Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this the mother of all calling out - Katherine Birbalsingh

767 replies

DramaFatigue · 02/07/2023 08:06

Katherine Birbalsingh has done the mother of all calling out and I can't help but sit here with my jaw on the kitchen table in awe.

She has written a 4-page open letter to Sir Kerr Starmer calling out Jess Phillip's behaviour online. Whilst I don't always agree with KB's methods of the school she runs, I do think that Jess Phillips behaviour towards her is shocking and unbefitting of someone who could be running the country. JP should resign TBH.

https://news.sky.com/story/headteacher-katharine-birbalsingh-brands-labour-mp-jess-phillips-social-media-posts-racist-and-bullying-12913139

Headteacher Katharine Birbalsingh brands Labour MP Jess Phillips' social media posts 'racist and bullying'

Katharine Birbalsingh addressed the open letter to Labour leader Sir Keir Starmer. Labour has not commented on the matter and Sky News has contacted Ms Phillips for her response.

https://news.sky.com/story/headteacher-katharine-birbalsingh-brands-labour-mp-jess-phillips-social-media-posts-racist-and-bullying-12913139

OP posts:
Thread gallery
48
cakeorwine · 05/07/2023 20:28

SunnyEgg · 05/07/2023 20:10

If MPs, or any one else doesn’t learn from it, then make sure you’re ready for the unconscious bias accusation

And rightly so.

Maybe MPs should do some unconscious bias training.

Parliament: Tory MPs to refuse unconscious bias training - BBC News

Several Conservative MPs say they will not take part in unconscious bias training provided by the House of Commons.
The training aims to tackle prejudices people are unaware they hold, on issues like race and gender.
Writing in the Mail this week, Ben Bradley called it "Orwellian" and "totally nonsensical".
Speaking on Thursday, Commons leader Jacob Rees-Mogg said it was for MPs to decide if they wanted to participate.
He said: "Finally, the House has made unconscious bias training available, and if people want to do it, that is a matter for them."
Mr Bradley, Conservative MP for Mansfield, said the training represented the "second phase of our re-education" after MPs attended sessions about valuing people in the workplace.

He added: "It seems totally nonsensical to me that, in my role as a representative of a community that has typically felt left behind and voiceless for many years, I should be advised that there are certain words I shouldn't use; certain issues that I should avoid; certain sensibilities that I should not offend.
"How am I to raise the true feelings of an electorate that broadly feels like it's being preached at by a metropolitan elite who neither understand nor care about them, if I have to walk on eggshells and dance around the problem?"
Several of his colleagues tweeted their agreement, including David Warburton, the MP for Somerton and Frome, who said he would "go no further down this rabbit hole".

Ben Bradley

Parliament: Tory MPs to refuse unconscious bias training

Commons authorities want to roll out the training, which is already given to staff, to all MPs.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-54282685

LittleBearPad · 05/07/2023 20:25

SunnyEgg · 05/07/2023 19:56

The time it took to write doesn’t really mean anything I don’t see why it should.

If she gets a whole load of flack because people don’t want to hear how she feels well tough really

She doesn’t have to say oh I didn’t feel this way because you lot say so, she did.

That’s the point of having a voice and telling your story

Having 6 weeks to write means you need to get your letter right.

She wasn’t against a deadline, she had time to write, edit and rewrite plus fact check her position.

Yes her letter was full of errors, badly written and too long.

Must try harder

LittleBearPad · 05/07/2023 20:23

SunnyEgg · 05/07/2023 20:05

Maybe MPs should think before they try to belittle black women on social media

If any lesson is learnt from that then good.

KB’s successfully made it about race for you hasn’t she?

SunnyEgg · 05/07/2023 20:10

If MPs, or any one else doesn’t learn from it, then make sure you’re ready for the unconscious bias accusation

And rightly so.

Clavinova · 05/07/2023 20:09

Kiwano

I forgot to add - I stand by my perception that Jess Phillips was bullying Katharine Birbalsingh. I don't know JP's motives for doing so - therefore I have no idea whether her attack on KB was racially motivated or not.

lifeissweet · 05/07/2023 20:08

If someone is blunt and opinionated as JP is (and I've already said on a few posts now that I don't like her use of Twitter for this reason), wouldn't it be worse for her not to speak her mind purely because the object of her criticism is a black woman? That is patronising, is it not?

cakeorwine · 05/07/2023 20:07

SunnyEgg · 05/07/2023 20:05

Maybe MPs should think before they try to belittle black women on social media

If any lesson is learnt from that then good.

