Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Permanently banned for ‘promoting hate’

390 replies

RumAndReisling · 04/07/2023 13:32

Following ten years uneventful membership of a major social media site I have been permanently banned for ‘promoting hate’.

Never again will I be able to participate on that site.

My crime? Saying that if you had given birth to a child, there was no way you could literally change sex and produce semen to father one.

Is this not a statement of fact, or is this now unacceptable to say?

AIBU to say that my husband isn’t able to give birth?

OP posts:
OMG12 · 05/07/2023 16:13

AmuseBish · 05/07/2023 14:44

If it's all about feelings, why don't trans women carry on dressing as they did before - no make up, jeans, t shirts etc...

There are some that do. This is why appearance isn't necessarily a factor in being trans. And why no-one can tell which male (or female) people are women (in the undefined gender way) from looking.

its always hard to tell if someone has a mental health condition from just looking at them. It’s easy to tell a man from a woman, one has a penis the other doesn’t. Job done.

flaffydaffy · 05/07/2023 15:50

literalviolence · 05/07/2023 13:39

So it's not about what they look like then in the case of the butch woman? But it is with the TM? That seems very confused.

As I already said, I belive some trans people can pass. But there are loads who don't. On occasion people have shared photos of people they say pass and they really don't.

It seems inappropriate to me to set rules or norms based on passing because it leaves some trans people treated differently than others.

A man is a man regardless of what surgery they've had or drugs they're taking. That's the only way to have equitability

Obviously the choice of the family is the most important factor, I thought that went without saying. A butch lesbian mother probably wouldn't choose to be called dad. My friend could, if he wanted, choose to be called mum, but he wouldn't want to do that since everyone sees him as a man and he isn't necessarily "out" publically as a trans person. So if his kid was calling him mum everyone would ask why. Presumably that's a conversation they'll have with the child when they're older. But in that circumstance why would the parents choose the word mum for him?

AmuseBish · 05/07/2023 14:44

If it's all about feelings, why don't trans women carry on dressing as they did before - no make up, jeans, t shirts etc...

There are some that do. This is why appearance isn't necessarily a factor in being trans. And why no-one can tell which male (or female) people are women (in the undefined gender way) from looking.

AmuseBish · 05/07/2023 14:41

The whole concept of "passing" also rests on the belief that men are male-bodied and women are female-bodied. Which is also a gender-critical belief.

I wonder if OP would have been allowed to state that without being banned?

Helleofabore · 05/07/2023 14:15

Panama2 · 05/07/2023 13:50

A poster has mentioned trans men/ women “passing” and that’s it really isn’t? A person may be surgically modified and medicated to pass/present as the opposite sex and they may pass but they have not changed sex.

I suspect that people will also lie about males who pass. Those males might pass until they move, speak or have a longer conversation. It may be that the male individual has had facial feminisation surgeries including the narrowing of the gap between the top of the lip and the base of the nose.

Male people have pelvis' that are different to female pelvis' and that also means that they then have q angles that are different which effects their gait.

There are many male cues and a large proportion of female people will pick up on those cues.

Transitioned female people could be said to 'pass' better due to the irreversible side effects of testosterone.

SockGoddess · 05/07/2023 14:07

Yes “passing” is an odd term. What does it really mean - that your disguise is effective or maybe that you are androgynous-looking naturally.

you could impersonate a police officer, a security guard, a doctor, a meter reader or just any other individual and you might “pass”. It doesn’t make you actually any more something you’re not, than if you don’t.

NameChange245 · 05/07/2023 13:59

KentuckyFriedChicken83 · 05/07/2023 13:26

A man is an adult who has a penis and XY chromosomes.

A woman is an adult who has a vagina and XX chromosomes.

Why does it need to be more complicated than that?

I totally agree.

When a man says 'i feel like a woman', how do they know that?? They don't know what it feels like to be a woman.

Also, why do most transwoman wear makeup, heels and skirts? I've never seen a transwoman who looks me - trainers, jeans, t shirt, no make up. Wearing a skirt and make up does not make you a woman.

I don't understand transgender stuff, I don't understand how someone can feel a different gender. But people can identify as whatever they want as far as I'm concerned. If my neighbour wanted to identify as a tree and wear a suit with leaves on, I'd support him all the way, be kind and respectful. But I wouldn't agree he's a tree because he says he is and wears an outfit of a stereotypical tree (branches, leaves etc..).

