Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this the mother of all calling out - Katherine Birbalsingh

767 replies

DramaFatigue · 02/07/2023 08:06

Katherine Birbalsingh has done the mother of all calling out and I can't help but sit here with my jaw on the kitchen table in awe.

She has written a 4-page open letter to Sir Kerr Starmer calling out Jess Phillip's behaviour online. Whilst I don't always agree with KB's methods of the school she runs, I do think that Jess Phillips behaviour towards her is shocking and unbefitting of someone who could be running the country. JP should resign TBH.

https://news.sky.com/story/headteacher-katharine-birbalsingh-brands-labour-mp-jess-phillips-social-media-posts-racist-and-bullying-12913139

Headteacher Katharine Birbalsingh brands Labour MP Jess Phillips' social media posts 'racist and bullying'

Katharine Birbalsingh addressed the open letter to Labour leader Sir Keir Starmer. Labour has not commented on the matter and Sky News has contacted Ms Phillips for her response.

https://news.sky.com/story/headteacher-katharine-birbalsingh-brands-labour-mp-jess-phillips-social-media-posts-racist-and-bullying-12913139

OP posts:
Thread gallery
48
SunnyEgg · 05/07/2023 18:49

..back up

SunnyEgg · 05/07/2023 18:48

cakeorwine · 05/07/2023 18:45

And Twitter should not be used to write an open letter accusing someone of racism, especially one that is full of mistakes and lies, followed up by friendly chats with friendly media outlets and a doubling down when caught out by lies.

There is a point in pile ons when people should just stop. The point has been made.

Unfortunately, it's too easy to reply and retweet - and forget the consequences.

JP tweeted before the letter though so by then she really had got KB’s up

If an MP said ‘that woman’ about me and said they might write to my place of employment to see what’s going on I’d feel pretty pissed too

cakeorwine · 05/07/2023 18:47

What KB should have done is do what Dorries does - and only allow selected people to comment - that means she can say all sorts of controversial things and not have to see anyone actually reply and challenge her on her comments.

But if you do say controversial things on Twitter - and especially if you are a prominent person, you will get responses. From prominent people, including MPs.

cakeorwine · 05/07/2023 18:45

SunnyEgg · 05/07/2023 18:42

It's clear that Katherine can't take criticism - that is very clear from her tweeting history over the years.

Twitter doesn’t need to be the place where a school’s process is criticised

If there are issues there are established channels to address that. The public dressing down of someone by an MP isn’t the way to go.

And Twitter should not be used to write an open letter accusing someone of racism, especially one that is full of mistakes and lies, followed up by friendly chats with friendly media outlets and a doubling down when caught out by lies.

There is a point in pile ons when people should just stop. The point has been made.

Unfortunately, it's too easy to reply and retweet - and forget the consequences.

SunnyEgg · 05/07/2023 18:42

It's clear that Katherine can't take criticism - that is very clear from her tweeting history over the years.

Twitter doesn’t need to be the place where a school’s process is criticised

If there are issues there are established channels to address that. The public dressing down of someone by an MP isn’t the way to go.

lifeissweet · 05/07/2023 18:39

Yes. 'The Head Teacher Woman' is belittling. It's pretty clear that JP doesn't like her.

Still no evidence it's about race, though. It seems more likely to me that JP doesn't like KB on a political level and doesn't like her education philosophy, because those that the things that JP has a passion for. I honestly don't think her race has the slightest thing to do with anything.

As I said before, it is unpleasant seeing them take lumps out of each other and it's not professional from either of them. I think bringing race into it is a reach, though - and that is isn't really ok to throw that around in public about an MP in an incredibly multi-cultural constituency unless you have evidence or more than 'it's unconscious bias because it always is with lefties'

CurlewKate · 05/07/2023 18:37

Yes, I believe that KB has been on the receiving end of unconscious bias and racism in her life. Just not on this particular occasion.

itsgettingweird · 05/07/2023 18:33

SunnyEgg · 05/07/2023 17:38

When KB says she has experienced unconscious bias during her life do people believe her?

Yes.

Lots of minority groups receive unwanted bias. It also happens to my disabled ds.

But in their case I don't believe that's the issue.

KB has said lots of things in the public domain and posted something inappropriate. She has publicly repeated she doesn't think people should 'place the race card'.

