Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Permanently banned for ‘promoting hate’

390 replies

RumAndReisling · 04/07/2023 13:32

Following ten years uneventful membership of a major social media site I have been permanently banned for ‘promoting hate’.

Never again will I be able to participate on that site.

My crime? Saying that if you had given birth to a child, there was no way you could literally change sex and produce semen to father one.

Is this not a statement of fact, or is this now unacceptable to say?

AIBU to say that my husband isn’t able to give birth?

OP posts:
RumAndReisling · 04/07/2023 15:32

wutheringkites · 04/07/2023 15:29

@GrinAndVomit

And calling someone a TRA for questioning the scientific validity of op's statement is abysmal

Is it scientifically invalid that only female people can give birth, and only male
people produce semen?

is it scientifically invalid that you can give birth, then go on to produce semen and father a baby?

Is there any evidence to contest these statements?

OP posts:
RachelNoire · 04/07/2023 15:32

ASGIRC · 04/07/2023 15:22

I literally read those exact comparisons on a post about a transwoman who posted a photo of her with a baby to the breast.

About 10 posts equated it to pedophilia.
Thats pretty hateful, if you ask me.

If you’re talking about the one trending on Twitter lately, if you read the facts rather than shouting “transphobia” at any opportunity, you’ll see that there is MAJOR concern over a man, however they choose to identify in their own head, indulging in their fetish over the needs of a helpless baby which is what is commonly known and recognised as CHILD ABUSE.

Or do you think men can breastfeed a baby and give them the nutrients and comfort they need?

TheLadyofShalott1 · 04/07/2023 15:32

araiwa · 04/07/2023 13:45

You broke their rules, you can't use their site any more

was it worth it?

Well I could have easily said the same thing and I wouldn't have realised that I had broken any rules!

I wonder if it actually says in the rules that you are not allowed to state biological facts?

@RumAndReisling I am very sorry that you have had this experience, but thanks for the warning. I have every - probably naively - hope that your ban won't last long, as surely they must come to their senses soon... 💐🥂

SockGoddess · 04/07/2023 15:32

There’s no evidence that anyone has ever been able to produce both sperm and eggs that can function and give rise to a baby. There is no evidence anyone has ever changed from being able to produce viable sperm to being able to produce viable eggs, whether by taking hormones or spontaneously.

so I can’t see that what you said is wrong or hateful. All I can think is that now in some circles/institutions it’s seen as hateful to discuss something that might upset a trans person, even if it’s the truth. However, if this doesnt apply to other groups (if it seems to be ok to say you don’t believe in god, or slag off white people or “cis” people, for example) then discrimination is being practised isn’t it? Other protected groups are not being given the same power to cancel people on the basis of being offended as trans people are.

GrinAndVomit · 04/07/2023 15:31

wutheringkites · 04/07/2023 15:27

And I was asking that if that wasn’t the case; why did only some of us give birth?

@GrinAndVomit

Is this statement true for all biological women?

By “some of us” Op is referring to some humans, but only the female ones.
Again, you’re confusing the words “all” and “only”. The basic biological function of female humans is to gestate and give birth. Only females do this.
Not all females do this.

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 04/07/2023 15:31

Createausername1970 · 04/07/2023 13:51

I am actually unfamiliar with what happens when you have "a sex change" operation. I was under the impression if you went from female to male, you would have an appendage you didn't have before, and if you went from male to female you would have a cavity you didn't have before. Beyond that, I am not sure what happens.

But my assume is that actually being able to produce an egg if you were born with a penis or produce sperm if you weren't born with one is not possible as you don't have all the inside bits transplanted.

So on the basis of my limited understanding, I can't see what is wrong with what you said. I would have called it a fact too.

I am sorry you have been banned from elsewhere. That must be upsetting.

Hardly anybody with a trans identity has genital surgery, which is a good thing because there's a high risk of infection, very poor outcomes and lots of complications to do with incontinence and loss of sexual function. And that's just surgeons trying to make that part of the body into a crude facsimile of the genitals of the opposite sex. It's completely impossible to make a male body function like a female body, or vice versa, even for sexual purposes, never mind for reproduction. Women's bodies are incredibly complex and every part of the body is involved in pregnancy. Activists sometimes seem to think it would be possible for a male person to have a womb implanted and some kind of hormone cocktail administered and bingo, they could have IVF and go through a pregnancy. No, they couldn't, as there's far more to it than having a womb and not having high levels of testosterone.

My personal view is that medical science shouldn't be wasting time and resources on even contemplating these procedures. We have so many real medical problems that need improved understanding and treatments and aren't a priority, and I'd like scientists and HCPs to focus on those. I'm thinking of conditions like endometriosis, painful periods, menopause problems, improving care for women through pregnancy, childbirth and breastfeeding. Psychological issues need psychological treatments, not surgery.

