Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask anyone who knows about books/grammar/literary agents if this is as bad as I think?

117 replies

Thosebloodyfullstops · 02/07/2023 05:44

I wrote a book. I worked really hard on it - research, rewrites, etc - but my one blind spot that I’ve always struggled with is punctuation in direct speech.

So my sentence might read -

‘I am going out now.’ he said.

Instead of the correct -

‘I am going out now,’ he said.

I’m so hot on all other aspects of grammar and spelling but as I say just seem to have a blind spot about this!

Amyway I asked a friend to proof read the book in exchange for me doing him a few house related and driving favours of equal time and value. He is a comms expert and former journalist and sub editor. He sent the book back to me as a word doc saying it was all proofed grammatically and spelling wise. I didn’t give it a full read through afterwards again but began to send it out to agents, the first 50 pages anyway.

Anyway yesterday I did look and there are still lots of direct speech errors like the one above.

I KNOW I should have read it again and I KNOW I should have gone through it myself. So I don’t need lots of posters coming on to tell me that. I would just like to hear opinions on how bad it is. I’ve sent to about 15 agents so far. Will they just stop reading at the first punctuation error? Would my sample be rejected on that alone if they like the rest of my book?

Ugh just wish I could send myself back in time a month and undo all of the emails I sent out!

OP posts:
krystalweedon · 02/07/2023 09:36

Randomly selected current best seller. Check out the punctuation of the dialogue.

read.amazon.co.uk/sample/B09SH8Z3ZN?f=1&l=en_GB&r=9192a3d2&rid=M8VQFSRDGT9ZH9S5XF1W&sid=262-0232775-0871602&ref_=litb_m

krystalweedon · 02/07/2023 09:29

HumanBurrito · 02/07/2023 08:39

BTW OP in British English the comma would be outside the inverted commas. Comma inside is US English.

"That is absolutely incorrect," said Krystal.

HumanBurrito · 02/07/2023 09:15

Are you sure about that?

It was the rule when I worked in publishing and it crops up on a million style guides. As do single quote marks for UK English, though doubles are now gaining ground.

determinedtomakethiswork · 02/07/2023 09:05

She can't nod dialogue!

FurryPelmet · 02/07/2023 09:01

That’s their job and these are minor things so I wouldn’t worry.

With the speech, I didn’t know if you wanted some help on knowing how to punctuate it. If not, ignore this post but perhaps someone else reading the thread will find it useful. I’ve taught English for 20 years and have worked as a proofer.

A lot of people use quotation marks and speech marks interchangeably. Most proofreaders follow the rule that speech uses two “ and quotes use one ‘ . It just makes it clearer to have the distinction.

E.g “No!” she repeated.
Wordsworth describes the flowers as ‘dancing gaily.’

You don’t want two full stops in the same sentence, so the speech needs to end with ,?! and not a full stop if you’re going to extend the sentence beyond the last speech mark.

E.g
”That works for me,” she nodded.
“Are you sure?” Jake asked.
“Absolutely.”
Laura looked relieved. “That’s sorted.”

In the UK, the punctuation definitely goes inside the speech marks.

Good luck with your book!

Corgilicious · 02/07/2023 08:58

Agents and publishers are both looking for a story - and a voice - that they can sell; they genuinely won't care about a bit of rogue punctuation.

YouJustDoYou · 02/07/2023 08:54

They won't care, if the story-telling itself is stellar.

It's nowhere near as bad as the book I bought whereby the writing, instead of saying "sat on the floor/fell on the floor" kept saying "fell in the floor, sat in the floor, walked in the floor". Drove me barmy, simply couldn't finish the book after that idiocy.

GlassWall · 02/07/2023 08:53

An agent is looking for something s/he can sell — if everything else works, and they think it’s very marketable, it’s not likely to be something that tips them into a ‘no’. If an agent asks you for the full MS, make sure it’s error-free, and let the others you’ve queried know.

Changingplace · 02/07/2023 08:47

flyhome · 02/07/2023 08:13

Ha. I wouldn't worry. Booker prize winner "Girl, Woman, Other" has got NO punctuation. How it got past the subs I have no idea. Unreadable because of it, IMO

Yeah to be fair lots of published books have the authors own style, Normal People has no speech punctuation and have you read Milkman? It’s weird to get into but it works!

ThatFraggle · 02/07/2023 08:46

Just checked BBC bitesize KS3 and they say inside.

The traditional difference between British and American is single/double marks

'
"

Changingplace · 02/07/2023 08:45

HumanBurrito · 02/07/2023 08:39

BTW OP in British English the comma would be outside the inverted commas. Comma inside is US English.

That makes more sense to me, I don’t think it looks right and I work in Comms 😁

ThatFraggle · 02/07/2023 08:44

HumanBurrito · 02/07/2023 08:39

BTW OP in British English the comma would be outside the inverted commas. Comma inside is US English.

Are you sure about that?

HumanBurrito · 02/07/2023 08:39

BTW OP in British English the comma would be outside the inverted commas. Comma inside is US English.

Nooneknowswhatgoesonbehindcloseddoors · 02/07/2023 08:22

HumanBurrito · 02/07/2023 08:12

It would put me off, sorry. And be aware that something like under 1% of submissions get accepted anyway.

This is unfortunately the harsh truth. For a first time author to send out work with consistent errors is a really bad look. Those who say they have read published books with errors in - well, it's a totally different thing for the publishers to make mistakes. That's on them. Your responsibility as an author is to ensure that you send out a professional looking manuscript.

