Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Permanently banned for ‘promoting hate’

390 replies

RumAndReisling · 04/07/2023 13:32

Following ten years uneventful membership of a major social media site I have been permanently banned for ‘promoting hate’.

Never again will I be able to participate on that site.

My crime? Saying that if you had given birth to a child, there was no way you could literally change sex and produce semen to father one.

Is this not a statement of fact, or is this now unacceptable to say?

AIBU to say that my husband isn’t able to give birth?

OP posts:
BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 04/07/2023 21:04

that's the beauty of the free market. Private entities, regardless of their size, are allowed to set their own terms & conditions when it comes to use and entering into agreements / contracts, providing they do not breach any legislation when doing so.

Denying service on the basis of a protected characteristic - and gender critical beliefs are so protected (Forstater) - breaches the Equality Act.

AmuseBish · 04/07/2023 21:04

However, someone born a woman can change their gender identity to male and even have a sex change operation to become more physically male.

Male is a sex. Gender is not the same thing. There is no such thing as a male being "more male" than another - in fact it's a little offensive.

People really need to stop mixing up sex and gender. The distinction is important.

SugarRaye · 04/07/2023 20:07

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 04/07/2023 19:26

Nope, that's the beauty of the free market. Private entities, regardless of their size, are allowed to set their own terms & conditions when it comes to use and entering into agreements / contracts, providing they do not breach any legislation when doing so.

The counter arguement that companies should be forced to work with people they do not want to work with, or that they must allow views they do not agree with to be aired on their plaform, is far more Orwellian than any enforcement of a company's T&Cs.

If you want a social media platform or bank that is bound by law to cater for all you'll need to campaign for a nationalised version to be created or set up your own organisation a la Telegram, BSAL, or Triodos, but even then there will be limits to what you can do.

On a wider point it's probably worth remembering that, in general, companies are there to make a profit and will either cater to the widest audience possible or to their most valued stakeholders. If you find yourself consistently in a situation where your views are not aligned to how major companies operate you may just have to accept you hold a minority view that may not be welcomed.

No one is entitled to a platform to share their opinions and no one is entitled to share their opinion without consequence. The sooner social media users, especially those who comment under their real names, realise this the easier their lives will be.

I maybe expressed myself wrongly. I'm not saying that that is illegal now. I'm saying it should be illegal. I have no problem with a company that have plentiful competition banning people. But if you're positioning your company almost to have a stakehold in the country, with the aim of becoming a monopoly, then the rules need to be different.

Banks might make you sign T&Cs but ultimately you have no choice about what you sign because we all need a bank account to survive. That's the same with some of these large sites. If you've manoeuvred your company into being used for business meetings, then by banning someone from participating in team meetings, you could be effectively firing them. That is too much power for companies like this to hold. We're effectively allowing unelected people to govern and control what people are allowed to say. What happens they make speechless anyone who criticises them? Or decides what parties are allowed to be spoken about, and those that must not be talked about? How is that different from Chinese controlled state tv?

That's a million times removed from any idea I've heard of a free market.

Endlesssummer2022 · 04/07/2023 19:31

Don’t people get a bit bored by the manufactured outrage? It’s the same comments over and over, ‘woke’, ‘at least he knows what a woman is’ rinse and repeat. I’m actually gender critical but this kind of stuff does nobody any favours.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 04/07/2023 19:26

SugarRaye · 04/07/2023 18:32

But that can't be right. I agree when you're talking about a small FB group of friends or something like that. But not when you're talking about these large multi-national platforms. These platforms have grown themselves so they can be an important part of people's personal and working lives. Being barred from it might cause an individual disadvantage.
It's similar to the banks. They've created a situation where we can't live in society without banks. Therefore banks should not have the right to close accounts purely because your views might not align to those of the CEO's.
When these huge businesses decide to become part of the infrastructure of how society operates, I don't believe they have the right to bar people just because they express opinions contrary to those of the site owner or operator.

Nope, that's the beauty of the free market. Private entities, regardless of their size, are allowed to set their own terms & conditions when it comes to use and entering into agreements / contracts, providing they do not breach any legislation when doing so.

The counter arguement that companies should be forced to work with people they do not want to work with, or that they must allow views they do not agree with to be aired on their plaform, is far more Orwellian than any enforcement of a company's T&Cs.

