Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask anyone who knows about books/grammar/literary agents if this is as bad as I think?

117 replies

Thosebloodyfullstops · 02/07/2023 05:44

I wrote a book. I worked really hard on it - research, rewrites, etc - but my one blind spot that I’ve always struggled with is punctuation in direct speech.

So my sentence might read -

‘I am going out now.’ he said.

Instead of the correct -

‘I am going out now,’ he said.

I’m so hot on all other aspects of grammar and spelling but as I say just seem to have a blind spot about this!

Amyway I asked a friend to proof read the book in exchange for me doing him a few house related and driving favours of equal time and value. He is a comms expert and former journalist and sub editor. He sent the book back to me as a word doc saying it was all proofed grammatically and spelling wise. I didn’t give it a full read through afterwards again but began to send it out to agents, the first 50 pages anyway.

Anyway yesterday I did look and there are still lots of direct speech errors like the one above.

I KNOW I should have read it again and I KNOW I should have gone through it myself. So I don’t need lots of posters coming on to tell me that. I would just like to hear opinions on how bad it is. I’ve sent to about 15 agents so far. Will they just stop reading at the first punctuation error? Would my sample be rejected on that alone if they like the rest of my book?

Ugh just wish I could send myself back in time a month and undo all of the emails I sent out!

OP posts:
krystalweedon · 02/07/2023 11:22

Usernamedownunder · 02/07/2023 11:17

Publishers need to get their heads out their arses if the op causes problems. Not everyone is taught grammar to the extent this becomes a problem so not everyone will know to look out for it. I'm well educated but didn't know this was a thing and I doubt the average person on the street will know it's a thing.

If the story is good the agent and publisher can polish up the grammar.

If someone wants to be an author, they need to read lots of fiction. So even if they weren't taught grammar at school, they can pick up on the conventions that way.

Usernamedownunder · 02/07/2023 11:17

Publishers need to get their heads out their arses if the op causes problems. Not everyone is taught grammar to the extent this becomes a problem so not everyone will know to look out for it. I'm well educated but didn't know this was a thing and I doubt the average person on the street will know it's a thing.

If the story is good the agent and publisher can polish up the grammar.

MyEyesHurt · 02/07/2023 11:13

Wait, so you did loads of favours for your friend and he, a sub editor, handed your book back with loads of errors? It sounds to me as though he didn't hold up his end of the bargain. Have you mentioned this to him?

MarkWithaC · 02/07/2023 11:07

Freelance book editor here. I feel like I spend much of my working life correcting stuff like this, so it clearly does get through agents/commissioning editors/in-house editors. I wouldn’t worry about it.

thecatsthecats · 02/07/2023 11:04

Ctrl & H

Find ."
Replace ,"

You also can go through them one by one with Ctrl & F, and correct as necessary.

You're welcome ;)

Pocketfullofdogtreats · 02/07/2023 11:04

I'm a freelance proofreader and copyeditor. I work with one successful author who is now on her seventh book and she still makes this error. It's a blind spot for her too. It's not a problem! I had to be trained to look for this kind of thing, and most people won't have had that training and aren't expected to know it. Your journalist friend may not have any experience with fiction editing, which has its own rules and conventions. Don't worry about it, and if you need an editor - pm me!

GlassWall · 02/07/2023 11:02

jc12689 · 02/07/2023 10:53

So why is the first one wrong? It's a quote where the person being quoted has finished their sentence.

Because their spoken sentence is part of a longer sentence which includes the information on who is speaking etc — the convention is that a comma concludes the direct speech and a full stop concludes the entire sentence. (Exception made for a question mark or exclamation mark ending the direct speech. So

’Get away from me!’ he shouted.

or

’Are you serious?’ she said.

But

’I had a nice time,’ he said.

jc12689 · 02/07/2023 10:53

heldinadream · 02/07/2023 06:20

Second one has comma inside speech marks, which is correct here. First one has full stop.

So why is the first one wrong? It's a quote where the person being quoted has finished their sentence.

Andrew101 · 02/07/2023 10:45

I think the error is a big deal if it is constantly repeated as it shows poor grammar and attention to detail.
More generally, I'd advise using an editing service such as Cornerstones. They can help you develop as a writer and they have the contacts if you have real talent.
Many people waste time writing a first book which has no chance so it's a good idea to find out as early as possible if your story/writing has potential.
Very tough getting published, I wish you luck.

ItsNotRocketSalad · 02/07/2023 10:33

Okay, six errors in 50 pages isn't a death knell if they love everything else. But the odds of being offered rep are still teeny tiny so concentrating on writing a new book is definitely the way to go.

When you say book two, is it a sequel to the one you're querying or an entirely new story?

Thosebloodyfullstops · 02/07/2023 10:28

Thanks everyone! I’ve gone over it again. There were six instances of this error in the sample I sent out which I have now corrected.

The problem is it really is my blind spot so it didn’t look wrong to me though I accept that to others it may make their teeth itch, a bit like ‘loose’ instead of ‘lose’ for me!

I will drive myself mad thinking about it so am just going to keep writing (am writing book two) and querying with what is now hopefully an error-free manuscript!

