Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Permanently banned for ‘promoting hate’

390 replies

RumAndReisling · 04/07/2023 13:32

Following ten years uneventful membership of a major social media site I have been permanently banned for ‘promoting hate’.

Never again will I be able to participate on that site.

My crime? Saying that if you had given birth to a child, there was no way you could literally change sex and produce semen to father one.

Is this not a statement of fact, or is this now unacceptable to say?

AIBU to say that my husband isn’t able to give birth?

OP posts:
wutheringkites · 04/07/2023 16:47

@PonyPatter44

Umm, I'm pretty sure that @TeenDivided is making the same point you are.

I don't get involved in threads on this issue often - are they always full of people shooting at their own shadow?

PonyPatter44 · 04/07/2023 16:45

TeenDivided · 04/07/2023 16:32

I don't think people have a right not to feel hurt or upset by truths they read.

I 'failed' at IVF. I've never been pregnant, never given birth.

I am sometimes upset when I read things related to pregnancy, birth, early months. But that hardly means I have the right to tell people not to talk about it.

I'm very sorry about your infertility, @TeenDivided , it must be very hard. I dont want to use you as a gotcha, but if sex really didn't matter, surely the doctors would be trying to get your husband/ male partner pregnant instead. The fact that they weren't, says something.

Gilead · 04/07/2023 16:42

@BathroomOnTheRight Sorry to disillusion you, I’m not stupid. I also have a trans (adult) child. Said child is not a threat to anyone. Nor are they trying to take over safe spaces, lavatories, sports or anything else. They would just like a quiet pleasant life.

Zebedee55 · 04/07/2023 16:38

I'm a pensioner, so probably out of the "new" thought loops.

But, in my view:

Male people are born with a penis.

Female people are born with a vagina.

Anyone can identify as they like, but that is biology...🙄

wutheringkites · 04/07/2023 16:34

@GrinAndVomit

I'm not picking a fight with anyone.

TeenDivided · 04/07/2023 16:32

I don't think people have a right not to feel hurt or upset by truths they read.

I 'failed' at IVF. I've never been pregnant, never given birth.

I am sometimes upset when I read things related to pregnancy, birth, early months. But that hardly means I have the right to tell people not to talk about it.

GrinAndVomit · 04/07/2023 16:32

wutheringkites · 04/07/2023 16:31

@BathroomOnTheRight

What definition do you prefer?

Why are you picking such ridiculous fights with people?

wutheringkites · 04/07/2023 16:31

@BathroomOnTheRight

What definition do you prefer?

BathroomOnTheRight · 04/07/2023 16:28

wutheringkites · 04/07/2023 16:24

@Fightyouforthatpie

Well yes, but I wasn't aware that definitions needed to read as short, snappy advertising slogans.

Nor do they need to read like a university dissertation.

Short and succinct is generally considered best.

wutheringkites · 04/07/2023 16:24

@Fightyouforthatpie

Well yes, but I wasn't aware that definitions needed to read as short, snappy advertising slogans.

Fightyouforthatpie · 04/07/2023 16:21

wutheringkites · 04/07/2023 16:20

@Cymbal

But wouldn't it be better to stick to biological facts that aren't connected to fertility?

For example: a person with a certain combination of sex characteristics, commonly including two X chromosomes in the cell nuclei, a vagina, a uterus and ovaries, and enlarged breasts developed at puberty.

Surely this is more accurate than 'people who give birth'?

It's a bit more long-winded though, isn't it?

SerafinasGoose · 04/07/2023 16:21

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 04/07/2023 16:11

There is an alternative place to post yes but I guess all of AIBU could be posted on a specific board. Sex and gender threads do seem to be being picked up as "shouldn't be here " type's currently

It's a topical discussion of interest to a broad spectrum of people. The OP posted it on AIBU because they wanted it on AIBU, and presumably those who clicked on the thread were interested to read its contents.

If I'm not interested in a particular thread - making the sole exception for the awful, awful COVID threads which pervaded the site recently and seemed inescapable - I scroll on past.

TheKeatingFive · 04/07/2023 16:21

The OP's husband cannot give birth. But if his sperm wasn't viable, and the OP used a donor, would anyone refuse to recognise him as the father?

No. Whatever gave you that idea?

If so, if the OP's husband genuinely changed his identity to female and parented the child, why would you refuse to recognise the OP's spouse as a mother?

Because mother is a term for the female parent - by sex. There is no such thing as 'genuinely changing your identity to female'. It's nonsense.

Fightyouforthatpie · 04/07/2023 16:20

catmothertes1 · 04/07/2023 14:16

I knew what this thread would be about before I even started reading it!

Wow, go you - collect your chocolate medal from reception right now.

wutheringkites · 04/07/2023 16:20

@Cymbal

But wouldn't it be better to stick to biological facts that aren't connected to fertility?

For example: a person with a certain combination of sex characteristics, commonly including two X chromosomes in the cell nuclei, a vagina, a uterus and ovaries, and enlarged breasts developed at puberty.

Surely this is more accurate than 'people who give birth'?

DdraigGoch · 04/07/2023 16:19

wutheringkites · 04/07/2023 14:00

There is a current thread on here that some posters want deleted because it doesn't align with their gender agenda so not all is well in Mumsnet land either.

The difference is that on here the cancel crew don’t generally get their way.

AlienatedChildGrown · 04/07/2023 16:18

I have a theory (born in the early 2000s, on the day that ivillage.com management took a hatchet to their golden goose). All Forums Eventually Die By Their Own Hand.

