Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I need help to nake a decision! (car related)

39 replies

Eezee · 02/07/2023 18:00

Budget 10-12k.

Need: reliability, ideally a good warranty, lower depreciation, no more than 4m long to fit on my drive.

Looking at a Toyota Yaris Design edition. 2017 model. 30k miles. Garage won't hold car past tm and I'm up the wall with exams do struggling to make a decision. This will be a cash purchase so a big deal for me as I can't get reasonable finance due student status / low income.

Can any yaris owners of this era give me the pros & cons of this era model before they release the car ftom my reservation? Please 🙏 I've given myself a migraine thinking about it on top of my exams!

OP posts:
MavisMcMinty · 03/07/2023 03:03

Eezee · 03/07/2023 02:44

@QuestionableMouse Wow that's impressove milage!

I was put off the skoda's in general when I learnt they have a cam belt that needs replacing every 5yrs / 80k miles. Currently at a cost £650 from the dealer so probably circa £400 from a generic garage. Seemed a lot to have to factor in every 5 yrs as running costs. Or for people not do it as often as advised?

I've only ever had cam chain.

Yeah, I thought “new cam-belt? Oh come on, that won’t break”… and then obviously it broke when I was doing 85mph in the outside lane of the M5. That was a very scary 3-lane crossing of a busy motorway to get to the hard shoulder in a powerless car. The AA eventually transported me the remaining 120 miles to my home in Devon in a recovery truck.

And that is my not-bothering-to-change-the-cam-belt-when-advised-to story.

Bromptotoo · 03/07/2023 02:55

A car is a tool to get you from a2b.

In the real world, for Yaris/Polo etc sized vehicles, the difference between models/manufacturers for reliability isn't as big as people like Honest John would have you believe.

Unless you need a car of your own tomorrow, in which case can you hire, being in middle of exams or a time of max work pressure, isn't the best time to decide.

Eezee · 03/07/2023 02:53

@SmartiesParty that's good to hear. How's your mileage? It is the 1.33 vvti engine? That's what I'm looking at. 99bhp I think.

OP posts:
Eezee · 03/07/2023 02:52

@MavisMcMinty I had a yaris from the same era actually 20 years ago but it was so long ago & such a completely different model despite the same name as current yaris I didn't feel I could compare. Mine was reliable back then. I think I'm a boring driver cos I loved that car 🤭 but I've never had a Ford or Vauxhall to compare.

OP posts:
Eezee · 03/07/2023 02:44

@QuestionableMouse Wow that's impressove milage!

I was put off the skoda's in general when I learnt they have a cam belt that needs replacing every 5yrs / 80k miles. Currently at a cost £650 from the dealer so probably circa £400 from a generic garage. Seemed a lot to have to factor in every 5 yrs as running costs. Or for people not do it as often as advised?

I've only ever had cam chain.

OP posts:
SmartiesParty · 02/07/2023 19:24

I have an earlier Yaris 2012 and I love it. It's so roomy and it's been very reliable. I changed the starter battery a few years ago but that's the main maintenance Ive had to do

MavisMcMinty · 02/07/2023 19:16

I had a much earlier Yaris (2005) than the one you’re talking about, and it was fine, nice high driving position, but hardly exciting to drive. I did 30,000 miles a year when I was working, so none of my cars lasted all that long, but the Yaris lasted the shortest time of all, Vauxhall Corsas and Ford Fiestas were much longer-lasting, even at my high mileage.

I have a Fiesta now I’ve retired and it’s FUN to drive round the B-roads of Devon, it’s so responsive and cheerful, and parts are always available, not that I’ve needed any yet, I’ve only done 30,000 in 7 years with this one!

bonfirebash · 02/07/2023 19:07

Toyota was named as one of the most reliable used car brand recently in a which survey so yes if you want longevity! Suzuki and Lexus were the others

Eezee · 02/07/2023 19:05

Polo's out of my budget I think. I'd have to increase the age or drop the power if I went to polo's.

OP posts:
QuestionableMouse · 02/07/2023 19:04

I've had a couple of Fabias and they're great cars! My old one has almost 200k miles and is still going strong with my mum 😁

Eezee · 02/07/2023 19:04

@HaveYouHeardOfARoadAtlas thanks, seems to be a theme of reliability but a little boring on there for the yaris in general. I'm torn. I need reliability but worry the unique front grill end looks dated & will look more so in 5 yrs... I tend to keep cars for over a decade!

OP posts:
Eezee · 02/07/2023 19:01

Wenfy · 02/07/2023 18:03

Yaris autos often have weird gear boxes. I wouldn’t be buying one without a test drive tbh.

my favourite car this size / budget are Polos. Nippy, reliable, and very easy to fix if needed. There is also a lot of self-help on the internet for minor things due to Polos being the car of choice for young men.

Test drove a skoda automatic. Didn't like it (the automatic aspect, the car was ok otherwise). So only looking at manuals now. Plus I read autos are around £1k extra! Which my budget can't justify!

OP posts:
Wenfy · 02/07/2023 18:03

Yaris autos often have weird gear boxes. I wouldn’t be buying one without a test drive tbh.

my favourite car this size / budget are Polos. Nippy, reliable, and very easy to fix if needed. There is also a lot of self-help on the internet for minor things due to Polos being the car of choice for young men.

HaveYouHeardOfARoadAtlas · 02/07/2023 18:02

Have you googled for Honest John reviews?