Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say schools should not charge for this?

106 replies

HelpIcantfindaname · 03/07/2023 19:43

Previously DDs (14) school have loaned all students laptops in years 10, 11 & 6th form because they are essential for lessons in school. They have been free...up to now.

Now parents have to pay what they call a 'low affordable' monthly rental fee.

This low affordable fee is £25 a month!!!! With £100 deposit!

How many families will be able to afford that? We can't. I've had to take ill health retirement & money is tight.

If this is an essential piece of equipment surely the school should provide them, like they have till now.

It's like telling the rest of the year groups they need to pay for their books . They are not allowed to take their own laptops in because of safety settings.

I know schools are struggling but so are families!

AIBU in thinking this is not going to be manageable for many families?

OP posts:
Chameleons39 · 03/07/2023 20:48

A child in my child's class broke an iPad and a laptop so I'm not really surprised

Blankscreen · 03/07/2023 20:47

I can imagine that some students/families don't respect the kit given if it's 'free'. You only need to look at the state the text books used to be returned in to know that.

Sadly a few ruin it for the majority.

I would say the monthly admin fee is ridiculously high. If there are 1000 students that £25k a month. Some one somewhere will be making a lot of profit in this scheme.

I do though think a fairly high deposit is reasonable to ensure it is looked after properly.

AxolotlOnions · 03/07/2023 20:46

I wouldn't pay this or allow my child to take an expensive piece of equipment into school unless the school was willing to cover it on their insurance. It's not necessary and it's clearly discriminatory.

Irritateandunreasonable · 03/07/2023 20:46

I feel like the majority of people that are voting YBU can afford this.

As a single working Mother who is not eligible for free school meals (and therefore funding)because I earn over £7400 a year this is a HUGE cost for me.

It’s totally unacceptable to create a cost that is not optional and pile pressure to pay it. I haven’t paid for eldests iPad rental.

Also, he’s not even allowed what he wants on it! The school set all the controls and boundaries and want me to pay for it. It’s a no from me.

IJustHadToLookHavingReadTheBook · 03/07/2023 20:46

Kennahevabescut · 03/07/2023 20:07

Challenge the school governing body. This sounds like a classic academy trust swizz.

Ask if the company providing these (overpriced) laptops is in any way related to, owned by, invested in etc, but the management of the academy trust.

This.

Very interested to hear if your child's school is part of an (evil) academy chain (or just a normal one even) @HelpIcantfindaname. This is textbook and I've seen several ACs do this over the past few years. They all backed down when governors were challenged on it (I do some work in education governance).

musicinspring1 · 03/07/2023 20:40

It is the norm for schools around here to have a scheme where parents have to sign up to a laptop agreement before they start and pay for a school approved device. Either outright or installments. But you then own it after it is paid. And this includes insurance/ software etc.
Rental at that price makes no sense at all.

difficultspaghetti · 03/07/2023 20:40

SunnyFrost · 03/07/2023 20:11

I know times are very hard but surely a basic laptop is kind of an essential item for a teenager’s education and aren’t parents expecting to provide it themselves along with school uniform, shoes, food etc? I can’t see how on Earth schools can accommodate providing laptops to every student - of course barely any will come back usable!

I would see this as a basic expense that everyone faces when raising teenagers - it wouldn’t cross my mind that schools would be providing them, sorry. Yet another reason why I can’t see how anyone affords 3+ kids!

I didn't need a laptop for school at all and I only left in 2019. Covid is the reason that this is now considered essential. It is also the reason that many families financial situations have changed in the last 3 years. Be considerate of people's circumstances.

difficultspaghetti · 03/07/2023 20:36

I assume that the reason children cannot use their own is because the laptops need to have school software installed to be able to monitor activity and also access school-specific files. If you buy one you could ask for them to install the software on that instead. Otherwise, I would go to the school and insist that you cannot afford the cost and therefore by disallowing personal laptops they are excluding financially disadvantaged families.

wyntersuhn · 03/07/2023 20:35

My DCs have to take their own laptop to school, which works well for us but is a nightmare for the school's IT department which is constantly sorting random issues across a massive range of devices. However, students tend to look after their laptops because they own them. My school hires laptops to all students (same sort of scheme OP has mentioned) and they are not respectful of them at all. So many have cracked screens, keys missing etc, which can all be fixed, but at a cost to the student, so they never are. The problem with insisting on taking your own device to a school that generally hires them to students is that your. child won't have the same software, Apps, easy access to wifi, troubleshooting etc, because the IT team will only be responsible for sorting school devices and licences will only be bought for school laptops.