Pandabear33 · 04/07/2023 15:31

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Cymbal · 04/07/2023 15:30

ASGIRC · 04/07/2023 15:22

I literally read those exact comparisons on a post about a transwoman who posted a photo of her with a baby to the breast.

About 10 posts equated it to pedophilia.
Thats pretty hateful, if you ask me.

There's no mechanism by which a man can nourish a child from his chest.

The baby does not benefit from suckling from a man

TeenDivided · 04/07/2023 15:29

wutheringkites · 04/07/2023 15:27

And I was asking that if that wasn’t the case; why did only some of us give birth?

@GrinAndVomit

Is this statement true for all biological women?

Oh come on.

The group of people who give birth is a subset of the 'set of women' which is entirely separate from the 'set of men'. The OP's wording was fine.

Clymene · 04/07/2023 15:29

KentuckyFriedChicken83 · 04/07/2023 15:25

@loislovesstewie My first husband was male on the outside but was found to have ovaries and a uterus.

A 1 in 20,000 case of a 46, XX DSD. Still not able to produce sperm and give birth to a child.

TinaTeaspoons · 04/07/2023 15:29

trans woman I meant

wutheringkites · 04/07/2023 15:29

@GrinAndVomit

And calling someone a TRA for questioning the scientific validity of op's statement is abysmal

TinaTeaspoons · 04/07/2023 15:28

It's scary how things are going right now.
I commented saying how disgusting it was, the photo of the trans guy breastfeeding and was called a bigot.
Its actually insane right now and I fear we are heading towards a society where paedophilia is accepted. Truly terrifying.

GrinAndVomit · 04/07/2023 15:28

ASGIRC · 04/07/2023 15:22

I literally read those exact comparisons on a post about a transwoman who posted a photo of her with a baby to the breast.

About 10 posts equated it to pedophilia.
Thats pretty hateful, if you ask me.

A man getting his baby to suck his nipples for his own gratification is child abuse.

A man wearing a dress and wanting to call himself Mary is not.

wutheringkites · 04/07/2023 15:27

And I was asking that if that wasn’t the case; why did only some of us give birth?

@GrinAndVomit

Is this statement true for all biological women?

Arewehumanorarewecupboards · 04/07/2023 15:27

They are going to have to rewrite a whole lot of textbooks!

Iamgoingtohell · 04/07/2023 15:26

araiwa · 04/07/2023 14:44

On their website, it is

I'm not saying I agree with their position, but they make it very clear what will happen if you break their rules

I’d love to know the website that bans stating facts

GrinAndVomit · 04/07/2023 15:26

wutheringkites · 04/07/2023 15:20

@GrinAndVomit

Look, I get that you are trying to support a op here. In case you missed what I've told you twice, I am gender critical. But op's second post is wrong - women are not simply defined by their ability to give birth.

Do I think men can give birth? No.
Do I believe that biological sex can be changed? No
Do I think the definition of 'woman' should be based on feelings rather than biology? No.

But for a group of posters so obsessed with science, accuracy about definitions should matter, even if being made by someone on your side.

Gestating and giving birth is the basic biological function of the female species.

KentuckyFriedChicken83 · 04/07/2023 15:25

@loislovesstewie My first husband was male on the outside but was found to have ovaries and a uterus.

HaveYouHeardOfARoadAtlas · 04/07/2023 15:24

araiwa · 04/07/2023 13:54

What I think doesn't matter

Unless you've been living in a cave for last ten years, everyone should know the risk of comments like that on Facebook, Reddit etc

I thought being gender critical was protected by law?

MorganFreewoman · 04/07/2023 15:22

Testina · 04/07/2023 13:51

Context is all.

What context is needed? It’s a biological fact that if you were born female you will never be able to produce sperm.

ASGIRC · 04/07/2023 15:22

ItsFunToBeAVampire · 04/07/2023 15:19

Most posts there will even equate a trans woman to a pedophile.

If you read the board, you know that's a lie. It's not hateful to say men can't be and aren't women. There's no possible way that anyone can even suggest that without being called transphobic.

I literally read those exact comparisons on a post about a transwoman who posted a photo of her with a baby to the breast.

About 10 posts equated it to pedophilia.
Thats pretty hateful, if you ask me.

2bazookas · 04/07/2023 15:22

,AIBU to say that my husband isn’t able to give birth?

Only because he still hasn't started his periods.

Apparently if he uses the womens toilets, pees sitting down, and asks to borrow tampax, he can grow a womb of his own. Didn't Virginia Woolf write an essay about that?

loislovesstewie · 04/07/2023 15:21

Your mum does not know a hermaphrodite. There are extremely few documented cases of any individual having both male and female sexual organs ,either primary or secondary characteristics. People with a DSD are always male of female but have some difference of development which may give the appearance that the individual is not of their biological sex .

KentuckyFriedChicken83 · 04/07/2023 15:21

@AmuseBish It's transphobic to use sex and gender interchangeably?