Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this the mother of all calling out - Katherine Birbalsingh

767 replies

DramaFatigue · 02/07/2023 08:06

Katherine Birbalsingh has done the mother of all calling out and I can't help but sit here with my jaw on the kitchen table in awe.

She has written a 4-page open letter to Sir Kerr Starmer calling out Jess Phillip's behaviour online. Whilst I don't always agree with KB's methods of the school she runs, I do think that Jess Phillips behaviour towards her is shocking and unbefitting of someone who could be running the country. JP should resign TBH.

https://news.sky.com/story/headteacher-katharine-birbalsingh-brands-labour-mp-jess-phillips-social-media-posts-racist-and-bullying-12913139

Headteacher Katharine Birbalsingh brands Labour MP Jess Phillips' social media posts 'racist and bullying'

Katharine Birbalsingh addressed the open letter to Labour leader Sir Keir Starmer. Labour has not commented on the matter and Sky News has contacted Ms Phillips for her response.

https://news.sky.com/story/headteacher-katharine-birbalsingh-brands-labour-mp-jess-phillips-social-media-posts-racist-and-bullying-12913139

OP posts:
Thread gallery
48
SunnyEgg · 06/07/2023 13:02

Hobbi · 06/07/2023 12:58

Apparently you can. A feeling born of entitlement and narcissism gives you license to slander someone. Who'd have thunk it?

Entitled and narcissistic?

She’s too loud.. I’d call you out for unconscious bias on that. Maybe she should stay in her lane

Hobbi · 06/07/2023 12:58

CurlewKate · 06/07/2023 12:41

Absolutely. She is entitled, of course, to feel in any way she does. She is not entitled to make entirely unsubstantiated and damaging accusations based entirely on this feelings.

Apparently you can. A feeling born of entitlement and narcissism gives you license to slander someone. Who'd have thunk it?

SunnyEgg · 06/07/2023 12:52

CurlewKate · 06/07/2023 12:41

Absolutely. She is entitled, of course, to feel in any way she does. She is not entitled to make entirely unsubstantiated and damaging accusations based entirely on this feelings.

Why not?

She feels she’s experienced unconscious bias, she knows what this is like, pp have agreed she’d know what that is like.

So you accept it but draw short at a Labour MP, because you feel favourably perhaps to that person and unfavourably towards KB.

That’s why the answer has to be ok I believe you, otherwise it’s just who represents you best.

It’s always going to be I believe you and if that’s an issue don’t belittle minority groups. It’s great as a tool for societal change.

You must see this as you say you’ve known about unconscious bias on the left for longer.

Hobbi · 06/07/2023 12:49

SunnyEgg · 06/07/2023 12:01

I’ll put it another way since some have said they have experienced unconscious bias

Someone makes you feel awful because they belittle you, in a professional setting perhaps

You want to tell people how it made you feel but find every error or lack of alignment to their views used as a reason to stop

By then you feel you haven’t been given a voice at all

That’s why I think anyone, regardless of what people think of your politics etc gets to tell their story. It doesn’t work otherwise

She has been given a voice, way beyond that of most people. And way beyond her competence. She was head of the Social Mobility Commission. In that role she ridiculed unconscious bias, thus diminishing the voices of minorities. Is there any criticism of right wing POC that would be valid in your view? If not, that seems a trifle disingenuous.

CurlewKate · 06/07/2023 12:41

Absolutely. She is entitled, of course, to feel in any way she does. She is not entitled to make entirely unsubstantiated and damaging accusations based entirely on this feelings.

SunnyEgg · 06/07/2023 12:30

CurlewKate · 06/07/2023 12:24

As I have said earlier, I am sure that KB has been on the receiving end of unconscious-and conscious- bias many times. But neither she, nor anyone else, has shown that is the case in this particular instance.

So you discount her view?

Surely she’s more the authority on how she feels than anyone else.

CurlewKate · 06/07/2023 12:24

As I have said earlier, I am sure that KB has been on the receiving end of unconscious-and conscious- bias many times. But neither she, nor anyone else, has shown that is the case in this particular instance.

SunnyEgg · 06/07/2023 12:01

I’ll put it another way since some have said they have experienced unconscious bias

Someone makes you feel awful because they belittle you, in a professional setting perhaps

You want to tell people how it made you feel but find every error or lack of alignment to their views used as a reason to stop

By then you feel you haven’t been given a voice at all

That’s why I think anyone, regardless of what people think of your politics etc gets to tell their story. It doesn’t work otherwise

Caramelatt · 06/07/2023 11:57

SunnyEgg · 06/07/2023 10:05

It’s not bizarre at all. That’s what process is there for.

Have you or your dc experienced unconscious bias?

and would you be ok with the language JP used?