Lessons need to be learnt.

Social media is so easy to see something, react, and once you've reacted, it's out there forever.

SunnyEgg · 05/07/2023 20:05

Maybe MPs should think before they try to belittle black women on social media

If any lesson is learnt from that then good.

cakeorwine · 05/07/2023 20:03

SunnyEgg · 05/07/2023 19:56

The time it took to write doesn’t really mean anything I don’t see why it should.

If she gets a whole load of flack because people don’t want to hear how she feels well tough really

She doesn’t have to say oh I didn’t feel this way because you lot say so, she did.

That’s the point of having a voice and telling your story

The time it took is relevant - she had plenty of time to think, to reflect and to ensure that she had accurate information.

And the letter she wrote was full of mistakes.

Writing an open letter like that is a very serious thing. You need to get it right

Is this the mother of all calling out - Katherine Birbalsingh
Clavinova · 05/07/2023 20:02

Kiwano
But then, you're the person who thinks Johnson was merely "unwise" to appoint a sex molester to a position of power within the party, and then to send people out to lie for him. I'm not sure your perceptions are reliable.

I also used the phrase 'error of judgment' in the same sentence - and in our previous discussion I described Chris Pincher's appointment as 'poor judgment'. Seems a fair assessment to me - but apparently you were not happy with 'poor judgment' either. Since our last discussion, I have read (on Wikipedia) that Theresa May also appointed Chris Pincher to the role of Deputy Chief Whip following allegations - I would have to say that TM made an error of judgment in Pincher's appointment as well - I don't believe her motives were nefarious (perhaps you do). I didn't actually address your point on whether Johnson 'sent people out to lie for him' during our last discussion (I didn't have time), although I did answer the same question when you asked me under your previous username. I am certain now that you are the same poster, even though you denied it - therefore I think my perceptions are reliable.

SunnyEgg · 05/07/2023 19:56

The time it took to write doesn’t really mean anything I don’t see why it should.

If she gets a whole load of flack because people don’t want to hear how she feels well tough really

She doesn’t have to say oh I didn’t feel this way because you lot say so, she did.

That’s the point of having a voice and telling your story

cakeorwine · 05/07/2023 19:56

*edit

Girls and physics - this was when she was the Social Mobility Adviser

Birbalsingh clarifies girls' choices on maths and physics A-levels - BBC News

A government social mobility adviser criticised for comments on A-level choices has admitted her language was clunky but that she had explained things as she saw them.

Appearing before MPs on Wednesday, Katharine Birbalsingh said physics was not a subject girls "tend to fancy", as it included “hard maths”.
On Thursday's Politics Live, she clarified this was a single comment based about her own school, and she had also given 20 minutes on other issues across the country that did not get the same publicity.
She added: "I am quite sincere, and I have not planned what I am going to say.”

Katharine Birbalsingh: Girls dislike hard maths, says education adviser - BBC News

A government social mobility adviser has been criticised for saying girls are less likely to choose physics A-level because it involves "hard maths".
Head teacher Katharine Birbalsingh told MPs it was not a subject girls "tend to fancy", adding: "I just think they don't like it."
She said 16% of A-level physics pupils at her school were girls, but she wasn't "campaigning" for this to go up.
The Institute of Physics (IOP) said it was alarmed by the comments.
Liberal Democrat education spokeswoman Munira Wilson also called on Ms Birbalsingh to apologise for her remarks.
"Just from my own knowledge of these things, physics isn't something that girls tend to fancy. They don't want to do it," she added.
"I just think they don't like it. There's a lot of hard maths in there that I think that they would rather not do.
"That's not to say there isn't hard stuff to do in biology and chemistry - there is, but it's not mathematical."
Asked to explain why she thought girls would be less likely to make the choice, she responded: "Research generally, they say that's just a natural thing.
"I mean I don't know. I can't say - I mean, I'm not an expert at that sort of thing. That's what they say.
"We're certainly not out there campaigning for more girls to do physics - we wouldn't do that, and I wouldn't want to do that," she added.
"I mean, I want them to do what they want to do."