However she's now decided that where is being pulled up for her mistakes and pulled up again for her mistakes whilst trying to cover her mistakes - that it must be due to unconscious bias. She's backed down from accusing racism.

I don't believe in this instance it is. Because it's KBs own words and actions being quoted as she misquotes others!

SunnyEgg · 05/07/2023 18:32

"That headteacher women" - I am not sure why she used that.

I know I wouldn’t like to receive any of that tweet, it’s not an offer to help, but this is belittling.

That’s why she used it

cakeorwine · 05/07/2023 18:30

SunnyEgg · 05/07/2023 18:20

You mentioned below you thought JP was offering help

cakeorwine
I thought she offered to write some lesson plans and policies on Domestic Abuse

Comes across as a criticism (even a threat) - not an offer;

‘I'm courageous enough to tweet under my own name. Seems that far from holding any kind of line that headteacher woman seems not to be able to take criticism of her actions. I'd be keen to hear of domestic abuse policies she has in her school or teaching plans, perhaps I'll write’

On reading that do you really think it’s an offer of help?

How does ‘that headteacher woman’ fit in with that and the rest which sounds critical

Do you get the "Holding the line " bit?

.At the Nat C conference, Katherine used that phrase as an example of people being courageous, standing up for their values and should "Hold the line".
I can see why Jess used the "Hold the line " comment - I am sure you can too.

Katherine tweets under Miss Snuffy - although her name is in her bio.

It's clear that Katherine can't take criticism - that is very clear from her tweeting history over the years.

"That headteacher women" - I am not sure why she used that. Better to have tagged her.

"I'd be keen to hear of domestic abuse policies she has in her school or teaching plans, perhaps I'll write"

Jess is passionate about teaching about, educating people on and preventing DV.

Where is the threat?

And - as you bought up "unconscious bias" - where is the unconscious bias?

SunnyEgg · 05/07/2023 18:20

cakeorwine · 05/07/2023 18:03

Absolutely.

The question is:

How do you prove unconscious sexism / racism/ homophobia?

And what evidence do you need to prove that someone has unconscious bias?

And if you are going to write an open letter accusing someone of hating them because:

""My view is that Ms Phillips' extreme and unprompted hostility towards me is motivated by my race. By this I do not mean that she hates all people of colour.

"Her behaviour is a clear example of 'unconscious bias'. I mean that she hates me, despite not knowing me, because she subscribes to the idea that Black and Asian individuals in public life owe a duty to voice opinions that match with a left-wing view of the world, or they are worthy of her contempt.""

, you would surely need to have a lot of evidence that could be believed and was true.

You mentioned below you thought JP was offering help

cakeorwine
I thought she offered to write some lesson plans and policies on Domestic Abuse

Comes across as a criticism (even a threat) - not an offer;

‘I'm courageous enough to tweet under my own name. Seems that far from holding any kind of line that headteacher woman seems not to be able to take criticism of her actions. I'd be keen to hear of domestic abuse policies she has in her school or teaching plans, perhaps I'll write’

On reading that do you really think it’s an offer of help?

How does ‘that headteacher woman’ fit in with that and the rest which sounds critical

lifeissweet · 05/07/2023 18:19

Agreed. I thought about Toby Young, but dismissed him as a crank and a highly unserious person. He wasn't a Head Teacher with any professional credentials. It didn't seem equivalent.

I'd also bet that JP has no time for him either!

NeverDropYourMooncup · 05/07/2023 18:14

lifeissweet · 05/07/2023 16:27

There is absolutely no evidence that JP criticises KB on the basis of being a right-leaning black woman. None whatsoever

There is no Head Teacher who is as much of a self-publicist. Name another one with this sort of profile. A white male if you like... I'll wait.

The only vaguely related ones I can think of would be

Toby Young - obviously not a head, but he was one of the founders of another free school and absolutely adored the controversy/attention.

The guy who was head of a private schools' association of some kind who fetched up in the papers regularly (about a decade ago) pontificating about things like children drinking wine so that they learned to be as middleclass as their parents and suchlike.

This headteacher seems to be angling for the void left by TY moving on from Education to twatter about Covid instead.

lifeissweet · 05/07/2023 18:12

SunnyEgg · 05/07/2023 17:38

When KB says she has experienced unconscious bias during her life do people believe her?

Yes. I'd be amazed if she hadn't at a lot of points in her life.

cakeorwine · 05/07/2023 18:07

I would also say that KB has unconscious bias towards people on the left - given her comments generalising about people on the Left.

