Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

All drivers should have eye sight tests to retain their licence

165 replies

LoisPrice · 04/07/2023 18:23

and they should be every 5 years reducing to yearly when over 70 years old https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-66053510

Jim Tassell smiles with a medal around his neck after participating in a race

Concerns about older drivers rising, DVLA figures suggest

The number of people contacting the DVLA worried about someone's fitness to drive is rising.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-66053510

OP posts:
thecatsthecats · 05/07/2023 15:13

I think that this will keep getting kicked into the long grass until driverless cars are the norm.

It's simply not worth it to set up infrastructure for this that will only have value for 15-20 years max.

IncomingTraffic · 05/07/2023 14:50

LoisPrice · 05/07/2023 13:33

In how many cases would the accident still (most likely) have happened if the driver had the right glasses on?

as howcanihelp123 points out - you can't force drivers to wear the glasses to see with, this man killed twice without his glasses https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2182587/Short-sighted-lorry-driver-killed-pedestrian-93-ignoring-warnings-wear-glasses-causing-death-cyclist-years-ago.html

But that’s exactly my point.

Making eye tests mandatory for licensing may not even solve the problem at all. In fact, the problem in that case and PP’s gran is that they aren’t wearing their glasses. Not that they haven’t had their eyes tested.

It would cost loads and require all sorts of changes to all sorts of things and still wouldn’t be addressing the actual issue.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 05/07/2023 14:25

LoisPrice · 05/07/2023 13:24

The death penalty was revoked in 1998 in the uk so unless they bring it back, its not going to happen

I'm aware of that. I meant I hope the poster is joking and no one is quite as ridiculous as that. Did you read the rest of it? 5 year ban from driving for a non fault accident🙄

Mountainpika · 05/07/2023 14:16

cushioncovers · 04/07/2023 19:43

Most older generation vote Tory so they aren't going to introduce a law where over 70s have to take an eyesight or competency test.

Please don't generalise and sterotype older people.

I am 76, my husband is 80 and we DO NOT vote tory. We did not vote for Brexit.
We both drive and have our eyes tested regularly and glasses updated as necessary. And yes, regular eye tests should be compulsory for all drivers.

SBAM · 05/07/2023 13:54

I wear glasses, get my eyes tested regularly and get new glasses if needed, and my license has it written on that I need glasses or lenses to drive. I wouldn’t dream of driving without them, I feel uncomfortable going for a walk without them and I have a relatively mild prescription (-3.0).

Would a quicker way of ensuring sight tests are done be to link it to car insurance. In the same way parking off-road is a lower risk for the car, you having sight checks is hopefully safer. Your insurer asks if you’ve had a sight test in the last 24 months and if you have you get a lower price on your insurance. If you haven’t you pay an extra £50 a year (or another sum. It would need to be more than the cost of the eye test I think).

Sissynova · 05/07/2023 13:37

I really don’t see anyone have a reasonable argument against this. The only people I see actively against eye tests or renewing driving tests are older people who would probably fail them!

LoisPrice · 05/07/2023 13:33

In how many cases would the accident still (most likely) have happened if the driver had the right glasses on?

as howcanihelp123 points out - you can't force drivers to wear the glasses to see with, this man killed twice without his glasses https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2182587/Short-sighted-lorry-driver-killed-pedestrian-93-ignoring-warnings-wear-glasses-causing-death-cyclist-years-ago.html

Short-sighted lorry driver killed pedestrian, 97, while ignoring warnings to wear glasses after causing death of cyclist two years ago

Joao Correia-Lopes was sentenced to four years in prison after hitting 97-year-old Nora Gutman when she stepped onto a pedestrian crossing outside Madame Tussaud's in Marylebone Road, London in June 2011.

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2182587/Short-sighted-lorry-driver-killed-pedestrian-93-ignoring-warnings-wear-glasses-causing-death-cyclist-years-ago.html

OP posts:
LoisPrice · 05/07/2023 13:24

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 05/07/2023 09:27

I'm hoping this is a joke...

The death penalty was revoked in 1998 in the uk so unless they bring it back, its not going to happen

OP posts:
purpleboy · 05/07/2023 12:24

HollaHolla · 04/07/2023 19:22

I'd have everyone do a general competence test of driving when they have to renew their photo licence, every 10 years. Terrible driving (and poor eyesight) are not the sole issue of the over 70s.

For example, there's a young woman who lives near me who is a hazard and danger to all - drives through lights/across junctions/on pavements. Would love the Police to see her....

If you have dash cam you can send the footage to the police and they can deal with her.

