Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this right to say?

82 replies

shhhhbaby · 03/07/2023 00:22

I've been seeing someone since January who got divorced a couple of years ago. He's made it clear he's not ready for a relationship but beyond that, he's not communicating with me at all. At the moment, I have no idea whether he means he doesn't want a relationship with me but he's using me as a placeholder until he finds someone he likes. Or he just doesn't have the mental capacity to have a relationship but he likes me and fancies me and maybe sees it working. My therapist told me to put my minimum requirements to him in a message to see if he can meet them. What do you think of this message below? Please don't be mean and tell me to fuck him off. I want to know about the message, not that he's a useless shit or I'm a nobhead. But if you're a post-divorced man, I'd welcome your thoughts more generally!!

You know, I think, that I really like you and love spending time with you and I really want it to continue. I feel like we have a connection and you make me feel calm and safe and happy. I'm more than happy to continue in the way that it is right now and I've never needed a relationship or a label. I've been on my own for a while and long enough to know I'm ok. Ive said that to you many times and I hope you believe me. I know you think I'm needy and generally I'm not actually but maybe this situation is making me so.

But I do need some clarity around what you can give and what you can't for me to make that judgement. I think I need to know whether this is just sex for you and filling a void whilst you look for something better.

And if not, and you want to keep seeing me cos you like me and you like spending time with me I want to continue because I like this and you add to my life right now irrespective of a label. There's that theory in peace negotiations (going back to my masters) about the maximum someone can give and the minimum someone can expect and do they overlap.

What I need isnt formalising anything. The minimum I need is basic communication like to know what I can expect from you. Telling me when you don't have capacity to see me or respond to my messages and just making it clear to me that youre just a bit busy or done in emotionally but you'll be in touch when you're ready or able or mentally equipped. I'd happy with that and I appreciate what your life is right now so I don't want to put pressure on you or make you engage when you can't. I just need to know you can't when you can't. Just with that, I'll know what to expect and that's fine with me. I really like being with you irrespective of any formality but with the caveat that I do need more honesty and communication so I know where I'm at.

Is that something you feel able to do?

OP posts:
GoodChat · 03/07/2023 06:48

I don't think that message even sets out what you need. You've only asked him for communication (enough to tell you he's not going to communicate!). If you're going to settle for that you're going to be scared to challenge him when he doesn't follow through.

Find your self respect and set some proper boundaries.

SoWhatEh · 03/07/2023 06:44

That's way too long, OP.

I'd say, 'I've enjoyed spending time with you over the past six months but I'm aware you've said you are not ready for a relationship. For me, it's inevitable that the longer I spend with someone I like, the closer I get to them and I'm now at the stage with you where I don't feel comfortable getting closer to you, if you still feel this is casual.'

I wouldn't say anything else, just state what you think and see how he reacts.

ProfessorXtra · 03/07/2023 06:37

I think you maybe missing one huge point.

He recently divorced. Knows he doesn’t want commitment. But he probably doesn’t know wether this is a temporary thing or a long term thing. He probably doesn’t know if it’s how he feels in general or if it’s you he feels this way about.

A lot of the word contradicts the message. You have ‘yeah I am cool with no label and happy on my own’ but then throwing in phrases like ‘I love spending time you’ which is often something people say when testing the water before saying I love you and don’t feel brave enough.

The whole ‘you make me feel calm and safe and happy’ is really intense. And it’s putting responsibility onto him for you feeling safe, happy and calm. When someone has said they don’t want something serious, that’s going to make them think you are needy and intense.

He has communicated. He finds you intense and needy. You are insisting that you aren’t. But the language suggests you are, which is why there’s a disconnect. You think you are being laid back, and you might be, but your language isn’t.

I think the fat shorter version posted above is much better. I would send that.

hattie43 · 03/07/2023 06:31

Cringe .
Far too long and wordy .
Can't you just really cut it down , hello , I like you and enjoy spending time with you . I hope I'm respectful about your needs but I also need you to be more communicative with me . I need to know where I stand .

ZekeZeke · 03/07/2023 06:23

OP I mean this kindly, he isn't that into you and probably using you for sex.

Bin and move on.
Don't send a needy lengthy message. Talk to him if you want to communicate!

MysteriesOfTheOrganism · 03/07/2023 06:19

You're asking for clarity - effectively asking what the "rules" are for your interactions. That's a relationship (of some sort, even if it doesn't have a nice neat label). Some people don't want any rules at all, don't want to feel obliged to respond. They want to feel free to talk or not talk, meet or not meet as they see fit without any consideration for the other person. I once dated someone like that, and when I asked for clarity she immediately dumped me.

WandaWonder · 03/07/2023 05:25

People can use all the nice fluffy words and come across and wonderful calm caring people to try and not upset you the way you need them to do, if you really feel you have to send this then no I do not think you really will get whatever answer you are looking for, I personally would accept this person for who they are now or move on

Ladybug14 · 03/07/2023 05:24

You've been dating this guy for 6 months which is no time at all

That message is way too long, way too emotional and way too needy

If you need clarification as to how he wants to proceed with your dating simply say to him, face to face:

'Do you see our dating turning into a serious relationship or not?'

I'd bet not , because he's just not into you imo

wandawaves · 03/07/2023 05:17

It's way too long! And it makes you sound like hard work, which I'm sure you're probably not, it just sounds that way through your essay. Just keep it short and to the point. Would it be better to have the chat in person?

