Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this the mother of all calling out - Katherine Birbalsingh

767 replies

DramaFatigue · 02/07/2023 08:06

Katherine Birbalsingh has done the mother of all calling out and I can't help but sit here with my jaw on the kitchen table in awe.

She has written a 4-page open letter to Sir Kerr Starmer calling out Jess Phillip's behaviour online. Whilst I don't always agree with KB's methods of the school she runs, I do think that Jess Phillips behaviour towards her is shocking and unbefitting of someone who could be running the country. JP should resign TBH.

https://news.sky.com/story/headteacher-katharine-birbalsingh-brands-labour-mp-jess-phillips-social-media-posts-racist-and-bullying-12913139

Headteacher Katharine Birbalsingh brands Labour MP Jess Phillips' social media posts 'racist and bullying'

Katharine Birbalsingh addressed the open letter to Labour leader Sir Keir Starmer. Labour has not commented on the matter and Sky News has contacted Ms Phillips for her response.

https://news.sky.com/story/headteacher-katharine-birbalsingh-brands-labour-mp-jess-phillips-social-media-posts-racist-and-bullying-12913139

OP posts:
Thread gallery
48
Onegroupcard · 02/07/2023 13:53

cakeorwine · 02/07/2023 13:45

I would love to know how many pupils are sent to the referral centre and how many get demerits / detentions - and if that stat changes over the years a pupil is at the school. There is a strict uniform policy.

Uniform-and-Appearance-Policy-September-2022.pdf (michaela.education)

I remember being at school and not allowed to remove my jumper in 28 degree plus weather.

That list exemplifies almost everything I hate about the school system and one of the many reasons I prefer to keep my children out of it.

WhiteFire · 02/07/2023 13:53

I'm not sure why so many posters think the options for, checks notes black, brown and working class white children is a Michaela style school or a school that subjects them to "low inspirational messaging"

Many schools are working with a similar cohort and not having go to such drastic measures and are still achieving good outcomes for their pupils.

AgathaSpencerGregson · 02/07/2023 13:52

Endlesssummer2022 · 02/07/2023 13:26

This. As a mixed raced woman with mixed raced kids, I despise the left wing view they we must all be victims. Many left wing white people prefer that black and brown people stay as victims and as their pet projects for help. Victim mentality and low expectations will do nothing for black and brown children (and white working class children).

I have one DC in private secondary and one in state primary. DC2 will also go to the private secondary (if they pass the exam, God willing) because I will not have them exposed to low aspirational messaging.

I do not agree with everything or even most things KB says but I do agree with some of her methods. The children who go to her school will be much more ready to be the next generation of leaders than if they went to some school where the teachers just celebrated BLM once a year and told them all they are is the descendants of slaves. They would also let them get away with all kinds, because they are disadvantaged, as though this will help them in the real adult world. These same teachers will be safe in the knowledge their own kids aren’t given these messages, have high self esteem and see themselves as being able to be high achievers. Some of the messaging I received from teachers about my prospects was appalling, thank goodness I didn’t listen.

Some of this reminds me of what my FIL, from a working class background in a pit village in Yorkshire says. Everyone around him voted labour but he never did as he said he felt the Labour Party wanted people like him kept down, to be pitied and patronised and patted on the head. But those were the days of the grammar schools were expectations were not low, at least for those who could get in. Labour did for them
of course.

cakeorwine · 02/07/2023 13:50

luckylavender · 02/07/2023 13:29

I haven't followed this recent spat. But wasn't there something about children in KB's school being alienated if their dinner money accounts weren't up to date? They were made to eat in isolation and had something very very basic. That is horrible if true.

Headteacher defends policy of putting pupils in 'lunch isolation' | School meals | The Guardian

Katharine Birbalsingh, the head of Michaela community school in north-west London who imposed the policy, argued that the children affected were from dysfunctional homes and needed the school’s support.

“Should we charge a poor single mum twice so she can pay for Jonny just because she has a sense of personal responsibility and Jonny’s mother doesn’t?” Birbalsingh said.
“Free school meals looks after the poorest. Even then we have all sorts of systems for people who really are in financial need, and I mean the real ones. I don’t mean the ones who are playing the system, trying to get other poor families to pay for their child’s food.”
The controversy surfaced after the Daily Mail reported that a parent of a pupil received a letter from the school’s deputy head saying: “You are currently £75 overdue. If this full amount is not received within this week your child will be placed in lunch isolation.”

The letter sent in June said that pupils in lunch isolation “will receive a sandwich and a piece of fruit only. They will spend the entire 60-minute period in lunch isolation. Only when the entire outstanding amount is paid in full will they be allowed into family lunch with their classmates.”

