Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School full time at 4

139 replies

Holeymoleyy · 04/07/2023 14:04

My DC turns 4 at the end of July. I received the letter a few months ago and applied for her school place. The offer came back and it says she is to start school full time from the 6th September. There didn’t seem to be any option of part time

She currently goes to nursery, who are not able to keep any children on who turn 4 before the start of September term and they were encouraging all parents to apply for a school place

She is very bright and sociable and her confidence has grown a lot since going to nursery so I have no worries there. I just hope that I’m doing the right thing. Any opinions appreciated?

OP posts:
Regholdsworthswaterbed · 04/07/2023 19:58

My son is August born so was only just 4 when he went to school. He was absolutely fine, but it does depend on the child. I do know others who started part time.

Curiosity101 · 04/07/2023 19:58

It's going to be different for every child.

DS was an Aug 2019 baby, but had been due October 2019 (he was almost 7 weeks early). Given his original due date and how he is socially/emotionally we've delayed his start. He'll be starting school in Reception in 2024 (like he should have if he'd been born even a couple of days later).

Personally I wouldn't start a child part time, they'll miss too much of the curriculum. However as some have mentioned you don't legally need to start them full time until the term after they've turned 5 which is when they hit compulsory school age. You could still delay if you really feel you need to. I'd be surprised if the nursery really can't keep kids past 4. That would mean all the September kids get kicked out too..? It's quite common that childcare providers think they can't keep delayed summer borns, until you point out they're no different to the September born kids.

Bumblebeestiltskin · 04/07/2023 19:56

Sugargliderwombat · 04/07/2023 16:07

They will have to make the jump back to their normal year group at some point. Schools are very used to summer born babies, yours won't even be the youngest there will be a few at least born in August. Part time would not work. They will miss big chunks of the day and miss out on developing friendships. Remember school is only 9-3 and most of that will be playing.

Totally incorrect.

Notimeforaname · 04/07/2023 19:54

That's how it was when I went to school. It was the norm. Turned 4 in May, started school in September.

gogomoto · 04/07/2023 19:52

I'm an august birthday, didn't do me any harm. Your teenage child may resent you if you hold them back, imagine realising you could have finished school???

Bumblebeestiltskin · 04/07/2023 19:51

My daughter was 5 at the beginning of June, she could have started reception last September at 4 years 3 months, but I chose to delay her reception start to compulsory school age, and she's starting reception this September at 5 years 3 months. There is SUCH a difference in her this year compared to last, she's ready to thrive this year whereas I'd have been stressed about her starting last year. She wasn't emotionally or physically ready at just turned 4.

Kennahevabescut · 04/07/2023 19:49

My DC is august born & starting full time.i think she'll love it.

poormanspombears · 04/07/2023 19:48

My daughter has been more than full time (7.45 - 4.30) at a school nursery since she was just 3 (august baby). She will be the same at school from the first day because that's what she's used to.
I actually called them today and asked to bypass all the half day piffle and they said yes thank god!

The first few weeks might have a lot of danger naps but she'll get used to it in time.

Mysteriousgirl2 · 04/07/2023 19:41

RoomOfRequirement · 04/07/2023 15:14

You can't possibly be that naive!

There are maybe 3 days a year you could possibly conceive a baby due in August - around a 20% chance, if you're tracking ovulation - and then there is absolutely no guarantee baby will arrive in August anyway!

You make it sound like you're scheduling your Amazon day delivery and it is absolutely hilarious.

This.

jamimmi · 04/07/2023 19:25

My nearly 16 yr old dd has just finished her GCSE'S . She's a late July birthday and has academically done very well, top set etc
Socially she has struggled a little but I think that's more due to covid than age, and her introverted personality. I am suggesting a year out pre uni so far that's a no from her through. I'd try it an see. I think you will have age issues what ever you do.

Freshstarts23 · 04/07/2023 19:22

BeezHoney · 04/07/2023 19:13

100% your last comment. It’s a great system overall, I personally had the best time at school and got good grades, however it’s not a one-size-fits-all and there isn’t enough teachers/space/materials/funding to facilitate every child’s needs and learning styles. So you’re right, whilst it works for most we can’t deny that it doesn’t work for all.

Out of interest, did you homeschool your SEN child after you pulled them out?