Along the lines of ‘that woman’, or child, or would you find it belittling

If people can honestly say they wouldn’t mind if it happened to their dc well that’s up to them, I wouldn’t be.

I have experience unconscious bias. But that does not mean everything is unconscious bias, even when I make a mistake.

Have you seen the post Jess Phillips made to react to KB's tribute post about Tina Turner with her abuser in the photo. What is so racist in calling out that?

SunnyEgg · 06/07/2023 11:54

CurlewKate · 06/07/2023 11:51

AIBU to be delighted at the Right's late conversion to the concept of unconscious bias? Batter Kate than never, eh?

So you’ve known it a long time, but still deny it for KB

Not sure why that’s so good

LittleBearPad · 06/07/2023 11:53

SunnyEgg · 06/07/2023 11:33

If there are issues in the school proper channels, as I’m sure anyone who works would ask for.

JP offered to write DV lesson plans for her this really is nonsense though. It was a public dressing down not a kind offer.

If she talks with what people view as unsavoury people it still doesn’t mean that she alone doesn’t get to have a voice.

She gets that as other minority women should

That it ruffles people on the left isn’t a factor. If you want society to change around unconscious bias you’ll need to step aside and let people speak, even if it’s not completely aligned to your politics.

As a party with a not great record on race via anti semitism I’d actually be inclined to say don’t do it again

She can if she thinks she’s immune, but I think it would be a mistake for her career. I’m reminded a bit of Emily Thornberry too who did that white van tweet.

Basically it’s not within your gift to silence KB or other minority groups.

No one is silencing KB. I think it would be impossible but nor should it be tried.

Equally people are allowed to question what she says, respond to it and point out her errors. They are also allowed to say she appears to be behaving unprofessionally and may be bringing her school into disrepute by writing a poorly thought through personal letter on school letterhead. They are also allowed to think she’s focussed on personal publicity.

SunnyEgg · 06/07/2023 11:53

I’m not obviously doing anything other than being more aware of unconscious bias and hoping people will accept she has authority on how it made her feel.

KB like anyone else gets to speak.

All the excuses on why not don’t change that for me.

If people really do want societal structure to rebalance for minority groups then it’s for all, not some.

CurlewKate · 06/07/2023 11:51

AIBU to be delighted at the Right's late conversion to the concept of unconscious bias? Batter Kate than never, eh?

Hobbi · 06/07/2023 11:48

So you are ignoring every single point I asked about including, and I believe this to be extraordinary important, her recent conversion to unconscious bias theory? You are obviously also setting your argument around party political lines. I don't want to silence her, eventually she will spout enough nonsense and lies that even the Daily Mail will abandon her. As I said previously, my ethnicity has the lowest achievement academically in the UK and is frequently vilified without sanction by people in the public sphere and on SM. I still wouldn't expect impunity if I lied and courted publicity through promotion of evidence free policy.

SunnyEgg · 06/07/2023 11:33

If there are issues in the school proper channels, as I’m sure anyone who works would ask for.

JP offered to write DV lesson plans for her this really is nonsense though. It was a public dressing down not a kind offer.

If she talks with what people view as unsavoury people it still doesn’t mean that she alone doesn’t get to have a voice.

She gets that as other minority women should

That it ruffles people on the left isn’t a factor. If you want society to change around unconscious bias you’ll need to step aside and let people speak, even if it’s not completely aligned to your politics.

As a party with a not great record on race via anti semitism I’d actually be inclined to say don’t do it again

She can if she thinks she’s immune, but I think it would be a mistake for her career. I’m reminded a bit of Emily Thornberry too who did that white van tweet.

Basically it’s not within your gift to silence KB or other minority groups.

Hobbi · 06/07/2023 11:24

@SunnyEgg
And you still haven't reconciled the fact that KB said unconscious bias was nonsense, put a child in isolation for having what she described as an 'Afro' hairstyle, lied about 'the left's' plans for the curriculum and was, in fact, the one who reported JP to her boss. JP offered to write DV lesson plans for her, and accused her, very accurately, of not being able to take criticism. This is before we discuss the platform she gave to Jordan Peterson and his delightful views on women.

SunnyEgg · 06/07/2023 11:17

Hobbi · 06/07/2023 11:12

@SunnyEgg
She didn't say 'that woman', she said 'that headteacher woman.' A different emphasis, I'm sure you'll agree. And JP didn't use that term in isolation, it was in response to KB's words and actions. FYI, KB is at it again today, claiming that the last decade has seen improvements in education (😳) and that Labour's revealed policies focusing on skills and a modernised curriculum require god's intervention. She repeatedly demonstrates her lack of understanding of educational research and comparative standards.

Fine you think she does the last line, no issue

But no it doesn’t change emphasis at all.

Pp have agreed it was belittling anyway, so even if people deflect many can already see that.