If you want a social media platform or bank that is bound by law to cater for all you'll need to campaign for a nationalised version to be created or set up your own organisation a la Telegram, BSAL, or Triodos, but even then there will be limits to what you can do.

On a wider point it's probably worth remembering that, in general, companies are there to make a profit and will either cater to the widest audience possible or to their most valued stakeholders. If you find yourself consistently in a situation where your views are not aligned to how major companies operate you may just have to accept you hold a minority view that may not be welcomed.

No one is entitled to a platform to share their opinions and no one is entitled to share their opinion without consequence. The sooner social media users, especially those who comment under their real names, realise this the easier their lives will be.

Leastsaidsoonestscrewed · 04/07/2023 19:21

Sure. That's all you said. Sure.🙄

FOJN · 04/07/2023 19:19

flaffydaffy · 04/07/2023 19:08

What if the trans man is the parent who didn't give birth? Is he a mother or a father?

I don't know for sure but would imagine it would depend on whether they had a GRC.

SugarRaye · 04/07/2023 19:10

TheKeatingFive · 04/07/2023 18:02

I would call them by their preferred gender. That's just polite. It wouldn't stop me noticed what their sex really was.

So you would collude in a lie because you think it's 'polite'? I don't understand that at all I must say.

Why deny the evidence of your eyes and ears, material reality? Whose agenda does that ultimately serve?

I don't necessarily agree with your word 'lie' but I'll carry on using it because I understand your meaning. We collude in lies all the time. When people talk how brilliant their children are, for example, and we know they're not. We don't point out their flaws, we politely go with the flow.

I don't understand what you mean about agenda. Some people just feel, for reasons I admittedly don't understand, that they were born with the wrong sexed body. But just because I don't understand how that feels, doesn't mean it's not real for them. There are lots of ways that people live their lives that I don't understand. I respect them as much as I can. If it makes their lives more pleasant by me calling them he or she, I'd happily do that. It doesn't mean that I believe their rights trumps those of people living as they sex they were born. But I don't want to make my friends life worse by dismissing something important to them.

flaffydaffy · 04/07/2023 19:08

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 04/07/2023 17:44

Refusing to recognise such a person as a father is hurtful

Fortunately the UK Supreme Court decided that facts were more important than hurt feelings in this matter, and transmen continue to be recorded on their children's birth certificates as mothers, not fathers, and quite right too, given that they gave birth to the children concerned.

(Still waiting for someone to explain how it's living as a man to do one of the most female things imaginable, i.e. become pregnant and give birth.)

What if the trans man is the parent who didn't give birth? Is he a mother or a father?

KentuckyFriedChicken83 · 04/07/2023 19:05

EmmaGrundyForPM · 04/07/2023 19:03

@KentuckyFriedChicken83 on the thread about telling the grandmother-to-be the "gender" of the baby. At 14:12 you were insisting that sex and gender meant the same thing. Even though lots of posters (including myself) were saying that sex is a fact, whereas gender is to do with crap stereotypes, and the difference is crucial.

I don't understand how my comment on here contradicts that?

EmmaGrundyForPM · 04/07/2023 19:03

@KentuckyFriedChicken83 on the thread about telling the grandmother-to-be the "gender" of the baby. At 14:12 you were insisting that sex and gender meant the same thing. Even though lots of posters (including myself) were saying that sex is a fact, whereas gender is to do with crap stereotypes, and the difference is crucial.

KentuckyFriedChicken83 · 04/07/2023 18:53

EmmaGrundyForPM · 04/07/2023 18:51

@KentuckyFriedChicken83 I said almost exactly that on another thread today and you had a real go at me. Make up your mind.

Apologies, but you'll have to refresh my memory. I don't recall.

SugarRaye · 04/07/2023 18:52

Helleofabore · 04/07/2023 18:31

On the contrary.

I am pointing out that there are indeed ramifications for this. Maybe that you were unaware of.

What part about people politely calling that male person 'she' and calling them a 'woman' have they have not attempted to leverage to change sport's policy to the detriment of any female athlete? How do you know who you are being polite to isn't going to attempt to leverage it in the same way for any other reason?

I do understand that you believe that people should be polite & respectful. I don't believe that it is respectful for any person to expect me to affirm their gender identity. They have not changed sex and pronouns are based on sex in the English language. Words have consequences.

Apogee if I misunderstood.
I have said quite clearly that people should have a right to not call a man 'he' if their biological sex is a woman. And I believe that's the same whether in a public debate, to strangers, or to friends. But we also, as a society, should be respectful to each other on a personal level. Without that society breaks down. Most people are polite and respectful. They don't want or intend to give offence. But that doesn't mean they'll let their rights be overruled.
I've read quickly about Veronica Ivy/Rachel McKinnon. In a social setting I'd call them Veronica and 'she'. But that doesn't override my view that they are biologically male and I'd fight them in any situation where they're trying to get included in female sport, etc.

EmmaGrundyForPM · 04/07/2023 18:51

@KentuckyFriedChicken83 I said almost exactly that on another thread today and you had a real go at me. Make up your mind.

KentuckyFriedChicken83 · 04/07/2023 18:36

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 04/07/2023 18:03

If I knew someone who announced that she now identified as something I knew she wasn't, e.g. 20 years younger than her actual age, a different ethnicity, a person with a disability (all of which have happened in recent years), I would be unable to go along with that fantasy. Depending on the circumstances, I might be concerned about her mental health. I would regard a request to start referring to a female with male pronouns in the same light.

Change of name is a different matter. Lots of people change their names, for all sorts of reasons.

I agree. I too would not be able to go along with calling a man 'she' and vice versa. It's not something I would be comfortable with and it's not true.

SoSoSoSo · 04/07/2023 18:36

Good for you if it doesn't bother you but you know it does hurt some women who would love to have children but it can't happen for them. I was with a friend when someone announced she wasn't a real woman because she couldn't have children and she was devastated

I also have fertility issues and The very fact that a woman has fertility problems and has trouble conceiving or can't conceive a child proves that she's a real woman. No Doctor is in the least bit concerned when a man, of any age, is unable to get pregnant because biology dictates that they cannot under any circumstances become pregnant, but if a pre-menopausal woman is unable to conceive in spite of trying then yes there is a problem and a Doctor may refer for further investigation and treatment because she's a woman and women are the only one of the two sexes who can become pregnant.

SugarRaye · 04/07/2023 18:32

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 04/07/2023 18:17

You can start your own site / platform if you're not happy with the current offerings and how they are run.

But that can't be right. I agree when you're talking about a small FB group of friends or something like that. But not when you're talking about these large multi-national platforms. These platforms have grown themselves so they can be an important part of people's personal and working lives. Being barred from it might cause an individual disadvantage.
It's similar to the banks. They've created a situation where we can't live in society without banks. Therefore banks should not have the right to close accounts purely because your views might not align to those of the CEO's.
When these huge businesses decide to become part of the infrastructure of how society operates, I don't believe they have the right to bar people just because they express opinions contrary to those of the site owner or operator.

Tomateen · 04/07/2023 18:32

araiwa · 04/07/2023 13:45

You broke their rules, you can't use their site any more

was it worth it?

It’s always worth it to state the truth.

Helleofabore · 04/07/2023 18:31

SugarRaye · 04/07/2023 18:23

I respect your response but it doesn't address what I said.
I have been clear that under free speech, people should be able to use pronouns as they see fit. And so if you were debating the issue on a TV show, you might indeed use the pronoun appropriate to the biological sex.
However, that is separate from courtesy and good manners. There's a transformation in my local M&S. She was always,super helpful and pleasant. Why would I belittle her by calling her 'he' when she didn't want that? I 100% believe I have the right to, but just because you have the right, doesn't mean you have to exert them all the time.
Imagine your child had acne. I believe I have the right to say to them that they have acne. But I wouldn't do that. It doesn't change the situation and it's rude. On a personal level, I try to respect people's feelings.

On the contrary.

I am pointing out that there are indeed ramifications for this. Maybe that you were unaware of.

What part about people politely calling that male person 'she' and calling them a 'woman' have they have not attempted to leverage to change sport's policy to the detriment of any female athlete? How do you know who you are being polite to isn't going to attempt to leverage it in the same way for any other reason?

I do understand that you believe that people should be polite & respectful. I don't believe that it is respectful for any person to expect me to affirm their gender identity. They have not changed sex and pronouns are based on sex in the English language. Words have consequences.

Whatwouldscullydo · 04/07/2023 18:25

Debating that it's biologically impossible for a woman to become a man, doesnt mean that you have to be rude to transpeople you are introduced socially by telling them that

Depends on your definition of rude I guess. Personally I find lying to someone's face,.indulging untruths and encouraging needy and narcissist behaviour thinking hou are " being kind" rude and unkind. As is expecting nom consenting strangers to participate in a delusion , gaslighting them in the process.

That's ruder than the truth can ever be tbh

SugarRaye · 04/07/2023 18:23

Helleofabore · 04/07/2023 18:06

Out of good manners we would address the transman as 'he' because that's the polite thing to do and it doesn't do us any harm to be polite.

And people have different boundaries regarding indulging people in their gender identity beliefs.

Considering there have been male transitioners who have used exactly the fact that people 'use their preferred pronouns' to then convince policy makers to make policies that put women and girls into harmful situations, I disagree with 'it doesn't do us any harm'. There are other impacts from using preferred pronouns too.

But if you want the name of a male who has done this, Veronica Ivy said this to sports policy makers to allow Veronica Ivy and other males to compete in female sports categories. I cannot find it though amongst all the other things that Veronica Ivy has said. They may have said it when they were known as Rachel McKinnon though - they did change their name. If I remember correctly, that change happened after this male athlete declared anyone who disagrees that they are a woman should die in a grease fire.

I respect your response but it doesn't address what I said.
I have been clear that under free speech, people should be able to use pronouns as they see fit. And so if you were debating the issue on a TV show, you might indeed use the pronoun appropriate to the biological sex.
However, that is separate from courtesy and good manners. There's a transformation in my local M&S. She was always,super helpful and pleasant. Why would I belittle her by calling her 'he' when she didn't want that? I 100% believe I have the right to, but just because you have the right, doesn't mean you have to exert them all the time.
Imagine your child had acne. I believe I have the right to say to them that they have acne. But I wouldn't do that. It doesn't change the situation and it's rude. On a personal level, I try to respect people's feelings.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 04/07/2023 18:17

TheKeatingFive · 04/07/2023 13:57

Unless you've been living in a cave for last ten years, everyone should know the risk of comments like that on Facebook, Reddit etc

And what ... we should just sit back and take it? Reality be damned?

You can start your own site / platform if you're not happy with the current offerings and how they are run.

TeenDivided · 04/07/2023 18:15

Iwasafool · 04/07/2023 18:12

Good for you if it doesn't bother you but you know it does hurt some women who would love to have children but it can't happen for them. I was with a friend when someone announced she wasn't a real woman because she couldn't have children and she was devastated.

You don't speak for all women who are infertile.

That's totally different!

Only women can have children, but not all women can have children.
You aren't less of a woman if you can't have children.

Iwasafool · 04/07/2023 18:12

Cymbal · 04/07/2023 16:12

It's a great example.

I'm a woman who can't have children and have no problem with basic facts. Only women have children. Don't co-opt my experience to shore up your argument.

I've been deeply offended by trans describing themselves as infertile women. In fact, a transwoman on this website once told me his infertility was sadder than mine, because at least I had a womb. He was a father.

Good for you if it doesn't bother you but you know it does hurt some women who would love to have children but it can't happen for them. I was with a friend when someone announced she wasn't a real woman because she couldn't have children and she was devastated.

You don't speak for all women who are infertile.

SugarRaye · 04/07/2023 18:12

TeenDivided · 04/07/2023 17:56

However Sugar it should still be your choice which pronouns to use within your own speech. You can choose to 'be kind' or choose to use sex based pronouns.
There has been at least one case where a female victim was directed to refer to her male attacker as 'she' in court. Why should the attacker's feelings matter more than the victim?

Isn't this just what I said, though. People shouldn't be cancelled for having free speech. They shouldn't be cancelled for saying women can't become men; for using a pronoun a person doesn't like; for telling someone their cousin us slimmer and prettier; for saying there should be white history month.

That's the essence of free speech.
But if we have rights under free speech, we should also have responsibilities. So if we have the right to say someone is fat and ugly (and, as a fat and certainly not pretty person, I believe it shouldn't be against the law to do that), it also behooves us to have the responsibility to think through the consequences our words.

Debating that it's biologically impossible for a woman to become a man, doesnt mean that you have to be rude to transpeople you are introduced socially by telling them that.