Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this the mother of all calling out - Katherine Birbalsingh

767 replies

DramaFatigue · 02/07/2023 08:06

Katherine Birbalsingh has done the mother of all calling out and I can't help but sit here with my jaw on the kitchen table in awe.

She has written a 4-page open letter to Sir Kerr Starmer calling out Jess Phillip's behaviour online. Whilst I don't always agree with KB's methods of the school she runs, I do think that Jess Phillips behaviour towards her is shocking and unbefitting of someone who could be running the country. JP should resign TBH.

https://news.sky.com/story/headteacher-katharine-birbalsingh-brands-labour-mp-jess-phillips-social-media-posts-racist-and-bullying-12913139

Headteacher Katharine Birbalsingh brands Labour MP Jess Phillips' social media posts 'racist and bullying'

Katharine Birbalsingh addressed the open letter to Labour leader Sir Keir Starmer. Labour has not commented on the matter and Sky News has contacted Ms Phillips for her response.

https://news.sky.com/story/headteacher-katharine-birbalsingh-brands-labour-mp-jess-phillips-social-media-posts-racist-and-bullying-12913139

OP posts:
Thread gallery
48
OneTC · 07/07/2023 11:46

Saying you're not a racist but you're being racist because you can't help it is a pretty clear accusation of racism.

I don't think there's any unconscious in JPs bias. She' quite clear why she doesn't like her. It's because she's a dickhead

Clavinova · 07/07/2023 11:05

Blossomtoes
Is the head of that pin you’re dancing on painful Clav?

I don't know what you mean - but have a nice day - I'm off to Hampton Court.

Blossomtoes · 07/07/2023 10:41

Clavinova · 07/07/2023 10:06

itsgettingweird
My ds is a swimmer.

Yes - I know.

"That swimmer boy" wouldn't be insulting with regards unconscious bias towards his disability.
It would be a way of defining you meant him!

But I deliberately labelled him as 'that swimming boy' for my example (not 'that swimmer boy') - 'swimming boy' undermines the ability and professionalism of a disabled athlete (in my opinion).

Is the head of that pin you’re dancing on painful Clav?

Clavinova · 07/07/2023 10:15

itsgettingweird
The question that doesn't seem to have been asked and therefore answered is why KP reacted to JPs tweet when hundreds of others had tweeted the same previously.
I find the psychology around the mind fascinating.

KB answers that question throughout her letter:
[JP] called into question my school's safeguarding policies in a deliberate attempt to challenge my competence as a Headteacher. Ms Phillips is the official Labour representative on matters of safeguarding.

I repeat, Ms Phillips is not an ordinary member of the public but Shadow Minister for Safeguarding.

She also points out that JP tweeted 4 times and has over 630k followers.

Clavinova · 07/07/2023 10:06

itsgettingweird
My ds is a swimmer.

Yes - I know.

"That swimmer boy" wouldn't be insulting with regards unconscious bias towards his disability.
It would be a way of defining you meant him!

But I deliberately labelled him as 'that swimming boy' for my example (not 'that swimmer boy') - 'swimming boy' undermines the ability and professionalism of a disabled athlete (in my opinion).

cakeorwine · 07/07/2023 08:05

itsgettingweird · 07/07/2023 07:21

The question that doesn't seem to have been asked and therefore answered is why KP reacted to JPs tweet when hundreds of others had tweeted the same previously.

I find the psychology around the mind fascinating.

Indeed.

And I wonder how much her misreading of "Aslan" contributed to her thought process and make her decide to write that ietter.

And the process she has gone through this week when she has been pulled up on her mistakes.

itsgettingweird · 07/07/2023 07:21

The question that doesn't seem to have been asked and therefore answered is why KP reacted to JPs tweet when hundreds of others had tweeted the same previously.

I find the psychology around the mind fascinating.

SunnyEgg · 07/07/2023 06:55

itsgettingweird · 07/07/2023 04:24

I agree with part of this pp She is entitled to feel however she feels. but would add and she gets to talk about it.

She does get to talk about it. Correct.

The same way we get to discuss how we dislike how she runs her school. We get to discuss how we dislike the tweets she put out.

The same way we get to discuss how she misread Aslan for Asian and therefore must have been reacting in some kind of bias herself and it was - at best - unwise to publicly use this against the person as she was incorrect.

The point is we all get to discuss out thoughts and feelings and to discuss them publicly if we choose.