Lizzt2007 · 03/07/2023 05:05

I'm sorry op but in your very first paragraph you answer your own question. He's told you clearly that he's not ready or looking for a relationship. Whether that's just with you or at all is irrelevant, he's told YOU in the situation that you're in that he doesn't want a relationship. Your choice is to accept what he's offering or walk away. He's been clear about what he's offering you at this time. It could change, but right now all he's offering is casual sex, and it's up to you if that's enough for you or not.

cassiatwenty · 03/07/2023 03:27

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

PushmePull · 03/07/2023 03:25

I think @AtrociousCircumstance 's version is a lot more digestible and clearer.

If there is nuance missing from that, I'm afraid I missed it in the full version. I do think it's a bit too long to get your point across.

You are asking very, very little of him. You shouldn't have to tie yourself in knots to ask for this small thing.

cassiatwenty · 03/07/2023 03:24

MBappse · 03/07/2023 00:51

Send the abbreviated version suggested.

This. Well-written but a tad too long.

I've never met a man who communicated well as women idk 🤷‍♀️

Newnamehiwhodis · 03/07/2023 03:22

I’m so sorry, OP. this is a good one to journal. Not to send, and you’ll be able to see that when you have a bit of distance.

  1. do not cut yourself down and call yourself “needy.”

  2. simply know that you deserve clarity , and ask for it. He needs to measure up to what YOU want, not the other way around, simply because you’re advocating for your own life, and if you both want something different, it’s best to move on.

  3. don’t hem and haw about how you don’t really need a relationship. You don’t need to be the “cool girl,” and trying to behave as if you don’t care (when you do), just makes you sound weak and scared.
    don’t say you don’t need labels.

just say flat out what you’re looking for, the future you wish to be building toward, and If that’s not what he wants, it’s far far better to know now and move on than to pretend you’re ok with casual and “whatever, no label,” and find yourself feeling unsafe, tying yourself into knots for him.

there is no man on earth who deserves your discomfort, lack of safety, and putting your needs last. Absolutely not one single man is worth giving up your well being.

Aquamarine1029 · 03/07/2023 03:20

That message makes you look desperate and rather pathetic. If you were so amenable to settling for scraps you wouldn't have the need to clarify this "relationship", you simply wouldn't care.

This is absolutely not the "situationship" for you.

Ponoka7 · 03/07/2023 03:13

I think that you need to drop the first paragraph and take out the parts about him adding to your life. That could get used against you in the future. Stop saying that you don't need things formalising, because really that's what you want. Just set out your basics, without the declarations of things being so good, because they aren't. His head is a mess, but he wants a sex life. I've been there, as a woman. I'm not saying that it's impossible for things to develop, but you are opening up way too much. All you need to do is set your boundaries, but you need to stick to them.

MavisMcMinty · 03/07/2023 01:43

Too long, I couldn’t read it all.

“Is this something you feel able to do?” sounds suspiciously like Rachel, after her 18-pages-front-and-back letter to Ross in Friends. Your options are a) say nothing, hope he starts to love you, enjoy all the sex in the meantime; b) ask him outright (not in a long letter imo); or c) accept he’s not that into you or playing games with you, and be too busy to see him again.

Avondale89 · 03/07/2023 01:19

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

The way that message was worded was harsh. But if you paid attention to the sentiment, I do think it would save you a lot of wasted time and emotional pain in the long term. I understand it’s easier said than done. I also say this as someone who has wasted way too much time trying to make relationships work that were never going to. Maybe take some time to be really honest with yourself about whether you’re actually as happy with this situation as you’re portraying yourself to be.

pizzaHeart · 03/07/2023 01:15

It’s way too long and woolly, sorry OP but you’ve asked.
Who is initiating meet ups you or him? If you, maybe you should stop this and you would get your answer without messaging.

shhhhbaby · 03/07/2023 01:04

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

dillydal · 03/07/2023 00:54

OwlBabiesAreCute · 03/07/2023 00:41

Omg you sound desperate, needy and that message is ridiculous.

Take the hint op, you like him more than he likes you. Either live with that or get rid. 7

And get a different therapist - one who's actually going to work on you rather than setting you up for a fail.

Tbf you sound like a dick. Give her a bit of space. She's not ridiculous. If she's posting on Mumsnet, she's probably sad and wondering what to do. You sound like a judgemental twat.

Juanmartinez · 03/07/2023 00:52

If you've been seeing him since January but he doesn't want a relationship, I'd be a bit wary .
I'd send a shorter message

' I need some clarity around what you can give and what you can't for me to make a judgement on whether to continue seeing you.I think I need to know whether this is just sex for you and filling a void whilst you look for something better.'

Or better still, dump him and find someone more straightforward.

MBappse · 03/07/2023 00:51

Send the abbreviated version suggested.

Landndialamrhf · 03/07/2023 00:46

He’s not ready for a relationship and is showing no signs of respectful communication

im not sure what else you need to know
he’s not ready to commit

your options are to hang out anyway
or hang out hoping it’ll be something more one day.

I wouldn’t send that message anyway
sorry it’s a bit shit for you

OwlBabiesAreCute · 03/07/2023 00:44

Op go and find someone who'll treat you as you would like to be treated. This person is not the one.