Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to even consider getting a puppy in my circumstances?

83 replies

NeedPerspective1234 · 01/07/2023 19:40

Before I get flamed, I am looking for real advice/ opinions and posting here on AIBU for traffic. I haven't made a decision on getting a dog as I know it is a big commitment and I want to make this choice responsibly.

I am a single woman in her mid 30s, working a full time professional job on a good wage. My office is 10 mins from my place and I only have to be at the office for either the morning or afternoon 3/4 days a week. I can WFH for the rest of the time. I live in a nice big one bedroom flat. Dog would be alone for 4-5 hours every day, but with me otherwise. I could easily take one or two weeks off to help the puppy settle in initially of course

I have been dreaming of getting a Labrador puppy since I can remember. Now for the first time in many years I feel like I have the financial, logistical and emotional stability to actually consider getting a dog and I have found a serious breeder. I really want to do it, but the sheer size of the commitment is making me hesitate as I want to make sure I can meet the dog's needs in my circumstances.

Do you think it would be unfair for me to get a dog? AIBU to even consider getting a puppy as a single working person? Is it doable? Thanks for your advice!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
00100001 · 03/07/2023 08:02

IggysPop · 02/07/2023 17:32

The Labrador Retriever is from the gundog group. They adapt as family dogs (this is why they are so popular), but unless you can compensate for a non-working life - with daily physical and mental stimulation- then you should seriously re-consider. There are too many overweight and bored Labrador/Golden Retrievers around as it is. Just because you can, doesn’t mean you should.

Maybe start with the kennel club to see if your living conditions are suitable for specific breeds https://www.thekennelclub.org.uk/search/breeds-a-to-z/breeds/gundog/retriever-labrador/

Yep, I know a lab owner who only takes it once a day for 5-10minute walk round the block.

This dog is fat, charges about the house, chews chews chews on blankets and towels, rips pillows....and she wonders why it can't just be a calm lay down dog!

I have suggested she walks it more but she claims "oh he's lazy!"

00100001 · 03/07/2023 07:57

gogomoto · 01/07/2023 19:58

People are saying you can't leave a puppy 5 hours, well it really is breed and personality dependent. My ddog was left circa 4 hours from the start without any issues but not a lab. Think also about having to walk many times a day without a garden, again doable but have you the time?

I personally wouldn't recommend a dog with only one person to do the work as they take so much time. We had 4 people capable of walking etc at the time we got our dog (circumstances different now but still 3 when he's with me)

So you bought a dog, put him in your house for a few hours and promptly left it alone for 4 hours? And have done this every day since??

Vetoncall · 02/07/2023 23:49

No flaming at all but in your circumstances I wouldn't recommend a puppy, and definitely not a large, boisterous, active, human-oriented breed like a Lab. An older dog could be a better option but again you would ideally be able to take a month or so to settle them in, and arrange daycare or a walker on an ongoing basis. In any case please do think very carefully about breed suitability - be brutally honest about your lifestyle and what type of dog (if any) it might be suitable for.

Totalwasteofpaper · 02/07/2023 23:39

There are other breeds much more suited to a flat. I would look into those

Id also look at rehoming an older dog we got a 4 year old rescue and is was a piece of cake vs puppy.

I also suggest practicing your "dog life" now. Ie be home at 4 hour intervals take imaginary dog out to go to the toilet.
Turn down after work drinks because...dog.

Its not to put you off but you do need to be aware of the reality.
My ddog isb"easy" but is still bsically another baby with its own needs and wants. Your calendar is set by them

StayAnonn · 02/07/2023 22:52

People are saying you can't leave a puppy 5 hours, well it really is breed and personality dependent. My ddog was left circa 4 hours from the start without any issues but not a lab

No, it's really not breed or personality dependent.

Getting a puppy then leaving it alone for 4 hours 'from the start' is awful, neglectful and unfair on the dog.