Forest school (ours is actually a nursery as it is from ages 2-5, but is still almost totally outdoors all year round) should be accessible to all. There is one fairly locally that caters to up to year 11, which looks INCREDIBLE, however it is £5k per term 😢 so only accessible to those with a lot of disposable income. When I win the lottery, I’ll buy a huge plot of land and create my own forest school that would purely be “pay what you can, if at all” so that it doesn’t discriminate to socioeconomic status. The benefits of being outdoors is just so incredible, it’s such a shame most are priced out. Or don’t have access to it geographically :(

No, I’m financially (and mentally) unable to. Now at a specialist school tbat I don’t think is right either but I really didn’t have much choice and was already at risk of losing my job over all the time off.
I don’t think formal learning should start until 6/7 personally. I don’t think there’s many children that are ‘better off’ starting sooner. It should all be child led and play based.
Unfortunately most have to conform and we as parent have to help them do so.

19991234c · 04/07/2023 19:20

You do have the option of part time, it should of been in your paper work from the LA it’s your legal right untill age 5

19991234c · 04/07/2023 19:19

My summer born will be going part time untill 5. I don’t care about anyone else’s opinions , the classes are huge - 30 kids and my child doesn’t like big groups quite shy with new people. I just think they’re too little.

ladygindiva · 04/07/2023 19:18

FlyingSoap · 04/07/2023 14:28

We are hoping to TTC an August baby later this year. I know they will go to school earlier but our DC will likely be tall so won’t look too out of place. It’s £12000 saved potentially in childcare costs vs September birthday where you’d pay 12k more. That 12k, instead of being spent on nurseries, could buy them some fantastic holidays and experiences and/or go towards uni fees. No brainer for us! I don’t think the difference is that marked as some say, kids soon catch up especially if you put the effort in with them at home xx

If you're in UK 3yo funded hours surely make the month of birth irrelevant ?

BeezHoney · 04/07/2023 19:13

Freshstarts23 · 04/07/2023 17:43

I fully agree with you. It’s just a shame the system isn’t set up to support this. Mine are a bit older and I had to work so didn’t have an option but forest school would have been perfect for my SEN youngest. Instead he was straight in full time at 4. He coped fine in nursery for the most part, and reception. Real problems surfaced in yr 1. He unfortunately had to leave mainstream.

I agree with others, most are fine in school, and there’s benefits. Doesn’t mean it’s the best option, just all that’s available to most.

100% your last comment. It’s a great system overall, I personally had the best time at school and got good grades, however it’s not a one-size-fits-all and there isn’t enough teachers/space/materials/funding to facilitate every child’s needs and learning styles. So you’re right, whilst it works for most we can’t deny that it doesn’t work for all.

Out of interest, did you homeschool your SEN child after you pulled them out?

Forest school (ours is actually a nursery as it is from ages 2-5, but is still almost totally outdoors all year round) should be accessible to all. There is one fairly locally that caters to up to year 11, which looks INCREDIBLE, however it is £5k per term 😢 so only accessible to those with a lot of disposable income. When I win the lottery, I’ll buy a huge plot of land and create my own forest school that would purely be “pay what you can, if at all” so that it doesn’t discriminate to socioeconomic status. The benefits of being outdoors is just so incredible, it’s such a shame most are priced out. Or don’t have access to it geographically :(

Freshstarts23 · 04/07/2023 17:43

BeezHoney · 04/07/2023 17:36

Yeah I truly hear what you’re saying.

Mine is currently at a forest school 2 x a week, which is mainly outdoors and rather unstructured. Even if it’s raining, the doors are left open and they can come in and out as they please (obviously wearing waterproof overalls) and enjoys it thoroughly. Mine would much rather be outside in the rain climbing the low-lying trees or digging in the mud, than inside listening to instructions/tasks. Of course this can and probably will change, but at the moment I feel I would be doing them a disservice; forcing them to do reception when I can see their love and interest in the outdoors, and learning about what interests them, right in front of me. Whilst I can, I’d love to just take their lead. Even if it’s just for a year x

I fully agree with you. It’s just a shame the system isn’t set up to support this. Mine are a bit older and I had to work so didn’t have an option but forest school would have been perfect for my SEN youngest. Instead he was straight in full time at 4. He coped fine in nursery for the most part, and reception. Real problems surfaced in yr 1. He unfortunately had to leave mainstream.

I agree with others, most are fine in school, and there’s benefits. Doesn’t mean it’s the best option, just all that’s available to most.

Lulu1919 · 04/07/2023 17:37

OwlBasket · 04/07/2023 14:17

I’m not in the UK, here children all start f/t school the day after their 4th birthday (unless it falls in a holiday, then first day after the holidays). It works really well. Some (a very few) parents hold their children back but it seems to disadvantage them socially

Wow that must be tricky for the teacher having new children join randomly throughout the school year !

BeezHoney · 04/07/2023 17:36

Freshstarts23 · 04/07/2023 17:28

That’s not my experience (as a parent or professionally). Reception is still EYFS and should definitely be child led and learning through play. It’s sad if some are not implementing this.

