't be bad if schools taught scratch and stuff but it's used for stuff that could be written and that's a shame.

Anyway YANBU, I'm pretty sure they can't insist on parents paying for something that they're saying is mandatory.

Ihearticecream · 05/07/2023 07:43

Loverofoxbowlakes · 05/07/2023 07:40

Absolutely absurd.

If they can't provide devices for those who can't afford it then they shouldn't be using that technology to deliver learning. Education has to be accessible to all, and this level of parental financial input is ludicrous. Are they going to replace it if it breaks down? Are they going to insure it?

@Loverofoxbowlakes Apparently the reason it’s so expensive is because of the warranty which covers breakages and replacement.

But I do agree that it has to be for all not just those who sign up and pay.
I think the cheapest repayment is about £15 a month for three years.

OP posts:
Ihearticecream · 05/07/2023 07:40

Saracen · 05/07/2023 07:36

If the majority sign up and it goes ahead, what happens to the kids whose families cannot pay?

@Saracen They have some laptops that children can share in class.

OP posts:
Loverofoxbowlakes · 05/07/2023 07:40

Absolutely absurd.

If they can't provide devices for those who can't afford it then they shouldn't be using that technology to deliver learning. Education has to be accessible to all, and this level of parental financial input is ludicrous. Are they going to replace it if it breaks down? Are they going to insure it?

Thirty5 · 05/07/2023 07:37

No 8 year olds don’t need laptops, we aren’t in lockdown anymore (I would consider buying it in that situation) and ICT isn’t the be all and end all.
My daughters homework is all electronic and she struggles to complete her maths homework as she likes to write it down and work it out, so she has asked her teacher if she can have it printed out for her, lots of her peers asked the same when they realised it was an option. She is in Yr 3.

Saracen · 05/07/2023 07:36

If the majority sign up and it goes ahead, what happens to the kids whose families cannot pay?

ithinkifeelaliveagain · 05/07/2023 07:32

thats crazy! How can they just expect everyone to suddenly come up with £500. Is this the first year that they’ve done this? In my area kids are all provided with a chrome book in p5 which they keep right though until the end of secondary.

CaptainMyCaptain · 05/07/2023 07:06

VisionsOfSplendour · 05/07/2023 06:55

I wouldn't pay even if I could afford it, I'd rather the whole class worked without than parents who couldn't afford it were made to pay such a ridiculous price for a non essentail

I accept that technology is everywhere in schools now but primarily age children can learn perfectly well without expensive individual devices

This. It's ridiculous.

booktokbear · 05/07/2023 07:00

I know for my DS now nearly 11 , has used chrome books at school for the last two years and it's helped him so much with being able to get his work down (ADHD and Dyslexia) and I've only seen it as a positive but, and it's a big but, the chrome books are provided to each child by the school. Our county in Wales has made sure that each child in each primary gets them from year 4. Which is fantastic.

Unfortunately though the high school (DS starts sept) doesn't have the same facilities and won't let us provide our own. I'd do anything to be able to provide him with one it's that much of a help to him.

Your situation is obviously not going to be affordable for every parent in the class though and this seems a really bad way of doing things.

JunipeJuniper · 05/07/2023 06:59

That sounds like a lot. My school is fortunate to have tablets one between two for the whole school though, and it does make a huge difference being able to use them so easily, not having to book their use and fight other classes for them. They are just incorporated into a lot of lessons. We got them under strange circumstances and I know we're fortunate. I doubt as a school well will ever have the money to replace them. If it were a case of paying say £200 for my child to have that provision, I'd absolutely do it. £500 just seems far too high though - that's not what tablets/software cost if you buy a class set.

VisionsOfSplendour · 05/07/2023 06:55

I wouldn't pay even if I could afford it, I'd rather the whole class worked without than parents who couldn't afford it were made to pay such a ridiculous price for a non essentail

I accept that technology is everywhere in schools now but primarily age children can learn perfectly well without expensive individual devices

Theos · 05/07/2023 06:52

Where is this school? It sounds ludicrous