Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School full time at 4

139 replies

Holeymoleyy · 04/07/2023 14:04

My DC turns 4 at the end of July. I received the letter a few months ago and applied for her school place. The offer came back and it says she is to start school full time from the 6th September. There didn’t seem to be any option of part time

She currently goes to nursery, who are not able to keep any children on who turn 4 before the start of September term and they were encouraging all parents to apply for a school place

She is very bright and sociable and her confidence has grown a lot since going to nursery so I have no worries there. I just hope that I’m doing the right thing. Any opinions appreciated?

OP posts:
Zanatdy · 04/07/2023 17:20

My middle child is August born, made zero difference and he was the top performer in his secondary school, now at University

Freshstarts23 · 04/07/2023 17:18

BeezHoney · 04/07/2023 15:51

A large majority of it is. As opposed to not going at all, where I can facilitate museums/outdoors/going on trains and buses/following their lead and engaging in the stuff they are actually interested in, with no pressure just purely lead by fun and enjoyment.

That’s what a good reception will be like but obviously not as frequent regarding trips. But it’s all play based, they maybe spend 15 mins sitting on the carpet once or twice a day. I wouldn’t expect reception children to be at chairs and tables often, unless maybe doing art, practicing fine motor skills etc but the majority of this will be choice. These things will be set up and they can choose where they go, what they play with, indoor, outdoor etc.

granof8 · 04/07/2023 17:18

In Ontario , Canada children start full time school in the September of the year they turn 4 ( even if they have a December birthday). While it is not compulsory, it is highly recommended

SunnyFrost · 04/07/2023 17:12

FlyingSoap · 04/07/2023 14:28

We are hoping to TTC an August baby later this year. I know they will go to school earlier but our DC will likely be tall so won’t look too out of place. It’s £12000 saved potentially in childcare costs vs September birthday where you’d pay 12k more. That 12k, instead of being spent on nurseries, could buy them some fantastic holidays and experiences and/or go towards uni fees. No brainer for us! I don’t think the difference is that marked as some say, kids soon catch up especially if you put the effort in with them at home xx

You’re clearly well intentioned but please come back and comment when (if) you have an august child who is little more than a toddler, looking down the barrel of full time school. Of course lots cope and are fine but I find the idea of actively aiming for what is statistically a significant disadvantage for your child, bizarre (that’s being polite). If a few months of nursery fees makes that much difference then raising a child will be financially very precarious for you. It’s a drop in the ocean of the vast cost of child raising for 18+ years.

Do you really think the issue with August babies is their height and how they look next to their peers…?! All the effort in the world can’t give a just four year old the gross and fine motor skills, emotional development etc. of a nearly five year old. The majority struggle, quite a bit. Especially boys. Why would you actively wish that for your baby???

Trying not to be rude but you sound utterly clueless and like you’re coming at parenthood from very much what’s best for you and not the well-being of the child. Can’t help thinking you may have some big surprises ahead….

toomuchlaundry · 04/07/2023 17:03

But surely if you don’t want your child sitting still in a classroom you would delay a bit longer @BeezHoney? most children find the step up from reception to Y1 a shock, more so for a child who won’t have even been in school

MissDollyMix · 04/07/2023 17:02

With a July birthday she won’t be the youngest in the year. The school have seen it all before and are used to managing a wide range of abilities and maturities.
I personally sit on the fence wrt deferring. It’s quite a normal thing to do where I live and our school seem supportive of summer babies who aren’t ready to start with their cohort. My own eldest (July baby) was too old for this more enlightened approach so had to start with his cohort. In some ways it was brilliant for him. He was a bright kid who was already used to long days at nursery and he needed the stimulation - much better than being stuck at home with his sleep-deprived, frazzled mother (DC2 was a terror!) He’s never seemed to suffer academically. That said, there’s a big gap- both physically and emotionally between him and the eldest in his year. Right now he’s 12 whereas the eldest in his year are nearly 14- that’s a massive gap! He’s found his tribe (mostly other summer-born boys) but he’ll never be a sportsman! If I could do my time again, I would probably have deferred him but we are where we are. I think I will strongly encourage him to take a gap year if he wants to go to uni as I think he will get more out of it if he’s a bit older when he goes (if, indeed he wants to go at all!)

