Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Permanently banned for ‘promoting hate’

390 replies

RumAndReisling · 04/07/2023 13:32

Following ten years uneventful membership of a major social media site I have been permanently banned for ‘promoting hate’.

Never again will I be able to participate on that site.

My crime? Saying that if you had given birth to a child, there was no way you could literally change sex and produce semen to father one.

Is this not a statement of fact, or is this now unacceptable to say?

AIBU to say that my husband isn’t able to give birth?

OP posts:
literalviolence · 05/07/2023 21:38

flaffydaffy · 05/07/2023 20:55

I do not think my friend's child is going to be harmed by calling him dad, when he is their dad in every way except genetically, and being told about that latter aspect at some point when they are old enough to understand it. I genuinely can't think of any way in which that would harm the child.

And I'm not segueing into a conversation about "women's spaces" because this conversation is about parenting and we'll be here all night if we go onto a different topic so I'll ignore any more questions about that.

It's not a different topic. It's part of the same topic. If your friend is a 'man' than Eddie Izzard is a woman and women have to accept him and others like him in their spaces.

We can't say that your friend is really a man but that TW aren't really women.

If you can't see that then god help you.

literalviolence · 05/07/2023 21:35

flaffydaffy · 05/07/2023 20:35

Trans people aren't generally forcing you to do anything. I haven't ever spoken to my friend about his trans status and he hadn't asked me to do anything, but still I call him a man and so does everybody. I don't think Eddie Izzard is forceful about what people call her either. I don't know anything about Leah Thomas's attitude but you can't force yourself onto a swim team, they have to let you be in it.

Good god this is ridiculous. Women have been hounded out of their jobs for saying a man in a man. Women are threatened and assaulted because they think TWAW. Women's sports is being eroded because of all the men in women's sports. But none of this seems like attempts to force people to pretend that men are women?

I'd say you do you but please don't because it's dangerous and ignorant.

MistyGreenAndBlue · 05/07/2023 21:06

Conkersinautumn · 04/07/2023 14:12

Gender identity is a protected characteristic. I don't see why you think you spouting conspiracy theories and hate is somehow OK. There are agreed terms of use, review them.

No it isn't. But sex is.

You're thinking of gender reassignment.

And since when is material reality a conspiracy theory? Do you know how stupid you sound?

flaffydaffy · 05/07/2023 20:55

BathroomOnTheRight · 05/07/2023 20:39

It's about teaching a child reality, not lying to them. You don't think lying and misrepresenting a man as a woman can harm a child?

I do not think my friend's child is going to be harmed by calling him dad, when he is their dad in every way except genetically, and being told about that latter aspect at some point when they are old enough to understand it. I genuinely can't think of any way in which that would harm the child.

And I'm not segueing into a conversation about "women's spaces" because this conversation is about parenting and we'll be here all night if we go onto a different topic so I'll ignore any more questions about that.

PonyPatter44 · 05/07/2023 20:44

@flaffydaffy , so why are trans criminals asking to go to women's prisons? OK, they aren't exactly forcing their way in, but there is an expectation that they will be considered for a place, which puts the women alreadylivingin those jails at high risk of assault. And unfortunately transwomen DID force their way into the bathing pond on Hampstead Heath, which meant that orthodox Jewish and Muslim women couldn't swim there any more.

These are two very different groups of women, with vastly different levels of privilege and life experience, but both groups were substantially disadvantaged when transwomen demanded access to their spaces.

BathroomOnTheRight · 05/07/2023 20:40

flaffydaffy · 05/07/2023 20:19

Is it "forcing others to pretend" if others don't actually know that you're trans? If that is the case then why is "reality" of any concern for anyone? If nobody had told me my friend was trans I probably still wouldn't know, and why would I need to know? Whose business is it and why does it matter?

Firstly, 99.999999% of trans people never pass.

Secondly, do we really have to go through this again? Of course it matters if a man is posing as a woman and entering womens spaces. It should matter to everyone!

BathroomOnTheRight · 05/07/2023 20:39

flaffydaffy · 05/07/2023 19:45

I brought up passing because I mistakenly thought there might be some situation where it would be acceptable to you for a child to call their parent by their gendered parent name instead of the parent name corresponds with their biological sex. I was wrong about that so passing isn't relevant after all.