OP posts:
Nooneknowswhatgoesonbehindcloseddoors · 02/07/2023 10:24

flyhome · 02/07/2023 08:13

Ha. I wouldn't worry. Booker prize winner "Girl, Woman, Other" has got NO punctuation. How it got past the subs I have no idea. Unreadable because of it, IMO

"Girl, Woman, Other" by Bernadine Evaristo is an experimental novel, which is why there is no punctuation. She uses a stream of consciousness style. It's a great novel. OP is nowhere near Evaristo's level. Evaristo won the Booker Prize. It's like saying to a painter. Just splash paint on a canvas any old how - if Jackson Pollock got away with it you will too and gallery owners will be chasing after you and pay millions of pounds for your work. Ain't gonna happen, I'm afraid. OP has to stick to the rules and submit their work to as high a standard as they can.

Nooneknowswhatgoesonbehindcloseddoors · 02/07/2023 10:19

ItsNotRocketSalad · 02/07/2023 10:11

I'm a published author and also used to read for a literary agency. I'm very surprised at some of the posts above from people claiming to know the industry. The truth is a manuscript from a non-celebrity with "lots of" basic errors is going to be instantly rejected.

Thank you.

Nooneknowswhatgoesonbehindcloseddoors · 02/07/2023 10:18

YouJustDoYou · 02/07/2023 08:54

They won't care, if the story-telling itself is stellar.

It's nowhere near as bad as the book I bought whereby the writing, instead of saying "sat on the floor/fell on the floor" kept saying "fell in the floor, sat in the floor, walked in the floor". Drove me barmy, simply couldn't finish the book after that idiocy.

The reality however is that most aren't stellar. No first time author should ever assume that others will think their work is "stellar" and overlook errors. Once you have a few publications under your belt you might adopt such an attitude, although by the time you have a few publications under your belt you will be the consummate professional and will be mortified if you send something out with errors.

I think a lot of you on here don't seem to understand what a difficult industry op is trying to get into. Finding an agent is the first of many hurdles.

Trust me, OP. Don't listen to those who think it doesn't matter. It really does.

HumanBurrito · 02/07/2023 10:14

Other sources say the opposite. I suspect it's a changing norm related to the globalisation of publishing. Either way, it's not hugely relevant to the OP and I should not have started the sidetrack, sorry!

ItsNotRocketSalad · 02/07/2023 10:11

I'm a published author and also used to read for a literary agency. I'm very surprised at some of the posts above from people claiming to know the industry. The truth is a manuscript from a non-celebrity with "lots of" basic errors is going to be instantly rejected.

krystalweedon · 02/07/2023 10:09

krystalweedon · 02/07/2023 10:06

Not in fiction dialigue. Punctuation inside. always.

I have had three fiction books published by a major publisher and not one editor or proof reader ever suggested the punctuation should be outside the speech marks.

Dialogue!

krystalweedon · 02/07/2023 10:06

Archeron · 02/07/2023 09:47

Both of your examples are incorrect though. In British English the punctuation goes outside the quotes.

Not in fiction dialigue. Punctuation inside. always.

I have had three fiction books published by a major publisher and not one editor or proof reader ever suggested the punctuation should be outside the speech marks.

PriamFarrl · 02/07/2023 10:03

Given that I’ve read published books with glaring spelling errors I can’t imagine it would matter that much.

SoupDragon · 02/07/2023 10:01

I was taught that the punctuation goes within the speech marks and I was taught in the 70s.

HumanBurrito · 02/07/2023 09:55

It probably matters to an agent though, since they are looking for more than just a story. They are looking to represent an author and it makes their job easier if that author is attuned to professional expectations. The occasional typo is fine, but a glaring error on page one (not saying this is the case for you BTW OP! depends how systematic it is[* will be offputting. And since they're getting hundreds of submissions a week, they can afford to be picky. Given a roughly 0.25% acceptance rate from the slush pile, anything that creates a bad impression is to be avoided.

*No idea why but closing parentheses always come out as square brackets for me on MN...

CheekyHobson · 02/07/2023 09:50

Editors are looking for great original ideas, vivid imagery, clever plotting and pacing and and memorable dialogue. If you have those things, frankly it doesn’t matter if there’s a spelling or punctuation mistake in every paragraph. That’s what copy-editors are for.

Archeron · 02/07/2023 09:47

Both of your examples are incorrect though. In British English the punctuation goes outside the quotes.

krystalweedon · 02/07/2023 09:43

FurryPelmet · 02/07/2023 09:01

That’s their job and these are minor things so I wouldn’t worry.

With the speech, I didn’t know if you wanted some help on knowing how to punctuate it. If not, ignore this post but perhaps someone else reading the thread will find it useful. I’ve taught English for 20 years and have worked as a proofer.

A lot of people use quotation marks and speech marks interchangeably. Most proofreaders follow the rule that speech uses two “ and quotes use one ‘ . It just makes it clearer to have the distinction.

E.g “No!” she repeated.
Wordsworth describes the flowers as ‘dancing gaily.’

You don’t want two full stops in the same sentence, so the speech needs to end with ,?! and not a full stop if you’re going to extend the sentence beyond the last speech mark.

E.g
”That works for me,” she nodded.
“Are you sure?” Jake asked.
“Absolutely.”
Laura looked relieved. “That’s sorted.”

In the UK, the punctuation definitely goes inside the speech marks.

Good luck with your book!

"That works for me,” she nodded.

AAAAGH! The only way that sentence would work for me would be:

She nodded. "That works for me."

Better still, either axe the nodded as it is clear from the dialogue she agrees. Or axe the dialogue and just use she nodded.

Swipe left for the next trending thread