Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Permanently banned for ‘promoting hate’

390 replies

RumAndReisling · 04/07/2023 13:32

Following ten years uneventful membership of a major social media site I have been permanently banned for ‘promoting hate’.

Never again will I be able to participate on that site.

My crime? Saying that if you had given birth to a child, there was no way you could literally change sex and produce semen to father one.

Is this not a statement of fact, or is this now unacceptable to say?

AIBU to say that my husband isn’t able to give birth?

OP posts:
OMG12 · 05/07/2023 10:59

wutheringkites · 05/07/2023 10:55

@OMG12

I quoted a dictionary definition of a biological female on this thread and was accused of 'picking ridiculous fights with people' even though I'm also gender critical.

Both sides have absolutely lost their minds on this issue.

I would argue the insanity of one side on this has been the cause. Where is anyone going to go when someone has lost a grip on reality to such an extent they think someone with a penis, male chromosomes who produces male gametes is actually a woman. I can’t even. Begin to understand how anyone can reach this conclusion with a straight face!

literalviolence · 05/07/2023 10:57

Screamingabdabz · 04/07/2023 13:42

People can’t change sex full stop. It’s not hate, it’s fact. Unfortunately the world is going a bit loopy. I think it’s end time hysteria.

Indeed it's hate to women to pretend that men can become one. That sort of hate is OK though.

flaffydaffy · 05/07/2023 10:56

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 05/07/2023 10:49

When I asked that question I meant socially, not legally. I can't find anything online about what would go on a birth certificate in that situation.

But yeah if a woman had a baby and she had a husband who was a trans man, and everyone around him saw him as a man generally then would it be fine for him to be called dad by his children or should he have to be called mum?

Ah, sorry - I see. But I would still answer largely the same, socially speaking. When a same-sex couple seek to become parents, they know very well that there are going to be two mums or two dads in the child's upbringing from the very beginning.

If you were previously known as one biological sex and are seeking to become known by the parent word that refers to the other biological sex, not only is it deliberately confusing to all concerned, but it detracts from the person of the sex who is (or naturally expects to be) known as the that-sex parent, and thus also the child's understanding of the world and their place in it.

It seems to be 'A Thing' for some transwomen - who transition when they are older - to then declare themselves as their children's mother. Of course, they already have an actual mother - who is not in a lesbian relationship and therefore expects the right to be acknowledged as their only one.

It's just another way for certain biological males to forcefully appropriate women's identities; the actual mother is then pressured to take on an additional qualifier (as with the hideous 'cis' slur) - so she has to become 'Mum Louise', to be distinguished from 'Mum Phyllis' - when just 'Mum' should always have been enough within her family, when she 'signed up' right from the start to take that unique role, alongside Philip, known just as 'Dad'.

In the hypothetical situation I'm talking about the child has a mum who gave birth, who they would call mum, and the other parent is a trans man. Everyone, including the child, would be confused if the child was calling him mum, because everyone considers him to be a man.
I don't see why it would be different for families with two mums one of whom is a trans woman. Yes they'd have to add a qualifier or give them slightly different names (mummy and mama) but all lesbian parents have to do that. And nobody is particularly concerned in daily life which parent gave birth to them. Certainly not what type of genitals each parent has. Children shouldn't really have anything to do with their parents genitals after conception and birth is done.

wutheringkites · 05/07/2023 10:55

@OMG12

I quoted a dictionary definition of a biological female on this thread and was accused of 'picking ridiculous fights with people' even though I'm also gender critical.

Both sides have absolutely lost their minds on this issue.

OMG12 · 05/07/2023 10:52

Some stood cunt from Brighton reported me to Facebook for quoting the dictionary definition of woman which apparently was bullying. I had my account restricted.

if people cannot see the problem with this they’re blind and stupid. Just because the restrictions currently accord with your world view (most likely created by social
media) doesn’t mean that one day the thought police won’t come for you.

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 05/07/2023 10:49

When I asked that question I meant socially, not legally. I can't find anything online about what would go on a birth certificate in that situation.

But yeah if a woman had a baby and she had a husband who was a trans man, and everyone around him saw him as a man generally then would it be fine for him to be called dad by his children or should he have to be called mum?

Ah, sorry - I see. But I would still answer largely the same, socially speaking. When a same-sex couple seek to become parents, they know very well that there are going to be two mums or two dads in the child's upbringing from the very beginning.

If you were previously known as one biological sex and are seeking to become known by the parent word that refers to the other biological sex, not only is it deliberately confusing to all concerned, but it detracts from the person of the sex who is (or naturally expects to be) known as the that-sex parent, and thus also the child's understanding of the world and their place in it.

It seems to be 'A Thing' for some transwomen - who transition when they are older - to then declare themselves as their children's mother. Of course, they already have an actual mother - who is not in a lesbian relationship and therefore expects the right to be acknowledged as their only one.

It's just another way for certain biological males to forcefully appropriate women's identities; the actual mother is then pressured to take on an additional qualifier (as with the hideous 'cis' slur) - so she has to become 'Mum Louise', to be distinguished from 'Mum Phyllis' - when just 'Mum' should always have been enough within her family, when she 'signed up' right from the start to take that unique role, alongside Philip, known just as 'Dad'.

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 05/07/2023 10:45

”I have serious concerns for my physical safety in an intimate setting around a biological male that still has a penis and who hasn’t undergone reassignment surgery” is rather different to “all trans people in these spaces must be rapists”.

The only people I have ever heard say the latter are TRAs wilfully misrepresenting women's arguments.

flaffydaffy · 05/07/2023 10:33

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 05/07/2023 10:22

What if the trans man is the parent who didn't give birth? Is he a mother or a father?

Obviously not the father, as a female can never become a father. The birth certificate belongs to/is about the child, not the parents. The parents are essentially just there to provide context.

If you really must collude with the government to retrospectively falsify your own birth certificate, that's one thing; but how extremely arrogant to believe that you should be allowed to falsify somebody else's official record of their birth.

Subsequent adoption certificates may of course vary; but again, as the focus is on the child and not the adults, it is grossly arrogant to expect to use that child's official record to validate yourself as any kind of actual/in loco mother (if you are male) or as any kind of actual/in loco father (if you are female).

When I asked that question I meant socially, not legally. I can't find anything online about what would go on a birth certificate in that situation.

But yeah if a woman had a baby and she had a husband who was a trans man, and everyone around him saw him as a man generally then would it be fine for him to be called dad by his children or should he have to be called mum?

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 05/07/2023 10:22

What if the trans man is the parent who didn't give birth? Is he a mother or a father?

Obviously not the father, as a female can never become a father. The birth certificate belongs to/is about the child, not the parents. The parents are essentially just there to provide context.

If you really must collude with the government to retrospectively falsify your own birth certificate, that's one thing; but how extremely arrogant to believe that you should be allowed to falsify somebody else's official record of their birth.

Subsequent adoption certificates may of course vary; but again, as the focus is on the child and not the adults, it is grossly arrogant to expect to use that child's official record to validate yourself as any kind of actual/in loco mother (if you are male) or as any kind of actual/in loco father (if you are female).

Panama2 · 05/07/2023 10:10

To paraphrase George Orwell, “Every book rewritten, every picture repainted”. We are being forced to believe the unbelievable and to accept it as a fact

maddening · 05/07/2023 10:01

Conkersinautumn · 04/07/2023 14:12

Gender identity is a protected characteristic. I don't see why you think you spouting conspiracy theories and hate is somehow OK. There are agreed terms of use, review them.

Protected from facts?

HorseyMel · 05/07/2023 09:58

I don't use social media as a platform for political (or other) rants and the like.

It's a shame that, whatever hobby space you go to, there is always someone who wants to get into politics or whatever soap box they have.

TheKeatingFive · 05/07/2023 09:54

all trans people in these spaces must be rapists

I've literally never heard anyone say this. On here or anywhere else.

MrsPinkCock · 05/07/2023 09:35

GrinAndVomit · 05/07/2023 09:28

I am pro women’s rights and probably would be classed as holding gender critical beliefs

But also

with good reasoning behind it (not just the blanket “but they are menz and I might get raped”

interesting interpretation of pro women’s rights

That wasn’t an interpretation of women’s rights, but you’ve just backed up exactly the point that I was making in my post.

”I have serious concerns for my physical safety in an intimate setting around a biological male that still has a penis and who hasn’t undergone reassignment surgery” is rather different to “all trans people in these spaces must be rapists”.

One is a reasonable position to take, the other is not. One helps the cause, the other does not.

Hold and express an educated, rational and reasonable view and maybe we will be listened to.

GrinAndVomit · 05/07/2023 09:28

I am pro women’s rights and probably would be classed as holding gender critical beliefs

But also

with good reasoning behind it (not just the blanket “but they are menz and I might get raped”

interesting interpretation of pro women’s rights

MrsPinkCock · 05/07/2023 09:24

BlackForestCake · 04/07/2023 18:02

Gender identity is a protected characteristic

No it isn't.