Appleofmyeye2023 · 02/07/2023 17:48

I’m acting as doggy assistant with my families puppy. He’s about 5 months now but can’t go more that 5 hours without a wee. When my family aren’t around I go round to let him out , play a bit and a bit of cuddle time . Otherwise they’d be messes
im not that keen on dogs - but even I know that my family need this help from me to get through 5his stage.
he’s there 4 lab, they always try to have 2 with overlaps so they know what they’re doing. But they do need help to ensure cover for odd times when pup and elder dog are on their own for extended period
you need to think about that- who’s your assistant ?

creativeusername23 · 02/07/2023 17:41

Double Lab owner here.

I wouldn’t do it living in a flat nor without anyone else to help out. They have bags of energy and if that’s not channeled correctly, they turn into absolute power chewers, especially as babies and into teenage time. Think whole walls eaten into, absolute worst case scenario. Their tails are like destructive weapons which can swipe clean any surface within a second and they have no idea how big they are! With chewing also comes the risk of blockages and I say that as someone who experienced the near death and emergency surgery of one of mine.

They’re incredible dogs, loving, loyal and funny but they’re very hard work and just staying at home for a couple of weeks to settle them in isn’t enough. You may have a clever Lab like my eldest who trained incredibly quickly and has impeccable manners/obedience or you may get one who’s like my younger Lab, an absolute cuddle bug and tries her best but in her own little world at times and still thinks pulling drying cloths off radiators is a good game!

IggysPop · 02/07/2023 17:32

The Labrador Retriever is from the gundog group. They adapt as family dogs (this is why they are so popular), but unless you can compensate for a non-working life - with daily physical and mental stimulation- then you should seriously re-consider. There are too many overweight and bored Labrador/Golden Retrievers around as it is. Just because you can, doesn’t mean you should.

Maybe start with the kennel club to see if your living conditions are suitable for specific breeds https://www.thekennelclub.org.uk/search/breeds-a-to-z/breeds/gundog/retriever-labrador/

Missingmyusername · 02/07/2023 17:22

A puppy, yes you are insane. The lab will chew up your apartment and poo and pee all over!

A dog would be better. Do you have stairs? My dog tore his ligament age5, huge op and no stairs after that. Do you have a gff so they can do their business? My dog would eat random stuff and be outside vomiting and having diarrhoea whilst I cleaned inside. It wasn’t pretty. I can’t imagine that in a flat. You need a dog you can carry!

off · 02/07/2023 17:19

*some kindS of rat interaction

WiddlinDiddlin · 02/07/2023 17:18

Puppy training/management/advice is what I do for a living (alongside treating/avoiding separation anxiety!)...

No. Thats totally nuts.

Puppies have NO ability to be on their own, reliably, for a useful time frame, for about the first 9 months to a year of their life.

(That doesn't mean some individuals can't manage half an hour here, an hour there, once they are 6 months old... before anyone dives in to say 'yeah but my puppy...').

Even if a puppy is relaxed and comfortable on their own:

  • What are they learning
  • What are they NOT learning
  • Who are they bonding with?

A puppy on their own is not learning what you want them to learn, may be learning things you do not want them to learn and is not bonding with you (so even if you've got a neighbour, daycare, whatever set up... it's not you providing their security, it is not you they are bonding with).

A couple of weeks off is NOT long enough to set your puppy up to handle being alone - a couple of months wouldn't be.

What you are suggesting would involve a puppy suffering, probably trashing your house, upsetting the neighbours, at risk from hypoglycemia (yes they need to eat every few hours, 4 times a day and small breeds are at a higher risk). A puppy who grows up to be an anxious reactive mess because they missed out on the early habituation, security and confidence building puppies need.

I am sure if you ask enough people, some will tell you its fine, they did it, it's no bother - if you ask any question often enough you will eventually get the answers you want. You will also find breeders unscrupulous enough to sell you a puppy, or of course you can lie to them.

This will not be fun for you, or the puppy.

If you REALLY want a dog - first, sort out being able to take a month off work. Then sort out a sitter who can stay in your home.

Then find a suitable rescue dog - perhaps small independent rescue, breeder who is rehoming older ex show dogs. Spend that first month settling them in and introducing them to the sitters/day care etc.

Then spend the next 6 months ensuring they become confident and secure, then work on building up the time they can be alone for very gradually.

