Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To choose nursing over medicine?

51 replies

nurseormedicine · 03/07/2023 00:13

I'm really conflicted. I have a degree and master's in Biology (first class and distinction). I've been working in pharmaceutical sales but haven't enjoyed it, and want a patient-facing role in the NHS. I've always had medicine at the back of my mind since I was at school, but never seriously considered it as I thought I wasn't clever enough and outgoing enough.

I've applied for a nursing degree and I have some interviews lined up. I like the idea of being a nurse and the routine and consistency of it, being able to specialise in a particular area and having better work-life balance both during training and after qualifying compared with medicine.

However, I'm wondering if I'll regret doing nursing instead of trying for medicine. I think I would find medicine more intellectually-stimulating as I love the problem solving aspect of it, and really enjoyed studying pathology and physiology at university. However, it's so competitive to get into and such a demanding degree, I've already had 4 years at university and I'm not sure if I can sustain the level of motivation and determination needed to study medicine. That said, I do find it very interesting.

I'm also not convinced I'd get a place to study graduate-entry medicine. It's so competitive.

I've considered Physicians Associate but I can't afford the fees as the NHS don't fund it and there's no access to student finance for me as I have already taken out a student loan and master's loan.

I did post about this before and received some really helpful advice, but just wanted to get some more opinions now that I've applied to nursing and got interviews. I feel so stressed out and unsure with what path to go down.

OP posts:
Medstudent12 · 03/07/2023 00:31

Doctor here. It’s tough at the moment but I hope with strikes we can push for improvements in pay, conditions and morale.

How old are you? What are your circumstances like? I know lots of doctors who did medicine as a graduate. Don’t write it off or assume you’re not smart enough.

Physician associate is an option but if you do that you’ll never have the progression to registrar or consultant. You’ll watch junior doctors progress quickly above you whilst you stay fairly static in terms of pay/responsibility for decades. However you won’t have the stress of rotational training, professional exams etc and less responsibility. No moving across the country for a job, get more flexibility over where you work. Less stress. I expect they’ll be able to prescribe soon but they’ve been saying that for over a decade!

You could also become a nurse and after a few years train as an ACP.

Nurses work less hours than doctors but I think they work far more antisocial hours than doctors do, constant shift work. Physically demanding job, increasing stresses, they have so much paperwork to do on top of patient care. Hopefully some nurses can come advise soon.

Swipe left for the next trending thread