Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Parents moving into house at back of us

311 replies

Eeyore1997 · 03/07/2023 19:46

Am I being unreasonable to not want my parents living that close to us? They are not the sort to keep popping round - in fact far from it, they are the most unsupportive parents ever, but I still feel it's an invasion of our privacy.

I tried to express my husband and my feelings explaining that we can see in each other's gardens and that we feel we need a community of our own in which we can have independent relationships and received this reply.

"Hi again,
We feel that it's important for you to know that we spent another sleepless night which also incorporated some distress. Such is the impact this situation is having on us.
Firstly, as our family, this surely isn't beyond an amicable solution. Each of us have stressed that we want to avoid any further upset.
Secondly, anyone who ultimately moves into that house can presumably see what we could see, which should surely cause you the same problem. How would you approach that? In actual fact, all that we could see from the garden was tree and the top of the basketball net! If curiosity really got the better of us then yes, if we open the window of the only back bedroom and lean out, we perhaps would get a slightly better view if so inclined! On the other hand, if you happen to catch sight of me hanging out the washing I promise I'll refrain from wearing a bikini when doing so!
Thirdly, we're really perplexed as to how our presence would have any detrimental effect on your relationships within the community. Having lived in a community as tight as our existing village for nearly six years we understand first hand how it works and becomes a special place. And in any case, why or how would anything involve us unless you wanted it to? We managed to blend seamlessly into an existing community without any problems and recieved the warmest of welcomes which still remains.
For what it's worth, we lived just as close to Nanna, as you know and nothing was any different from when we lived further away."

What on earth do you do with a message like that? Am I being unreasonable to feel incredibly invalidated?

OP posts:
I8toys · 05/07/2023 20:34

YANBU - I'd hate it. My parents moved into a town nearby when our kids were little but we respect each others boundaries and we always call before visiting.

Is there any expectation of care in the future?

Incognito1975 · 05/07/2023 20:27

I would avoid at all costs! My parents moved next door to me and it was a complete nightmare. I could hear them arguing every time I went into the garden. My mother several times mentioned personal and private things to other neighbours and there was an expectation that I visited them at least daily whatever my circumstances. They even suggested I put a gate between the two gardens for ease of access. If you can somehow prevent it I would do. Good luck

PrtScn · 05/07/2023 20:00

Don't see the problem myself and they've articulated their reply very well.
You could be extra annoying and just send the kids around every 5 minutes or constantly ask if they can baby sit for you since they are so close until they get fed up and move

literalviolence · 05/07/2023 19:43

So sorry OP. I'd hate this too. I think the people giving you a hard time don't always recognise that having a family which is not invalidating and mean is a privilege. If it were me I'd have to move. Or I'd be tempted to carry on sitting with a glass of wine at the end of my garden and debriefing with my OH after my family have been at their most dickish/rude/controlling. The fact that they are happy to do something which makes you spent unhappy and to belittle you for not feeling the same as them shows their true colours.

cakehoover123 · 05/07/2023 19:09

YANBU to find this intrusive given that you're not close and YANBU to ask them not to move nearby. I think the advice to have as little contact as possible, and get ready to move yourself, is good.

I have a mum who sounds a bit like yours (though thank god has never suggested moving nearer us), and I'd wonder if this could be undiagnosed ASD?

There are some unusual things in the response - e.g. "anyone who ultimately moves into that house can presumably see what we could see, which should surely cause you the same problem". It's curious not to grasp that a stranger there is very different from your own mother 🤔

Dominating conversations, not understanding social norms (like treating children equally), and not being able to acknowledge your feelings might all be other clues.

While I'm still sad about the impact my mum's behaviour had on me, suspecting ASD has helped me realise she doesn't actually know what she's doing, and I can't change it. But I still keep my distance, and don't feel guilty about it.

Sorry you're in this situation@Eeyore1997 and good luck. 💐

IncreasinglyGrumpy · 05/07/2023 18:24

I don't think you're being unreasonable to be unhappy with their choice but reading their reply it doesn't sound the most cosy of relationships - I had my MIL live around the corner and she managed to avoid all contact with us and her 4 grandchildren so I'm sure you'll get used to it x

AncientBallerina · 05/07/2023 16:59

Well done. Say very little more. It has taken me most of my 55 years of life to realise how powerful it is not to react the way people expect you to. Or at least not to let them see your reaction.
Ignore the posters claiming not to understand. They either come from incredibly well functioning families, lack insight and/or empathy or are pretty entitled themselves.