BeezHoney · 04/07/2023 16:58

Nursemumma92 · 04/07/2023 16:18

It's not that the content can't be taught in those four walls, it's that the jump between reception and year 1 is huge and they won't have had the year at school getting used to the school routines, and integrating with their peers. Sending them into a class where all the children have their friendship groups when they don't know how to follow the structure is quite a big deal. If you think your dc is too young to start school in September, then defer for a year and start reception next year. Sending them straight to year 1 would be a huge leap.

A good school has reception children learning through play, my DD has almost finished her reception year and they have their own garden for their class and do outdoor learning 4 times a week as well as P.E and their outdoor breaks. She is in a typical 2 form entry state school.

They are 5/6 - friendship groups won’t be a concern. I joined a school in year 9, I settled in well.

The school routine, in my opinion, is far too young to impose on most (not all) 4/5 year olds. By delaying it a year I’m allowing my child that extra year to be just that, a child, and allowing them to be a bit more grown/mature to understand it the following year. In fact I feel like I’m doing them a disservice forcing them to do it that young “just so they’re used to it”. My child can learn through play, meet other children, have routine, learn, everything they’d do in reception all at home, with less pressure and more attention from “the teacher”.

Again, appreciate the concern. I’m glad your child’s school is fit for purpose and that they’re thriving, that’s great. Like you have done what’s best for your child, I’m doing what’s best for mine ❣️

Gymmum82 · 04/07/2023 16:55

Mine is the youngest in her year group. She’s done well and moving to year 3 now she’s definitely not the bottom of the class either socially or academically

Sugargliderwombat · 04/07/2023 16:52

PuttingDownRoots · 04/07/2023 16:09

Deferred children stay with their cohort now.

Do you have a link for this info? Most recent document on a council website : "Transition to secondary school and transferring school In-Year:
Admission authorities are not required to automatically agree for
a child to be placed outside of their normal year group and may
decide they will only offer a school place for the normal year
group"

Sissynova · 04/07/2023 16:44

FlyingSoap · 04/07/2023 14:28

We are hoping to TTC an August baby later this year. I know they will go to school earlier but our DC will likely be tall so won’t look too out of place. It’s £12000 saved potentially in childcare costs vs September birthday where you’d pay 12k more. That 12k, instead of being spent on nurseries, could buy them some fantastic holidays and experiences and/or go towards uni fees. No brainer for us! I don’t think the difference is that marked as some say, kids soon catch up especially if you put the effort in with them at home xx

Presumably if you need childcare when they are under 4 then you will still need wrap around care for the short primary school day. The savings will be significantly less than 12k.

PuttingDownRoots · 04/07/2023 16:36

@Ohhmydays Reception class has phonics and early maths... so pretty similar to "preschool" or "kindergarten" in other countries. Just part of school in England. So less formal than Scottish P1, but not more learning than nursery.

Ohhmydays · 04/07/2023 16:31

Zonder · 04/07/2023 14:39

Only some do and only 15 hours.

I think that it depends where you live or the ELC provider. In my area you can get 30free term time hours or you can spread them out throughout the year.

I don’t no if I am just a bit thick or because I stay in Scotland(don’t have reception)but what is the difference between reception and the preschool year at nursery?

BusyMum47 · 04/07/2023 16:28

Starting school the Sept after you're 4yrs old is the norm for 99% of the population in the UK isn't it? Some schools ease them in with a week or 2 of half days but that's it.
🤷‍♀️

Nursemumma92 · 04/07/2023 16:18

BeezHoney · 04/07/2023 16:00

If you believe that the content in reception, can only be learnt within 4 walls, from a book and by a teacher, then you’re wrong. So, for us year 1 will be absolutely fine. I appreciate the concern though ❤️

It's not that the content can't be taught in those four walls, it's that the jump between reception and year 1 is huge and they won't have had the year at school getting used to the school routines, and integrating with their peers. Sending them into a class where all the children have their friendship groups when they don't know how to follow the structure is quite a big deal. If you think your dc is too young to start school in September, then defer for a year and start reception next year. Sending them straight to year 1 would be a huge leap.