Katharine Birbalsingh

My language was clunky - advisor on girls maths remarks

A government adviser criticised for comments on A-level choices says press focused on one part of what she said.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/av/uk-politics-61261873

cakeorwine · 05/07/2023 19:52

SunnyEgg · 05/07/2023 19:34

It has been a better discussion particularly where people have said they or their dc have experienced unconscious bias

One thing that happens for accent but not race is that lessens over time, but what can absolutely happen is there can be a trigger of an earlier awful feeling that reminds you again. It’s really gutting (rarely happens but I get to change my difference)

I do think what JP sent was intended to belittle, it probably hurt a bit and may have reminded KB of other life experiences where she felt a bit powerless and othered

It took 6 weeks to write that letter.
A letter full of mistakes.
On school paper.
In public.

It may well have triggered a reaction - but if you are going to do such a public thing, then you make sure you have it right and can back it up.

And when people point out your mistakes, you should really think about them and ask yourself, have I got this right?

But based on KBs previous tweets, she doesn't back down. See the "girls and maths " conversation she had.

SunnyEgg · 05/07/2023 19:34

It has been a better discussion particularly where people have said they or their dc have experienced unconscious bias

One thing that happens for accent but not race is that lessens over time, but what can absolutely happen is there can be a trigger of an earlier awful feeling that reminds you again. It’s really gutting (rarely happens but I get to change my difference)

I do think what JP sent was intended to belittle, it probably hurt a bit and may have reminded KB of other life experiences where she felt a bit powerless and othered

itsgettingweird · 05/07/2023 19:30

Just nasty. Be professional if it’s your professional account

You are right. KN should be professional because it's attached to her name and therefore the school she leads and also her role within government has held.

In my school bringing the school into disrepute as she has done is a disciplinary action.

minou123 · 05/07/2023 19:30

SunnyEgg · 05/07/2023 19:02

On whether I have. Yes for sure. Absolutely as someone who moved countries, not due to race though but I can imagine that’s even harder

I found it a good argument. I kind of didn’t get into the Harry stuff when he went on about it but I get it now. I also get do the work

To me that means listening and when someone says this is my experience you hear that rather than dismiss it

To me that means listening and when someone says this is my experience you hear that rather than dismiss it

Absolutely, I agree.

When KB said she has experienced white people, telling her she is betraying the left because as a black women she shouldn't hold right wing view (or words to the effect) - I was listening.
I was also listening when she said people on the right dismiss 'unconscious bias'.

I believe her. I do think she has experienced that, and I'm not going to dismiss this.

What I am questioning is, that KB experience of other white people telling her she owes a duty to voice opinions that match with a left-wing view automatically means JP thinks this as well.

KB has correlated:
I have experienced unconscious bias from white people in the past, due to my race = JP is white and criticised me, therefore JP has unconscious bias due to my race

I'm not sure that equation adds up.

cakeorwine · 05/07/2023 19:21

SunnyEgg · 05/07/2023 19:10

I think we get to tell our own stories and have our own voices

That’s the only way to overcome unconscious bias

KB doesn’t need to be relegated to the’ that woman’ corner by anyone really, least of all an MP she hasn’t met, she’s got her own life experience, which is true to her

True

Biases are fascinating - and when people learn about them, you can see them all the time.

Assuming Jess had written "You aren't no Asian" - I wonder if that appealed to a confirmation bias and so it helped form her view of Jess?

I recommend people read "Thinking fast and slow" - a good introduction to the way people think, react and biases.

CurlewKate · 05/07/2023 19:13

"We know KB has unconscious bias, because she thinks people on the left have a problem with black people on the right.
She also has conscious bias-she thinks girls are not as good at "hard maths" as boys!

SunnyEgg · 05/07/2023 19:10

I think we get to tell our own stories and have our own voices

That’s the only way to overcome unconscious bias

KB doesn’t need to be relegated to the’ that woman’ corner by anyone really, least of all an MP she hasn’t met, she’s got her own life experience, which is true to her

lifeissweet · 05/07/2023 19:06

There is a difference between dismissing it out of hand and thinking about it, reasoning it through and deciding it's not applicable here.

We know KB has unconscious bias, because she thinks people on the left have a problem with black people on the right.

