Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to be upset because they didn’t like My Home?

189 replies

StarshipCaptain · 03/07/2023 13:54

A former work colleague came to visit me at home a week ago. Now, I’m all for people being blunt and honest, but I really didn’t expect them to criticise everything in My Home from my plants to my furniture to my wall colours, to the location of my property to the Holly bush out the front… When they left I felt really deflated and upset. I don’t want to invite anybody into my home again.

I’m very happy with my home and the way it is, I don’t have expensive things but I like what I have and I’ve made the best of what I’ve got. It’s my sanctuary and calming place for me to relax. I know I shouldn’t care what others think, but I’m terribly upset that somebody would dislike it so much, and tell me.

OP posts:
sandgrown · 04/07/2023 06:16

@FarmGirl78 I couldn’t have said it better myself . My house needs loads of work and I have no money at present but it’s my little piece of this country and I love it .

SheerLucks · 04/07/2023 00:20

OP he sounds like an absolute nut job and was just using the visit to vent uncontrollably!

Your home sounds lovely - just don't invite him round again.

I'm sorry you experienced this.

FarmGirl78 · 03/07/2023 23:49

What an absolute cowbag!!

I'd say about 80% of my friends have very modern stylish "on trend" houses where they've all had the same copy-and-paste kitchen extension "family rooms" with log burners, vaulted ceilings, velux roof windows and bifold doors with laminate flooring throughout. Whereas my wonky old cottage with the strange floor plan, brick arch fireplace and weeds in the garden is very different. But my home is my castle. Its my own square of this rich and varied land. My little piece of England. No-one elses. Mine. I shut the door, turn the lock at night and its just me and my house, my palace where I am King. I have it exactly how I want. Your colleague doesn't like it? Tough shit to her, it's not her house and she doesn't pay the bills or call the shots. You do. Have it how you like and mentally wave 2 fingers at her every time you have misfortune to see her again. How rude!! Your house is pretty. Her manners are ugly.

ComeTheFckOnBridget · 03/07/2023 22:57

RiseYpres · 03/07/2023 20:01

No. And in some cases it would be even worse for a family member to do this.,

because families tend to have such intricate and tricky ties and relationships can be fraught.

I would never comment on anyone's house except to say 'how lovely! I love that paint shade, what is it?'. Or (as i did this week) ' It looks so lovely. cosy, and welcoming without being intimidating'. (Cousin- new house).

If you seriously think that your 'constructive criticism' is welcome- about homes; about weight; about children- about anything is really welcome then you have a certain world view of your own superiority that may not correlate with the recipient 's view of your words of wisdom.

Totally agree.

And what about the people who think its ok to share what they would do to improve the house if they lived there ("because it has so much potential")...Rude, arrogant tits.

Notjustabrunette · 03/07/2023 22:57

TheWalrusdidbeseech · 03/07/2023 19:41

It's not about "giving them a list", it's a normal discussion between adults when you are close 🙄

You walk past something, you mention it, in normal families it's a complete non-issue.

Yeah, totally normal to point out jobs that need doing in someone else’s house.
oh look your garage needs painting, your stairs need hovering, your tap in dripping.
Not normal to need to point these out to a fully functioning adult.

billy1966 · 03/07/2023 20:05

Unbelievable rude.

What a pity you didn't show him the door.

Forget it and him.

I wouldn't entertain such a rude ignorant pig again, ever.

RiseYpres · 03/07/2023 20:01

TheWalrusdidbeseech · 03/07/2023 19:41

It's not about "giving them a list", it's a normal discussion between adults when you are close 🙄

You walk past something, you mention it, in normal families it's a complete non-issue.

No. And in some cases it would be even worse for a family member to do this.,

because families tend to have such intricate and tricky ties and relationships can be fraught.

I would never comment on anyone's house except to say 'how lovely! I love that paint shade, what is it?'. Or (as i did this week) ' It looks so lovely. cosy, and welcoming without being intimidating'. (Cousin- new house).

If you seriously think that your 'constructive criticism' is welcome- about homes; about weight; about children- about anything is really welcome then you have a certain world view of your own superiority that may not correlate with the recipient 's view of your words of wisdom.

RiseYpres · 03/07/2023 19:57

Rosietheravisher · 03/07/2023 18:42

Mum are allowed to do stuff like that, no?

To answer your question.

No.

Liamgallaghersparka · 03/07/2023 19:54

I would pop round to their house and do the same to them, see how they like it.

TheWalrusdidbeseech · 03/07/2023 19:41

Notjustabrunette · 03/07/2023 19:28

Nope, I wouldn’t go round my parents house and point out all the jobs I think need doing. They’re adults and don’t need someone giving them a list of jobs to do for their own home. They are perfectly capable of seeing and sorting their own house repairs.

It's not about "giving them a list", it's a normal discussion between adults when you are close 🙄

You walk past something, you mention it, in normal families it's a complete non-issue.

Notjustabrunette · 03/07/2023 19:28

TheWalrusdidbeseech · 03/07/2023 14:37

It might be a bit rude, but a mother commenting on her son's home is less weird. You'd do the same at your parents house, this or that need sorting.

But a random work colleague?

Nope, I wouldn’t go round my parents house and point out all the jobs I think need doing. They’re adults and don’t need someone giving them a list of jobs to do for their own home. They are perfectly capable of seeing and sorting their own house repairs.

