Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Son been split from best friend at school.

60 replies

MadammeGazelle · 02/07/2023 10:21

Long story short, DC is in year1. The classes always get split for the next year and DC has been split from their best friend. Admittedly DC plays in a group but the actual BF is going to another class.

I'm wondering why this has happened and AIBU to be annoyed?

OP posts:
Chocolateship · 02/07/2023 11:48

This is one reason we chose a single form entry school. That said I'm sure he will be fine OP, they can still play together etc and it helps expand their friendship groups.

MadammeGazelle · 02/07/2023 11:46

BlueLiquid · 02/07/2023 11:39

You really need to take this as an opportunity to build not only your son’s resilience, but also your own. Spending your Sunday morning so shocked that you have to post about it online over such a small and commonplace situation isn’t normal.

Apart from all the reasons listed above, it could be a case that the friend’s parents requested that they were separated if they felt the relationship was too intense/not beneficial for their son.

Yes, I realise this and it's consumed me a bit and reading all the replies on here has brought things into perspective, so thank you everyone for replying and giving me an insight as to how things really are.

I'm learning everyday, it's not just the kids ☺️

OP posts:
AuntMarch · 02/07/2023 11:46

Carouselfish · 02/07/2023 11:27

Yes they did this to my DD and her best friend. It really spoiled her enjoyment of school to be honest. I really am not at all concerned about academics at primary level and think they should just be happy and not put off school/learning as the top priority. When they reunited in year 2 it wasn't the same as DD had made a new friend and then and after they've been an awkward threesome with constant spats. They are so little in year R and 1 it's absolute bullshit that separating them from their security of a new, good friend, if they've succeeded at making one, (when they've just been separated from their security of home) is going to benefit them be making them resilient etc. It's like, well done, 6 year old, you've managed to navigate being shoved into an unfamiliar environment with a load of strangers, let's see what new problems we can create! I think they should be trying to keep friends together at that stage for their emotional security and happiness.

They could have tried as far as we know, but there have been plenty of reasons given in this thread as to why it won't always work out.

BlueLiquid · 02/07/2023 11:39

You really need to take this as an opportunity to build not only your son’s resilience, but also your own. Spending your Sunday morning so shocked that you have to post about it online over such a small and commonplace situation isn’t normal.

Apart from all the reasons listed above, it could be a case that the friend’s parents requested that they were separated if they felt the relationship was too intense/not beneficial for their son.

mummyh2016 · 02/07/2023 11:37

Mariposista · 02/07/2023 11:21

Good. Intense friendships age 6 are not good. They should be mixing with a lot of different children. If the friendship is meant to last the distance, it will do.

This. I'd be over the moon if my 6 year old was in a different class to her BF.

FilthyforFirth · 02/07/2023 11:27

This happened to DS1 in YR last year. I was unimpressed to say the least. DS was split from pretty much all his friends. I did complain and the school admitted because DS played with a wide range of kids he was easy to 'slot in anywhere'. I was very unhappy with this response. To their credit they apologised and promised his transition to Y2 would be fairer.

I have just been told about his new class and he is with the friends he requested. It might be worth a friendly chat.

Carouselfish · 02/07/2023 11:27

Yes they did this to my DD and her best friend. It really spoiled her enjoyment of school to be honest. I really am not at all concerned about academics at primary level and think they should just be happy and not put off school/learning as the top priority. When they reunited in year 2 it wasn't the same as DD had made a new friend and then and after they've been an awkward threesome with constant spats. They are so little in year R and 1 it's absolute bullshit that separating them from their security of a new, good friend, if they've succeeded at making one, (when they've just been separated from their security of home) is going to benefit them be making them resilient etc. It's like, well done, 6 year old, you've managed to navigate being shoved into an unfamiliar environment with a load of strangers, let's see what new problems we can create! I think they should be trying to keep friends together at that stage for their emotional security and happiness.

Mariposista · 02/07/2023 11:21

Good. Intense friendships age 6 are not good. They should be mixing with a lot of different children. If the friendship is meant to last the distance, it will do.

IMustDoMoreExercise · 02/07/2023 11:10

Slightly different, but me and my best friend were put in the same class when moving from junior to secondary school.

My sister was put in a different class from her best friend and I think that was because they were a bad influence on each other.

Ariela · 02/07/2023 11:01

'How exciting, you'll have the opportunity to make new friends in lessons in the new class, and you'll still be able to play with BF at break times' was my response.

