Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Permanently banned for ‘promoting hate’

390 replies

RumAndReisling · 04/07/2023 13:32

Following ten years uneventful membership of a major social media site I have been permanently banned for ‘promoting hate’.

Never again will I be able to participate on that site.

My crime? Saying that if you had given birth to a child, there was no way you could literally change sex and produce semen to father one.

Is this not a statement of fact, or is this now unacceptable to say?

AIBU to say that my husband isn’t able to give birth?

OP posts:
Helleofabore · 04/07/2023 18:06

Out of good manners we would address the transman as 'he' because that's the polite thing to do and it doesn't do us any harm to be polite.

And people have different boundaries regarding indulging people in their gender identity beliefs.

Considering there have been male transitioners who have used exactly the fact that people 'use their preferred pronouns' to then convince policy makers to make policies that put women and girls into harmful situations, I disagree with 'it doesn't do us any harm'. There are other impacts from using preferred pronouns too.

But if you want the name of a male who has done this, Veronica Ivy said this to sports policy makers to allow Veronica Ivy and other males to compete in female sports categories. I cannot find it though amongst all the other things that Veronica Ivy has said. They may have said it when they were known as Rachel McKinnon though - they did change their name. If I remember correctly, that change happened after this male athlete declared anyone who disagrees that they are a woman should die in a grease fire.

TeenDivided · 04/07/2023 18:05

SugarRaye · 04/07/2023 18:00

Say you went to a friend's party and she introduced you to a person called Mary. They seemed very friendly and courteous and it was clear they were biologically male, would you insist on knowing what their real name was and call them 'he'? Or would you address them as they'd like to be known?

A name is a name. Anyone can have any name.
And you wouldn't need to use he or she in that person's presence (remember the saying 'who's she, the cat's mother?)

But the pronouns is surely somewhat of a side issue. If people can't state basic biological facts like 'you can't change sexes' then we are in big trouble.

Whatwouldscullydo · 04/07/2023 18:05

SugarRaye · 04/07/2023 18:00

Say you went to a friend's party and she introduced you to a person called Mary. They seemed very friendly and courteous and it was clear they were biologically male, would you insist on knowing what their real name was and call them 'he'? Or would you address them as they'd like to be known?

I would refrain from using their name or any pronouns at all tbh.

Someone else's identity is not my problem its their choice I don't ha e to play along.

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 04/07/2023 18:03

If I knew someone who announced that she now identified as something I knew she wasn't, e.g. 20 years younger than her actual age, a different ethnicity, a person with a disability (all of which have happened in recent years), I would be unable to go along with that fantasy. Depending on the circumstances, I might be concerned about her mental health. I would regard a request to start referring to a female with male pronouns in the same light.

Change of name is a different matter. Lots of people change their names, for all sorts of reasons.

BlackForestCake · 04/07/2023 18:02

Gender identity is a protected characteristic

No it isn't.

Gender reassignment is protected. All that means is that you cannot be discriminated against compared with people who are not undergoing gender reassignment.

It does not give you the right to use single-sex spaces of the opposite sex, and it does not oblige anyone to pretend they believe you have changed sex.

FOJN · 04/07/2023 18:02

Refusing to recognise such a person as a father is hurtful

If the person has actually given birth to the baby then the baby has a right to know who their mother is. We should not pander to adult wants at the expense of a child.

TheKeatingFive · 04/07/2023 18:02

I would call them by their preferred gender. That's just polite. It wouldn't stop me noticed what their sex really was.

So you would collude in a lie because you think it's 'polite'? I don't understand that at all I must say.

Why deny the evidence of your eyes and ears, material reality? Whose agenda does that ultimately serve?

SugarRaye · 04/07/2023 18:00

Whatwouldscullydo · 04/07/2023 17:54

I respect all people until they do something to lose that respect. Wanting to live their life in a different way to me would not be reason enough to be disrespectful to them

Expecting strangers to play along is extremely entitled and disrespectful dont you think?

Say you went to a friend's party and she introduced you to a person called Mary. They seemed very friendly and courteous and it was clear they were biologically male, would you insist on knowing what their real name was and call them 'he'? Or would you address them as they'd like to be known?

FOJN · 04/07/2023 17:57

ASGIRC · 04/07/2023 15:02

In this example, yes, the person might just be rude or inept.

However, in the context of trans people, from what Ive read here on MN, it is ALWAYS hateful. All you have to do is go on the Feminism board and read literally any thread about trans people (trans women seem to be the biggest target).

Most posts there will even equate a trans woman to a pedophile.

It is not just stating the fact that a trans woman cannot give birth or a trans man does not produce sperm. Sure, those are facts. But Ill bet anything the OP did not just state the facts.

