Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Prison visit TikToks

139 replies

Emptychairdoasolo · 02/07/2023 11:30

One video popped up a week or so ago and I watched it so now my feed is inundated with these videos. Young girls and women making videos like ‘get ready with me to visit my boyfriend’ ‘spend the day with me visiting my baby’ which was in fact their partner.

I absolutely do not begrudge men in prison having visits and I actually have very strong feelings about rehabilitation and safety in prisons, quality of life etc but AIBU to think this is just glamourising it?

For the younger girls and women 18-24 that I see, can use common sense and assume that the types of crimes their partners of the same age would be committing are assault, drug possession/dealing, drink driving. Hardly victimless crimes and it doesn’t sit right with me that they are putting that online for others to consume the videos and make a cutesy video out of it.

It makes me desperately sad reading the comments and so many people saying it’s their situation too and it’s girls so early into their adult life in relationships with these men.

OP posts:
usernother · 02/07/2023 16:51

I agree that these TikTok videos are posted for attention and status. All of the women in the videos I've seen were similar. They seemed proud of having a boyfriend who was in prison. Pathetic really.

Againstmachine · 02/07/2023 16:50

JudgeRudy · 02/07/2023 16:47

@Againstmachine
You are completely wrong you are judging what they mean to you, you ignore the victims of the crime and most of the time there is a victim....

No, I'm not ignoring that, I'm taking in the full picture and considering what brought them to where they are. I've just come to a different conclusion. To put it in perspective I believe the majority of prisoners are selfish/entitled. I also know some prisoners who've committed awful crimes. They are under no illusion how much their actions have harmed their victims. They just dont care enough. These are bad men. Some have pleasant personalities, but it's hard to see past their crimes. They define them.

I don't care what brought them where they are.

Plenty of people in those situations make different choices, commiting crime is a choice.

BusyInTheGarden · 02/07/2023 16:49

There are some very odd things on Tik Tok.

Get ready to come to hospital to have my baby....saw one of those recently

LolaSmiles · 02/07/2023 16:48

Againstmachine there's some interesting correlations between low literacy levels and offending behaviour and I believe that undiagnosed

The problem is that the issues are complicated and correlation doesn't equal causation.

Are adults with an offending history back to their teens engaged in criminality because they didn't do well at school, or did they not do well at school because the sort of community they're in and their families didn't value education and we're rather hands off on their children's criminal activity?

Some people like to try to explain away personal responsibility though so instead of considering the victims of crime, there's endless whataboutery to ensure the people with criminal histories are centred.

JudgeRudy · 02/07/2023 16:47

@Againstmachine
You are completely wrong you are judging what they mean to you, you ignore the victims of the crime and most of the time there is a victim....

No, I'm not ignoring that, I'm taking in the full picture and considering what brought them to where they are. I've just come to a different conclusion. To put it in perspective I believe the majority of prisoners are selfish/entitled. I also know some prisoners who've committed awful crimes. They are under no illusion how much their actions have harmed their victims. They just dont care enough. These are bad men. Some have pleasant personalities, but it's hard to see past their crimes. They define them.

creativeusername23 · 02/07/2023 16:47

I don’t have anything to add but I always cringe when prison related threads pop up either here or elsewhere as the inevitable ‘I work in one’ newer type of person into the prison service will arrive and proceed to discuss topics they shouldn’t or put out information they shouldn’t.

Politely - please think on current HMPPS staff.

Againstmachine · 02/07/2023 16:40

SayHi · 02/07/2023 16:35

Yes you are correct.

Some men in prison are obviously just bad people but most have special needs who have been coerced into doing something or didn’t have the support growing up to know right from wrong.

Apparently at least half of all prisoners have some sort of learning disability. And fortunately it is becoming more well known now and things are being put into place to help them like help with reading and writing, instead of just punishing them which usually results in committing other crimes as soon as they get out.

I'm calling rubbish on this.

This thread is just excuses for people commiting crimes.

Shame no one cares about victims.

