Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Permanently banned for ‘promoting hate’

390 replies

RumAndReisling · 04/07/2023 13:32

Following ten years uneventful membership of a major social media site I have been permanently banned for ‘promoting hate’.

Never again will I be able to participate on that site.

My crime? Saying that if you had given birth to a child, there was no way you could literally change sex and produce semen to father one.

Is this not a statement of fact, or is this now unacceptable to say?

AIBU to say that my husband isn’t able to give birth?

OP posts:
flaffydaffy · 06/07/2023 08:14

GrinAndVomit · 06/07/2023 08:11

We can’t have laws if we don’t have clear definitions.
We can’t have child protection laws if we can’t define a child.
We can’t protect women if we can’t define what a woman is.

If you are part of a movement that seeks to obfuscate the definition of words which are the foundation of laws to protect vulnerable people, you’re going to be responsible for any person who consequently suffers from this lack of protection.

Yeah that's right we can't, and I'm not the person who writes definitions for lawmakers am I.

I'm not "part of a movement" I'm just arguing with people on Mumsnet.

AmuseBish · 06/07/2023 08:12

When you say 'someone seems like a man' you must have a "thing" in mind that you are mentally comparing them to, to know that they are either like that thing or not like it.

If that "thing" is a generic male person that's very different from the "thing" being a female who looks like Kylie Jenner but is wearing a "i love kickboxing" badge. And different again from a can of spaghetti.

flaffydaffy · 06/07/2023 08:12

AmuseBish · 06/07/2023 08:08

I'm just using the word to try to express what I mean.

Well, you have said you don't know what you mean, so you can't believe you are expressing it?
At least you're open about using words and not knowing what they mean!

Please define for me the following words without pulling a definition from a dictionary:
Well
Have
Know
Believe
Expressing
Open
Not
About
Mean
Words
What
They

If you're not able to do this I'll disregard your post because you obviously don't know what you mean.

GrinAndVomit · 06/07/2023 08:11

flaffydaffy · 06/07/2023 07:29

First off, it wasn't an attempt at a definition. I don't have a definition of "man". People don't usually define words unless they're required to for an essay or because it's their job or because someone demands they do so in a debate. And to define a word takes a huge amount of careful thought. I don't go about the world with a definition of "man" in my head. When I said a man is a person who seems like a man, I meant that if I see someone who seems to me like they are man (for whatever reason, including subconscious cues) then I'll think they're a man and put them in the "man" category in my head. If I received further information about the person that changed what category I thought of them as, then it would change. That's it. It's not a definition, it's just the way language works in practice.

@literalviolence can I say you're not a genuine poster now, because I said a whole paragraph to you and you only engaged with the final point and ignored the rest?

We can’t have laws if we don’t have clear definitions.
We can’t have child protection laws if we can’t define a child.
We can’t protect women if we can’t define what a woman is.

If you are part of a movement that seeks to obfuscate the definition of words which are the foundation of laws to protect vulnerable people, you’re going to be responsible for any person who consequently suffers from this lack of protection.

flaffydaffy · 06/07/2023 08:09

Whatwouldscullydo · 06/07/2023 08:04

But we are adults. Not children. We can read . We have the benefit of life experience.

How do you tell if someone is a man or a can of spaghetti if we haven't learnt what words mean

So if you categorise humans in your head what definition are you using.

You encounter things in your life and you're told what they are and that's how you learn to speak. Adults continue using language based on that knowledge, not because they've read the dictionary. If my child asks me what a word means, usually the best way to explain is to give them some examples of things that are that.

AmuseBish · 06/07/2023 08:08

I'm just using the word to try to express what I mean.

Well, you have said you don't know what you mean, so you can't believe you are expressing it?
At least you're open about using words and not knowing what they mean!

Whatwouldscullydo · 06/07/2023 08:04

But we are adults. Not children. We can read . We have the benefit of life experience.

How do you tell if someone is a man or a can of spaghetti if we haven't learnt what words mean

So if you categorise humans in your head what definition are you using.

flaffydaffy · 06/07/2023 08:04

AmuseBish · 06/07/2023 07:51

It's hard to follow your posts flaff but I think it's because you see "man" and "male" as essentially the same thing so you use them interchangeably, forgetting that we don't know what you actually mean by "man"!

You do understand why laws, policies, medicine, etc need to have a clear definition of what a man is though, right?

If it kept changing from "male" to "person of either sex who has a red car" to "person that has big hands" to "person that is a natural leader" to "person who is tough and aggressive" we'd have real problems.