So you think that no matter what the family's preference is and no matter how a person lives their life, their appearance, their legal sex that's on their birth certificate and ID documents, how the child sees their parent, any factors whatsoever, a child has to call their parent dad if that parent was born with a penis and mum if they were born with a vulva. That's incredibly weird but whatever.

It's about teaching a child reality, not lying to them. You don't think lying and misrepresenting a man as a woman can harm a child?

flaffydaffy · 05/07/2023 20:35

literalviolence · 05/07/2023 20:26

People do know most people are trans. Sure it's only pretending if you know the truth but again we're back to the 'most trans people don't pass' reality. We need a rule which applies to all not just to those who can't fool people regarding their sex. Are you agreeing then that when we're told Eddie Izzard, Leah Thomas, as examples, are women that we are being forced to pretend?

Trans people aren't generally forcing you to do anything. I haven't ever spoken to my friend about his trans status and he hadn't asked me to do anything, but still I call him a man and so does everybody. I don't think Eddie Izzard is forceful about what people call her either. I don't know anything about Leah Thomas's attitude but you can't force yourself onto a swim team, they have to let you be in it.

literalviolence · 05/07/2023 20:26

flaffydaffy · 05/07/2023 20:19

Is it "forcing others to pretend" if others don't actually know that you're trans? If that is the case then why is "reality" of any concern for anyone? If nobody had told me my friend was trans I probably still wouldn't know, and why would I need to know? Whose business is it and why does it matter?

People do know most people are trans. Sure it's only pretending if you know the truth but again we're back to the 'most trans people don't pass' reality. We need a rule which applies to all not just to those who can't fool people regarding their sex. Are you agreeing then that when we're told Eddie Izzard, Leah Thomas, as examples, are women that we are being forced to pretend?

flaffydaffy · 05/07/2023 20:19

literalviolence · 05/07/2023 20:06

I'm actually not so bothered about what they call them. In the same way as a person's first name is e.g. Jill but they go by the name Dawn. It doesn't change their legal name. Neither does being called dad make you a man. What I think is that it's highly offensive for any man to call himself a mum and that 'man' is a matter of biology, not identity. Your friend is a woman. I do actually feel sorry for them because an inability to accept reality is a hard thing to live with. That doesn't mean we get to force others to pretend that reality is different. Whether your friend is one of the few who pass is not relevant.

Is it "forcing others to pretend" if others don't actually know that you're trans? If that is the case then why is "reality" of any concern for anyone? If nobody had told me my friend was trans I probably still wouldn't know, and why would I need to know? Whose business is it and why does it matter?

literalviolence · 05/07/2023 20:06

flaffydaffy · 05/07/2023 19:45

I brought up passing because I mistakenly thought there might be some situation where it would be acceptable to you for a child to call their parent by their gendered parent name instead of the parent name corresponds with their biological sex. I was wrong about that so passing isn't relevant after all.

So you think that no matter what the family's preference is and no matter how a person lives their life, their appearance, their legal sex that's on their birth certificate and ID documents, how the child sees their parent, any factors whatsoever, a child has to call their parent dad if that parent was born with a penis and mum if they were born with a vulva. That's incredibly weird but whatever.

I'm actually not so bothered about what they call them. In the same way as a person's first name is e.g. Jill but they go by the name Dawn. It doesn't change their legal name. Neither does being called dad make you a man. What I think is that it's highly offensive for any man to call himself a mum and that 'man' is a matter of biology, not identity. Your friend is a woman. I do actually feel sorry for them because an inability to accept reality is a hard thing to live with. That doesn't mean we get to force others to pretend that reality is different. Whether your friend is one of the few who pass is not relevant.

flaffydaffy · 05/07/2023 19:45

literalviolence · 05/07/2023 19:13

Your friend is a woman and always will be. What definition of man are you using that an xx chromosome person with no DID fits into?

Why did you introduce the concept of passing if you're now saying it's not relevant?

