Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to be upset because they didn’t like My Home?

189 replies

StarshipCaptain · 03/07/2023 13:54

A former work colleague came to visit me at home a week ago. Now, I’m all for people being blunt and honest, but I really didn’t expect them to criticise everything in My Home from my plants to my furniture to my wall colours, to the location of my property to the Holly bush out the front… When they left I felt really deflated and upset. I don’t want to invite anybody into my home again.

I’m very happy with my home and the way it is, I don’t have expensive things but I like what I have and I’ve made the best of what I’ve got. It’s my sanctuary and calming place for me to relax. I know I shouldn’t care what others think, but I’m terribly upset that somebody would dislike it so much, and tell me.

OP posts:
StarshipCaptain · 03/07/2023 15:41

I thought they came to see how I was getting on since we didn’t work together anymore. I thought we were just gonna have a nice chat and catch up. He walked in the front door kicked off his shoes. I tried to direct into the living room and offered him a cuppa. But I soon realised he wasn’t behind me. So I pulled out where have you gone? Just having a look around. I’m only glad that I’m a tidy person, otherwise that would’ve been another criticism. No doubt he went into every room and every cupboard. In my study, he stopped and looked around and said what is this room supposed to be? One of my cover to comment that there was a lot of stuff in there, yes that’s why I keep my Christmas decorations my ironing basket and it’s the only storage cupboard in the whole house so yes it’s got everything in it.

OP posts:
QuickDraining · 03/07/2023 15:40

If I were to give my honest appraisal of my own house as an outsider I'd be mortified. I had a friend come over recently and he tutted pretty much the entire tour of the garden. Telling me I should get rid of this and that and the other. Then proceeded to video the garden, say he'd show it to his garden designer friend and see what they could come up with. But TBH our garden is a long and arduous project. And we are in the middle of a project, so it is chaos. In my minds eye I can imagine the end result. But actually if the building materials would evaporate it would be fine. My friend is rather uncensored at the best of times. Previously stated we had too much stuff, and should bin most of our crockery. My Mum also is pretty opinionated, everything has to suit her tastes. And she can't help but tell me what I should do. Including painting my house white throughout. Now I personally detest white paint, so that's never going to work for me. She never asks me what I like or want. She'll say things like, I'd move if I were you, the garden is just too much work, I wouldn't live on a terrace. I couldn't deal with that, or this, or the other. It's a constant eruption from her mouth. Now I'm all too aware of many of our issues, and all the jobs that need doing. If only we could find the money and time to tackle them! Or if only we could migrate to a big detached house in the country or another country. Anyway to cut a long story short some people just can't help themselves. Neither my Mum or friend are horrible people, quite the contrary they are lovely. Just a little blind as to how they come across. But houses, decor, and everything is soo subjective. My Mum just spent night on 5,000, to literally put lipstick on a pig of a horrible house. A complete waste of money in my eyes. But she likes it. I had to learn a long time ago not to express my unwarranted opinions. Which took quite some effort, as I had been brought up with my Mum as a role model. I personally think you should decorate your house for yourselves. Because in the grand scheme of things, like when you sell it, the next owner will likely start afresh.

Sounds like you are content in your own surrounds. And that's amazing. I'd love to be in that situation. For me there is no worse judge than myself.

CastlesAndCurlews · 03/07/2023 15:37

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

DOBARDAN · 03/07/2023 15:32

Jealousy

FluffyFlannery · 03/07/2023 15:30

I once had a buyer come and look and she literally ran into each room and moaned out loud about the colour and decor. I was in complete shock!

AiryFairy1 · 03/07/2023 15:28

Rude and jealous, I say.

I’d be rethinking the relationship, but don’t be put off inviting others round. I love visiting friends for a cup of tea and a chinwag, and wouldn’t dream of making any negative remarks about their home, where they live.

And I hope that holly gave them a good scratch on the way out Grin

ps loved the upthread comment about entitled cats so much, that grump would hate coming to our house Grin

diddl · 03/07/2023 15:25

I’m very happy with my home and the way it is,

That's all that matters.

Sometimes people put others down as a way of feeling better about themselves.

Doesn't excuse of course but what a way to live!

KatherineSwynford1403 · 03/07/2023 15:20

They were incredibly rude!

AutumnCrow · 03/07/2023 15:18

DoOne.Com

Loving it Grin

notsofamous · 03/07/2023 15:12

Nomorethanthree73 · 03/07/2023 15:08

@notsofamous it was the only area where he may have had a point!

Yes, tbf he was right about that one!

Zarah123 · 03/07/2023 15:09

ScattyHattie · 03/07/2023 15:05

Some people (very common if neurodiverse) do truly lack the polite filter to not say exactly what they're thinking but while blunt don't intend to be rude or cause hurt.
Others (arseholes) seem to believe only their opinions are important so like to voice them and expect people to be grateful for their amazing insight, not offended.

I think once over the stinging criticism, you'll look back at dick colleague's visit with humour at how they disliked absolute everything. Perhaps it's a ploy to alienate anybody who may possibly want to socialise or visit their home in future.

Are neurodiverse people also correspondingly fine with blunt speaking from others?

I have ADHD and I’m very easygoing, I feel like it’s quite hard to offend me and yet at the same time I’m ultra aware of not wanting to offend others.