For instance, how would you suggest writing a policy that kept men out of spaces but allowed transwomen? What do you believe actually makes someone a woman or man, and would you really change that based on what anyone you met tells you? A definition that is not consistent makes the word utterly meaningless.

Maybe sometimes when I've used the word man on this thread I've specifically meant male and other times I haven't? I don't remember. I'm just using the word to try to express what I mean. I don't consciously define every word as I write it. Nobody does that.

Yes sometimes policymakers need definitions of words, that's not my job. I'm glad it's not my job because it's hard. That's why I'm not providing you with definitions here because I don't routinely define things.

flaffydaffy · 06/07/2023 08:00

Whatwouldscullydo · 06/07/2023 07:47

And to define a word takes a huge amount of careful thought. I don't go about the world with a definition of "man" in my head. When I said a man is a person who seems like a man, I meant that if I see someone who seems to me like they are man (for whatever reason, including subconscious cues) then I'll think they're a man and put them in the "man" category in my head

So you have a definition then. Because you cant put someone in a category you say you have no definition for.

You can't identify as something you can't define.it needs a definition or the whole thing is meaningless.

Man- adult human male. Its three words. Its not complex at all.

So how when you dont know what a definition, can u use a word?

It's a subconscious definition, I haven't got a verbalised one that I use. My brain thinks someone is a man. I don't go over in my head the definition of a man. I've never attempted to define "man" until today. People don't learn language by definitions. Children start to use words without ever defining them. You know this.

AmuseBish · 06/07/2023 07:51

It's hard to follow your posts flaff but I think it's because you see "man" and "male" as essentially the same thing so you use them interchangeably, forgetting that we don't know what you actually mean by "man"!

You do understand why laws, policies, medicine, etc need to have a clear definition of what a man is though, right?

If it kept changing from "male" to "person of either sex who has a red car" to "person that has big hands" to "person that is a natural leader" to "person who is tough and aggressive" we'd have real problems.

For instance, how would you suggest writing a policy that kept men out of spaces but allowed transwomen? What do you believe actually makes someone a woman or man, and would you really change that based on what anyone you met tells you? A definition that is not consistent makes the word utterly meaningless.

Whatwouldscullydo · 06/07/2023 07:47

And to define a word takes a huge amount of careful thought. I don't go about the world with a definition of "man" in my head. When I said a man is a person who seems like a man, I meant that if I see someone who seems to me like they are man (for whatever reason, including subconscious cues) then I'll think they're a man and put them in the "man" category in my head

So you have a definition then. Because you cant put someone in a category you say you have no definition for.

You can't identify as something you can't define.it needs a definition or the whole thing is meaningless.

Man- adult human male. Its three words. Its not complex at all.

So how when you dont know what a definition, can u use a word?

flaffydaffy · 06/07/2023 07:31

AmuseBish · 06/07/2023 07:10

Look, it seems like you're defining "man" by 'having a male body or appearing to be male, due to deliberate actions to change one's appearance'. Would you say that is fair, flaffy?

If you thought it was a feeling or inner sense there would be no concept of "passing" by appearance.

If so, I think we are mostly in agreement on the latter point at least.

Basically you use 'trans' to mean wanting to be the opposite sex, right?

My initial assessment of whether someone is a man or a woman would be based on appearance yes. Then if they or someone else told me something else then my assessment might change based on that.

flaffydaffy · 06/07/2023 07:29

GrinAndVomit · 06/07/2023 06:25

a man is someone who seems like they're a man.
Again, you’re basing someone’s gender on how well they “pass” and what the general public think of them.

How does this square with women who wear jeans, t-shirts and have short hair? Does this make her a man because she “seems” to favour wearing more stereotypical masculine clothing?

You’re saying that we have to define who are men and who are women on sexist, regressive stereotypes but what about people who don’t fit these stereotypes?

First off, it wasn't an attempt at a definition. I don't have a definition of "man". People don't usually define words unless they're required to for an essay or because it's their job or because someone demands they do so in a debate. And to define a word takes a huge amount of careful thought. I don't go about the world with a definition of "man" in my head. When I said a man is a person who seems like a man, I meant that if I see someone who seems to me like they are man (for whatever reason, including subconscious cues) then I'll think they're a man and put them in the "man" category in my head. If I received further information about the person that changed what category I thought of them as, then it would change. That's it. It's not a definition, it's just the way language works in practice.

@literalviolence can I say you're not a genuine poster now, because I said a whole paragraph to you and you only engaged with the final point and ignored the rest?