It's a lot of work, but then this is someone who will rely on you 100% for their every need for the next 10 years or more.

ItsCalledAConversation · 02/07/2023 17:07

I have a 1 year old lab. I wouldn’t want to live with her in a one bed flat now, let alone when she was younger. She would climb the walls. It’s not enough space. You wouldn’t be around enough to stimulate her and she could become destructive.

off · 02/07/2023 16:57

LunaandLily · 02/07/2023 09:16

I wouldn’t write off this suggestion either! Consider it!

Agree, it's possible a cat would fulfill whatever it is that OP is looking for from dog ownership. I don't remember her actually mentioning what exactly that is, only that she's been dreaming of getting a Labrador puppy forever, so it's hard to make informed suggestions based only on that. The suggestions of an older, smaller, calmer, trained, vaccinated dog would also seem to make some sense.

I know my suggestion of rats would have probably also been instantly written off by the majority… I'm aware it might sound kind of left-field to those who aren't familiar with pet rats, and it's possible that rats wouldn't work for OP.

But when the pet somebody is thinking about getting (but for practical reasons, reluctantly decides they currently shouldn't) is a dog, then compared to a cat, the experiential quality of looking after, interacting with, and building a relationship with pet rats is IMO closer to the specific flavour of animal companionship you get from a dog. Obviously keeping rats isn't the same thing as having a dog, but I don't think it's as different from dogs as the way you look after, interact with, and build a relationship with a cat is.

If what somebody is looking for when they're thinking of getting a dog is an animal that's friendly, intelligent, responsive to you, always glad to see you, playful (except middle-aged+ male rats, who mostly want to chill), (somewhat) trainable, and that relates to you in a kinda dog-like way and thinks in a way that's kinda familiar to humans (if less complex), rats might be a good choice. (Always worth mentioning you shouldn't just have one lone rat; they're social and intelligent, and you're incapable of some kind of rat interaction, so they need rat companions.)

Lots of people obviously love having pet cats, but depending on what OP is looking for from dog ownership, cats may be too fundamentally different an animal from a dog.

The natural social structure of rat family and friend/acquaintance groups, the rat ecological niche and strategy, and the way that rats think and behave, is extremely similar to humans, just closer to the ground, with more tail and less brainpower. Like us, they naturally build complex networks of relationships, and they tend to treat their owners… not quite as another rat, exactly, but as a sort of giant friend, someone who's always worth spending time with.

Dogs also live in fair-sized social groups, and of course have developed specific behavioural tendencies towards building relationships with humans that have a particular quality about them. Rats and dogs aren't anything like identical in how they relate to humans, but they're not completely different.

The relationships cats build with their owners and vice versa are of a type that do feel pretty different from that, IME. That's no less rewarding, of course, for those looking for that kind of interaction and relationship, but because of the natural differences in the way cats interact socially and build relationships, their way of life, ecological niche and their psychology, they're a really different pet.

Also, if you really really need to go for walks, you can (if you like) go for a walk with a rat on your shoulder, pirate-style, or in a hoodie pouch. Just saying Grin As long as you're mindful of the fact that small animals have small digestive tracts, and can't hold on forever…

Anyway… OP probably has a lot of different options for pets that she could provide a wonderful life to, without massively disrupting her life, but if what she actually wants is specifically and solely to have a Labrador from puppyhood onwards, maybe settling for an alternative wouldn't be the best thing. It wouldn't be what OP really wants, and that could end up being a really difficult situation.

LunaandLily · 02/07/2023 09:16

WeightInLine · 02/07/2023 08:44

what you want is a cat

I wouldn’t write off this suggestion either! Consider it!

LunaandLily · 02/07/2023 09:15

4-5 hours a day is absolutely fine once the dog is 6 months old. I think your situation sounds ideal compared to some others I’ve seen! Get him crate trained early as well so he just sleeps in his cosy little den while you’re out. Maybe your employer can let you reduce time in the office for the first few months, or you can pay a dog walker to do puppy visits.

WeightInLine · 02/07/2023 08:44

what you want is a cat

greyhairnomore · 02/07/2023 08:42

I know very little about dogs but I know that a puppy would take longer than two weeks to settle in.
How will you toilet train it ?
I know people who work part time and they still have a dog walker.
I don't think it would work for you at the moment.