I brought up passing because I mistakenly thought there might be some situation where it would be acceptable to you for a child to call their parent by their gendered parent name instead of the parent name corresponds with their biological sex. I was wrong about that so passing isn't relevant after all.

So you think that no matter what the family's preference is and no matter how a person lives their life, their appearance, their legal sex that's on their birth certificate and ID documents, how the child sees their parent, any factors whatsoever, a child has to call their parent dad if that parent was born with a penis and mum if they were born with a vulva. That's incredibly weird but whatever.

PonyPatter44 · 05/07/2023 19:29

SockGoddess · 05/07/2023 11:42

not just the blanket “but they are menz and I might get raped”**

what’s wrong with this? It’s true and it’s the reason separate spaces for women exist - along with the increased risk of murder, assault, harassment, intimidation, leering, flashing etc. it literally is the reason - alongside privacy and religious beliefs etc, but it’s the most important reason.

when we’re talking about women’s safety generally, aside from the trans issue, everyone understands this. Protection for women in the form of singe sex toilets, hospital wards, prisons etc is there to save women from the vastly higher likelihood of being raped and similar, if men are there.

add to that that we know trans-identifying men are MORE likely to be sex offenders than the average man. That doesn’t mean they all are, of course not. It means more of them are than the background level of men who are not allowed into women’s spaces.

that’s not surprising at all when self-Id policies mean any man can say he’s a woman and get access to women’s spaces. Who wants that? Sex offenders. And saying you’re a woman gets male offenders access to women’s prisons. Who wants that - sex offenders. And we know many TW, even if they are not deliberately lying just to get access, have a fetish about being in women’s spaces and find it a turn-on - many openly say so themselves.

so the reason for women’s safe single-sex spaces becomes even more pressing when it’s TW we don’t want there, not less. And that reason is sexual assault and flashing (and btw flashing is known typical precursor to more serious sex crimes).

Brilliant post, Sock. I agree with every word.

literalviolence · 05/07/2023 19:13

flaffydaffy · 05/07/2023 18:24

I'm fine with anything! I did say the family's choice is the important factor. It's none of my business what anyone decides their children should call them, or how they refer to themselves. If my friend WANTED to be called mum, for whatever reason, he could do that if he wanted and I wouldn't say anything against it. But obviously he doesn't want to because he's a man for all intents and purposes other than literally the fact that he doesn't produce sperm and doesn't (presumably, I haven't asked or looked) have a penis. Neither of which is any of the child's concern other than to tell them when they're older that they were born from somebody else's sperm. That's it. So he's a dad.

Your friend is a woman and always will be. What definition of man are you using that an xx chromosome person with no DID fits into?

Why did you introduce the concept of passing if you're now saying it's not relevant?

flaffydaffy · 05/07/2023 18:24

literalviolence · 05/07/2023 18:06

Because your friend is a woman. That's why.

Anyway in terms of your argument appears to have moved from 'a person who looks like a man should be called dad' to 'it's their choice'. So you think it's fine for someone who looks like a man to be called mum? So the looking like a man is irrelevant? So your friend could become comfortable with their sex and be called mum?

I'm just trying to follow the point you're making. You seem to now be saying you're OK with people choosing to call themselves either mum or dad. Personal.preference is all that matters?

I'm fine with anything! I did say the family's choice is the important factor. It's none of my business what anyone decides their children should call them, or how they refer to themselves. If my friend WANTED to be called mum, for whatever reason, he could do that if he wanted and I wouldn't say anything against it. But obviously he doesn't want to because he's a man for all intents and purposes other than literally the fact that he doesn't produce sperm and doesn't (presumably, I haven't asked or looked) have a penis. Neither of which is any of the child's concern other than to tell them when they're older that they were born from somebody else's sperm. That's it. So he's a dad.

literalviolence · 05/07/2023 18:09

flaffydaffy · 05/07/2023 17:58

I said literally nothing whatsoever about women's spaces and I haven't said a single thing on this thread about women's spaces so no, I'm not saying that.

There is a tall woman in the picture but you can only see how tall she is in comparison to the other people in the picture so I don't know her height. I'm assuming this is the person in the picture who is trans, because of the height. If indeed there is a trans person in the picture and you're not just tricking me.