Headteacher defends policy of putting pupils in 'lunch isolation'

Katharine Birbalsingh says lunches where children are separated from classmates do not target those on free meals or with money issues

https://www.theguardian.com/education/2016/jul/29/headteacher-defends-policy-of-putting-pupils-in-lunch-isolation

Onegroupcard · 02/07/2023 13:48

Demerits for being "distracted" is grossly ableist for neurodiverse pupils.

cakeorwine · 02/07/2023 13:45

I would love to know how many pupils are sent to the referral centre and how many get demerits / detentions - and if that stat changes over the years a pupil is at the school. There is a strict uniform policy.

Uniform-and-Appearance-Policy-September-2022.pdf (michaela.education)

https://michaela.education/wp-content/uploads/2022/11/Uniform-and-Appearance-Policy-September-2022.pdf

HermioneWeasley · 02/07/2023 13:32

Exactly @Endlesssummer2022

luckylavender · 02/07/2023 13:29

WilkinsonM · 02/07/2023 08:31

Are people missing the bit about Jess Philips essentially saying KB is a terrible headteacher and her school is unsafe? That's the bit KB is objecting to, not that she called out her poor photo choice on twitter.

I haven't followed this recent spat. But wasn't there something about children in KB's school being alienated if their dinner money accounts weren't up to date? They were made to eat in isolation and had something very very basic. That is horrible if true.

Endlesssummer2022 · 02/07/2023 13:26

HermioneWeasley · 02/07/2023 11:08

I’m struggling to put into words how angry some of the comments are making me. Just because this school isn’t a perfect fit for all kids doesn’t mean that it shouldn’t exist to benefit the many many capable children who need boundaries, discipline and high expectations. These exist in the form of grammar schools in white affluent suburbs, but apparently all poor kids and black and brown kids must be sacrificed for the greater good.

This. As a mixed raced woman with mixed raced kids, I despise the left wing view they we must all be victims. Many left wing white people prefer that black and brown people stay as victims and as their pet projects for help. Victim mentality and low expectations will do nothing for black and brown children (and white working class children).

I have one DC in private secondary and one in state primary. DC2 will also go to the private secondary (if they pass the exam, God willing) because I will not have them exposed to low aspirational messaging.

I do not agree with everything or even most things KB says but I do agree with some of her methods. The children who go to her school will be much more ready to be the next generation of leaders than if they went to some school where the teachers just celebrated BLM once a year and told them all they are is the descendants of slaves. They would also let them get away with all kinds, because they are disadvantaged, as though this will help them in the real adult world. These same teachers will be safe in the knowledge their own kids aren’t given these messages, have high self esteem and see themselves as being able to be high achievers. Some of the messaging I received from teachers about my prospects was appalling, thank goodness I didn’t listen.

WhiteFire · 02/07/2023 13:08

CecilyP · 02/07/2023 12:57

And it looks like SEN children are admitted on the over subscribed criteria IF the school is named on the ECHP which I don't know is unusual or not

Pretty much all schools have that on their over subscription criteria. The numbers involved are usually very small.

The vast majority of children with SEN do not have an EHCP, they will be the ones who will "sink or swim" in an environment like this.

DrManhattan · 02/07/2023 13:08

100% jess P
She sounds like one of the most normal MPs we have.

cakeorwine · 02/07/2023 13:05

I can see KB is retweeting supportive tweets of her.
I wonder if JP will comment / retweet the response from Alex Sturdy which seems to contradict the claims made by KB - or will that then lead to a pile on?

CecilyP · 02/07/2023 12:57

And it looks like SEN children are admitted on the over subscribed criteria IF the school is named on the ECHP which I don't know is unusual or not

Pretty much all schools have that on their over subscription criteria. The numbers involved are usually very small.

AgathaSpencerGregson · 02/07/2023 12:56

cakeorwine · 02/07/2023 11:57

When someone is challenged over something and that person is a member of a minority group, how do you know if the person is challenging you because of your race / gender / religion / sexuality etc or are they just challenging your behaviour / comments?

That’s the issue isn’t it? It can be very difficult to pinpoint unconscious and institutionalised bias - and very often that’s only part of a picture with political or personal differences also influencing how people behave to each other.
what’s interesting to me is that all of this has been quite widely discussed since summer 2020 and the “progressive” consensus seems to be we should listen to ethnic minority experience and be alert to unconscious bias. But once someone who is viewed less favourably by progressives comes along, all of that gets chucked in the trash.

babbscrabbs · 02/07/2023 12:56

AlienatedChildGrown · 02/07/2023 12:41

I have a formal diagnosis of dyslexia and ADHD

Thank god for the school that did not lower expectations for me. Because I thrived (although some of the 70s stuff I could have done without).

I nosedived in a not very elegant manner when I moved to a progressive school that didn’t have clear, scrupulously policed boundaries that were unequally applied.

People with the same disorder do not necessarily blossom/wilt under the exact same conditions.