So JP can continue to talk to people like that on Twitter if she doesn’t learn from this, but I’d suggest she quits it for black or minority people otherwise a general picture will start to build. And other people will tell their story

As they should as that’s how you address power imbalance in society.

Hobbi · 06/07/2023 11:12

@SunnyEgg
She didn't say 'that woman', she said 'that headteacher woman.' A different emphasis, I'm sure you'll agree. And JP didn't use that term in isolation, it was in response to KB's words and actions. FYI, KB is at it again today, claiming that the last decade has seen improvements in education (😳) and that Labour's revealed policies focusing on skills and a modernised curriculum require god's intervention. She repeatedly demonstrates her lack of understanding of educational research and comparative standards.

SinnerBoy · 06/07/2023 11:01

Caramelatt · Today 10:40

How what JP posted is racist? KB is a bigger bully for accusing JP of racism and causing people to get all worked up.

A school which KB was in charge of lost a racial discrimination case and had to pay a Black girl more than £8,000.

KB insisted that the girl should shave her head, because her Afro "was messy." The girl was put into isolation, because she wouldn't follow KB's order to shave her head.

KB accusing someone else of racism is grimly ironic.

SunnyEgg · 06/07/2023 10:51

Hobbi · 06/07/2023 10:49

@SunnyEgg

If I foolishly accused an MP with a proven history of defending minority rights of racism, I might expect to be called worse than 'that woman.' Nevertheless you are using JP's response as an excuse for KB's prior behaviour. That's fallacious reasoning.

Surely you have the order wrong here.

JP said it before the accusation returned.

SunnyEgg · 06/07/2023 10:49

lifeissweet · 06/07/2023 10:44

You seem to be mixing up two issues here, @SunnyEgg.

'That woman' is belittling. JP doesn't like KB and uses that sort of language towards her. I think she probably does that to a lot of people.

I don't like the way she addresses people on Twitter from a professional standpoint.

Does that say anything about unconscious bias though? I don't think so. She is blunt and 'belittling' with a lot of people regardless of their ethnicity.

I’m not, I’m centring KB as the person who gets to tell her own story. Not that which is determined by others. Not by JP and not by posters on here.

That's how you start to address the issue of unconscious bias in society. People tell their story where typically in the past that was not facilitated.

JP will have to learn that minority women may well find it similar to other incidences of unconscious bias and say so.

If she needs training on that to change her approach then so be it.

Hobbi · 06/07/2023 10:49

@SunnyEgg

If I foolishly accused an MP with a proven history of defending minority rights of racism, I might expect to be called worse than 'that woman.' Nevertheless you are using JP's response as an excuse for KB's prior behaviour. That's fallacious reasoning.

AgathaSpencerGregson · 06/07/2023 10:47

lifeissweet · 06/07/2023 10:44

You seem to be mixing up two issues here, @SunnyEgg.

'That woman' is belittling. JP doesn't like KB and uses that sort of language towards her. I think she probably does that to a lot of people.

I don't like the way she addresses people on Twitter from a professional standpoint.

Does that say anything about unconscious bias though? I don't think so. She is blunt and 'belittling' with a lot of people regardless of their ethnicity.

But this is always the problem. We can wonder whether such language would be used to a white male. I suspect it wouldn’t, but you can’t prove it.
what’s interesting is who we demand proof from and who we don’t. When the right type of person (ie one the left sympathises with) complains of racial bias, we don’t seem to be quite so exacting.

lifeissweet · 06/07/2023 10:44

You seem to be mixing up two issues here, @SunnyEgg.

'That woman' is belittling. JP doesn't like KB and uses that sort of language towards her. I think she probably does that to a lot of people.

I don't like the way she addresses people on Twitter from a professional standpoint.

Does that say anything about unconscious bias though? I don't think so. She is blunt and 'belittling' with a lot of people regardless of their ethnicity.

SunnyEgg · 06/07/2023 10:42

Hobbi · 06/07/2023 10:37

I don't hate her, that's a ludicrous accusation. I am variously bewildered and concerned about her beliefs regarding education and her influence on public policy. I engaged with her on Twitter before I had any idea of her ethnicity - she was rambling on about original sin, of all things, justifying her potentially dangerous and haphazard approach to behaviour management and safeguarding. As for experiencing unconscious bias, my ethnicity is just about the only one where overt prejudice is openly accepted. I still deserve to be treated and judged based on my wilful words and deeds.

So would you be ok with an MP or anyone referring to you as ‘that woman’?

And the rest of the tweet on approaching your employer

You are welcome to talk about her policies and why you disagree with them, I’m talking about language and how someone who has experienced a life of unconscious bias could feel.

And their right to have a voice on that.

Swipe left for the next trending thread