You can't limit that privilege to one side of a debate based on a characteristic or you do end up silencing people and you don't end up with a balanced view.

She does get to talk about it. Correct.

I’m glad you agree.

You can certainly discuss how she runs her school. Someone might actively not choose that school based on it, which is up to them.

Some of it though, all the narcissist, entitled, self publicist stuff is similar to the Meghan Markle threads, some object but I don’t think they’ve been stopped yet.

I probably would take care with non anonymous platforms though, as JP should. Hopefully a bit of a wake up on how not to speak to black women where the latter might have her own view on how belittling she found it.

Re your ds, surely his view on whether or not he found it belittling would be more relevant.

itsgettingweird · 07/07/2023 04:24

I agree with part of this pp She is entitled to feel however she feels. but would add and she gets to talk about it.

She does get to talk about it. Correct.

The same way we get to discuss how we dislike how she runs her school. We get to discuss how we dislike the tweets she put out.

The same way we get to discuss how she misread Aslan for Asian and therefore must have been reacting in some kind of bias herself and it was - at best - unwise to publicly use this against the person as she was incorrect.

The point is we all get to discuss out thoughts and feelings and to discuss them publicly if we choose.

You can't limit that privilege to one side of a debate based on a characteristic or you do end up silencing people and you don't end up with a balanced view.

itsgettingweird · 07/07/2023 04:20

Clavinova · 06/07/2023 22:54

itsgettingweird
My ds has experienced unconscious bias due to his disability.
But calling him "that boy" wouldn't make me think it's unconscious bias. As he's male!

The comparison wouldn't be 'that boy' - it would be 'that [ ... ] boy'
'that headteacher woman' , 'that MP woman' , 'that swimming boy' - I don't like any of those those labels.

My ds is a swimmer.

"That swimmer boy" wouldn't be insulting with regards unconscious bias towards his disability.

It would be a way of defining you meant him!

It's a lazy choice of words I admit. But I really would be discouraging him from making defamatory remarks and accusations of unconscious bias towards his disability because someone defined him by the "job" he does.

cakeorwine · 07/07/2023 00:13

SunnyEgg · 07/07/2023 00:05

I watched the link up thread of the interview, which is similar in wording to the unconscious bias tweet

If someone hadn't seen the interview and had just read the headlines, I think people would get the impression that KB had accused JP of being racist.

I wonder how much that misreading of Aslan affected her response and prompted her to write the letter?

I wonder how much her unconscious bias toward people on the Left prompted her to believe JP was like that and got her to write that letter?

SunnyEgg · 07/07/2023 00:05

SingingNettles · 06/07/2023 23:52

Its a plain and obvious accusation of racism. Surely the nature of the accusation is not up for debate?

When SunnyEgg said “Even KB has said she doesn't think it was racism” I assumed KB had been back-pedalling.

I watched the link up thread of the interview, which is similar in wording to the unconscious bias tweet

cakeorwine · 07/07/2023 00:02

SingingNettles · 06/07/2023 23:52

Its a plain and obvious accusation of racism. Surely the nature of the accusation is not up for debate?

When SunnyEgg said “Even KB has said she doesn't think it was racism” I assumed KB had been back-pedalling.

Just some of her recent tweets

I have to say that that letter has had some cropped images so any context is lost on the images.

She has posted the "Sure" GIF from Schitt's Creek without posting the tweet that was under it - and has claimed that the "sure" is JP's response to KB saying she does not support DV

It's also quite a claim to suggest that JP suggested that she supported DV and that the children in her care were in danger. It is also quite a claim to suggest that it was JP's actions that led to a lot of abuse from other people on Twitter.

Is this the mother of all calling out - Katherine Birbalsingh
Is this the mother of all calling out - Katherine Birbalsingh
Is this the mother of all calling out - Katherine Birbalsingh
Is this the mother of all calling out - Katherine Birbalsingh
SingingNettles · 06/07/2023 23:52

Its a plain and obvious accusation of racism. Surely the nature of the accusation is not up for debate?

When SunnyEgg said “Even KB has said she doesn't think it was racism” I assumed KB had been back-pedalling.

cakeorwine · 06/07/2023 23:45

Sorry - this was on the page after.

Is this the mother of all calling out - Katherine Birbalsingh
cakeorwine · 06/07/2023 23:42

In the letter, KB claims that JP hates her because she is black and dared to speak at the Nat C conference

She "holds me in contempt" for not bending the knee and considering her master"

The reason she attacked me is because as a white woman on the left , she feels she owns me.