KB herself probably has ADHD

babbscrabbs · 02/07/2023 12:55

nopuppiesallowed · 02/07/2023 09:08

@Onegroupcard
I've been watching another thread about appalling behaviour in schools where teachers and children are routinely bullied - eg a child getting up during a lesson, marching over to another pupil and sitting down hard on his arm. When the teacher told him off, he flung a chair at her and asked "What's your problem?". The number of posters in despair at the behaviour in their children's schools is shocking. You may not like / agree with KB's approach to teaching and behaviour, but she doesn't have this problem in her school - in fact, she has parents queuing up to get their children a place there and she has children from this inner city school regularly getting places in Oxbridge and other Russell Group universities. She demands good behaviour from children with impoverished and broken backgrounds. Personally, I feel her approach should be adopted by all schools.

OR

Maybe we need to look into why a small number of children are behaving like this and aim to treat the root cause, so that the majority of children who DO behave in class don't have to have a rigid, micro controlled, prison-like environment?

LittleBearPad · 02/07/2023 12:51

cakeorwine · 02/07/2023 12:48

KB does seem to have made a mistake in one of the tweets she used as evidence

"You aren't no Aslan" in a tweet about Rishi Sunak, She seems to have misread that as "You aren't no Asian" and used that to accuse JP of racism.

She's also used school headed paper - which seems a bit of a brave thing to do as it represents the school, not herself.

Using the school letterhead isn’t on.

I’d be interested in what her board of governors thinks about that.

cakeorwine · 02/07/2023 12:48

KB does seem to have made a mistake in one of the tweets she used as evidence

"You aren't no Aslan" in a tweet about Rishi Sunak, She seems to have misread that as "You aren't no Asian" and used that to accuse JP of racism.

She's also used school headed paper - which seems a bit of a brave thing to do as it represents the school, not herself.

AlienatedChildGrown · 02/07/2023 12:41

LittleBearPad · 02/07/2023 12:27

She excludes or manages out any child who is in any way problematic.

Fine if your child doesn’t have SEND or difficult home life etc. What if they do. There’s no place in Michaela for them.

I have a formal diagnosis of dyslexia and ADHD

Thank god for the school that did not lower expectations for me. Because I thrived (although some of the 70s stuff I could have done without).

I nosedived in a not very elegant manner when I moved to a progressive school that didn’t have clear, scrupulously policed boundaries that were unequally applied.

People with the same disorder do not necessarily blossom/wilt under the exact same conditions.

Alyso · 02/07/2023 12:29

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

LittleBearPad · 02/07/2023 12:29

Dolphinnoises · 02/07/2023 12:21

Rather undermines her whole argument.

cakeorwine · 02/07/2023 12:28

She is absolutely targeted for her race, by people who can’t stand that somebody of her race doesn’t toe the line of “opinions people like you are supposed to have

If she was a white woman, would she be targetted for being female?
How do you know she is targetted for her race or is she targetted because of her views?

She claimed that children must be taught to be good because they are born with original Sin

Katharine Birbalsingh is right: children do have original sin | The Spectator

This caused some backlash on Twitter.

A prominent headteacher saying children must be taught to be good because they have original sin should expect some backlash.

If she gets backlash for such comment, are the people who comment on such things racist? Or sexist?

Katharine Birbalsingh is right: children do have original sin

When my son was about six he heard something at school about slavery but was not quite clear what it was all about. So I spelled it out. I told him that a slave was someone that someone else owned and ordered around and probably mistreated. I waited fo...

https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/katharine-birbalsingh-is-right-children-do-have-original-sin/

LittleBearPad · 02/07/2023 12:27

AlienatedChildGrown · 02/07/2023 12:17

I follow her. Have done for years. That specific photo with that that tagline was an unintentional error. Which she explained immediately.

Having personally been on the sharp end of one of your MPs (thankfully now ex… although there might be something in the water in certain parts) I have ample sympathy for anybody one of them choses to focus on with a less than “the truth, the whole truth, nothing but the truth” perspective. I discovered there is fuck all you can do about. But if she has found a way to remind MPs certain standards of engagement are expected of them, then good.

She is absolutely targeted for her race, by people who can’t stand that somebody of her race doesn’t toe the line of “opinions people like you are supposed to have”. And that was before she poured fuel on the fire by getting an exceptional outcome for her school. Progress 8 ? Or something like that. It measured not just fixed outcomes like GCSEs results, but the amount of improvement pupils had made. When that came out the amount of battering she took went through the roof and remained consistently high.

I like her. She isn’t somebody who witters on about “strong women”. She just goes about her business being one. If she’s had enough of whipped up outrage on the internet by the “be kind” mobsters then more power to her elbow. If the accused have been doing nothing to be ashamed of then they have no reason to be concerned. It not like they are unspeakable humans, or worse < the horror!> a small c conservative, who won’t get a fair hearing from the get go.

She excludes or manages out any child who is in any way problematic.

Fine if your child doesn’t have SEND or difficult home life etc. What if they do. There’s no place in Michaela for them.

Onegroupcard · 02/07/2023 12:22

Dolphinnoises · 02/07/2023 12:21

Link doesn't work for me.