AmuseBish · 06/07/2023 07:10

Look, it seems like you're defining "man" by 'having a male body or appearing to be male, due to deliberate actions to change one's appearance'. Would you say that is fair, flaffy?

If you thought it was a feeling or inner sense there would be no concept of "passing" by appearance.

If so, I think we are mostly in agreement on the latter point at least.

Basically you use 'trans' to mean wanting to be the opposite sex, right?

literalviolence · 06/07/2023 06:51

flaffydaffy · 06/07/2023 00:06

I think you're projecting everything you don't like about "TRAs" onto me. I've been involved in conversations about trans issues on a few Mumsnet threads, I'm not an activist and I don't use specific tactics. In my own neck of the woods I'm just a normal person who supports trans people, like everybody I know. I've never met an openly gender critical person in real life so it seems like a bit of a chronically online thing to me, and I'm mystified by it. I'm not heavily involved in discussions like this normally though so please believe me that I don't bring up things like genitals because it's a tactic that I follow. And it's unfair of you to demand I debate certain topics with you and say I'm not a genuine poster if I don't. And ask me for definitions of words for no reason.

It's not no reason though is it? It's a vital reason. You are promoting a world view which is hateful to women and anti women's equality. If you can't define a core issue which supports your anti women stand perhaps you need to look at your thinking and move to a more equality supporting place.

GrinAndVomit · 06/07/2023 06:25

flaffydaffy · 05/07/2023 23:11

@literalviolence you seriously want to continue this? I thought our conversation ended gracefully. Alright here we go:

I asked you what your definition of a man is. You didn't answer.
I don't recall being asked that. And I don't have a definition of "man" for you. You don't learn what a man is through being told the definition. A man is someone who seems like they're a man.

You think this is not connected with conversations about protected spaces for women.
It comes under the same very wide topic umbrella but we were talking about parenting and you tried to move the conversation on to women's spaces which is not the same topic even though they are both trans related issues.

You introduced the silly idea of 'obsessed by genitals' which is a TRA strategy to deflect from actual conversation
I didn't say obsessed by genitals. I did say the only thing that would make my friend not a man is his genitals, because it's true.

You went round in circles with confused talk about whether someone passed
I brought it up because I thought it was relevant and it turned out not to be.

You made up definitions of 'forced' in order not to engage in the content of a point
I didn't define "forced".

You're not engaging with the point that if your friend is a man then anyone who says their a woman is a woman - and that is a problem.
I don't have a problem with considering trans women to be women.

You're not engaging at all. You're fluffy, deflecting.
I am engaging with you except with my refusal to enter a conversation about women's spaces.

Absolutely none of these things show that I'm not a genuine poster. Some of them show I didn't respond to every single one of your points. It's fine if you think I have imperfect debating technique but that doesn't make me not genuine.

a man is someone who seems like they're a man.
Again, you’re basing someone’s gender on how well they “pass” and what the general public think of them.

How does this square with women who wear jeans, t-shirts and have short hair? Does this make her a man because she “seems” to favour wearing more stereotypical masculine clothing?

You’re saying that we have to define who are men and who are women on sexist, regressive stereotypes but what about people who don’t fit these stereotypes?

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 06/07/2023 00:30

Then if a trans woman second parent 1. Looked like a woman i.e passed and everyone assumed they were a woman, and 2. The birth mother was also very happy for her partner to be another "mum" and referred as such (no abuse or coercion involved and she is supportive of their gender identity) do you still think the children should have to call that second parent "dad"?

I realise that this is all hypothetical, but would the transwoman happen to be the biological father of the child too?

Transitioned female people could be said to 'pass' better due to the irreversible side effects of testosterone.

They invariably grow beards - which is unusual in itself as a large proportion of biological men are clean-shaven - and wear stereotypically 'masculine' clothes (or at the very least 'neutral' ones); but it's their height and slight build that almost always prevents them from 'passing'.

Mothers of sons usually notice the point at which their sons grow taller and bigger than them, and this is usually well before they are actually adults.

I'm not convinced that even most very tall transmen would necessarily pass as actual men, as very few tall women also have the wide frames that a man of that height usually would.

flaffydaffy · 06/07/2023 00:06

literalviolence · 05/07/2023 23:45

You haven't been conversing gracefully at any point in time.

Definition of man - I clearly asked you. You still haven't answered. 'A man is anyone who seems like a man' is not a definition. It doesn't explain or clarify. It's circular and silly. Feel free to give an actual definition.