There may be an experience she has had that has formed that generalisation, but she has taken that generalised bias of hers and projected it onto one person. I think that's pretty bad.

SunnyEgg · 05/07/2023 19:02

minou123 · 05/07/2023 18:58

Yes. I very much believe she has.

A lot of people have experienced unconscious bias during thier life.
I know I have, based on my sex, age, disability, religious beliefs etc.

Have you experienced it?

Interestingly, in that interview with GB news, KB admits she has her own unconscious bias towards men when she conducts interviews.
"I myself have unconscious bias when I'm appointing teachers. I'm looking for presence. Men can come across as having.. you know...if thier tall, or they have a deeper voice, I have to check myself and think is this me being biased or am I picking the right person"

I don't understand her rationale on this one. She explains it really well - everyone can have unconscious biases, including herself.
But in this instances, KB has sort of jumped from JP has unconscious bias towards her , to concluding this means JP "hates her" because JP thinks all Black and Asian people, who hold right wing views, are betraying the left. (or words to that effect)

On whether I have. Yes for sure. Absolutely as someone who moved countries, not due to race though but I can imagine that’s even harder

I found it a good argument. I kind of didn’t get into the Harry stuff when he went on about it but I get it now. I also get do the work

To me that means listening and when someone says this is my experience you hear that rather than dismiss it

SunnyEgg · 05/07/2023 18:58

itsgettingweird · 05/07/2023 18:53

If you are very public about your schools processes etc then you can't complain when the disagreements about those processes are also public.

Also - have you seen the schools complaints policy. It's very clear they won't deal with any complaints effectively anyway!

Yes she can. She doesn’t need to be belittled by MPs on Twitter because they hate her for whatever reason

And maybe stop hate following in general. Why do it, it sounds like people get to caught up in hating whomever for a hobby

I often hear programmes bemoaning the state of society and divisions and SM makes it worse. Nobody seems grown up enough to do anything about that. Much more fun calling a HT that woman etc

Just nasty. Be professional if it’s your professional account

minou123 · 05/07/2023 18:58

SunnyEgg · 05/07/2023 17:38

When KB says she has experienced unconscious bias during her life do people believe her?

Yes. I very much believe she has.

A lot of people have experienced unconscious bias during thier life.
I know I have, based on my sex, age, disability, religious beliefs etc.

Have you experienced it?

Interestingly, in that interview with GB news, KB admits she has her own unconscious bias towards men when she conducts interviews.
"I myself have unconscious bias when I'm appointing teachers. I'm looking for presence. Men can come across as having.. you know...if thier tall, or they have a deeper voice, I have to check myself and think is this me being biased or am I picking the right person"

I don't understand her rationale on this one. She explains it really well - everyone can have unconscious biases, including herself.
But in this instances, KB has sort of jumped from JP has unconscious bias towards her , to concluding this means JP "hates her" because JP thinks all Black and Asian people, who hold right wing views, are betraying the left. (or words to that effect)

cakeorwine · 05/07/2023 18:56

SunnyEgg · 05/07/2023 18:48

JP tweeted before the letter though so by then she really had got KB’s up

If an MP said ‘that woman’ about me and said they might write to my place of employment to see what’s going on I’d feel pretty pissed too

I am sure she had got KB's back up.

The letter came out 6 weeks later.
Full of mistakes.
And when called out on her mistakes, she called the people who said they were mistakes "liars"

"These people just lie and lie"

Except "these people " weren't lying.

I would suggest that KB needs to reflect about her response.

What do you think of her response to the people who pointed out her mistakes?

Is this the mother of all calling out - Katherine Birbalsingh
Is this the mother of all calling out - Katherine Birbalsingh
Is this the mother of all calling out - Katherine Birbalsingh
itsgettingweird · 05/07/2023 18:53

SunnyEgg · 05/07/2023 18:42

It's clear that Katherine can't take criticism - that is very clear from her tweeting history over the years.

Twitter doesn’t need to be the place where a school’s process is criticised

If there are issues there are established channels to address that. The public dressing down of someone by an MP isn’t the way to go.

If you are very public about your schools processes etc then you can't complain when the disagreements about those processes are also public.

Also - have you seen the schools complaints policy. It's very clear they won't deal with any complaints effectively anyway!