ToWhitToWhoo · 03/07/2023 19:11

How incredibly rude of him!

I don’t want to invite anybody into my home again.

No need for that; just don't invite HIM again. Most people don't act like that!

ChildrenOfRuin · 03/07/2023 19:05

This is really unusual behaviour from a guest. Most people visiting someone else’s home will find something to be complimentary about, or at least keep quiet about things they don’t like.

DH and I have had some criticism of our home from parents and siblings, although phrased tactfully. And TBF, there were parts of what they said that I agreed with.

But outside of immediate family, we’ve only ever had unsolicited criticism of our home from one person.
And that was a (now ex) colleague of DH’s, who was later sacked for gross misconduct because he’d been saying things to numerous people at work, that were overly critical, downright offensive, and on at least one occasion, verging on criminal.

So his behaviour was a reflection on him, and his complete lack of an internal filter and / or him being a c**t, not on our house, IYSWIM.

Rosietheravisher · 03/07/2023 18:42

Oldraver · 03/07/2023 16:02

My Mum once walked into my bedrroom and just stood there staring just repeatedly saying OMG oh dear OMG.

She's never been allowed upstairs since

Mum are allowed to do stuff like that, no?

JMSA · 03/07/2023 18:06

What a horrible person! YANBU. And I'm sure your home is lovely - you love it, and that's the only thing that counts!

Rosietheravisher · 03/07/2023 17:55

Your colleague is a jealous bitch.

mathanxiety · 03/07/2023 17:50

StarshipCaptain · 03/07/2023 15:57

I’m not even responsible for the Hollybush out the front, because I live in a ground floor apartment, so the gardens are maintained and are very neat. when he mentioned the Hollybush, I said I don’t mind it because come Christmas I’ll chop a bit off and do some internal festive decorating.

I just didn’t understand his behaviour at all I don’t know whether it’s supposed to be endearing or something I didn’t get it.

This is not a criticism of you.

Please don't take it as such .

When he criticized the holly bush, you made an excuse for it. When he criticized the cupboard, you also made an excuse for it.

Another answer to his criticism would have been an eye roll and a sarcastic 'Really?' Alternatively, 'I don't remember asking for your opinion'.

It's easy to think of all sorts of smart retorts in hindsight, but when you're faced with unexpected rude remarks, you can be too gobsmacked to react. Stop beating yourself up. Your house is yours to decorate as you wish (and it's none of my business, but it sounds lovely). Your guest is a boor. Rude isn't strong enough a word for him going through the house, his examination of it, and his remarks.

Clearly, you're never going to see this man again as long as you draw breath. I love the DoOne.com suggestion. You have nothing to lose, and I think it would be liberating for you to really send him that note.

RiseYpres · 03/07/2023 17:33

I well know this kind of person. DH's best friend invites himself to stay annually as we live near a festival he goes to. I have put up with it for about 8 years. he is critical. Everything. I cannot even tell you what he criticises as it is too outing Grin. But he criticises decor; which room is designated for what;' how i once made bolognese for dinner.

Last year I finally snapped and told him that if he did not like things in MY house then he could fuck off and he wasn't welcome.

This year he has booked a hotel nearby.

Some people are just arrogant entitled shitheads who think that every piece of shit that drops from their mouth has to be held up like the tablets the ten commandments were on.

the80sweregreat · 03/07/2023 17:18

The spade a spade brigade.
They can never take any criticism themselves !
Ignore it.
I've a friend who picks holes in things too
They seem to find it hard to be positive.
I'm sure your home is lovely op!

WickedSerious · 03/07/2023 17:13

GasPanic · 03/07/2023 16:00

I know a few people like this.

What I always find strange is that the "straight talking" and "I tell it like it is" types always seem great at dishing out their forthright opinions, but a lot less happy when it is someone else dishing out a forthright opinion back to them.

Learn to value the opinions of people whose opinions are worth valuing. Feel free to ignore the rest.

I have a cousin like this,she thinks everyone is desperate for her approval and she sulked for a month when I told her to mind her own business.

ColdHandsHotHead · 03/07/2023 17:11

I had this with a friend. She came to see my house and while she didn't directly criticise much, she praised small things in a really over the top way so that it was clear she thought everything else was rubbish. Eg she liked the curtain tie-backs and one of the food items I'd bought. She had nothing else positive to say about the house at all.

She's now an ex friend.

momtoboys · 03/07/2023 16:43

I just don't understand what is wrong with people. What satisfaction did it give them to say anything except "thank you for having me. Your house is lovely"?

Don't feel defeated. They are taking the piss.

Rainbow1901 · 03/07/2023 16:37

Ignore them OP - as the saying goes an Englishman's home is his castle and your former colleague was way out of order when invited into your home to disparage it.
Everyone has their own style, some live in chaos, some are minimalist, some are totally something else - it is their home and they like it that way. Just as you love your home - you have put your own mark on it and it has your personality stamped on it. Your hopefully ex-friend is not worth another wasted thought!!

Makemyday99 · 03/07/2023 16:33

I wouldn’t worry. I was criticised once for not having any photos of family or children in the main room, I only had art prints. I would never make a comment on someone else’s home though it is rude as everyone has different tastes

InSpainTheRain · 03/07/2023 16:32

I understand how it may be slightly upsetting, but you like your home amd how you have it. Why pay attention to some critical and rude person? Just don't meet with them again.