Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say schools should not charge for this?

106 replies

HelpIcantfindaname · 03/07/2023 19:43

Previously DDs (14) school have loaned all students laptops in years 10, 11 & 6th form because they are essential for lessons in school. They have been free...up to now.

Now parents have to pay what they call a 'low affordable' monthly rental fee.

This low affordable fee is £25 a month!!!! With £100 deposit!

How many families will be able to afford that? We can't. I've had to take ill health retirement & money is tight.

If this is an essential piece of equipment surely the school should provide them, like they have till now.

It's like telling the rest of the year groups they need to pay for their books . They are not allowed to take their own laptops in because of safety settings.

I know schools are struggling but so are families!

AIBU in thinking this is not going to be manageable for many families?

OP posts:
Maddy70 · 04/07/2023 10:23

Just say you can't afford it. Schools often lease them ad they can't afford the equipment

But if you can't afford it then they will sort it

Whenwillglorioussummercome · 04/07/2023 10:12

As I posted upthread it is not legal for schools to require this sort of payment. I suspect there is a fund for those who can’t afford it that they are keeping quiet about but that is deeply unhelpful if they are giving the impression that there is no other option but to pay.

Bromptotoo · 04/07/2023 10:01

Anybody who thinks £100 deposit then £25/month is fair and reasonable needs their head wobbling. Even just for one child never mind two or three.

At the very least there should be a hardship fund and concessions for people in means tested benefits.

Shopper727 · 04/07/2023 09:40

In my sons schools they get chromebooks in primary that they can take home if needed then at high school they are issued one in s1 after signing an agreement to take care of it with parents and keep till s6 which is great for my youngest as he has sen and struggles to write etc the computer helps him communicate.

when I was at school 30 years ago (feels weird saying that) I had a little laptop called a Tandy I used at school and we had a bbc computer at home I used for homework due to dyslexia my mum taught me to type and my work improved as I didn’t have to spend hours trying to write a piece of work that was barely legible. I also had a reader/scribe & extra time for exams. So for kids like me they are invaluable - and I can write and spell fine now - nurse so write notes etc but it’s great that kids universally have one so they don’t get why have you got a ‘special’ computer etc I think it’s positive and they don’t use them all the time according to my sons (have 4 and one going up this year) so that would be 100 a month for me to pay if they used that scheme which is a shame.

greenacrylicpaint · 04/07/2023 09:40

similar at my dc school.
but they can use their own device (laptop or tablet with separate mouse & keyboard).
school just gives out specifications.
school work happens on cloud based apps that the school control and update.

anyone with an older primary school child - get into a habit of paying into a 'school fund'. start of secondary school is bloody expensive.

poetryandwine · 04/07/2023 09:35

Just ….wow. There is a lot to unpack here.

OP, are you sure pupils won’t be keeping the laptops at the end of Sixth Form? I would think another cohort of parents would be even more unhappy about paying these rates to rent 5 year old computers. The market value of the computers after Sixth Form is zilch and they should be given to the pupils.

What else would be done with them? The Governors should know. Not giving the pupils the laptops doesn’t make sense, although I realise this is not OP’s concern.

I don’t like the forced expense at all and I believe there should be a hardship fund. Again I would take this up with the Governors.

It is undoubtedly much easier to manage certain software when everyone has the same computer. Voice of experience. And to block pupils from porn, etc. It is easy for us to say ‘install blocks on personal laptops’ but not all parents will agree, and then the school will have a mess to deal with. Security is better when the school controls it. So school laptops for school makes sense.

However I am struggling to see why all of this even with a service contract should cost each pupil £1250.

OwlRightThen · 04/07/2023 09:32

Needmorelego · 04/07/2023 09:26

@OwlRightThen a lot “get away with it” because they are Academy Schools which are government funded private schools and can have all sorts of silly rules and regulations and do what they want and go by the theory that “you choose to send your child there”. Unfortunately in many places a LA funded school doesn’t exist anymore. So you don’t have that choice.

They are a tad 'law unto themselves' but I also think sometimes they just aren't challenged. Same with uniforms that are stupidly expensive or from one supplier or when they refuse to make reasonable adjustments to uniform. We are way to laissez faire sometimes in this country.

WhenIWasAFieldMyself · 04/07/2023 09:31

(ours are allowed to BYOD but we do have a scheme in place for those who can't)

WhenIWasAFieldMyself · 04/07/2023 09:30

The OP will possibly find that the school also has a scheme in place (which will obviously not be widely publicised in order not to make struggling families feel worse) whereby under certain circumstances, devices are provided to the student.

OwlRightThen · 04/07/2023 09:26

Whenwillglorioussummercome · 04/07/2023 07:36

I would complain to the governors, pointing out that the school is breaching Sections 451 and 454 of the Education Act 1996, as explained in this guidance on charging for school activities.

We challenged our academy school on something similar in which we all had to pay for a tablet supplied by a company contracted by the school who came to tell us all how much better our kids’ lives would be for it. The school continued to plug the scheme but was forced to publicise that this was a purely voluntary request and the costs could be met by the school if the parents couldn’t or wouldn’t pay.

https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/706830/Charging_for_school_activities.pdf

This!