HowcanIhelp123 · 05/07/2023 11:57

If you'd have tested my grandmas eyesight she would have turned up with her glasses and aced it. Then got in her car, taken the glasses off because she doesn't like them and it's 'just driving' then off she goes, hitting curbs and coming off roundabouts on the wrong side of the road and going through traffic lights she didn't see. There's little you can do about it, we took her keys but that was technically illegal.

speluncean · 05/07/2023 11:45

I had a car drive into my car when it was parked in a parking space and I wasn't even in it.

Would I be banned from driving?

KimberleyClark · 05/07/2023 11:45

User13630934 · 04/07/2023 18:43

There needs to be some way of keeping your driving licence and not being able to drive though as some are probably reluctant to give it up as it is their only form of ID unless they pay out for a passport.

Bus pass(free)?
Senior railcard?

LittleLegsKeepGoing · 05/07/2023 11:44

Dotjones · 05/07/2023 08:38

I'd rather see the minimum age for driving being raised to 30. A lot of accidents are caused by young, inexperienced drivers, so taking them off the road would inevitably reduce the number of accidents. There could also be a system where if you're involved in any kind of accident you're banned from driving for five years (even if you were entirely innocent). That would hopefully make people adopt a more risk-averse attitude when driving. I'd also have life imprisonment or the death penalty for anyone who drove without a licence/while disqualified/without insurance.

That's just nuts! I was rear-ended at a red traffic light. 100% not my fault (stationary car, red light) but you'd see me banned from driving for 5 years.

And how precisely are millions of under 30 year olds expected to get to work etc without the ability to drive? Outside of London and possibly a handful of other English cities public transport is an expensive joke. Plus turning 30 won't magically make someone a more experienced driver - the 30 year old drivers around now have generally been driving for at least a decade....starting out as inexperienced youths. I think the insurance solution of black boxes is a far better idea than yours frankly.

Honestly, get a fucking grip!

LittleLegsKeepGoing · 05/07/2023 11:40

Part of the issue is that there isn't an automatic requirement for medical professionals to notify the DVLA of someone's unsuitability to drive. They can do it voluntarily - but there's no process whereby they are required to.

It should be an automatic process that the DVLA are notified when someone is diagnosed with something notable. Relying on the person doing so when they have so much to lose and an inflated sense of them being a 'safe driver' is such a flawed system.

For example, there was absolutely nothing forthcoming from any of my father's 5 consultants to do with his MND care or his GP to the DVLA about the potential for his driving to need to be evaluated. This is a degenerative disease that massively affects strength, co-ordination and control. To my father's mind this meant no one was concerned about his ability to drive therefore he was allowed to (we didn't let him).

This shouldn't be an individual decision, it should be a mandated and assessed properly - if you diagnose someone with something concerning for the ability to drive you're legally required to report it to the DVLA for investigation.

tigger1001 · 05/07/2023 11:17

I get my eyes tested every two years, more if needed.

The last time (last year) I went early as I felt a change in vision and was concerned about driving. The optician said that while there was a change of prescription needed, I was miles off the threshold for safe driving and he showed me what the legal minimum was..., frightening!

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 05/07/2023 09:27

Dotjones · 05/07/2023 08:38

I'd rather see the minimum age for driving being raised to 30. A lot of accidents are caused by young, inexperienced drivers, so taking them off the road would inevitably reduce the number of accidents. There could also be a system where if you're involved in any kind of accident you're banned from driving for five years (even if you were entirely innocent). That would hopefully make people adopt a more risk-averse attitude when driving. I'd also have life imprisonment or the death penalty for anyone who drove without a licence/while disqualified/without insurance.

I'm hoping this is a joke...

arapunzel · 05/07/2023 09:21

For those saying to just get drivers to read a chart at DVLA office/post office etc, that does not constitute a sight test. A sight test can only be performed by a registered optometrist/student optometrist under supervision/registered medical professional ie ophthalmologist.

Also just reading the chart could miss things like visual field loss

The biggest step right now would be to make it easier for Optometrists to be able to report to the DVLA those patients who have been told they longer meet the visual standard for driving.

Dotjones · 05/07/2023 08:38

I'd rather see the minimum age for driving being raised to 30. A lot of accidents are caused by young, inexperienced drivers, so taking them off the road would inevitably reduce the number of accidents. There could also be a system where if you're involved in any kind of accident you're banned from driving for five years (even if you were entirely innocent). That would hopefully make people adopt a more risk-averse attitude when driving. I'd also have life imprisonment or the death penalty for anyone who drove without a licence/while disqualified/without insurance.

IncomingTraffic · 05/07/2023 08:32

Effectively not defectively. 🤣

IncomingTraffic · 05/07/2023 08:31

How do you know that the money wouldn’t be more defectively spent on a road safety and eyesight campaign?

Or that it wouldn’t be better solved by spending the money on free eyetests and glasses for everyone?

Why are people so certain that including additional eye tests in licensing requirements is the best way to solve the problem?

I see this at work all the time. People so attached to the back of a fag packet ‘obvious’ solution they’ve come up with, and unwilling to actually think about what the problem really is and how it would be best to solve it.

IncomingTraffic · 05/07/2023 08:17

LoisPrice · 05/07/2023 05:25

The chart is in a cupboard and they just open the door and ask you to read the line. It takes less than a minute.

it doesn’t have to be difficult, it’s a test that could be conducted is siilomannerin U.K. at the theory test centres. Admin costs to cover costs and your 34.8 million drivers could be tested regularly, they not all be tested the same year. 6 million are aged over 70 years

But it’s not that easy. Because currently people in the UK do not visit a DVLA office to apply for or renew their licenses. The network of DVLA offices is small and not designed for the demand this would create.

It’s not just opening a cupboard door. It’s ensuring there are enough offices - conveniently located for people to use them. The offices also have to be designed so that eye tests can be administered in them (things like ensuring consistent lighting and placement and various issues that affect eye test results need to be considered too - it needs to be fair and accurate). That involves making changes to all the existing offices. The offices also have to be staffed. And trained to administer eye tests. And all the forms and processes need to be adapted to reflect the entirely new process.

Even the ‘just do it at theory test centres’ is naive. These centres aren’t operated by the DVLA and are not set up for eye tests. The staff are not trained to administer eye tests. There are capacity issues - it’s hard enough for people who need a theory test to book one without adding in appointments for everyone renewing a license, or updating their eye test every 2 years.

Same with ‘just’ getting opticians to do it. That’s creating an entirely new service and expecting independent businesses to just adapt their processes and create capacity (not just for the additional tests, but all the additional admin). Then there’s the data sharing issues. How is that going to be done? Is it going to be paper forms (for the DVLA to process, again requiring additional processes and resources) or some kind of electronic data sharing (which will require developing a whole IT system to achieve).

Then there’s the people who want all sorts of other tests in there. Reflexes. Who is going to administer that? Where? When? How are they going to be trained to properly and efficiently assess people’s reflexes? Will the test be fair to people with disabilities who are driving adapted cars? Cognitive tests? You going to get GPs to do that? 🤦🏻‍♀️😩 There’s so much spare capacity there, isn’t there?

It is so easy to decide there are easy fixes to these things. But there really isn’t. It’s complex stuff. Other countries have set their entire services up differently.

and there simply isn’t the evidence that doing all the work to make changes so there are more eye tests would significantly improve road safety. It’s easy to look at individual cases and think ‘something must be done’. But if you’re going to create new legislation and make big changes to driving licensing processes, you would want to be sure that it’s going to make a real difference.

Police data has shown that around 3,000 people are killed or injured by drivers with bad eyesight (or where eyesight has played a part in the cause of the collision) every year.

It sounds like eye tests would solve this problem on the surface. But whether it would actually make a difference is not clear. How many of those people just weren’t wearing prescribed glasses? How many of those cases was it the main, causative factor in the collision? In how many cases would the accident still (most likely) have happened if the driver had the right glasses on? This stuff makes a difference to whether your proposed solution will actually work.

If you go through the police accident data, they record all sorts of things. And they may determine that many things played a part in the cause of the collision. I’d guess that driving in the dark or in the rain is listed as a contributing factor to the cause of far, far more accidents on UK roads. Being distracted by your radio or fiddling with your centre console or dealing with fighting kids in the back of the car are also probably things that played a part in causing many, many collisions.

Maybe banning driving in the rain would make the bigger difference to road safety. Maybe insisting that cars don’t have distracting media systems would be better.

It’s not as simple as it might appear. And the stats are not as clear in defining the problem as people like to present them - never mind in determining the solution (which is different).

speluncean · 05/07/2023 08:14

gogomoto · 05/07/2023 08:02

The number one problem here is lack of public transport. No car means housebound for many people, even in town it's a 30 minute walk to the nearest bus stop possibly more for the very slow. The drs is by the bus stop!

This is very true.

SoftAsABearsElbow · 05/07/2023 08:12

If eyes (and teeth) weren't considered an optional nice to have by the NHS we wouldn't have this problem as the tests would be free.

Totally agree with this. It's ridiculous that they are not.

Also agree about publlic transport. For as long as I can remember, several governments have promised to make it better and it has instead become worse and worse.

Willmafrockfit · 05/07/2023 08:05

there was an incorrect story on casualty, as usual, that a man with macular degeneration was driving when he shouldnt
you can still drive with macular degeneration

Willmafrockfit · 05/07/2023 08:03

what is the test they do at the age of 75?
just a phone call?