Also, bit weird this thread just descended into "here's a picture of a trans person let's judge their appearance"

You talked about passing and said that was relevant in how people are treated. You bought it up as a factor which was important in relation to your friend. A person's appearance is not being judged. Their sex is being recognised.

GrinAndVomit · 05/07/2023 18:08

flaffydaffy · 05/07/2023 17:58

I said literally nothing whatsoever about women's spaces and I haven't said a single thing on this thread about women's spaces so no, I'm not saying that.

There is a tall woman in the picture but you can only see how tall she is in comparison to the other people in the picture so I don't know her height. I'm assuming this is the person in the picture who is trans, because of the height. If indeed there is a trans person in the picture and you're not just tricking me.

Also, bit weird this thread just descended into "here's a picture of a trans person let's judge their appearance"

But, ultimately, women’s spaces and language is what this whole debate is about.
If we’re forced to call trans women women, and pretend we can’t see that they’re male, then there’s no hope or possible protection of women’s spaces.

literalviolence · 05/07/2023 18:06

flaffydaffy · 05/07/2023 15:50

Obviously the choice of the family is the most important factor, I thought that went without saying. A butch lesbian mother probably wouldn't choose to be called dad. My friend could, if he wanted, choose to be called mum, but he wouldn't want to do that since everyone sees him as a man and he isn't necessarily "out" publically as a trans person. So if his kid was calling him mum everyone would ask why. Presumably that's a conversation they'll have with the child when they're older. But in that circumstance why would the parents choose the word mum for him?

Because your friend is a woman. That's why.

Anyway in terms of your argument appears to have moved from 'a person who looks like a man should be called dad' to 'it's their choice'. So you think it's fine for someone who looks like a man to be called mum? So the looking like a man is irrelevant? So your friend could become comfortable with their sex and be called mum?

I'm just trying to follow the point you're making. You seem to now be saying you're OK with people choosing to call themselves either mum or dad. Personal.preference is all that matters?

flaffydaffy · 05/07/2023 17:58

GrinAndVomit · 05/07/2023 17:24

So you’re saying that trans women, who are clearly seen to be male, can be excluded from women’s spaces?
We’ve just got to allow the ones who pass 100% of the time in?

I said literally nothing whatsoever about women's spaces and I haven't said a single thing on this thread about women's spaces so no, I'm not saying that.

There is a tall woman in the picture but you can only see how tall she is in comparison to the other people in the picture so I don't know her height. I'm assuming this is the person in the picture who is trans, because of the height. If indeed there is a trans person in the picture and you're not just tricking me.

Also, bit weird this thread just descended into "here's a picture of a trans person let's judge their appearance"

BathroomOnTheRight · 05/07/2023 17:41

Women are hard-wired to tell a male person at 100 paces or more. It's inbuilt in us from caveman era for our survival. To suggest women can't tell a man from a woman (tell signs include height, gait, arm/limb length, hand size, head size, jaw, voice etc) is just gaslighting nonsense.

GrinAndVomit · 05/07/2023 17:24

flaffydaffy · 05/07/2023 16:57

Presumably at least one person in the picture is trans otherwise you wouldn't have posted it. It's not always easy to tell if you haven't been given some kind of contextual rip-off.

So you’re saying that trans women, who are clearly seen to be male, can be excluded from women’s spaces?
We’ve just got to allow the ones who pass 100% of the time in?

JudgeAnderson · 05/07/2023 17:02

Oh come on. You have eyes.

flaffydaffy · 05/07/2023 16:57

Tip off not rip off.

flaffydaffy · 05/07/2023 16:57

CliantheLang · 05/07/2023 16:25

Transitioned female people could be said to 'pass' better due to the irreversible side effects of testosterone.

Except... you can guess which one of these three is a man.

Presumably at least one person in the picture is trans otherwise you wouldn't have posted it. It's not always easy to tell if you haven't been given some kind of contextual rip-off.

CliantheLang · 05/07/2023 16:25

Transitioned female people could be said to 'pass' better due to the irreversible side effects of testosterone.

Except... you can guess which one of these three is a man.

Sensitive content
Permanently banned for ‘promoting hate’