BusyInTheGarden · 02/07/2023 16:39

@regustering because YOI is from 18 and SEN covers children and 'young people'

And there's education in prison

JeminaSunshine · 02/07/2023 16:36

Yeah anyone who has visited someone in prison knows it's not glamorous.

If anyone thinks different they must be a bit daft.

SayHi · 02/07/2023 16:35

ohfook · 02/07/2023 16:08

My understanding was that a vast proportion of men in prison have learning difficulties/undiagnosed sen, are functionally illiterate and often have been abused as children. A friend used to work in prison ed and she used to make it clear she wasn't working with flashy drug dealers and tax evaders but young men who, with a different start in life, would never have ended up in prison.

Yes you are correct.

Some men in prison are obviously just bad people but most have special needs who have been coerced into doing something or didn’t have the support growing up to know right from wrong.

Apparently at least half of all prisoners have some sort of learning disability. And fortunately it is becoming more well known now and things are being put into place to help them like help with reading and writing, instead of just punishing them which usually results in committing other crimes as soon as they get out.

Rosemarypots · 02/07/2023 16:30

You're absolutely right @LolaSmiles. Women as support humans was the gist of it. It's about ten years ago that I spoke to my acquaintance about it, so things might have changed in more recent years now there's more of an awareness of power imbalances and coercive control etc. However, I can see support on release is one of the considerations, so I imagine the conflicts are still there.

JudgeRudy · 02/07/2023 16:28

FuppingEll · 02/07/2023 15:33

What do you think she means? It's pretty bizarre that you are pushing for an explanation of a pretty self explanatory sentence. She doesn't believe that most crims are good people.

I've come across prisontok a few times OP and it is pretty bizarre. Women(never men) wasting their lives waiting for 'their man' to get released, trying to twist the whole thing into some kind of fairytale. The ones who have never ever met these blokes in real life but think they have found their soulmate are even crazier. Why they think all that they deserve is a man in a cage is beyond me.

I think someone's being pedantic. The statement 'there are some good people in prison' means exactly that.
Saying it's mostly untrue is incorrect. If there were only 2 good people in prison it would satisfy the statement. There are definitely at least 2 sothe statement is correct. What maybe should have been said is that most people in prison aren't good. That's probably accurate.

I've said elsewhere that I know 'good' people in prison and bad people out of prison.

SayHi · 02/07/2023 16:27

It’s not the men in prison, it’s the women who are trying to get their 5 minutes of fame which is the issue here.

Its embarrassing what some people will do to become ‘famous’ online.

You watching these videos are giving them exactly what they want and you’re the reason why so many keep doing it.
If a video has millions of views then of course it’s going to glamourise it.

regustering · 02/07/2023 16:25

BusyInTheGarden · 02/07/2023 15:56

Prisoners (men cat A)

Range from bad as you'd imagine through to men with SEN

Why are you calling them SEN when they aren't children?

MynameMyname · 02/07/2023 16:21

Very manipulative with a good sense of humour . Keep their bodies toned and fit . So many female prison officers get caught having affairs with them . They are so good at getting into peoples heads .

Againstmachine · 02/07/2023 16:20

JudgeRudy · 02/07/2023 16:18

It's either true or false. It's true. There are good people in prison. They've done something illegal and got caught. The behaviour was bad but that might not define them as a person.
Likewise, there are bad people not in prison. Not all crimes are illegal. Some people are morally corrupt but may never break the law....but they'll hurt and use plenty of people throughout their life.
I know 2 prisoners I trust. One's in, one's out. Both are essentially decent people and both are kind. They just struggle to fit in and earn a living in a normal way.

You are completely wrong you are judging what they mean to you, you ignore the victims of the crime and most of the time there is a victim.

JudgeRudy · 02/07/2023 16:18

Againstmachine · 02/07/2023 15:00

Mostly that's very untrue.

It's either true or false. It's true. There are good people in prison. They've done something illegal and got caught. The behaviour was bad but that might not define them as a person.
Likewise, there are bad people not in prison. Not all crimes are illegal. Some people are morally corrupt but may never break the law....but they'll hurt and use plenty of people throughout their life.
I know 2 prisoners I trust. One's in, one's out. Both are essentially decent people and both are kind. They just struggle to fit in and earn a living in a normal way.