And she has accused JP of unconscious bias because JP is on the Left wing and KB has unconscious bias towards people on the Left.

And has, over the last few days, dug in, done lots of interviews, tweets, and has herself contributed to a pile on on JP.

cakeorwine · 05/07/2023 18:03

SunnyEgg · 05/07/2023 17:38

When KB says she has experienced unconscious bias during her life do people believe her?

Absolutely.

The question is:

How do you prove unconscious sexism / racism/ homophobia?

And what evidence do you need to prove that someone has unconscious bias?

And if you are going to write an open letter accusing someone of hating them because:

""My view is that Ms Phillips' extreme and unprompted hostility towards me is motivated by my race. By this I do not mean that she hates all people of colour.

"Her behaviour is a clear example of 'unconscious bias'. I mean that she hates me, despite not knowing me, because she subscribes to the idea that Black and Asian individuals in public life owe a duty to voice opinions that match with a left-wing view of the world, or they are worthy of her contempt.""

, you would surely need to have a lot of evidence that could be believed and was true.

CecilyP · 05/07/2023 18:01

I am also surprised that KB used the "Aslan" tweet and misread it.

If JP had tweeted "You aren't no Asian" and if it was referring to Sunak, I am pretty sure that would have been in the news. Or on Twitter.

It would certainly seemed more than a little bit odd! While Aslan and Asian look pretty similar, especially on a phone, you’d think the lack of it making sense would make someone so a double take.

SunnyEgg · 05/07/2023 17:38

When KB says she has experienced unconscious bias during her life do people believe her?

cakeorwine · 05/07/2023 17:30

I am also surprised that KB used the "Aslan" tweet and misread it.

If JP had tweeted "You aren't no Asian" and if it was referring to Sunak, I am pretty sure that would have been in the news. Or on Twitter.

But she didn't.

I wonder if critical thinking is taught in that school.
I also wonder if either of the people involved have read "Thinking fast and slow" and thought about just engaging their brains before they tweet. Just to think about what they are saying, how it might come across and have they got their facts absolutely correct and is there any bias going on.

Something a lot of people should really do.

Quiverer · 05/07/2023 17:24

lifeissweet · 05/07/2023 16:27

There is absolutely no evidence that JP criticises KB on the basis of being a right-leaning black woman. None whatsoever

There is no Head Teacher who is as much of a self-publicist. Name another one with this sort of profile. A white male if you like... I'll wait.

It's really bizarre that KB thinks that JP would be in any way unfamiliar with the concept of black people being right wing. After all, she sits opposite a load of right-wingers a number of whom are black every time she goes into the House of Commons.

cakeorwine · 05/07/2023 17:21

I can see KB has done even more different claims on Twitter today - and the response from people who understand how Twitter works seems to contradict her claims - and she's basing the claims on a misinterpration of the evidence Alex gave to her when he told her the errors in her original claim.

As someone said, never before has a letter of complaint to the Labour Party been so looked forward to as they have loads of evidence to debunk her claims.

She is not just doubling down, she is quadrupling down.

lifeissweet · 05/07/2023 16:27

There is absolutely no evidence that JP criticises KB on the basis of being a right-leaning black woman. None whatsoever

There is no Head Teacher who is as much of a self-publicist. Name another one with this sort of profile. A white male if you like... I'll wait.

Exasperatednow · 05/07/2023 16:19

Swrigh1234 · 05/07/2023 14:45

Wow the racism on this thread against KB is really quite something. The mask really slips from the progressives when they find a target, doesn’t it. The hypocrisy is exposed yet again.

Evidence for your sweeping generalisation?

GuinnessBird · 05/07/2023 16:05

Swrigh1234 · 05/07/2023 14:45

Wow the racism on this thread against KB is really quite something. The mask really slips from the progressives when they find a target, doesn’t it. The hypocrisy is exposed yet again.

Receipts please.

itsgettingweird · 05/07/2023 15:53

Hobbi · 05/07/2023 08:48

@cakeorwine

That's the point I'm making when I said it's lazy. KB admits it would be ludicrous to call JP a racist so uses a definition of bias that is impossible to prove but will still plant the accusatory seed, rather than owning up to her errors.

Yes. I describe such people as being those who load the gun - but don't pull the trigger.

Swipe left for the next trending thread