Next to these words are the tweet that she thought said "You aren't no Asian" when it said "You aren't no Aslan"

Why would she put that tweet next to those words - is it supposed to be evidence of JPs "racism" and wanting to own her and consider her "master"

She read the tweet wrong - and those are very strong words to use saying that JP holds her in contempt for not bending the knee and considering her master and thinking she owns me - and then using a tweet that she thought was racist as evidence.

Is this the mother of all calling out - Katherine Birbalsingh
cakeorwine · 06/07/2023 23:31

SunnyEgg · 06/07/2023 20:57

Why do people talk about deserving belittling due to accusations, when the order of events was the other way around. JP tweet then accusations. But no I wouldn’t want my dc to receive that treatment. No chance. I would talk about being more careful about what you put up in the first place.

Even KB has said she doesn't think it was racism.

And I have used her words. Unconscious bias, so I’m not sure why there’s an issue there.

She gets to define it, I just listened to what she said and believed her.

You would be forgiven to think that it was about racism.

Some of the quotes:

UK's strictest teacher brands Jess Phillips 'racist' in bombshell letter to Keir Starmer | Politics | News | Express.co.uk

The UK’s strictest headteacher today launched a brutal tirade on Labour MP Jess Phillips, accusing her of being “racist”, “bullying” and encouraging a “vicious mob attack” on her in a jaw-dropping Twitter spat sparked by the death of music icon Tina Turner

Britain's strictest headteacher says Labour's Jess Phillips is 'racist and bullying' | Daily Mail Online

Britain's strictest headteacher today claimed Labour MP Jess Phillips is 'racist and bullying' for firing up a 'vicious mob attack' on her in an extraordinary Twitter storm sparked by the death of Tina Turner.

Katharine Birbalsingh accuses Labour MP Jess Phillips of racism on Twitter (thetimes.co.uk)

Jess Phillips is not racist, Labour's Bridget Phillipson says after online row - BBC News

Labour MP Jess Phillips is not racist, shadow education secretary Bridget Phillipson has said, following a social media row involving Ms Phillips and a prominent headteacher.
Katharine Birbalsingh - from the Michaela Community School - has accused Ms Phillips of racism and bullying.

You'd be forgiven for thinking that KB had accused JP of racism and of being racist.

UK's strictest teacher brands Jess Phillips 'racist' in bombshell open letter

Katharine Birbalsingh launched the astounding attack on the Labour MP following a sharp-tongued Twitter row earlier this year.

https://www.express.co.uk/news/politics/1786567/strictest-teacher-katherine-birbalsingh-jess-phillips-racist

SingingNettles · 06/07/2023 23:28

SunnyEgg · 06/07/2023 22:57

The tweet prompted the response, ie the letter. I thought the criticism below was it was too slow anyway.

Her right is she gets to say how she feels.

She says she’s experienced unconscious bias in her life, which pretty much everyone agreed was likely.

She knows what that’s like, if she found it belittling then that’s her call.

I agree with part of this pp She is entitled to feel however she feels. but would add and she gets to talk about it.

So anyone can make allegations against whoever they like, without any objective evidence, so long as they ‘feel’ them to be true?

SunnyEgg · 06/07/2023 22:57

Quiverer · 06/07/2023 22:32

No, it wasn't that way round. Criticisms started well before JP's first tweet.

What gives KB the right to define unconscious bias? There is simply no logical or factual basis for what she has said.

The tweet prompted the response, ie the letter. I thought the criticism below was it was too slow anyway.

Her right is she gets to say how she feels.

She says she’s experienced unconscious bias in her life, which pretty much everyone agreed was likely.

She knows what that’s like, if she found it belittling then that’s her call.

I agree with part of this pp She is entitled to feel however she feels. but would add and she gets to talk about it.

Clavinova · 06/07/2023 22:54

itsgettingweird
My ds has experienced unconscious bias due to his disability.
But calling him "that boy" wouldn't make me think it's unconscious bias. As he's male!

The comparison wouldn't be 'that boy' - it would be 'that [ ... ] boy'
'that headteacher woman' , 'that MP woman' , 'that swimming boy' - I don't like any of those those labels.

Quiverer · 06/07/2023 22:32

SunnyEgg · 06/07/2023 20:57

Why do people talk about deserving belittling due to accusations, when the order of events was the other way around. JP tweet then accusations. But no I wouldn’t want my dc to receive that treatment. No chance. I would talk about being more careful about what you put up in the first place.