Gender reassignment is protected. All that means is that you cannot be discriminated against compared with people who are not undergoing gender reassignment.

It does not give you the right to use single-sex spaces of the opposite sex, and it does not oblige anyone to pretend they believe you have changed sex.

Just for context, I am pro women’s rights and probably would be classed as holding gender critical beliefs (which is ironic really considering my job).

But what you have posted here is factually inaccurate.

Where a person undergoing gender reassignment is compared to someone who is not, that is covered by direct discrimination in the EqA. But that isn’t the only type of discrimination covered!

GR individuals are also protected from indirect discrimination (which could cover a requirement to use specific sex changing spaces) and harassment or victimisation depending on context (others failing to use their correct pronouns - which would probably only apply in the context of employment, or the provision of goods and services).

But the EqA DOES protect GR in the examples you gave. I say this because I believe that people holding gender critical beliefs are more likely to be taken seriously if they understand fully the law and reasoning behind those beliefs. But putting forward legally and factually incorrect information won’t help the cause and is more likely to damage it.

There is an interesting counter point to this too though after Maya v Forstater which means that gender critical beliefs can potentially be protected in law under the religion/belief discrimination legislation in the EqA - provided that they are not manifestly inappropriate. So ultimately where there is a clash of two protected rights, provided that they aren’t “manifested” in an inappropriate way, there should be some protection there at least.

I would take that to mean that you should use a persons chosen pronouns, as that applies to gender, but expecting to recognise that person as a biological male/female should not be required. But harassing them over it would still be unlawful.

And I suppose theoretically that if you held a genuine and appropriate belief that single sex changing spaces should cover biological sex only, with good reasoning behind it (not just the blanket “but they are menz and I might get raped”) then that could be covered too… although from a public policy perspective I can’t see that right trumping trans rights, as much as I personally disagree with that.

Helleofabore · 05/07/2023 09:20

Bloodysoapoperas · 05/07/2023 08:42

@Helleofabore so essentially if you were working with a trans person you'd refuse to call them by their new gender or name ? To their face ? And would that apply to transmales too ?

I did not say anything about names.

Can you tell me what third person pronouns would I be using ‘to their face’?

Would you use someone’s chosen religious honorific if you are not part of their religion? Or just speak to them directly using their name? Why? And is it respectful for a religious person to demand this of an atheist?

Can I assume you think I am what? Rude? Disrespectful?

Why? Because I think respect goes both ways?

Seems to be an issue that you yourself have around respecting people’s boundaries. Pronouns are based on sex. I choose not to validate gender identities by pretending that the impossible has happened. A trans person is a trans person and deserving of the same level of respect and dignity as all people, including myself. They deserve to not be discriminated against for having their identity except where sex matters for the protection of women and children.

Why is their boundary deemed more important than mine by you? If I have interpreted your question correctly.

JazbayGrapes · 05/07/2023 09:13

Don’t people get a bit bored by the manufactured outrage? It’s the same comments over and over, ‘woke’, ‘at least he knows what a woman is’ rinse and repeat. I’m actually gender critical but this kind of stuff does nobody any favours.

We are "bored" of our rights being taken away

Helleofabore · 05/07/2023 08:50

Bloodysoapoperas · 05/07/2023 08:42

@Helleofabore so essentially if you were working with a trans person you'd refuse to call them by their new gender or name ? To their face ? And would that apply to transmales too ?

What is a transmale please?

Whatwouldscullydo · 05/07/2023 08:48

Bloodysoapoperas · 05/07/2023 08:42

@Helleofabore so essentially if you were working with a trans person you'd refuse to call them by their new gender or name ? To their face ? And would that apply to transmales too ?

People have mistaken me for a man multiple times. I have letters addressed to Mr scully. Even one from the police addressing me as mr.

The world didn't stop turning. I didnt spontaneously combust because someone thought I might be a man.

Why is it so important that people play pretend? Why is it seen as acceptable that someone lays the responsibility of their mental wellbeing onto others instead of seeking help to come to terms with the reality that triggers them. Its their job to learn to deal with who they are and what they are and reality around them. Its not everyone else's job to participate in their delusion.

Bloodysoapoperas · 05/07/2023 08:42

@Helleofabore so essentially if you were working with a trans person you'd refuse to call them by their new gender or name ? To their face ? And would that apply to transmales too ?