Equally, if a man identifies as a woman and wants to wear stereotypical female clothes, that's fine with me. I'll be kind and respectful. But I'm not going to believe he's a woman.

I personally think trans women perpetuate a female stereotype that I don't like. If it's all about feelings, why don't trans women carry on dressing as they did before - no make up, jeans, t shirts etc... Why do they perpetuate this idea that being female is wearing makeup, heels and skirts?

Personally I think transwoman is about fetish for wearing female clothes, not about how a person feels (since no transwoman can possibly know how it feels to be a woman)

I know people will disagree with me, but at least there is some freedom of speech (on this matter at least) on mumsnet.

Panama2 · 05/07/2023 13:50

A poster has mentioned trans men/ women “passing” and that’s it really isn’t? A person may be surgically modified and medicated to pass/present as the opposite sex and they may pass but they have not changed sex.

literalviolence · 05/07/2023 13:39

flaffydaffy · 05/07/2023 13:34

I don't know about "some" people knowing without being told. Maybe. But I have a whole group of friends who didn't know until they were told. He's the sort of person who, if he was in a group of men and you were told one of them is trans, then maybe you'd guess it was him. But you wouldn't know if it wasn't suggested that he might be.

To your other point, you seem skeptical of the idea that trans people can pass in general, so I don't know what to say to your suggestion that there could be a butch lesbian who is mistaken for a man so exclusively that it would make sense for her child to call her dad. And presumably she wouldn't make the choice to get her child to call her dad either.

So it's not about what they look like then in the case of the butch woman? But it is with the TM? That seems very confused.

As I already said, I belive some trans people can pass. But there are loads who don't. On occasion people have shared photos of people they say pass and they really don't.

It seems inappropriate to me to set rules or norms based on passing because it leaves some trans people treated differently than others.

A man is a man regardless of what surgery they've had or drugs they're taking. That's the only way to have equitability

flaffydaffy · 05/07/2023 13:34

literalviolence · 05/07/2023 13:26

I think some people might know full well that the TM is a woman but be being polite or top afraid to talk up. It's a bit harsh to suggest that very butch women have to be called dad tbh.

I don't know about "some" people knowing without being told. Maybe. But I have a whole group of friends who didn't know until they were told. He's the sort of person who, if he was in a group of men and you were told one of them is trans, then maybe you'd guess it was him. But you wouldn't know if it wasn't suggested that he might be.

To your other point, you seem skeptical of the idea that trans people can pass in general, so I don't know what to say to your suggestion that there could be a butch lesbian who is mistaken for a man so exclusively that it would make sense for her child to call her dad. And presumably she wouldn't make the choice to get her child to call her dad either.

KentuckyFriedChicken83 · 05/07/2023 13:26

A man is an adult who has a penis and XY chromosomes.

A woman is an adult who has a vagina and XX chromosomes.

Why does it need to be more complicated than that?

literalviolence · 05/07/2023 13:26

flaffydaffy · 05/07/2023 12:30

I'm just trying to drill it down. There are scenarios where it makes sense to call a parent by the gendered parent name that they actually look like. This whole debate has got me thinking because I have friends who are the hypothetical scenario I was describing. They've just had a baby through IVF and the trans man is, of course, the dad. Nobody who meets him thinks he's a woman so it would be extremely weird if he was referred to as mum.
Knowing that my friends exist, there has to be an equivalent scenario where one parent is a trans woman and why would it be different there? So I personally have found it weird seeing people talk about this and saying a trans woman can never be called mum. It must come down to how well the person passes really because if you think a child should call their parent dad if they look like a woman and have a woman's name etc that's a weird point of view.

I think some people might know full well that the TM is a woman but be being polite or top afraid to talk up. It's a bit harsh to suggest that very butch women have to be called dad tbh.

AmuseBish · 05/07/2023 13:13

flaffydaffy · 05/07/2023 11:22

In the hypothetical situation the trans man looks just like a man and you wouldn't know unless you were told. Trans people who pass obviously do exist.

Just to be clear: when you say "man", you mean "male adult"?

In gender terms a man is an innate identity, not something you can tell by looking. Hence the need to clarify, sorry...

flaffydaffy · 05/07/2023 12:30

literalviolence · 05/07/2023 12:16

Yes I think they do. But it's a tiny minority of trans people. Is this comment o ly applicable to that tiny minority? If there were a woman who was sometimes thought to be a man do you think they should be called dad? (I mean an actual woman here, not transwoman).

I'm just trying to drill it down. There are scenarios where it makes sense to call a parent by the gendered parent name that they actually look like. This whole debate has got me thinking because I have friends who are the hypothetical scenario I was describing. They've just had a baby through IVF and the trans man is, of course, the dad. Nobody who meets him thinks he's a woman so it would be extremely weird if he was referred to as mum.
Knowing that my friends exist, there has to be an equivalent scenario where one parent is a trans woman and why would it be different there? So I personally have found it weird seeing people talk about this and saying a trans woman can never be called mum. It must come down to how well the person passes really because if you think a child should call their parent dad if they look like a woman and have a woman's name etc that's a weird point of view.

literalviolence · 05/07/2023 12:16

flaffydaffy · 05/07/2023 11:22

In the hypothetical situation the trans man looks just like a man and you wouldn't know unless you were told. Trans people who pass obviously do exist.

Yes I think they do. But it's a tiny minority of trans people. Is this comment o ly applicable to that tiny minority? If there were a woman who was sometimes thought to be a man do you think they should be called dad? (I mean an actual woman here, not transwoman).

GrinAndVomit · 05/07/2023 12:05

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 05/07/2023 10:45

”I have serious concerns for my physical safety in an intimate setting around a biological male that still has a penis and who hasn’t undergone reassignment surgery” is rather different to “all trans people in these spaces must be rapists”.

The only people I have ever heard say the latter are TRAs wilfully misrepresenting women's arguments.

Same here.

My eyebrow has been raised a few times by posters claiming to be “pro women’s rights and actually gender critical but…”

SockGoddess · 05/07/2023 11:47

I actually also am a GC person who doesn’t go along with attacking trans people on the basis of how they look or how deluded they may seem. One reason for that is because I know there are often MH issues involved and people often struggle a lot with the disappointment of transition and need to convince themselves. I don’t think jeering at them is a good idea and I don’t.

But facts are facts and my approach is that policy should not be based on ideas that have no evidence to support them. We need to stay in touch with the evidenced facts, statistics and material reality when marking policies. Banning talking about facts is extremely dangerous ground.

SockGoddess · 05/07/2023 11:42

not just the blanket “but they are menz and I might get raped”**

what’s wrong with this? It’s true and it’s the reason separate spaces for women exist - along with the increased risk of murder, assault, harassment, intimidation, leering, flashing etc. it literally is the reason - alongside privacy and religious beliefs etc, but it’s the most important reason.

when we’re talking about women’s safety generally, aside from the trans issue, everyone understands this. Protection for women in the form of singe sex toilets, hospital wards, prisons etc is there to save women from the vastly higher likelihood of being raped and similar, if men are there.

add to that that we know trans-identifying men are MORE likely to be sex offenders than the average man. That doesn’t mean they all are, of course not. It means more of them are than the background level of men who are not allowed into women’s spaces.

that’s not surprising at all when self-Id policies mean any man can say he’s a woman and get access to women’s spaces. Who wants that? Sex offenders. And saying you’re a woman gets male offenders access to women’s prisons. Who wants that - sex offenders. And we know many TW, even if they are not deliberately lying just to get access, have a fetish about being in women’s spaces and find it a turn-on - many openly say so themselves.

so the reason for women’s safe single-sex spaces becomes even more pressing when it’s TW we don’t want there, not less. And that reason is sexual assault and flashing (and btw flashing is known typical precursor to more serious sex crimes).

flaffydaffy · 05/07/2023 11:39

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 05/07/2023 11:27

In the hypothetical situation I'm talking about the child has a mum who gave birth, who they would call mum, and the other parent is a trans man. Everyone, including the child, would be confused if the child was calling him mum, because everyone considers him to be a man.
I don't see why it would be different for families with two mums one of whom is a trans woman. Yes they'd have to add a qualifier or give them slightly different names (mummy and mama) but all lesbian parents have to do that. And nobody is particularly concerned in daily life which parent gave birth to them. Certainly not what type of genitals each parent has. Children shouldn't really have anything to do with their parents genitals after conception and birth is done.

In that case, if the actual mother is truly happy for her partner to use a female title, then I suppose it might be a case of what works for them. I suppose the child would need to be told at a later stage that 'Dad' isn't their biological father, just like with all cases of sperm donation, if they are too young yet for it to be obvious to them.

However, as PP says, the vast majority of trans people do not look like the opposite sex at all. Some may refer to them as their appropriated 'gender' and pronouns, but it's done as a twee social nicety, validating their beliefs, rather than from any kind of conviction. It's done with the kindest of intentions, but as we've all seen at length on these forums, it isn't really a kindness to anybody really - not to the deluded person who genuinely thinks that they 'pass' and most certainly not to the women whose rights and protected spaces are taken by biological males.

Then if a trans woman second parent 1. Looked like a woman i.e passed and everyone assumed they were a woman, and 2. The birth mother was also very happy for her partner to be another "mum" and referred as such (no abuse or coercion involved and she is supportive of their gender identity) do you still think the children should have to call that second parent "dad"?

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 05/07/2023 11:32

In the hypothetical situation the trans man looks just like a man and you wouldn't know unless you were told. Trans people who pass obviously do exist.

Maybe a very, very tiny minority. It's often less obvious in (carefully-taken) photos, but when you see a transman in amongst a group of (biological) men, it's almost always blatantly obvious. Possibly less so if it were a group of 13/14yo boys - but the mannerisms and comportment are clearly very different between young teenagers and adults.

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 05/07/2023 11:27

In the hypothetical situation I'm talking about the child has a mum who gave birth, who they would call mum, and the other parent is a trans man. Everyone, including the child, would be confused if the child was calling him mum, because everyone considers him to be a man.
I don't see why it would be different for families with two mums one of whom is a trans woman. Yes they'd have to add a qualifier or give them slightly different names (mummy and mama) but all lesbian parents have to do that. And nobody is particularly concerned in daily life which parent gave birth to them. Certainly not what type of genitals each parent has. Children shouldn't really have anything to do with their parents genitals after conception and birth is done.

In that case, if the actual mother is truly happy for her partner to use a female title, then I suppose it might be a case of what works for them. I suppose the child would need to be told at a later stage that 'Dad' isn't their biological father, just like with all cases of sperm donation, if they are too young yet for it to be obvious to them.

However, as PP says, the vast majority of trans people do not look like the opposite sex at all. Some may refer to them as their appropriated 'gender' and pronouns, but it's done as a twee social nicety, validating their beliefs, rather than from any kind of conviction. It's done with the kindest of intentions, but as we've all seen at length on these forums, it isn't really a kindness to anybody really - not to the deluded person who genuinely thinks that they 'pass' and most certainly not to the women whose rights and protected spaces are taken by biological males.

flaffydaffy · 05/07/2023 11:22

literalviolence · 05/07/2023 11:00

It's not the case that everybody considers a trans man a man at all. Most look just like every other woman. And it's not about genitals ffs. Trans ideologists are the ones obsessed with genitals hence all the surgery. It's about whole bodies and social oppression.

In the hypothetical situation the trans man looks just like a man and you wouldn't know unless you were told. Trans people who pass obviously do exist.

Helleofabore · 05/07/2023 11:17

There is currently a police report out asking for information about a teenaged male who was horrendously sexually assaulted over the weekend. The sketchy report seems that this poor teenager woke up on a floor with head and other body injuries and the attack was described as a sexual assault.

The police report calls the two suspects women, aged between 18-20 years old and uses female pronouns. There is a rough description given.

Are we to look for female teenagers? Will this lead to the public giving useful information?

wutheringkites · 05/07/2023 11:05

@OMG12 yes, I think you're probably right there.

Still, I think being drawn into heated online discussions about specific (ridiculous) scenarios doesn't really help. Why engage with the delusion at all?

I'm not the first gender critical poster on this thread to comment on the antagonistic tone of posters towards them/ each other. This doesn't really help the cause.

literalviolence · 05/07/2023 11:00

flaffydaffy · 05/07/2023 10:56

In the hypothetical situation I'm talking about the child has a mum who gave birth, who they would call mum, and the other parent is a trans man. Everyone, including the child, would be confused if the child was calling him mum, because everyone considers him to be a man.
I don't see why it would be different for families with two mums one of whom is a trans woman. Yes they'd have to add a qualifier or give them slightly different names (mummy and mama) but all lesbian parents have to do that. And nobody is particularly concerned in daily life which parent gave birth to them. Certainly not what type of genitals each parent has. Children shouldn't really have anything to do with their parents genitals after conception and birth is done.

It's not the case that everybody considers a trans man a man at all. Most look just like every other woman. And it's not about genitals ffs. Trans ideologists are the ones obsessed with genitals hence all the surgery. It's about whole bodies and social oppression.