I fully agree with you by the way, that for most children, our system is not beneficial. They start formal school way too young. But unfortunately that’s the way it is, and in the current system I do think children that have been to nursery have an advantage going into reception, and the same for reception to year 1. It’s such a big change. When mine went from play based reception to yr 1 it was a shock.

In reception, you can tell which kids have been to nursery usually too.

Yeah I truly hear what you’re saying.

Mine is currently at a forest school 2 x a week, which is mainly outdoors and rather unstructured. Even if it’s raining, the doors are left open and they can come in and out as they please (obviously wearing waterproof overalls) and enjoys it thoroughly. Mine would much rather be outside in the rain climbing the low-lying trees or digging in the mud, than inside listening to instructions/tasks. Of course this can and probably will change, but at the moment I feel I would be doing them a disservice; forcing them to do reception when I can see their love and interest in the outdoors, and learning about what interests them, right in front of me. Whilst I can, I’d love to just take their lead. Even if it’s just for a year x

ThursdayFreedom · 04/07/2023 17:36

FlyingSoap · 04/07/2023 15:06

Why?

@FlyingSoap

print it out & come back to us in 20 years, let us know how it panned out.

cocksstrideintheevening · 04/07/2023 17:35

Dts turned 4 at the end of august and started 3rd September. It can't be a surprise to you? Mine were prem and actually due in the October so were technically 3+10 when they started. They were
Fine.

BeezHoney · 04/07/2023 17:31

Freshstarts23 · 04/07/2023 17:20

I don’t think she meant because of the learning the happens. More the social skills, routine, environment , expectations.

Freshly 4 (to 5) years old is so young to impose a lot of school/classroom norms. In my opinion**, and I want my kid to enjoy being a kid for a bit longer. A ratio of 1:30 (sometimes 2:30 if they’re lucky) or a ratio of one 1:1, where I can also facilitate play, learning, meet ups etc etc? So yeah, I’ve chosen the latter. They’ll be a whole year older by the time year 1 comes around. Perhaps more susceptible to the idea of classroom-based learning - all whilst having had a fun, easy-going year under their belt. I mean, as fun and easygoing as life with a young child could be 🤣

The above is all based on opinion of course, and don’t forget my decisions won’t affect you or your life so you don’t need to worry too much about it. Continue what you’re doing for your child - it’s going working well for you all, and I’ll continue with mine 🥰❤️

Freshstarts23 · 04/07/2023 17:28

BeezHoney · 04/07/2023 17:21

If only. I’ve really gotten a sense of that it’s still quite structured/not very child-led, and we live within walking distance of about 5 primary schools (admittedly probably wouldn’t get in to all 5, would probably depend on which we were geographically closest to). X

That’s not my experience (as a parent or professionally). Reception is still EYFS and should definitely be child led and learning through play. It’s sad if some are not implementing this.

I fully agree with you by the way, that for most children, our system is not beneficial. They start formal school way too young. But unfortunately that’s the way it is, and in the current system I do think children that have been to nursery have an advantage going into reception, and the same for reception to year 1. It’s such a big change. When mine went from play based reception to yr 1 it was a shock.

In reception, you can tell which kids have been to nursery usually too.

HideTheCroissants · 04/07/2023 17:25

We have children in reception class at our school who still aren’t five. They are absolutely fine.

Depends on your local authority maybe but the one child we had where the parent asked to defer starting until Sept this year (turned 5 last month) was told they could BUT would then have to go straight into year 1 and only if we weren’t full in that year group at the time - certainly no holding places open.

They opted to start last September with the rest of the children and again absolutely fine. He actually settled quicker than some of the older children.

BeezHoney · 04/07/2023 17:21

Freshstarts23 · 04/07/2023 17:18

That’s what a good reception will be like but obviously not as frequent regarding trips. But it’s all play based, they maybe spend 15 mins sitting on the carpet once or twice a day. I wouldn’t expect reception children to be at chairs and tables often, unless maybe doing art, practicing fine motor skills etc but the majority of this will be choice. These things will be set up and they can choose where they go, what they play with, indoor, outdoor etc.

If only. I’ve really gotten a sense of that it’s still quite structured/not very child-led, and we live within walking distance of about 5 primary schools (admittedly probably wouldn’t get in to all 5, would probably depend on which we were geographically closest to). X

Freshstarts23 · 04/07/2023 17:20

BeezHoney · 04/07/2023 16:00

If you believe that the content in reception, can only be learnt within 4 walls, from a book and by a teacher, then you’re wrong. So, for us year 1 will be absolutely fine. I appreciate the concern though ❤️

I don’t think she meant because of the learning the happens. More the social skills, routine, environment , expectations.