Helleofabore · 05/07/2023 08:33

”So you've got to ask yourself, as I already wondered, whose agenda are you serving?”

Speaking of serving agendas, last week I followed a thread where a mature male who transitioned young tried to convince women that they were indeed just as much a woman as us. They started out with the ‘I have so much respect for my fellow women type of posts’ that quickly descended into posts driven by their male socialisation and were misogynistic.

They even told us all that being female was just a constellation of data points and this individual felt theirs fitted the ‘female’ data points. While telling us all the stereotypes that lead them to believe they were ‘in the wrong body’. This is a now mature male. And admitted they knew very well their presence in female single sex spaces distressed others, but they were never going to stop using them. Despite telling us they supposedly had lots of empathy.

It became quickly clear what that male individual’s agenda on that thread was.

They also actively campaign for affirming only treatment for children and adolescents, including full medicalised treatments for female children and teens.

Why are we being shamed into using pronouns for this person by others saying ‘what is the harm’ and talk guidelines on MN when there was absolutely zero respect being shown for women and girl’s needs?

Helleofabore · 05/07/2023 08:17

“So you've got to ask yourself, as I already wondered, whose agenda are you serving?”

I have listened a lot to detransitioner voices. It is as you say. Often when these people start to realise that absolutely none of these treatments, often lauded by other trans people online or in their support groups, have worked, they realise that society has allowed them to believe a lie. I think many of them simply realise there was never any way that they would achieve their goal. That human instinct is irrepressible- humans, children and female people in particular, always identify sex cues in bodies. And very often in socialisation/attitudes.

Even numerous accounts from still transitioned people make this point. That some of them finally realised nothing would make all other humans accept them as changing sex. Sometimes that does lead them to transition again to a non binary identity. Maybe that offers them something closer to a truth they can live with. I don’t know.

Either way, I am coming to see that using preferred pronouns is following an agenda I reject because I see numerous harms. And if people are being told that my avoidance of using their desired pronouns is hate, then that again is the agenda of a group that is creating this impossible agenda that only leads to further deterioration of people’s mental health.

Who ultimately benefits from convincing vulnerable people that people hate them?

TheKeatingFive · 05/07/2023 07:41

I don't necessarily agree with your word 'lie' but I'll carry on using it because I understand your meaning. We collude in lies all the time. When people talk how brilliant their children are, for example, and we know they're not. We don't point out their flaws, we politely go with the flow.

What you're talking about here isn't a like for like comparison. Firstly, the example you're using here is about saying nothing, not lying.

Secondly, it is fundamentally a value judgement, not observable material reality. Would we tell a child who is shorter than another that they're actually taller? I don't think so.

I don't understand what you mean about agenda. Some people just feel, for reasons I admittedly don't understand, that they were born with the wrong sexed body. But just because I don't understand how that feels, doesn't mean it's not real for them. There are lots of ways that people live their lives that I don't understand. I respect them as much as I can. If it makes their lives more pleasant by me calling them he or she, I'd happily do that

In the end, does that really make their lives 'more pleasant'? I take big issue with that. I've seen lots of transitioners on social media who are very disappointed to find, in adulthood, that they are not actually accepted as the opposite sex for dating and other purposes. I don't think it is at all in their interests to start to collude in the lie that they will be. So you've got to ask yourself, as I already wondered, whose agenda are you serving?

Mummyoflittledragon · 05/07/2023 05:58

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 04/07/2023 19:26

Nope, that's the beauty of the free market. Private entities, regardless of their size, are allowed to set their own terms & conditions when it comes to use and entering into agreements / contracts, providing they do not breach any legislation when doing so.

The counter arguement that companies should be forced to work with people they do not want to work with, or that they must allow views they do not agree with to be aired on their plaform, is far more Orwellian than any enforcement of a company's T&Cs.

If you want a social media platform or bank that is bound by law to cater for all you'll need to campaign for a nationalised version to be created or set up your own organisation a la Telegram, BSAL, or Triodos, but even then there will be limits to what you can do.

On a wider point it's probably worth remembering that, in general, companies are there to make a profit and will either cater to the widest audience possible or to their most valued stakeholders. If you find yourself consistently in a situation where your views are not aligned to how major companies operate you may just have to accept you hold a minority view that may not be welcomed.

No one is entitled to a platform to share their opinions and no one is entitled to share their opinion without consequence. The sooner social media users, especially those who comment under their real names, realise this the easier their lives will be.

What minority view are we talking about here? Op didn’t express a minority view.

Swipe left for the next trending thread