AndrexPuppy · 02/07/2023 08:10

I have a lab. He is easy going and wonderful but that it as a result of a 2 way relationship where we don’t take the mick and he trusts us to be reliable and meet his needs.

He can and is left for 4 or 5 hours but it is more like once a week/fortnight rather than every day. We built up to that very slowly.

I agree with PP that a 1 bed flat is not much space for a large breed dog, unless we are talking about an extraordinary 2000sqft loft apartment style number. Even then, it’s not ideal with no garden.

In terms of working hours. Working for 4/5 hours a day is all very well but about the times when you want to go out socialising? The dog will be left alone then, too, so it’ll be more like 7-10 hours a day on days where you go out and are working. Or if you only socialise on days where you don’t work, it’ll be more like 4-5 hours a day, 7 days a week (or whatever the multiple is for you). Be honest with yourself and work it out. You can use doggy day care but some dogs can find that a very stressful environment, so don’t assume it’ll work for you.

Dogs are a HUGE tie. Very rewarding but a massive tie. You have to adjust your lifestyle a lot to accommodate their needs. Be honest with yourself as to whether or not that’s doable at the moment.

cinnamonfrenchtoast · 02/07/2023 08:09

Willmafrockfit · 02/07/2023 08:04

so much negativity here
i hope you can find more balanced opinions somewhere op @NeedPerspective1234

No negativity, just the reality of owning an energetic puppy 😉

Dalekjastninerels · 02/07/2023 08:09

00100001 · 02/07/2023 08:06

A person who suggests leaving a puppy for 5 hours a day, after it has been there two weeks and thinks bringing a lab into a 1 bed flat.... has an invalid opinion that shouldn't be listened to.

Correct, dogs are pack animals who don't like being left on their own for hours; 5 + hours will feel like forever to a dog.

00100001 · 02/07/2023 08:06

Willmafrockfit · 02/07/2023 08:04

so much negativity here
i hope you can find more balanced opinions somewhere op @NeedPerspective1234

A person who suggests leaving a puppy for 5 hours a day, after it has been there two weeks and thinks bringing a lab into a 1 bed flat.... has an invalid opinion that shouldn't be listened to.

Dalekjastninerels · 02/07/2023 08:05

00100001 · 02/07/2023 08:04

OP said 4-5 hours. Let's be realistic, it will be 5 hours.

Or more if she is stuck in traffic/on the bus.

TreadSoftlyOnMyDreams · 02/07/2023 08:05

We got a Labrador puppy last year. First dog for any of us and it was recommended as one of the easier dogs to train and handle family life.
Everyone who meets her esp those who know labradors say we have landed on our feet. She is very chilled and easy going. She would not struggle with 4 hrs by herself at 14 months but needs to be out very early for a long walk beforehand. Not a trot around the block.
Do you have a large park or outside space suitable to let a dog off a lead literally within 5 mins walk? If not then I am sorry but a lab is too big for your set up.

Ditto a pre bed time wee. Will you feel safe out v late and in the early ours to toilet a young dog?

Dog walkers early £20 per walk here. Transport costs on too (tax deductible) so a daily walk will add up.
Dog daycare is more expensive for puppies &50-60 per day. So a work business trip, away day, day out with friends, family event and you have more cost.
Insurance is £50 per month if you want lifetime cover (new conditions don't become pre-existing conditions in 12 months)

We love our dog but it is like having a large boisterous male toddler (she's female) around all the time. Clumsy, tail clearing coffee tables, endless desire to play tug of war or have a ball thrown. She's been life changing, we spend a lot more time outside but when the weather is bickering down she is a breed that means you just have to get on with it.

00100001 · 02/07/2023 08:04

Willmafrockfit · 02/07/2023 07:58

4 hours sounds reasonable.
obviously difficult at first

OP said 4-5 hours. Let's be realistic, it will be 5 hours.

Willmafrockfit · 02/07/2023 08:04

so much negativity here
i hope you can find more balanced opinions somewhere op @NeedPerspective1234