Nomorethanthree73 · 03/07/2023 15:08

@notsofamous it was the only area where he may have had a point!

ScattyHattie · 03/07/2023 15:05

Some people (very common if neurodiverse) do truly lack the polite filter to not say exactly what they're thinking but while blunt don't intend to be rude or cause hurt.
Others (arseholes) seem to believe only their opinions are important so like to voice them and expect people to be grateful for their amazing insight, not offended.

I think once over the stinging criticism, you'll look back at dick colleague's visit with humour at how they disliked absolute everything. Perhaps it's a ploy to alienate anybody who may possibly want to socialise or visit their home in future.

notsofamous · 03/07/2023 15:03

Nomorethanthree73 · 03/07/2023 14:42

I experienced something similar with the husband of an old friend who came to stay. He criticised everything from my decor to my garden, to the size of my house and my entitled cats! I asked them to leave early and was pretty upset immediately afterwards, particularly as I had put a lot of effort into hosting them. Within a couple of days however, I could see that it was his problem and not mine and he'll never be invited back. It's lovely that your home is your sanctuary, as it should be - please don't let one idiot ruin that for you. Put it out of your mind.

Aren’t all cats entitled? 😂

Maray1967 · 03/07/2023 15:03

YoungerDryas · 03/07/2023 14:50

I bet the op has that all going through their head afterwards. It can be so gobsmacking when people rudely blurt out unsolicited criticisms, you are stumped at the time.

Agreed. Most people don’t produce quick thinking responses because they are not expecting such appallingly rude behaviour. To be invited into someone’s home and then criticise things is very very rude. If I’d done that as a child in my mum’s hearing I don’t think I would have been able to sit down for a week as she would have hauled me out and tanned my backside.

OP, this person behaved very badly but most people are polite. If I see something in someone’s home that they’re clearly proud of I always comment positively on it even if it’s not to my taste. How well it goes with xx, what beautiful wood etc.

I hope this person’s bad behaviour won’t stop you welcoming others. Most people would not dream of telling someone how to improve their home.

putthatdownsteve · 03/07/2023 15:00

It’s astounding how ill mannered and rude some people can be.

You are invited to someone’s house, you tell them it’s lovely, what ever you actually think.

Larkslane · 03/07/2023 14:57

2bazookas · 03/07/2023 14:33

Your ex0colleague has very bad manners. That's her problem; you didn't cause it.
Now you know, you just scratch her off the social list and never see her again. She's gone.

The problem, is not your visitor's bad manners. It's your reaction to it.

"I felt really deflated and upset. I don’t want to invite anybody into my home again.*.

Your insecurity, fearfulness, low self esteem, irrational withdrawal from unrelated visists by others, are internal. Those emotional /social feelings are about you, not her.

You can't change her. But you can change your own outlook and behaviour.

Excellent advice.
I am going to pay heed to it myself.
I had a similar experience recently with a colleague of my DH.
Thank you Bazookas for putting their behaviour into perspective for me.

mainsfed · 03/07/2023 14:56

YoungerDryas · 03/07/2023 14:09

This person is really screwed up. At a guess they are the youngest child in their family, always being belittled and criticised and treated like an idiot, whose opinion holds no weight, so they are acting all this out when they visit others - completely oblivious to the fact that this behaviour isn’t normal. Unsolicited criticisms of others’ choices is unacceptable behaviour. I bet you aren’t the only person who doesn’t ask them back a second time.

You are in no way obliged to invite people into your home to have your choices appraised. Learn to sniff out people like this and avoid them, and make sure only warm and non-judgemental people cross your threshold.

I’m a youngest child and I’d say I’m often the scapegoat of the family but it has made me more empathetic to other people rather than critical.

I would say it’s more likely she has middle child syndrome 🤣

Violinist64 · 03/07/2023 14:56

How rude. It says far more about them than you. I am sure that your home is perfectly nice and the main thing is that you enjoy it. Don't let one very unkind person rock your confidence.

SkinnyMalinkyLankyLegs · 03/07/2023 14:55

I doubt that they actually didnt like it. They sound like ab absolute cunt and probably would have criticised it even if they secretly love it. They sound bitter and unhappy and these types are always sniping.

Noseylittlemoo · 03/07/2023 14:54

When I moved to my house an old school friend came round to see the house and go for a drink. We have been friends more than 30 years even though our lives are quite different . I could see her looking down her nose at things and she just kept saying well it's a good use of space! (Her house is probably 2.5 times the size and price). I am now cautious to only meet at public places with her now to save myself from her judgement. But as time has passed my OH and I laugh about it now.

pinkyredrose · 03/07/2023 14:54

You can discount everything they say as they're a rude, ill-mannered twat.

Hereforaglance · 03/07/2023 14:53

Unless we no whst was actually said then it hard to judge tjis could range from one throw away comment to being overly critical so hard to no if ur being overly sensitive about a throwaway comment or she genuinely was thst awful

YoungerDryas · 03/07/2023 14:52

Some families though…

YoungerDryas · 03/07/2023 14:52

No one ever put me down or made me feel stupid and I would never be rude to someone and criticise their choices in the way OP's visitor did.

Exactly

Swipe left for the next trending thread