Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do the people on here lie about their size?

133 replies

qualitychat · 02/07/2023 21:20

Anytime I am in AIBU everyone seems to be a size 12 and under. They exercise, don't drink and eat a very healthy diet. I have been looking at the Style & Beauty section. The vast majority of posters are plus size. Am I missing something?

OP posts:
bellac11 · 03/07/2023 13:47

I wonder where this idea that BMI is inherently flawed has come from, it is adjusted for ethnicity, for sex, for age (children's is different) and has a range over a couple of stone in some cases

Of course extreme outliers like professional athletes and body builders are not going to register accurately as such, it wasnt really designed for them but for the bog standard member of the public its an effective and accurate tool surely?

lljkk · 03/07/2023 13:38

BogTrollAtLarge · 02/07/2023 22:31

Do you get the urge to tell them they must look fat?

I suppose it's always in the context of them insisting that BMI guidelines are flawed and their evidence is "I don't feel fat so I can't be overweight" statements, "and therefore BMI guidelines can't indicate if someone is overweight". They may decide that they are comfy in own skin regardless of BMI, but that doesn't mean BMI guideline is therefore a completely useless guideline.

amusedbush · 03/07/2023 13:14

TallahatchieBridge · 02/07/2023 22:57

Someone on here the other day said they are 17 stone and a size 16.

I'm trying to work out why I am 14 stone and a size 20/22.

I'm 5' 5" exactly and this morning I weighed 14st 6lbs. I wear size 16 clothes and my bra size is 34G. It's not all muscle either, as much as I would like it to be! I have physical limitations due to chronic health conditions so I can't really exercise.

At my heaviest, I weighed 18st 5lbs and wore a size 20/22.

At my lightest, I weighed 12st and wore a size 12, though I was told in no uncertain terms by someone on here that I must be lying. I still have my size 12 skinny jeans and they seem so small when I hold them up now, but I have fond memories of wearing them around Paris in 2017 Smile

DontBeBitterGlitter2023 · 03/07/2023 13:13

Just started posting on S&B with full length pics so it would be very difficult to lie.... and I don't Edit my body despite being accused in the past (not on here and maybe a few edits in the face 🤣)

Im a size 6-8, I'd like to think I'm slim but curvy in the right places - 32DD although I paid a fortune for those! I'm in my late thirties now and have been everywhere from a size 4 to a 14 due to incredibly disordered eating - now resolved thankfully but I do watch what I eat to a certain degree (though drink far too much wine) and I do work out

EhrlicheFrau · 03/07/2023 12:16

I see no reason to lie, depending on the shop I'm anything from size 8 to14 (but mostly 10 or 12), I exercise regularly (swimming and walking mainly), I don't drink alcohol very often, and my diet is pretty atrocious. I don't think any of these facts make me a better or worse human though. 😬

StamppotAndGravy · 03/07/2023 11:41

A few people may really genuinely be deluded. I have a size 20 relative (I know the size because I buy her clothes as gifts) who straightfaced tells you she's not overweight and that she's really muscular from her one exercise class per week. She also goes onto rants about BMI being a colonialist irrelevant sick to beat women with (she's white average height Anglo, so definitely within the group where BMI is applicable...) I assume there must be some cognitive dissonance given that she brings all of these topics up in conversation. I'm a slightly tubby, sporty size 14 who could do with a bit less cake and a slightly healthier BMI, but am otherwise nothing remarkable.

Trees6 · 03/07/2023 09:29

HappyHippoBirthay · 03/07/2023 08:12

I was people watching and I saw many middle aged women who are slim. MN attracts a lot of middle class women and generally they are slimmer. I think the most vocal ones on S&B have disposable income and tend to be slimmer but we regularly see posters who are big(ger) and asking for advice.
I do think some people have a fantasy alter ego just for MN. 6 figure salary, nannies, husband with a top secret hobby, living off a massive salad and wearing size 4 bikini 2 weeks after birth 😂
I'm sure all this exists but the amount of posters who claim to have all those things is astonishingly high on this platform 😏I think it's funny. Read everything with a huge dose of salt.

also: live “rurally” with 6’ sons and stunning daughters.

Floatlikeafeather2 · 03/07/2023 08:47

That's weird. I have literally never seen anyone mention size 12 or any other specific size on AIBU. Perhaps it's just chance. I'm not glued to MN so I might have missed those threads. I've never been on any other board either. As to your question "do they lie?", of course they do. Some people come on MN specifically to do that. It's their fantasy haven where they they can be, do, say what they like. It's completely incognito, unlike other social media where you can be searched for. As long as you always remember that what you're reading might not be true, and take everything with a pinch of salt, it's fine. Not everyone is lying, not everyone is telling the truth.

liveforsummer · 03/07/2023 08:22

That's probably down to the different people posting on different threads. Personally I'm a size 10 and always have been. I'm not lying , why would I? I eat what I please and don't formally exercise but I have an active job and active home life with dc too. I don't post in s&b for clothing advice as it's pretty easy ti find stuff on the high street in stock in my size

Emmamoo89 · 03/07/2023 08:17

BeverlyHa · 02/07/2023 21:22

it is very easy to slim down once you just stop the bread and cake.

I'll never stop the bread and cake but don't need to.

AllOfThemWitches · 03/07/2023 08:16

Appleblossompetal · 02/07/2023 22:44

Surely you must be?

