Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask anyone who knows about books/grammar/literary agents if this is as bad as I think?

117 replies

Thosebloodyfullstops · 02/07/2023 05:44

I wrote a book. I worked really hard on it - research, rewrites, etc - but my one blind spot that I’ve always struggled with is punctuation in direct speech.

So my sentence might read -

‘I am going out now.’ he said.

Instead of the correct -

‘I am going out now,’ he said.

I’m so hot on all other aspects of grammar and spelling but as I say just seem to have a blind spot about this!

Amyway I asked a friend to proof read the book in exchange for me doing him a few house related and driving favours of equal time and value. He is a comms expert and former journalist and sub editor. He sent the book back to me as a word doc saying it was all proofed grammatically and spelling wise. I didn’t give it a full read through afterwards again but began to send it out to agents, the first 50 pages anyway.

Anyway yesterday I did look and there are still lots of direct speech errors like the one above.

I KNOW I should have read it again and I KNOW I should have gone through it myself. So I don’t need lots of posters coming on to tell me that. I would just like to hear opinions on how bad it is. I’ve sent to about 15 agents so far. Will they just stop reading at the first punctuation error? Would my sample be rejected on that alone if they like the rest of my book?

Ugh just wish I could send myself back in time a month and undo all of the emails I sent out!

OP posts:
Nooneknowswhatgoesonbehindcloseddoors · 02/07/2023 21:56

Usernamedownunder · 02/07/2023 14:59

Yet people are winning prizes for grammatical errors, that make a book unreadable, posters on here are saying wouldn't get a publishing deal.

Either grammar matters or it doesn't.

Prize winning author Bernadine Evaristo (who I assume you are referring to) did not make grammatical errors. She made an artistic choice to use stream of consciousness - which tries to emulate the thought process: we don't think in sentences with punctuation. It is a literary technique that you can only pull off if you have a mastery of the language. it isn't to everyone's taste because it can be challenging. Take a look at James Joyce's Finnegan's Wake.

This is completely different to grammatical errors which have the potential to ruin your literary effects and take the reader out of the story. A few errors really don't matter because we're not robots, but consistent and basic errors could look like carelessness or make you seem like a writer who isn't in control of their material. You wouldn't want the professionals you are hoping to persuade to invest in your work to think this about your wor

LysHastighed · 02/07/2023 21:21

Six instances doesn’t sound like the end of the world. It probably won’t be the basis of their decision.

ladyofshertonabbas · 02/07/2023 19:16

Too late now, but can’t you do a find for all instances of .’ Etc and replace?

MarkWithaC · 02/07/2023 19:03

Oh, and ‘Go home now." Sam said’ is patently wrong, whatever your spellcheck says; UK convention is definitely comma inside closing quote mark; and humans absolutely ARE still proofreading in 2023.

MarkWithaC · 02/07/2023 19:01

Andrew101 · 02/07/2023 16:28

All true.
A lot of advice from people who don't know the industry.
The books with errors are down to the publisher (or author if self-published). Doesn't mean it's ok.
The freelance editors saying it's common, don't worry, are probably getting copy from established writers and are finding typos or commissioned academics with poor grammar.
It's not a normal business where the product may sell itself. The publisher willl most likely loose money on any first book. They are investing in the writer for further content and marketing ability and first impressions are important.
OP is trying to find an agent which is very hard. Poor grammar will not help.

The freelance editors saying it's common, don't worry, are probably getting copy from established writers and are finding typos or commissioned academics with poor grammar.

No. I get manuscripts from established, new and in-between authors, and authors for whom it’s their main job, authors who are, as you say, primarily academics, authors who use a ghostwriter, whose grammar and punctuation I then have to correct(!); it’s often not typos but what an author doesn’t know.
(Or what they think they DO know, but don’t; I am increasingly being briefed to let authors use the ‘idiosyncratic’ punctuation and grammar of their choice even if it’s wrong, rather than upsetting them by correcting it, but that’s another thread.)

I used to work in-house too and problems with grammar etc never put me, my bosses or my colleagues off buying a book if it was good/sellable; that’s what you have freelance editors and proofreaders for.

Andrew101 · 02/07/2023 16:28

ItsNotRocketSalad · 02/07/2023 10:11

I'm a published author and also used to read for a literary agency. I'm very surprised at some of the posts above from people claiming to know the industry. The truth is a manuscript from a non-celebrity with "lots of" basic errors is going to be instantly rejected.

All true.
A lot of advice from people who don't know the industry.
The books with errors are down to the publisher (or author if self-published). Doesn't mean it's ok.
The freelance editors saying it's common, don't worry, are probably getting copy from established writers and are finding typos or commissioned academics with poor grammar.
It's not a normal business where the product may sell itself. The publisher willl most likely loose money on any first book. They are investing in the writer for further content and marketing ability and first impressions are important.
OP is trying to find an agent which is very hard. Poor grammar will not help.

Corgilicious · 02/07/2023 16:28

If the main takeaway an agent has from a submission is 'I'm not sure this writer understands how to punctuate speech', then there are much bigger problems for a writer to address in their first three chapters.

Usernamedownunder · 02/07/2023 14:59

Nooneknowswhatgoesonbehindcloseddoors · 02/07/2023 14:56

But I assume that you are not a potential author and read for leisure purposes not because you are learning the ropes.