Mumtothreegirlies · 03/07/2023 20:32

It isn’t rental it’s instalments. They get to keep it when they leave school .

whatkatydid2013 · 03/07/2023 20:32

I’m another who could afford it and would say no on principle. If it’s not feasible for the school to provide laptops (understandable) then it surely is to teach without them

EmeraldFox · 03/07/2023 20:18

SunnyFrost · 03/07/2023 20:11

I know times are very hard but surely a basic laptop is kind of an essential item for a teenager’s education and aren’t parents expecting to provide it themselves along with school uniform, shoes, food etc? I can’t see how on Earth schools can accommodate providing laptops to every student - of course barely any will come back usable!

I would see this as a basic expense that everyone faces when raising teenagers - it wouldn’t cross my mind that schools would be providing them, sorry. Yet another reason why I can’t see how anyone affords 3+ kids!

DS is in year 12 and has done just fine with a tablet and PC. Nothing for at school.

AHugeTinyMistake · 03/07/2023 20:18

We lend laptops to children across the whole school and any damage is expected to be paid for. It rarely is. We can't refuse to supply a replacement as they need one for lessons/homework. Whole families with 3, 4, 5 children have left the school without notice and they don't return the laptops. It's a daily struggle to keep on top of repairs and children leaving the school.

I don't agree that it should be compulsory to pay for a school laptop and not allow you to provide your own. But I do think a deposit focuses minds. £100 is steep though.

WhatADrabCarpet · 03/07/2023 20:17

I'm agog at this thread.

Both of my children, who went to different schools, had to have laptops that we 'contributed' a nominal amount toward, every month for three years.

After that , we were invited to pay a nominal amount as a one off payment, and the laptop was free to the pupils , bar a yearly payment for IT support.

All the school portals could only be accessed via the school laptop and not by a home laptop or PC.
The yearly fee was for School updates, virus updates and firewall.

Antoninus · 03/07/2023 20:15

Do they have to have them or are they available if needed ? If the latter and they’re being damaged or broken then paying to rent them makes sense

FloweryName · 03/07/2023 20:12

Considering they’re not allowed to use their own laptops, this is is an outrageous request from the school. Don’t pay it and let them figure out how they are going to ensure your child receives her education.

SunnyFrost · 03/07/2023 20:12

Sorry, just realised school is saying they can’t take their own - you can push back on that if they’re no longer providing one. No organisation can force people to buy from it, that includes a school.

CoreyTaylorsSoggyTshirt · 03/07/2023 20:11

I simply couldn't do it.

I couldn't scrape together £100 for a piece of equipment my dc have at home anyway. The £25 a month would be a struggle too.

What are they going to do for the multiple families who won't be able to afford this?

SunnyFrost · 03/07/2023 20:11

I know times are very hard but surely a basic laptop is kind of an essential item for a teenager’s education and aren’t parents expecting to provide it themselves along with school uniform, shoes, food etc? I can’t see how on Earth schools can accommodate providing laptops to every student - of course barely any will come back usable!

I would see this as a basic expense that everyone faces when raising teenagers - it wouldn’t cross my mind that schools would be providing them, sorry. Yet another reason why I can’t see how anyone affords 3+ kids!

listsandbudgets · 03/07/2023 20:10

Well a lot of people aren't going to have the £100 deposit to hand and that''s before even thinking about the £25 a month. Imagine if you have 2 or 3 children at the school - that would really add up fast

OhBeAFineGuyKissMe · 03/07/2023 20:08

Nonsense they can’t take their own. Lots of schools allow students to bring their own laptops. They are choosing to not allow it.

As said that is £300 per year plus deposit. You could buy cheaper (or already have) and use it for more than one year.

Pancake678 · 03/07/2023 20:07

What happens if they are broken or legitimately lost/stolen? Do they get another immediately? If there's a technical issue is it fixed immediately?

Kennahevabescut · 03/07/2023 20:07

Challenge the school governing body. This sounds like a classic academy trust swizz.

Ask if the company providing these (overpriced) laptops is in any way related to, owned by, invested in etc, but the management of the academy trust.

yogasaurus · 03/07/2023 20:06

Needmorelego · 03/07/2023 19:47

I wonder…..
How many have been loaned out vs the amount returned in usable condition 🤔
I have a suspicion many will have been “lost” or “stolen”.

This.

It’s fine for them to hire them out, but it should also be fine for students to take their own. I don’t see how a state school can insist on loaning a laptop, tbh.