AncientBallerina · 05/07/2023 16:49

RandomMess · 05/07/2023 07:31

I would tell your parents that if they move there you will be moving away.

It may or may not stop them doing it.

No because then they will move there. There is an ulterior motive going on here. No one moves to behind their child’s house because they ‘like the estate’

ninjafoodienovice · 05/07/2023 08:34

What a nightmare for you. Sounds like they are not interested in your feelings though.

Grow some big trees.
Invite over some mutual relatives and have a lovely bbq in the garden without inviting them.

RandomMess · 05/07/2023 07:31

I would tell your parents that if they move there you will be moving away.

It may or may not stop them doing it.

RiseYpres · 05/07/2023 07:31

saraclara · 04/07/2023 12:38

I was sixty years old before I managed to learn to stand up to my mother. Her moods dominated our lives as children/teens, and I left home and area as soon as I could. But I still feared anything setting her off. To be frank, her lack of interest in us and her grandchildren was a blessing. I feel no guilt because she's never been bothered about us visiting her. I do feel for my brother though, who never managed to escape.
My Dads most used phrases were "try not to upset your mother" and "anything for a quiet life"

So yes, I totally get what you're dealing with.

I really salute you for learning to stand up to your mother.

My mother never ever learned to stand up to hers, and her older sister carried on where their mother left off. My mother is in her late 70s and her sister is late 80s and my mother spent her entire life throwing my father and my siblings and I under the bus to appease her mother and her sister. It was a miserable way to grow up and has made my mother miserable.... but she still bends over backwards. One example... my mother was a nurse. Her sister fell ill while on holiday and my mother flew 5 hours to get to her nedside and as soon as she walked in her sister looked at her and said ;what the fuck are you doing here, I fucking hate you'.

Anyway. Just had to get that off my chest. I feel very sympathetic to the OP. I think the message her mother sent was really quite nasty and made it perfectly clear that not only will the OPs wishes be ignored but that probably she is going to be punished for expressing her feelings in some way- not just by ignoring them but I get a sense that there will ve repercussions for her that will be underhand and unpleasant. Undoubtedly projecting massively, but that is the sort of thing I have seen in my life.

Timeisfleetingmadnesstakescontrol · 05/07/2023 06:59

Unfortunately it sounds like they are moving whatever & that is how your mother has always been & your father really doesn't seem to have much choice but to do as he is told . She sounds from what you replied to another comment very narcissistic and everything is constantly about her & the people she deems worthy of her time like telling you in minute detail about her friends son's move . This kind of person is very sure they are right & there are never any grey areas for them it's just black & white . I feel the only thing to do unless you want to move yourself is to completely ignore them & keep contact to the very bare minimum. My Mil moved back to be nearer to her boys after living a couple of hours away & she is not a demanding person although she did live with us for a month & a half before her place was ready & it was very strained at times as personal space ended up being hard to come by . So I understand what you mean as they used to be far away but now they will be around all the same places that you go to . It's very difficult when someone who should unconditionally love & care about you but clearly does not all of a sudden is always around . She sounds a proper piece of work & your por dad just sounds like he has given up trying as she just does what she wants

Irritateandunreasonable · 04/07/2023 21:50

Holly60 · 04/07/2023 07:50

Would you ask your adult DC their thoughts on you moving next door to them?

If they said they would rather you didn't, for whatever reason, would you respect that?

I agree there isn't really anything OP can do about her situation if her mum won't listen to her, but it doesn't make her 'ridiculous' for feeling frustrated about her parent's disregard for her opinion.

It does really imo.

SpatulaSpatula · 04/07/2023 20:20

YANBU! Sorry for not reading all of the replies before adding my thoughts. I hope I'm not just repeating. Your situation seems so relatable to me, and I can only assume the people who think YABU have quite good relationships with their mums.

For me, it's very telling that your mum thinks they're just like any other neighbours, and that they have been unsupportive in the past. How awful for your own mother to be so uninvolved and uncaring that literally living next door will make no difference. I'd call or gaslighting, but I might be projecting. She's pretending she has no knowledge of any problem in your relationship and now it's a matter of brinkmanship. She wants to move close so she can lean on you, knowing full well she has never done the same for you, and if you call her out on it you're risking the relationship.

Again, I might be projecting here, but in my experience, people like her need you a lot more than you need them, and if you stand your ground there might be a falling out, but she'll come back eventually after she's punished you enough. I think you should be clear with yourself and with her about your boundaries. You can't control what she does, but you can tell her what you've found hurtful about how she has approached this and let her know exactly what you will and won't accept if she moves in there. If you can't have her moving in there, then be honest with yourself about why and figure out if you're comfortable with maybe not hearing from her for a year or two because she's so upset.