Same topic? Of course it is. Their interlinked and can't be fully separated. Wide umbrella or not, refusing to engage in discussions about the wider impact is not going to help a conversation.

Genitals? You said this "Certainly not what type of genitals each parent has" very early on in the exchange. You introduced the concept of genitals in a way which is very reminiscent of the TRA tactic. It's not true that this is eveything which makes your friend a woman. Your friend is a woman to their core. They have women's DNA which impacts every single cell of their body. It's not just their absence of a penis which is relevant.

Forced - you effectively made up a definition of forced in order to pretend that trans people are not trying to force women to pretend that TW are actual women.

I'm glad that you have now answered the question about whether TW who absolutely do not pass are women and should be allowed into women's spaces. I'm sorry though that you have so little regard for women's safety and needs that you feel that it's OK to make all women's spaces mixed sex. It is better to be open about your bigotry though so thanks for that. Personally I think it's disgusting to support the obliteration of women's sports and the locking up of fully intact men in women's prisons. I don't know how you live with yourself.

I think you're projecting everything you don't like about "TRAs" onto me. I've been involved in conversations about trans issues on a few Mumsnet threads, I'm not an activist and I don't use specific tactics. In my own neck of the woods I'm just a normal person who supports trans people, like everybody I know. I've never met an openly gender critical person in real life so it seems like a bit of a chronically online thing to me, and I'm mystified by it. I'm not heavily involved in discussions like this normally though so please believe me that I don't bring up things like genitals because it's a tactic that I follow. And it's unfair of you to demand I debate certain topics with you and say I'm not a genuine poster if I don't. And ask me for definitions of words for no reason.

JudgeJ · 06/07/2023 00:01

Meeting · 04/07/2023 13:50

Honestly, do you even want to be on a site that's so against people speaking true statements?

Exactly! Groucho Marx, 'I refuse to join any club that would have me as a member', it applies to so many groups now, they all seem to require total committment to their point of view, a cross between Stalin and Hitler,

literalviolence · 05/07/2023 23:45

flaffydaffy · 05/07/2023 23:11

@literalviolence you seriously want to continue this? I thought our conversation ended gracefully. Alright here we go:

I asked you what your definition of a man is. You didn't answer.
I don't recall being asked that. And I don't have a definition of "man" for you. You don't learn what a man is through being told the definition. A man is someone who seems like they're a man.

You think this is not connected with conversations about protected spaces for women.
It comes under the same very wide topic umbrella but we were talking about parenting and you tried to move the conversation on to women's spaces which is not the same topic even though they are both trans related issues.

You introduced the silly idea of 'obsessed by genitals' which is a TRA strategy to deflect from actual conversation
I didn't say obsessed by genitals. I did say the only thing that would make my friend not a man is his genitals, because it's true.

You went round in circles with confused talk about whether someone passed
I brought it up because I thought it was relevant and it turned out not to be.

You made up definitions of 'forced' in order not to engage in the content of a point
I didn't define "forced".

You're not engaging with the point that if your friend is a man then anyone who says their a woman is a woman - and that is a problem.
I don't have a problem with considering trans women to be women.

You're not engaging at all. You're fluffy, deflecting.
I am engaging with you except with my refusal to enter a conversation about women's spaces.

Absolutely none of these things show that I'm not a genuine poster. Some of them show I didn't respond to every single one of your points. It's fine if you think I have imperfect debating technique but that doesn't make me not genuine.

You haven't been conversing gracefully at any point in time.

Definition of man - I clearly asked you. You still haven't answered. 'A man is anyone who seems like a man' is not a definition. It doesn't explain or clarify. It's circular and silly. Feel free to give an actual definition.

Same topic? Of course it is. Their interlinked and can't be fully separated. Wide umbrella or not, refusing to engage in discussions about the wider impact is not going to help a conversation.

Genitals? You said this "Certainly not what type of genitals each parent has" very early on in the exchange. You introduced the concept of genitals in a way which is very reminiscent of the TRA tactic. It's not true that this is eveything which makes your friend a woman. Your friend is a woman to their core. They have women's DNA which impacts every single cell of their body. It's not just their absence of a penis which is relevant.

Forced - you effectively made up a definition of forced in order to pretend that trans people are not trying to force women to pretend that TW are actual women.