A good school has reception children learning through play, my DD has almost finished her reception year and they have their own garden for their class and do outdoor learning 4 times a week as well as P.E and their outdoor breaks. She is in a typical 2 form entry state school.

Frosty1000 · 04/07/2023 16:15

I have a July child and I didn't even consider deferral as I had faith in the school and my child's ability to be resilient with a new challenge.

We did part time for three weeks and I have to say as a working parent that's a ball ache juggling things.

See how they go and keep an open line of communication with their teacher and adapt as necessary. They'll be tired but by half term they'll have got used to it more.

As they go up through the school years you won't notice birthday months at all - we're year 3 now and we're on target and up amongst those born in September. Each child is different but just have faith.

WellWellWellWhatHaveWeHeree · 04/07/2023 16:12

FlyingSoap · 04/07/2023 14:28

We are hoping to TTC an August baby later this year. I know they will go to school earlier but our DC will likely be tall so won’t look too out of place. It’s £12000 saved potentially in childcare costs vs September birthday where you’d pay 12k more. That 12k, instead of being spent on nurseries, could buy them some fantastic holidays and experiences and/or go towards uni fees. No brainer for us! I don’t think the difference is that marked as some say, kids soon catch up especially if you put the effort in with them at home xx

This is the weirdest logic I've ever heard in my life. Wtf. You do you though.

Eggmcmuffin · 04/07/2023 16:12

In Wales this is standard that they start when 3/4. Some schools do part time for a while but lots are straight to full time. My 4 year old started at 3 and 9 months and has been fine, as have her friends. She was in full time nursery beforehand which helps though.

PuttingDownRoots · 04/07/2023 16:09

Sugargliderwombat · 04/07/2023 16:07

They will have to make the jump back to their normal year group at some point. Schools are very used to summer born babies, yours won't even be the youngest there will be a few at least born in August. Part time would not work. They will miss big chunks of the day and miss out on developing friendships. Remember school is only 9-3 and most of that will be playing.

Deferred children stay with their cohort now.

Sugargliderwombat · 04/07/2023 16:07

They will have to make the jump back to their normal year group at some point. Schools are very used to summer born babies, yours won't even be the youngest there will be a few at least born in August. Part time would not work. They will miss big chunks of the day and miss out on developing friendships. Remember school is only 9-3 and most of that will be playing.

CalmDownBoris72 · 04/07/2023 16:05

Two of my kids have July birthdays (both boys) and started school just after turning 4 and were fine, they seemed quite little to begin with but by the end of primary you wouldn’t have guessed.

BeezHoney · 04/07/2023 16:00

toomuchlaundry · 04/07/2023 15:54

@BeezHoney if you are going down that route I would do reception a year late rather than straight into Y1

If you believe that the content in reception, can only be learnt within 4 walls, from a book and by a teacher, then you’re wrong. So, for us year 1 will be absolutely fine. I appreciate the concern though ❤️

Kiwiandstrawberries · 04/07/2023 16:00

My son is a mid July baby and I was actually annoyed that he had to wait until after Christmas to start in reception. I felt that he was missing out on all the Christmas fun etc and friendship groups already established amongst the September starters .
It never occurred to me that his actual age was a problem.
He was absolutely fine and being one of the youngest was never a problem…different story when all his friends hit 18 before him though!

toomuchlaundry · 04/07/2023 15:54

@BeezHoney if you are going down that route I would do reception a year late rather than straight into Y1

UncleRadley · 04/07/2023 15:52

@FlyingSoap that's a risky little game 😀 you could easily be ending up with a September baby and pay a whole other year! If it's that vital to save on some nursery fees I'd be starting next month hoping for April/May at the earliest. To be fair, it's not something I ever thought about but it makes some sort of weird sense as you will pay less nursery fees if you time it right!

Bloomingbloms · 04/07/2023 15:51

Thankfully my Mum didn’t give it a second thought when she sent me to reception age 4 + 2 days in the 1980s.

There has to be a cut off somewhere. There will be other summer born kids. IME, as a summer born with 2 summer born kids, they tend to gravitate towards and form friendships with those around the same age.

This seems to me like an extension of wrapping them up in cotton wool. Which is really not doing children any good.

Swipe left for the next trending thread