You've given an example which does not work to prove hate but we're supposed to believe you know the motivation of everyone posting on the feminist board in defence of women's rights.

Most posts? I am familiar with the feminist boards and this is categorically not true. Unfortunately there are some men who say they are women who actually are paedophiles. A surprising number seem to find their inner woman after they have been arrested.

https://transcrimeuk.com/category/sexual-offences/possession-of-csa-images/

The reasons transwomen will be the subject of much discussion on a feminist board is because the acceptance of them as women in all areas of public life can both disadvantage and endanger women. Do you think we should be kind and not discuss these issues in case we hurt someone's feelings?

You have no idea what the OP said but you are quite sure she said something hateful, how? Plenty of people have been banned from social media for making quite innocuous remarks, I can easily believe she has been banned for simply stating facts. People have been taken to court for less.

I think you have committed to a belief in an ideology you do not fully understand but are willing to defend it anyway.

Possession of CSA images – Trans Crime UK

https://transcrimeuk.com/category/sexual-offences/possession-of-csa-images

TeenDivided · 04/07/2023 17:56

However Sugar it should still be your choice which pronouns to use within your own speech. You can choose to 'be kind' or choose to use sex based pronouns.
There has been at least one case where a female victim was directed to refer to her male attacker as 'she' in court. Why should the attacker's feelings matter more than the victim?

Whatwouldscullydo · 04/07/2023 17:54

I respect all people until they do something to lose that respect. Wanting to live their life in a different way to me would not be reason enough to be disrespectful to them

Expecting strangers to play along is extremely entitled and disrespectful dont you think?

Helleofabore · 04/07/2023 17:53

SerafinasGoose · 04/07/2023 16:21

It's a topical discussion of interest to a broad spectrum of people. The OP posted it on AIBU because they wanted it on AIBU, and presumably those who clicked on the thread were interested to read its contents.

If I'm not interested in a particular thread - making the sole exception for the awful, awful COVID threads which pervaded the site recently and seemed inescapable - I scroll on past.

But Serafina we KNOW there are some posters who simply have no impulse control and must come and shame all other posters for their wrong think (according to them!)

SugarRaye · 04/07/2023 17:51

TheKeatingFive · 04/07/2023 14:52

Out of good manners we would address the transman as 'he' because that's the polite thing to do and it doesn't do us any harm to be polite.

The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command - 1984

I disagree. If my friend told me they were now a man and wanted to be called Ronald, because they're my friend, I would do that. If I went to a dinner party and I was sat next to a trans person, I would call them by their preferred gender. That's just polite. It wouldn't stop me noticed what their sex really was. And it certainly doesnt mean that I wouldn't debate the issue that people can't change sex.
I respect all people until they do something to lose that respect. Wanting to live their life in a different way to me would not be reason enough to be disrespectful to them.

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 04/07/2023 17:48

Gender identity is a protected characteristic. I don't see why you think you spouting conspiracy theories and hate is somehow OK. There are agreed terms of use, review them.

So if somebody who had previously been pregnant and given birth to a baby went to (for ease, let's call this person) 'her' GP and sought tests, assistance and treatment to enable her to father a child, as she was not producing any sperm and was thus (as a 'male') 'infertile' - would you really expect the GP and any other medical staff to seriously fully investigate why their patient was not producing sperm and what the solution would be to enable said patient to father a child?

Or would you denounce them as 'hateful conspiracy theorists' as well, if they kindly told the patient that she would never be able to do so, and that it was, in fact, categorically not as a result of any kind of problem or dysfunction with her body that was preventing this from being a possibility?

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 04/07/2023 17:44

Refusing to recognise such a person as a father is hurtful

Fortunately the UK Supreme Court decided that facts were more important than hurt feelings in this matter, and transmen continue to be recorded on their children's birth certificates as mothers, not fathers, and quite right too, given that they gave birth to the children concerned.

(Still waiting for someone to explain how it's living as a man to do one of the most female things imaginable, i.e. become pregnant and give birth.)

Whatwouldscullydo · 04/07/2023 17:36

Of course someone born a woman with female biology cannot give birth to a child and then go to produce sperm. However, someone born a woman can change their gender identity to male and even have a sex change operation to become more physically male. Refusing to recognise such a person as a father is hurtful

Whats a male gender identity? As for the surgery, its bloody offensive to men to think a rolled up piece of arm flesh is a penis. In fact the whole ideology shows just what false ideas of the human body people have. Bodies are amazing. What they can do is incredible. A vagina is more than a hole to stick a dick in. Amd a penis is far more than a tube of skin created in an OR

A man without a penis is still a man BTW. You can't become physically male when you are female down to every cell in your body.