Even KB has said she doesn't think it was racism.

And I have used her words. Unconscious bias, so I’m not sure why there’s an issue there.

She gets to define it, I just listened to what she said and believed her.

No, it wasn't that way round. Criticisms started well before JP's first tweet.

What gives KB the right to define unconscious bias? There is simply no logical or factual basis for what she has said.

Clavinova · 06/07/2023 22:24

Kiwano
Not only did Johnson make the appointment knowing of the relevant allegations

And so it would seem did Theresa May.

he hesitated to suspend Pincher after the events in June last year

The Carlton Club allegations were reported 30th June 2022 - Pincher was suspended 1st July 2022 (the following day). Boris Johnson was speaking at the NATO Summit in Madrid 30th June 2022 and hosted Jacinda Ardern in Downing Street 1st July 2022. What is Keir Starmer's excuse for hesitating to take action in relation to several sexual misconduct cases in May this year?
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12071975/Pressure-piles-Keir-Starmer-sack-senior-Labour-aide-groped-woman-20s.html
https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2023/may/11/female-labour-mp-accuses-shadow-minister-of-sexual-assault
https://news.sky.com/story/charlotte-nichols-accuses-labour-of-gaslighting-her-after-mp-criticised-partys-handling-of-sexual-misconduct-claims-12898075

In fact - has Jess Phillips (since this thread is about Jess Phillips) spoken out regarding Labour's poor handling of sexual misconduct claims under Starmer? I can't see anything on her Twitter feed in May/June this year regarding the above links.

he told junior ministers to go out and lie for him

To be fair, that's speculation - particularly in relation to the first statement issued. Do they trot out the standard line of defence in the first instance? Labour seem to; Sir Keir's office have insisted the Labour leader retains a 'zero tolerance' stance on sexual harassment - quoted from the links - not exactly true is it?

characterising his conduct as "unwise" or an "error of judgment"

You missed out "poor judgment" - I posted that as well.

Given that over 50 members of Johnson's cabinet were pushed by all this into resigning

Indeed they did - all the more surprising then, that SNP MPs did not resign en masse over Ian Blackford's handling of a sexual harassment case - which also came to light in June 2022 - involving a former SNP Chief Whip (who was allowed to stay in post for three years with Blackford's blessing) - with allegations that Blackford coerced and intimidated the victim;

https://news.sky.com/story/ian-blackford-snps-westminster-leader-facing-calls-to-resign-over-handling-of-sexual-harassment-case-12638655

SingingNettles · 06/07/2023 21:03

SunnyEgg · 06/07/2023 20:45

Why are you making it about KPs race.

I didn’t make it about her race, KB talked about unconscious bias, said that she had experienced it in her life and talked about how the tweets made her feel.

I believe that. Like I believe other people who talk about how online abuse or insults makes them feel. I believe Sadiq Khan for instance, it doesn’t mean ‘I am him’, a ‘fan’ or ‘paid by him’ or whatever childish insult people lob.

I’m sure your Ds can be challenged by the way but if he said someone spoke to him on a way that he felt was belittling would you really dismiss his feelings?

She is entitled to feel however she feels.

However, she ought to have more sense than to make public, defamatory accusations based on nothing but her feelings and a tweet that she misread.

SunnyEgg · 06/07/2023 20:57

Why do people talk about deserving belittling due to accusations, when the order of events was the other way around. JP tweet then accusations. But no I wouldn’t want my dc to receive that treatment. No chance. I would talk about being more careful about what you put up in the first place.

Even KB has said she doesn't think it was racism.

And I have used her words. Unconscious bias, so I’m not sure why there’s an issue there.

She gets to define it, I just listened to what she said and believed her.

itsgettingweird · 06/07/2023 20:53

Id ds was all over SM tweeting silly things (Eg pictures of abuse I've husbands stating good times), and tweeted a 4 page letter full of inaccuracies and accusations based on his inability to read something properly - then yes. I'd tell him feeling belittled is what goes along with making wild inaccurate accusations.

And in this whole saga you miss a really big picture of events if we just focus on someone's chosen feelings in response rather than the actions of 2 parties - of whom neither come out smelling of roses.

One however is doing a better job of saving their reputation by knowing when to bounce back and keep quiet rather than double down and try and cover your inaccuracies by spouting more.

Even KB has said she doesn't think it was racism.

Swipe left for the next trending thread