I'm pretty much slap bang in the middle of the 'healthy' range. I consider myself 'medium' with wide-ish hips. Partner says slim but I really don't think men pay as much attention to our sizes as we think they do.

HappyHippoBirthay · 03/07/2023 08:15

@TallahatchieBridge I'm 5ft2. At 14 stone I was wearing size 16 to 18. I think it's body shape and some people like their fit looser or tighter than average.

Sendmymillioninaninvoice · 03/07/2023 08:15

Obviously some do.

HappyHippoBirthay · 03/07/2023 08:12

I was people watching and I saw many middle aged women who are slim. MN attracts a lot of middle class women and generally they are slimmer. I think the most vocal ones on S&B have disposable income and tend to be slimmer but we regularly see posters who are big(ger) and asking for advice.
I do think some people have a fantasy alter ego just for MN. 6 figure salary, nannies, husband with a top secret hobby, living off a massive salad and wearing size 4 bikini 2 weeks after birth 😂
I'm sure all this exists but the amount of posters who claim to have all those things is astonishingly high on this platform 😏I think it's funny. Read everything with a huge dose of salt.

00100001 · 03/07/2023 08:08

BeverlyHa · 02/07/2023 21:22

it is very easy to slim down once you just stop the bread and cake.

You should start your own Weight Loss Club and get people to pay to follow this ever so easy plan, then no-one would be over weight...!

Miraculous.

Hoppinggreen · 03/07/2023 08:07

TallahatchieBridge · 02/07/2023 22:57

Someone on here the other day said they are 17 stone and a size 16.

I'm trying to work out why I am 14 stone and a size 20/22.

I’m 15 stone and a size 16 at 5ft 4

lljkk · 03/07/2023 07:48

oh yeah, posters my height but BMI is 5+ higher, 5-15kg heavier (or more). They look "gaunt" if they get any lighter. Okay.

People lie about their family situations & jobs & salaries & spending habits & sex life too. Not just hiding ID details, but distorting details with reckless regard for truth. Any personal conflict or relationship hassle: just remember you only heard one side of the story.

OldBeller · 03/07/2023 02:54

I have never lied about my size. But I'm what other MNs often refer to as 'emaciated if they were the same size' as me. I find that very hard to believe.

I'm a perfectly normal healthy weight. In no way do I look skeletal.

I also eat whatever I want. I'm just murdering a packet of late night biscuits right now. I've been the same size more or less for the last twenty five years. I still wear clothes from when I was sixteen sometimes.

I think it's genetic that I stay around the same size. Just one of those things. I've never been on a diet.

Do the people on here lie about their size?
Happyhappyday · 03/07/2023 02:33

I am a size 8-10, exercise regularly. I drink occasionally but I really hate being hungover. Eat mainly home cooked food (never ever do ready meals) because I think McDonald is disgusting and likewise to ready meals. I’m not depriving myself, it’s gross. I pretty much what I feel like but also listen to my body and if I eat five slices of sourdough, I don’t usually find I want any for a couple weeks! I am not making it up 🤷‍♀️. My friends are a mix, most similar size to me but most do it more through portion control/being careful what they eat, rather than swimming for an hour every day (because I love swimming). I don’t work very much and only have one DC which undoubtedly makes it easier.

TallahatchieBridge · 03/07/2023 01:41

@Mirabai

Could be self-deception, or you could be small and she could be tall.

(Mind you 17 stone is over twice my body weight - how tall can she be?)

*No, I'm 5ft 7in so I'm not small.

Mind you, I have incredibly slim legs and carry ALL of my weight on my front (stomach and boobs) so this could be why I'm a bigger clothes size.*

wanttokickoffbutcant · 03/07/2023 01:00

I am usually a size 8 but I have gone up from 8 to 8.5 stone and my jeans feel a bit tight - but I am 5'2. I have been nearly 12 stone before but I had an ED.

echt · 03/07/2023 00:40

You're not short @Watchinghurling, you're very slightly above average height for UK women.

Watchinghurling · 03/07/2023 00:35

I'm a 12 but I'm only 5 foot 4 which is a bit of a faux pas on mumsnet where it seems being short is one of the worst things you can be. As a result, I'm curvy. I definitely don't have a model figure. I don't particularly care. I had wine this evening and I'm planning on eating a large viennese whirl for lunch tomorrow. I can't relate to all this frantic dieting or 'choose your face or your figure' as you get older. I'm forties and beyond a bit of normal maintenance, I choose neither, because I can't be arsed. Memento mori.

bonfirebash · 03/07/2023 00:26

TallahatchieBridge · 02/07/2023 22:57

Someone on here the other day said they are 17 stone and a size 16.

I'm trying to work out why I am 14 stone and a size 20/22.

That's me probably. I'm 5ft 10 and just posted this on the what are you wearing thread
Weighed this morning as I'm trying to lose and I'm 17st 6
Size 16 jeans here but I often need an 18 top to fit my boobs in but then it's too big on the waist

Do the people on here lie about their size?
bonfirebash · 03/07/2023 00:23

radiatorpipe · 02/07/2023 22:23

The other conundrum is all the 6 figure salaries but the mortgage threads are always full of people with tiny mortgages

I have a tiny mortgage

Because I'm on min wage and the houses near me are cheap
Grin