Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask anyone who knows about books/grammar/literary agents if this is as bad as I think?

117 replies

Thosebloodyfullstops · 02/07/2023 05:44

I wrote a book. I worked really hard on it - research, rewrites, etc - but my one blind spot that I’ve always struggled with is punctuation in direct speech.

So my sentence might read -

‘I am going out now.’ he said.

Instead of the correct -

‘I am going out now,’ he said.

I’m so hot on all other aspects of grammar and spelling but as I say just seem to have a blind spot about this!

Amyway I asked a friend to proof read the book in exchange for me doing him a few house related and driving favours of equal time and value. He is a comms expert and former journalist and sub editor. He sent the book back to me as a word doc saying it was all proofed grammatically and spelling wise. I didn’t give it a full read through afterwards again but began to send it out to agents, the first 50 pages anyway.

Anyway yesterday I did look and there are still lots of direct speech errors like the one above.

I KNOW I should have read it again and I KNOW I should have gone through it myself. So I don’t need lots of posters coming on to tell me that. I would just like to hear opinions on how bad it is. I’ve sent to about 15 agents so far. Will they just stop reading at the first punctuation error? Would my sample be rejected on that alone if they like the rest of my book?

Ugh just wish I could send myself back in time a month and undo all of the emails I sent out!

OP posts:
Nooneknowswhatgoesonbehindcloseddoors · 02/07/2023 07:26

krystalweedon · 02/07/2023 06:40

OP, maybe I am being too gloomy. No one else thinks the agents will care, so maybe I am wrong. Good luck with your subs, the waiting to hear is torture.

I agree with you. The errors may annoy the first readers of the book because it may come across as unprofessional. Wishing the op the best of luck.

Loobydoobies · 02/07/2023 07:25

Honestly? An agent is not a publisher- some of the SPAG we see a book publishers is...interesting, and that is why copyeditors exist!

Agents are basically looking for something they can sell. A relatively minor we rror like this may be irritating, but won't be unusual.

Nooneknowswhatgoesonbehindcloseddoors · 02/07/2023 07:23

It takes them ages to get round to reading manuscripts so you could just write to them and say that you sent the wrong draft in error then send them the correct draft. It will make you feel better to know that they are reading a draft that you are happiest with. If you receive rejections (inevitable until you find the publisher that ‘fits’) you will be wondering if it’s because of the mistakes.

Minesril · 02/07/2023 07:21

There's a Pip and Posy book which has that error, it annoys me every time I see it. But if a pretty big children's publisher managed to not see it in a picture book that has around six words per page, I'm sure they won't mind if the rest of your book is amazing.

Artichokepiglet · 02/07/2023 07:01

I think it really depends how good the book actually is. They'll be happy to fix it if the content is great.
I once had a useless editor change your second example to the first though :) So maybe some won't even notice?

krystalweedon · 02/07/2023 06:40

OP, maybe I am being too gloomy. No one else thinks the agents will care, so maybe I am wrong. Good luck with your subs, the waiting to hear is torture.

krystalweedon · 02/07/2023 06:36

Pennyslotmachine · 02/07/2023 06:20

👋 Book publisher here. A few grammatical errors won’t make the slightest difference. All books published by reputable companies are edited, proofread & checked again before they hit the shelves, and most raw manuscripts will have errors of some sort. It’s the authors’s ability to tell the story we’re interested in, not whether they understand the use of a serial comma. Don’t worry & good luck!

Thing is, OP has sent it to agents not publishers.

krystalweedon · 02/07/2023 06:33

Changingplace · 02/07/2023 06:27

I don’t think they’ll care about minor punctuation errors, if they decide to publish they’ll have an editor look at it anyway.

And I work in Comms and have an English degree and that doesn’t jump off the page at me as massively wrong anyway! 😆

Agents aren't publishers and don't have editors. That error will jump out at them,I am afraid. It would to me (I am a published author).

Changingplace · 02/07/2023 06:27

I don’t think they’ll care about minor punctuation errors, if they decide to publish they’ll have an editor look at it anyway.

And I work in Comms and have an English degree and that doesn’t jump off the page at me as massively wrong anyway! 😆

Backstreets · 02/07/2023 06:22

So it’s not consistent? You proofed it yourself before giving it to your friend, but missed a few? Can’t imagine that being an issue

Pennyslotmachine · 02/07/2023 06:20

👋 Book publisher here. A few grammatical errors won’t make the slightest difference. All books published by reputable companies are edited, proofread & checked again before they hit the shelves, and most raw manuscripts will have errors of some sort. It’s the authors’s ability to tell the story we’re interested in, not whether they understand the use of a serial comma. Don’t worry & good luck!

heldinadream · 02/07/2023 06:20

SpongeBobJudgeyPants · 02/07/2023 06:15

As others have said, tis fine, don't overthink it.

It might be me...early, without coffee, but the two sentences you give as an example look the same to me. Am I missing something?

Second one has comma inside speech marks, which is correct here. First one has full stop.

unlikelychump · 02/07/2023 06:20

Surely if they can make money from the book they be able to polish it up first.

I think you are making more of that comma than you need to. Way more.

SpongeBobJudgeyPants · 02/07/2023 06:15

As others have said, tis fine, don't overthink it.

It might be me...early, without coffee, but the two sentences you give as an example look the same to me. Am I missing something?

krystalweedon · 02/07/2023 06:12

It may well put them off. As you know, agents are bombarded with subs and so if they read something with such a basic error, that might be enough for them to reject it and move on to the next sub.

But if the rest of the sub is stellar, they might not be put off. But I think they might worry about having to proof your MS before sending it to publishers.

OwlBabiesAreCute · 02/07/2023 06:11

You will ALWAYS notice your own errors. They literally leap off the page at you.

Funfamilytimes · 02/07/2023 05:56

No. If they like the book and want to take it on, it's down to the editor to pick up any mistakes before publishing.