Somebody gets a germ of a great idea. A ball starts rolling. It catches on. Tweaks and major reworking iron out bugs and add features. Success happens. People at various levels behind the scenes get a bit of a fizz from the power they have over who gets to say what. The users, generating the content that makes the place a going concern, get relegated to “civilians” status.

The “officer class” of people behind the scenes now really addicted (often entirely unknowingly) to being the arbitrator of right v wrong. A couple of power crazed bad apples, or a few people with a very big bee in their bonnet come on board. They shift the line of Right v Wrong. TOS goes from “don’t be a git” to “Abide By My Personal Values or Beliefs, The Line Is Where I draw it, Depending On How Much I Like Who Said It”

The “civilians” over time feel increasingly like they have to cower. They let some excommunication go. But soon it’s people they like. They think they are next, or just resent toeing a be kind/polite line they didn’t choose to point beyond the tolerable. Forum dies. Sometimes really fast, sometimes quite slowly.

It’s the only thing that gives me hope. I was so excited by the possibilities of web 2.0. I completely failed to see the potential unintended consequences. That the snake appears doomed to always eat its own tail until it chokes turned out to be the silver lining.

I’m pretty sure in ancient time quite a few of the people behind the scenes of SM platforms would have seen themselves as Gods. Or at least a mouthpiece of the Gods. At least we can unplug from the SM version of “drunk on power” people. And increasingly, I think we probably should. Well I certainly should. It’s getting rarer and rarer that I come off any forum or platform feeling better than when I clicked it open.

loislovesstewie · 04/07/2023 16:18

BTW as is said frequently men know what makes a woman when what they need is specicific to that sex.

SerafinasGoose · 04/07/2023 16:18

Theunamedcat · 04/07/2023 14:03

Let's not conflate racism with transgender ideology/ biological reality please we will be tying ourselves up in metaphorical knots again
I would suggest these are two seperate conflicts warranting seperate threads

Yes, I fully agree.

It's interesting how often in recent days these two issues ARE being conflated on this site. And it's happening hot on the heels of the widespread, crude, ill-justified generalization on SM that any critique of GI is akin to alignment with alt right US views, sometimes even Nazism.

There are no prizes for guessing who's making this embarrassingly tacit connection. Or, as is likely, plopping onto MN as they've done before, and stirring up the discussion so they can post screenshots all over SM showing how racist Mumsnetters are, and that 'look! We told you so: being critical of gender and critical of skin colour amount to one and the same thing. Feminism = fascism!'

It's not the first time, and it looks as though they're coming for the site again. Plus sa change ...

BathroomOnTheRight · 04/07/2023 16:15

Gilead · 04/07/2023 15:33

Intersex folk can give birth. Why are you so concerned about what people have in their pants

@Gilead if someone is intersex and can give birth, that person, even with intersex, is FEMALE. No male person, intersex or not, can give birth.

Why are we so concerned about what people have in their pants? Er, maybe because words have meanings, and what is in mens pants can be used to rape and hurt women and women need spaces away from male bodies. Maybe that's why? Do you ever take time to truly think about things, before asking such absurd questions?

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 04/07/2023 16:15

GaspOde your post about 45 minutes ago 👏

KentuckyFriedChicken83 · 04/07/2023 16:15

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 04/07/2023 16:13

About 10 posts equated it to pedophilia.
Thats pretty hateful, if you ask me.

//

For a man to take a photo of himself with his shirt unbuttoned to reveal his bare breast and then hold a newborn baby there specifically near his exposed nipple is absolutely skirting on a sexual fetish. That was not for the child that's for him.

Exactly. There is no benefit at all to the baby. In fact, the baby will probably be getting upset and frustrated as no milk is coming out. It is purely for the benefit of the man which raises its own questions.

Mama678 · 04/07/2023 16:14

Don’t let your bank know or they will close your accounts! Crazy isnt it

what stops you setting up a new email address with a random name and then setting up a new account on said social media page in your nickname??! Hmm 🤔

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 04/07/2023 16:13

About 10 posts equated it to pedophilia.
Thats pretty hateful, if you ask me.

//

For a man to take a photo of himself with his shirt unbuttoned to reveal his bare breast and then hold a newborn baby there specifically near his exposed nipple is absolutely skirting on a sexual fetish. That was not for the child that's for him.

therescoffeeinthatnebula · 04/07/2023 16:13

BibbleandSqwauk · 04/07/2023 15:59

@Squarepegz ok, so please can you actually explain what was wrong with what the OP posted and why it was right she was banned? What is wrong with the statement that someone who produces eggs cannot then become someone who produces sperm? Genuinely, I'd like to know.

There's a difference between a scientific fact expressed in a neutral way, and expressed in a goady way. Most neurotypical people can pick up on the underlying intent and tone.

Of course someone born a woman with female biology cannot give birth to a child and then go to produce sperm. However, someone born a woman can change their gender identity to male and even have a sex change operation to become more physically male. Refusing to recognise such a person as a father is hurtful.

Plenty of men born men cannot father children naturally - if they have a child using donor sperm and raise that child, no one says they're not fathers.

The OP's husband cannot give birth. But if his sperm wasn't viable, and the OP used a donor, would anyone refuse to recognise him as the father? If so, if the OP's husband genuinely changed his identity to female and parented the child, why would you refuse to recognise the OP's spouse as a mother?

We live in a society where raising a child is seen more important than biological parentage.

The OP's complaint would be more interesting with all the missing context...