Qilin · 02/07/2023 16:11

BusyInTheGarden · 02/07/2023 15:55

Well most of my colleagues are lovely people, those in healthcare are lovely people

Generally most of the staff!!

I think it's pretty clear that posters are referring to the prisoners serving time in prisons, rather than the staff.
Staff rarely have girlfriends and wives coming into the visit them - the op is about TikTok videos of them - so fairly obvious they mean inmates.

I've also worked in prisons - a lot of prisoners, including cat A and restricted ones - can come across as personable and often charismatic. However, the very fact that they are in prison suggests there is a flaw in their character in some way. Whilst some may be in there for dubious reasons, or have some form of Sen perhaps, most are in their for committing a crime and often behaving in pretty bad ways.

ohfook · 02/07/2023 16:08

BusyInTheGarden · 02/07/2023 15:56

Prisoners (men cat A)

Range from bad as you'd imagine through to men with SEN

My understanding was that a vast proportion of men in prison have learning difficulties/undiagnosed sen, are functionally illiterate and often have been abused as children. A friend used to work in prison ed and she used to make it clear she wasn't working with flashy drug dealers and tax evaders but young men who, with a different start in life, would never have ended up in prison.

isthismylifenow · 02/07/2023 16:06

I know one of these women.

She has had abusive relationships constantly through her life.

I wish I could wave a magic wand so that she can see things clearly, he is very manipulative and she cannot see this being in the bubble.

He's a lifer. Probably won't ever get out. But they are due to be married (they got engaged on one 15 min visit).

Personally I think it's because she knows he's never getting out, and so can't physically harm her. He's going a great job of it mentally though.

She just says people will never understand. Which is probably correct. But she is an adult and spends all she has on him, buying telephone time, flights, special outfits for the 15 min visit. It's all on tiktok too. She has quite a big following. She says it's her support group.

Btw he's in for life for domestic abuse, attempted murder (of said spouse), housebreaking and drugs. Not really a catch, nor a good person.

Againstmachine · 02/07/2023 16:04

Bananaandpecan · 02/07/2023 15:57

I see these videos also. I think that "get ready with me for..." is a trend as much as anything else and they are getting ready for a prison visit so film it and post it. In the comments you can see lots of other women are in the same situation and they seem to find support in each other.

There is absolutely nothing wrong with supporting someone in prison so why shouldn't they post the video if they're so inclined. They are not guilty of their partners crimes.
I dont think by putting out there that they have a loved one in prison is glorifying it.

They may not be guilty of their partners crimes, but if you benefit from them then you are consenting to them and let's be honest many women know there other half is dodgy

LolaSmiles · 02/07/2023 16:03

I knew somebody who used to sit on a parole board. She said it was so conflicting, as maintaining a relationship on the outside was viewed positively in terms of readiness for release, but that she considered being in a relationship with a prisoner was often really negative for the women they were in relationships with
That's really interesting and seems to overlap with the women as support animals for men outlook / the women being men's fixers outlook.

It's not healthy for a woman to have that responsibility on her.

Againstmachine · 02/07/2023 16:02

BusyInTheGarden · 02/07/2023 15:55

Well most of my colleagues are lovely people, those in healthcare are lovely people

Generally most of the staff!!

Are you deliberately being like this, we clearly aren't talking about the staff so stop being obtuse.

You are thinking you are looking clever with your comments but you are making yourself look stupid.

Bananaandpecan · 02/07/2023 15:57

I see these videos also. I think that "get ready with me for..." is a trend as much as anything else and they are getting ready for a prison visit so film it and post it. In the comments you can see lots of other women are in the same situation and they seem to find support in each other.

There is absolutely nothing wrong with supporting someone in prison so why shouldn't they post the video if they're so inclined. They are not guilty of their partners crimes.
I dont think by putting out there that they have a loved one in prison is glorifying it.

BusyInTheGarden · 02/07/2023 15:57

@Againstmachine

Naive 😆

Swipe left for the next trending thread