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 04/07/2023 17:36

@tt9, couldn't agree more.

tt9 · 04/07/2023 17:33

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 04/07/2023 15:31

Hardly anybody with a trans identity has genital surgery, which is a good thing because there's a high risk of infection, very poor outcomes and lots of complications to do with incontinence and loss of sexual function. And that's just surgeons trying to make that part of the body into a crude facsimile of the genitals of the opposite sex. It's completely impossible to make a male body function like a female body, or vice versa, even for sexual purposes, never mind for reproduction. Women's bodies are incredibly complex and every part of the body is involved in pregnancy. Activists sometimes seem to think it would be possible for a male person to have a womb implanted and some kind of hormone cocktail administered and bingo, they could have IVF and go through a pregnancy. No, they couldn't, as there's far more to it than having a womb and not having high levels of testosterone.

My personal view is that medical science shouldn't be wasting time and resources on even contemplating these procedures. We have so many real medical problems that need improved understanding and treatments and aren't a priority, and I'd like scientists and HCPs to focus on those. I'm thinking of conditions like endometriosis, painful periods, menopause problems, improving care for women through pregnancy, childbirth and breastfeeding. Psychological issues need psychological treatments, not surgery.

following on from your point... let's also not forget the millions of women in deprived circumstances around the world who are unable to access adequate reproductive care and suffer awful complications/risk of death. if we have spare cash, let's spend it on ensuring safe pregnancies for these women.

BathroomOnTheRight · 04/07/2023 17:15

Gilead · 04/07/2023 16:42

@BathroomOnTheRight Sorry to disillusion you, I’m not stupid. I also have a trans (adult) child. Said child is not a threat to anyone. Nor are they trying to take over safe spaces, lavatories, sports or anything else. They would just like a quiet pleasant life.

If you have a trans child, surely you would be more than aware right now of women struggling to keep male bodies (however that person identifies) out of womens spaces and sports, and why genitals matter. As the parent of a trans child, since this topic has blown up, you would definitely have heard of it. So I don't understand why you still can't see why what's "in a person's pants" matters. You of all people, would know why it's discussed so why ask the question.

AmuseBish · 04/07/2023 17:06

It's interesting how often in recent days these two issues ARE being conflated on this site.

"The regulars don't think it's racist? Well, we'll damn well MAKE IT racist!"

FarmGirl78 · 04/07/2023 17:05

I would assume it's not what you said it's the way that you said it. If the wording around your facts were done as to provoke hate, or directed at an individual so was bullying, then yeah, I can totally understand why this would get a bad response. The fact you haven't given full context or stated exactly what you said, well to me that speaks volumes.

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 04/07/2023 16:57

Nobody would be much bothered about who's female and who's male if it didn't have important real life consequences, rather than being as trivial as who prefers cats to dogs, or coffee to tea.

Two big reasons why it matters to stick to words having agreed meanings in this area:

  • Female humans have been discriminated against in most parts of the world all through recorded history. We've been told we can't have education, we can't vote, we can't do certain kinds of work, we can't be paid the same as men, we can't dress the way we want, we can't go out on our own, we can't drive, we can't play sport in public, the list is endless. This is sexism and if we can't define sex accurately we have no hope of fighting it.
  • Male violence. Not all males are violent. Some females are violent. However, crime statistics from all over the world and as far back as they've been kept show that most violent crime is committed by males. Almost all sexual offences are committed by males. When males do commit violence, because they are bigger and stronger than females and children of both sexes, they can do serious damage physically. Males can use the threat of violence to get what they want. All of this does serious emotional and psychological damage. Women and other vulnerable groups need safeguarding from males for our safety, dignity and privacy. We don't know in advance which males are a thread, so we exclude all fo them from some spaces and services that need to be female only. Decent males accept this. If we can't adequately define which groups need safeguarding, and from whom, we can't keep anybody safe.
wutheringkites · 04/07/2023 16:52

@PonyPatter44

I apologise, I misread the tone of your post.

PonyPatter44 · 04/07/2023 16:51

@wutheringkites , I know she is making the same point as me. It's called having a conversation. I wanted to sympathise with her as well, that's called empathy. You can call it shooting at your own shadow if you wish.

I do like your name though.

TeenDivided · 04/07/2023 16:48

PonyPatter44 · 04/07/2023 16:45

I'm very sorry about your infertility, @TeenDivided , it must be very hard. I dont want to use you as a gotcha, but if sex really didn't matter, surely the doctors would be trying to get your husband/ male partner pregnant instead. The fact that they weren't, says something.

Well precisely.
I've mainly 'got over' it now (except baby showers, those are hard).