I'm sorry you're having to deal with something so stressful after what sounds like a lifetime of no support. Good luck. Get therapy!

Hadjab · 04/07/2023 19:49

Just so you know @Eeyore1997 , if you didn't already, this has made the Metro - came up in my feed on Facebook

StopMindlesslyScrolling · 04/07/2023 18:22

Can you look at how much it would cost you to move (stamp duty etc) and go round to the people selling their house and offer them a huge chunk of £ (which would still be less than your moving costs) if they DONT sell to your parents?

I'm only half kidding.

My worst nightmare would be my in-laws moving nearby, I genuinely don't know how I'd cope.

You have my full sympathies OP, though I'm genuinely not sure how you can stop it from happening. ☹️

elenacampana · 04/07/2023 18:03

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

HulaChick · 04/07/2023 17:41

toodlesofoodles · 04/07/2023 17:31

Are you the OP's mum?

Haha, that made me laugh 😆 No, definitely not OP's Mum!! I hadn't read all her posts so didn't realise she had a strained, difficult relationship with her Mum, so I feel a bit more sympathetic now! I feel very lucky that I'm very close to mine & love spending time with her. I would love to live next door to my Mum & sister!! 😊

toodlesofoodles · 04/07/2023 17:31

HulaChick · 04/07/2023 17:27

Blimey, my parents would be so hurt if I told them what you told yours! In many ways, you're extremely lucky to have them close by. They sound normal, you don't! In my opinion, based on what you've posted, I think you're being extremely unfair and your parents' reply to you makes perfect sense!

Are you the OP's mum?

saraclara · 04/07/2023 17:30

They sound normal,

In what way @HulaChick ? In that OP's Mum has massive moods and shows no interest in her or her grandchildren? Or that OP's DF is deflated and just bends to his wife's whim to avoind her losing her temper constantly?

HulaChick · 04/07/2023 17:27

Blimey, my parents would be so hurt if I told them what you told yours! In many ways, you're extremely lucky to have them close by. They sound normal, you don't! In my opinion, based on what you've posted, I think you're being extremely unfair and your parents' reply to you makes perfect sense!

MasterCherry · 04/07/2023 16:39

I'm also astonished by the majority opinion on this thread. The email from OP's parent in the opening post was so self-righteous and guilt-tripping that none of OP's later posts struck me as drip-feeding in the least. OP clearly has a difficult relationship with her parents; they have no interest in her feelings, and yet so many posters can't understand why she would feel so uncomfortable with them living literally at the end of her garden.

FWIW, I would love to have my mum living very close by. The absolutely key difference is that if I was uncomfortable about it, my mum would never respond like the OP's parents. She would say, "I didn't realise this plan would make you so uncomfortable, but I can see it does and I don't want to do that to you. What would you think about me looking for somewhere a 15-minute drive away instead?" But OP's parents are very, very far from showing that kind of consideration for her.

Grumpy101 · 04/07/2023 15:48

Let them do whatever they want and then move house. Fuck that. They're being weird and I suspect want to engineer a way to rely on you in old age.

hiredandsqueak · 04/07/2023 15:32

I think if your relationship isn't great it's going to be difficult. FWIW my son is moving to the road next to mine next month but he did ask what I thought beforehand. He is moving knowing that I won't intrude on his life and I know that he won't turn up here uninvited or without texting first. He wouldn't move close to his df as he knows exh has none of those boundaries.

LookItsMeAgain · 04/07/2023 15:31

Crystals35 · 04/07/2023 15:01

You will have that same issue whoever buys the house. YABU.

Yes but if someone else buys the house, they won't be her parents moving in. Whatever about the noise, if the sound travels, the parents will hear everything that the OP and her husband says while out in their own garden. I wouldn't want that.

I don't even like it when I'm sitting out in my own back garden and I can overhear my next door neighbours (who I'm not related to) have a conversation in their garden. It is eavesdropping without any way to get out of it (except to go back indoors) and sure why would anyone have a garden then.

What baffles me is how many people on this thread clearly have zero issues with privacy, either with strangers or relatives. The numbers who say they wouldn't be bothered is really fascinating to me. I get on well with most of my family but honestly, if any of them started to make movements to live in the same estate as me, I think I would start to look to live elsewhere. I like the distance between us all. I value the distance between us. I think the OP is in a similar position.

Swipe left for the next trending thread