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 04/07/2023 09:26

Timeisallwehave · 04/07/2023 08:49

Couple of things:

£300 per laptop will be heavily subsidised already by the school

Bring your own device requires lots of infrastructure setup to achieve, due to network access. It’s not as simple as joining the Wi-Fi. Many expenses and considerations involved, licensing, access, load. Schools support a huge number of devices on very little funds compared to corporate, with a high number of users and network load (everyone logging in) at certain times each day with timetabled lessons.

I wouldn’t be too happy either, however its not an cheap task to achieve for anyone.

But it’s not £300, it’s £300 per year. I would expect a laptop to last a lot longer than 1 year.

Needmorelego · 04/07/2023 09:26

@OwlRightThen a lot “get away with it” because they are Academy Schools which are government funded private schools and can have all sorts of silly rules and regulations and do what they want and go by the theory that “you choose to send your child there”. Unfortunately in many places a LA funded school doesn’t exist anymore. So you don’t have that choice.

OwlRightThen · 04/07/2023 09:22

I don't know how schools get away with this tbh.

My child started a setting where they were given iPads. We were asked to sign forms taking responsibility and agreeing to pay for any damage/repairs. I just refused.

Needmorelego · 04/07/2023 09:16

Maybe if schools didn’t expect parents to spend £100s on uniforms - most of which is poorly made, poorly fitting and impractical for the actual school day - then some could afford laptops.
Imagine the job interviews….
”I see you only got a couple of GCSEs at low grades…”
”Well unfortunately my parents couldn’t afford a laptop so I couldn’t access lessons properly and I regularly got ill from overheating by wearing a tie and blazer in a heatwave. However I always had the correct colour socks.”
Okay….that’s totally sarcastic but it’s also a valid point.

Chocolateship · 04/07/2023 08:58

Schools should be given funding for laptops if they're an essential item. I wouldn't blame the school for having to charge (unless they're an academy on the grift), I blame the government. They keep on about 'closing the gap' which we know often includes those from low income households, what happens if their parents literally can't afford to pay this? Does their child not get to access lessons?

Fobabett · 04/07/2023 08:56

£300 per laptop will be heavily subsidised already by the school

Lol behave.

Fobabett · 04/07/2023 08:55

I can see why schools can't necessarily afford to give children laptops to use (especially if many get damaged or 'lost') but that is a lot of money for something that the children have to have. If it's a device they've chosen and locked down as it were then it's also ridiculous for people who can afford it. If they're utilising laptops extensively then there are settings they can lock down in the network which means everyone connected via the WiFi will be subject to them- sure some might have saved material on one from home but I'm not sure the answer is to charge everyone over the odds for what is probably a pretty shit laptop they got on a bulk deal.
⁰

Glittertwins · 04/07/2023 08:51

No request from our school here. They use school Chromebooks when needed. It would be a nightmare for their very limited IT dept to support multiple devices/firewalls/virus protection on personal devices too.

Timeisallwehave · 04/07/2023 08:49

Couple of things:

£300 per laptop will be heavily subsidised already by the school

Bring your own device requires lots of infrastructure setup to achieve, due to network access. It’s not as simple as joining the Wi-Fi. Many expenses and considerations involved, licensing, access, load. Schools support a huge number of devices on very little funds compared to corporate, with a high number of users and network load (everyone logging in) at certain times each day with timetabled lessons.

I wouldn’t be too happy either, however its not an cheap task to achieve for anyone.

FriendsDrinkBook · 04/07/2023 08:45

At my daughter's school they gave laptops to the children to use anyway. Then tried to flog them at the end of the year. From the volume of school ping messages I'd say that they sold none or few , so I don't think they'll be doing that again.

Quiverer · 04/07/2023 08:41

Have they said what would happen if parents just refuse to pay? They can hardly decide not to teach the ones without school laptops.

FriendsDrinkBook · 04/07/2023 08:31

My daughter's school tried this , they just used Google classroom so she used her own laptop. They wanted everyone to pay a premium for use of something that was much cheaper to buy anyway. Most parents refused.

NeverEndsWell · 04/07/2023 08:25

I didn't realise laptops were essential in so many schools. Thankfully DS school doesn't require a laptop.

The monthly fee paid, I'm assuming covers part of the laptop payment and goes toward software payments (school software plus anti virus etc).

Personally, I don't like the idea of using a laptop all the time (or any screen).

Op what happens when parents can't keep up with payments? Has the school said anything?

IggyAce · 04/07/2023 08:19

Id be refusing to pay that.
Ds school we pay £10 per month over 3 years for his school iPad it’s then ours to keep.

Meeting · 04/07/2023 08:13

Honestly I think this new 'need' for them to have iPads or laptops is just lazy teaching.

From what I gather a lot of teachers don't even bother to answer questions anymore because "that's what your iPad is for". It's pathetic and I think far more of a hindrance than a help. How can they be expected to retain and learn information when they've constantly got Google at their fingertips?