Agents/publishers receive tons of manuscripts a week. Yours is not going to stand out if it contains consistent errors. It just looks unprofessional. Don't let people on here lull you into a false sense of security. Recall the manuscript and send them one you are happier with and which reflects your professionalism.

flyhome · 02/07/2023 08:13

Ha. I wouldn't worry. Booker prize winner "Girl, Woman, Other" has got NO punctuation. How it got past the subs I have no idea. Unreadable because of it, IMO

SpongeBobJudgeyPants · 02/07/2023 08:12

@heldinadream thanks! Your attention to detail is much better than mine Grin

HumanBurrito · 02/07/2023 08:12

It would put me off, sorry. And be aware that something like under 1% of submissions get accepted anyway.

ThatFraggle · 02/07/2023 08:04

Have you heard of Reddit? There is a subreddit called r/FanFiction. There is a weekly thread where people offer exchanges of help. Usually it is not a 1:1 offer as it is usually an ongoing relationship, but the 'gift economy' means you give more help than you receive, usually based on word count.

Have you heard of FanFiction? It gets a bad rap, but there are writers of all levels of skill, from professional writers to school children who have this as a hobby. You can specify what kind of help you want, and what kind of help you need.

You can say something like:

"I have an original fiction work which is 100,000 words long. But you could help with part or all of the story. The story is complete, but I need help with grammar and punctuation. For example, a lot of my sentences are things like "Go home now." Sam said. (When the correct way of writing it is "Go home now," Sam said).

I can help people whose English is a second language proof read their story (but I would not be any help with the grammar). I can also help with Britpick, brainstorming or checking how well the story reads in general and I will offer feedback and suggestions."

You specify how long you want it to take, e.g. can they do it within one month or something like that (bear in mind, money is not allowed to be exchanged). The policy is you help for generally the amount of time it took people to help you.

You say what you don't want to read, e.g. "Stories rated teen and up only please, no sex, no horror or violence.

I can do either a 1:1 exchange for a story the same length, or if your story is shorter, a partial exchange. Over 18s only, please."

You create a gmail address, so that they don't have your real name and then paste your work into Google docs, usually each about 10,000 words long, for ease of scrolling. Depending on your book it will be about 5/10 docs long.

Don't be put off by an exchange with someone whose English is not a first language, often their grammar is perfect, but it's just their word choice which is sometimes off in their own story. Britpick is when someone (Usually American) writes something set in England, and you highlight and suggest changes for things like 'He got mad/sidewalk/he walked a block/he put on pants/he had a stack of pancakes for breakfast, etc. Things they didn't realise are not British.

Someone might offer to do it for nothing in exchange (because someone has helped them in the past, or just to keep up the spirit of support and helpfulness- gift economy).

Just like in real life, there will be chancers who only want to take without giving, flaky people who accept your help then don't fulfill their end of the bargain. Selfish schoolchildren who take your help but do a terrible job on yours. Sometimes it takes a few tries, but mostly people are lovely and passionate about their hobby.

I'm on mobile and I don't have pm, but if you're interested, or want to know more, reply here.

LysHastighed · 02/07/2023 07:49

It’s impossible to say, unfortunately. It depends on so many factors.
This is an incredibly easy error to fix in your last pass, just search for .” h and .” s and check them all. Or set up autocorrect to change .” he and .” she to the correct way.
Or find/write a macro that turns the error red when you type it.
Don’t worry about it. You’ve learned from it and won’t make the mistake again.

PriOn1 · 02/07/2023 07:36

I made a monumental cock-up several years ago when I sent out a manuscript with a glaring error in the very first sentence. I wrote a jokey e-mail about being so careful about fonts and headers and page numbers that I had somehow sent it out with this error and that I had been reading about agents being so busy that they were looking to reject, so I had probably done the agent a favour. It broke the ice and I ended up with that agent for a while. I think I sent the same to a couple of others without a response though, so it probably just hit the humour spot for that one. Agents aren’t a monolith and I think each might have their own individual lines in the sand. They might even decide differently depending on what kind of day they’re having.

I think the bottom line is that, if you have a really commercial idea and have sold it well, they would probably overlook it, or some of them would anyway. A tiny number of authors will end up with agents fighting over them for that reason. Most of us have to scrabble round and just find one who clicks.

Good luck, OP. Hope it goes well for you. Perseverance and picking yourself up when it doesn’t go to plan is invaluable.

poorbird · 02/07/2023 07:34

If it’s a brilliant book they won’t care about poor punctuation. If it’s a terrible book they won’t care about impeccable punctuation.

TheBirdintheCave · 02/07/2023 07:32

It depends on the agent I think. I'm a writer and seeing other people use a full stop instead of a comma in speech makes me itchy. My immediate assumption is always that they don't know how to write. I'm autistic so for me it's a hard thing to look past as it affects the way my inner voice reads the book, if that makes sense.

You'll get some agents who think like me and some who won't care I imagine.

Good luck with getting your book out there and I'm sorry your friend wasn't a very good editor. I'd go over the manuscript really carefully before you send to the next batch of agents.

sparepantsandtoothbrush · 02/07/2023 07:30

Considering some of the errors I've seen lately in books I've read on my kindle, I don't think the example you've shown is such a big deal.

The last book I read said that someone's cancer was in recession amongst other things!

Nooneknowswhatgoesonbehindcloseddoors · 02/07/2023 07:30

I just want to add that publishers may be more forgiving because the book has already been endorsed when they receive it. The agent is reading for the first time and unless the book is incredibly gripping, consistent errors will be off putting. Careful checking if the work is important. It is all part and parcel of being a professional author. When you become a literary megastar it will be less so.

Swipe left for the next trending thread