I'm glad that you have now answered the question about whether TW who absolutely do not pass are women and should be allowed into women's spaces. I'm sorry though that you have so little regard for women's safety and needs that you feel that it's OK to make all women's spaces mixed sex. It is better to be open about your bigotry though so thanks for that. Personally I think it's disgusting to support the obliteration of women's sports and the locking up of fully intact men in women's prisons. I don't know how you live with yourself.

flaffydaffy · 05/07/2023 23:11

@literalviolence you seriously want to continue this? I thought our conversation ended gracefully. Alright here we go:

I asked you what your definition of a man is. You didn't answer.
I don't recall being asked that. And I don't have a definition of "man" for you. You don't learn what a man is through being told the definition. A man is someone who seems like they're a man.

You think this is not connected with conversations about protected spaces for women.
It comes under the same very wide topic umbrella but we were talking about parenting and you tried to move the conversation on to women's spaces which is not the same topic even though they are both trans related issues.

You introduced the silly idea of 'obsessed by genitals' which is a TRA strategy to deflect from actual conversation
I didn't say obsessed by genitals. I did say the only thing that would make my friend not a man is his genitals, because it's true.

You went round in circles with confused talk about whether someone passed
I brought it up because I thought it was relevant and it turned out not to be.

You made up definitions of 'forced' in order not to engage in the content of a point
I didn't define "forced".

You're not engaging with the point that if your friend is a man then anyone who says their a woman is a woman - and that is a problem.
I don't have a problem with considering trans women to be women.

You're not engaging at all. You're fluffy, deflecting.
I am engaging with you except with my refusal to enter a conversation about women's spaces.

Absolutely none of these things show that I'm not a genuine poster. Some of them show I didn't respond to every single one of your points. It's fine if you think I have imperfect debating technique but that doesn't make me not genuine.

literalviolence · 05/07/2023 22:54

flaffydaffy · 05/07/2023 22:08

Oh come on, that was the first ridiculous or piss-takey thing I've said in this whole discussion. You can't say I'm not a genuine poster just because we disagree. Obviously we have nothing more to say to each other though if you think it's perfectly fine to be an utter arsehole to a friend who is trans in the way I've described. Goodnight!

You think that's the first ridiculous thing you've said? Really? Really????!!!!

You're going round in circles and refusing to answer questions.

I asked you what your definition of a man is. You didn't answer.

You think this is not connected with conversations about protected spaces for women.

You introduced the silly idea of 'obsessed by genitals' which is a TRA strategy to deflect from actual conversation

You went round in circles with confused talk about whether someone passed

You made up definitions of 'forced' in order not to engage in the content of a point

You're not engaging with the point that if your friend is a man then anyone who says their a woman is a woman - and that is a problem.

You're not engaging at all. You're fluffy, deflecting.

Entry level DARVO. You have nothing to add here.

flaffydaffy · 05/07/2023 22:08

literalviolence · 05/07/2023 21:53

I'm not engaging with you any more. I don't think you are a genuine poster but if you are, you're either not able to, or don't want to, think things through.

Personally I think what you're suggesting is an awful lot better than a man calling himself a woman or Eddie Izzard being in my hospital ward.

Oh come on, that was the first ridiculous or piss-takey thing I've said in this whole discussion. You can't say I'm not a genuine poster just because we disagree. Obviously we have nothing more to say to each other though if you think it's perfectly fine to be an utter arsehole to a friend who is trans in the way I've described. Goodnight!

literalviolence · 05/07/2023 21:53

flaffydaffy · 05/07/2023 21:51

Next time I see my friend, I'll start referring to him as 'she' in front of everyone. And when I hold his baby I'll say "here you are, back to Mummy" when I hand them back. And if anyone questions me or gives me a funny look I'll say that I have to reflect biological reality in my speech from now on, because otherwise I might have to go to the toilet with Eddie Izzard. Someone on Mumsnet told me and I found it very convincing.

I'm not engaging with you any more. I don't think you are a genuine poster but if you are, you're either not able to, or don't want to, think things through.

Personally I think what you're suggesting is an awful lot better than a man calling himself a woman or Eddie Izzard being in my hospital ward.

flaffydaffy · 05/07/2023 21:51

literalviolence · 05/07/2023 21:38

It's not a different topic. It's part of the same topic. If your friend is a 'man' than Eddie Izzard is a woman and women have to accept him and others like him in their spaces.

We can't say that your friend is really a man but that TW aren't really women.

If you can't see that then god help you.

Next time I see my friend, I'll start referring to him as 'she' in front of everyone. And when I hold his baby I'll say "here you are, back to Mummy" when I hand them back. And if anyone questions me or gives me a funny look I'll say that I have to reflect biological reality in my speech from now on, because otherwise I might have to go to the toilet with Eddie Izzard. Someone on Mumsnet told me and I found it very convincing.