I find that this lazy attitude only pertains to writing. One would never expect less than professional attitudes from ballerinas or pianists or other musicians, or from sportspeople.

Yet people are winning prizes for grammatical errors, that make a book unreadable, posters on here are saying wouldn't get a publishing deal.

Either grammar matters or it doesn't.

Nooneknowswhatgoesonbehindcloseddoors · 02/07/2023 14:56

Usernamedownunder · 02/07/2023 11:25

Can they? I read a lot and honestly don't pay attention to the grammar to this level of detail. If a book is completely unreadable (like it sounds the booker prize winning book mentioned earlier is) then I'll notice it.

But I assume that you are not a potential author and read for leisure purposes not because you are learning the ropes.

I find that this lazy attitude only pertains to writing. One would never expect less than professional attitudes from ballerinas or pianists or other musicians, or from sportspeople.

Andrew101 · 02/07/2023 14:26

continentallentil · 02/07/2023 12:37

No it won’t.

They are looking for content that will sell. It’s a business, they aren’t English teachers.

Yes it will.
Do you really think an agent or publisher wants to represent an author who's own twitter account, blog or website is prone to errors?
OP said it's her only blind spot which is good and it's a small hurdle, just saying in this instance it might be enough to put some agents off after just one or two pages.

Random789 · 02/07/2023 13:04

People could easily read it as a typo, rather than ignorance of basic grammar, and I would imagine that an agent wuld be reasonably forgiving of typos ... if the content is good and marketable. That's the big, BIG 'if'

filka · 02/07/2023 12:53

I pasted these into MS Word
"Go home now," Sam said.
"Go home now." Sam said.
...then ran a spell/grammar check in UK and US English, with no mistakes identified.

But if you are using Word you can always just search the whole document for ." and check them all.

HumanBurrito · 02/07/2023 12:45

It's precisely because it's a business that they don't have time to handhold newbies with a poor grasp of professional standards (again, not saying this is the OP's case, 6 instances in 50 pages isn't too bad IMO[.

TrueScrumptious · 02/07/2023 12:43

HopelessEstateAgents · 02/07/2023 12:05

Next time just get an AI tool to do the proof, humans aren't proofing in 2023!

Yes, humans do proof. We do use a lot of AI but it’s not perfect. You do realise that your sentence is grammatically incorrect, so can I assume you didn’t use AI?

continentallentil · 02/07/2023 12:37

krystalweedon · 02/07/2023 06:12

It may well put them off. As you know, agents are bombarded with subs and so if they read something with such a basic error, that might be enough for them to reject it and move on to the next sub.

But if the rest of the sub is stellar, they might not be put off. But I think they might worry about having to proof your MS before sending it to publishers.

No it won’t.

They are looking for content that will sell. It’s a business, they aren’t English teachers.

Andrew101 · 02/07/2023 12:19

Usernamedownunder · 02/07/2023 11:26

A good well told story is really hard to find these days. Surely that's more important than grammatical conventions?

Yes, the writing and story are important but first the OP needs an agent. The agent is unlikely to read the whole manuscript, just the cover letter and if you're lucky, a few pages before making an initial decision. They'll likely see poor grammar and editing as lazy and this won't help.

HopelessEstateAgents · 02/07/2023 12:05

Next time just get an AI tool to do the proof, humans aren't proofing in 2023!

krystalweedon · 02/07/2023 11:51

Good luck OP. Even if you don't get anywhere with this book, keep going. Persistence is key in the publishing game!

Thosebloodyfullstops · 02/07/2023 11:47

Thanks everyone. Yes, book two is a sequel but like book one can also be read as a stand alone. I’ve seen conflicting advice about mentioning this in the query letter so just said it’s a stand alone with series potential. It’s commercial historical fiction.

OP posts:
Notmybloodymonkeys · 02/07/2023 11:44

sparepantsandtoothbrush · 02/07/2023 07:30

Considering some of the errors I've seen lately in books I've read on my kindle, I don't think the example you've shown is such a big deal.

The last book I read said that someone's cancer was in recession amongst other things!

Is that The In-Laws or is there another author out there making that mistake? The In-Laws is, without doubt, the worst book I’ve read in terms of the amount of errors on every page.

TrueScrumptious · 02/07/2023 11:41

HumanBurrito · 02/07/2023 08:39

BTW OP in British English the comma would be outside the inverted commas. Comma inside is US English.

That isn’t right at all. British punctuation has the comma before the end quotes in that example. I’m an editor. Doing it the other way would be marked as an error in my work.

krystalweedon · 02/07/2023 11:34

I need a proof reader for my posts!🙄🙄🙄

krystalweedon · 02/07/2023 11:33

I was not taught grammar at school and I couldn't explain a lot of the rules, but I know them because I read a lot.

Yes, agents and publishers want a good story, but the competition is extrenely fierce and the industry cut throat. If an agent reads two cracking subs on the same day, one carefully punctuated the other not which one are they more likely to choose?

Telling aspiring authors not to worry too much about SPaG is doing them no favours.

Usernamedownunder · 02/07/2023 11:26

A good well told story is really hard to find these days. Surely that's more important than grammatical conventions?

Usernamedownunder · 02/07/2023 11:25

Can they? I read a lot and honestly don't pay attention to the grammar to this level of detail. If a book is completely unreadable (like it sounds the booker prize winning book mentioned earlier is) then I'll notice it.