Calloffruity · 02/07/2023 10:59

Try not to worry. DD was in a group of 4 girls in reception - going into y1 the other 3 went into a class together and DD was put in the other one. I was worried but they sought each other out every break and lunchtime, and the friendship group remained strong throughout the year. Y2 they were all back together and remained so for the rest of primary, and stayed friends throughout.

electriclight · 02/07/2023 10:56

Spinet · 02/07/2023 10:55

For some reason on MN you are never allowed to criticise teachers for even the tiniest thing. But realistically as a small child being separated from your best mate unexpectedly is a huge thing so it's perfectly reasonable to mention it. As an adult it's your own responsibility to make sure you get what you need but as a kid you can't and people are shocked if you try.

That doesn't mean your son can't learn to live with the new arrangements op. Maybe you can plan a weekly play date with the old friend and make space for a regular play with new friends too, if you're in a position to do that.

Not allowed? Every other thread is criticising school or teachers so that can't be true!

Spinet · 02/07/2023 10:55

For some reason on MN you are never allowed to criticise teachers for even the tiniest thing. But realistically as a small child being separated from your best mate unexpectedly is a huge thing so it's perfectly reasonable to mention it. As an adult it's your own responsibility to make sure you get what you need but as a kid you can't and people are shocked if you try.

That doesn't mean your son can't learn to live with the new arrangements op. Maybe you can plan a weekly play date with the old friend and make space for a regular play with new friends too, if you're in a position to do that.

electriclight · 02/07/2023 10:54

I'm a teacher. They make new best friends within weeks and often hang on to the old one too, who they are excited to see at playtime and lunchtime. It widens their social circle, gives them more friendship options and helps them learn the important skill of getting to know new people.

When we sort classes at our school we have to have equal numbers, fair mix of boys and girls, fair mix of SEN/G&T, pupil premium/fsm balance.

On top, aim to give everyone at least one good friend and split up dynamics that don't work or have been requested by parents.

Awful when parents complain and you only split them because the other child or parents asked you to!

MadammeGazelle · 02/07/2023 10:54

Maybe annoyed was the wrong word to use. Maybe shocked was more appropriate.

This is my first DC at school so it's a learning curve for me also and by no means a teacher/school bashing thread.

I have the upmost respect for teaching and the school is a fantastic one. Nor was I ever approaching the school about the separation.

OP posts:
Glittertwins · 02/07/2023 10:52

It's definitely for the best. I really don't think parents should encourage the special best friend thing - we've certainly seen it lead to tears and serious repercussions later on.

GeriatricMumma · 02/07/2023 10:49

Every year my sons school mix up the classes; they soon find new best friends.

Rainbowqueeen · 02/07/2023 10:49

Best friends aren’t necessarily best learners when placed together. It may be that or it may be random.

Theoldgreygoose · 02/07/2023 10:46

Why on earth shouldn't they be split up? Schools really have more to do than make sure friends go into the same class. Your DC will make new friends, and can still see his best friend at breaks. When I was at primary school I was moved up a year and so was never in the same class as my friends ever again, and went off to high school while they were still at primary. My parents most certainly didn't get annoyed and I survived.

AuntMarch · 02/07/2023 10:43

Happened to me, having been specifically told we would stay together! Never in another class together again, not even a single subject in secondary school. Still very close friends now, 30+ years later.

They may drift apart, but then they would have anyway. And if they don't, no harm done anyway!

mn29 · 02/07/2023 10:43

Happens all the time, teachers have more to worry about than keeping best friends together. You just have to get on with it.

Greenflamesburn · 02/07/2023 10:41

Ps you didn't enable voting YABVU it's school and this is not a battle I would consider with them

Greenflamesburn · 02/07/2023 10:38

Wow let's find another thing to flog teaches over.
Benny must sit with Matty.
What you don't see is Benny and Matty are little twats together that don't listen an cause disruption. Yes even at 5-6 they start to learn to rule the roost. Splitting them is easier.
My year 2 and best friend have been Split as all they do is chat to each other. I'm hoping going forward her effort to school work improves.

TimeToMoveIt · 02/07/2023 10:32

My 3rd had this in year 3 which was crap because he only started in the school in year 2 and had only managed to make a couple of friends and thet were both moved to a different class. Unfortunately it happens though.

The secondary school they go to doesn't take into account friendships so they end up in groups with people they dont know at all. There's 2 kids from his primary school in his group but he never really spoke to them at junior school

MadammeGazelle · 02/07/2023 10:32

MojoMoon · 02/07/2023 10:29

You would be better focused on building your son's resilience rather than complaining.

Much better life skill for him.

His friend is still at the school - they can play at lunchtime, playdates etc.

Life is full of small emotional challenges and here is a good opportunity to help model for him how to make the best of a situation and build new friendships.

The friend could have moved away entirely.
Their friendship may have withered anyway as they grew up
Etc
Your son needs to be resilient to these things. You will set him up better for life if you help him become so, rather than complain to the school

I haven't said anything of a sort about complaining to the school.

OP posts: